Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Nothing 'natural' about women's oppression

· Socialist Outlook no. 20, December–January 1990 · p 30 · 900 words

Women Marxism

FEATURES

The assertion that women's op- pression has origins is itself con- troversial. For the majority of people, the current position of men and women is a universal and "natural' phenomenon; and this view is reinforced by any number of anthropological text books and learned historical studies.

The marxist tradition stands in sharp contrast with this prevailing line of thought. Friederich Engels in his pioneering work, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, (1884) clearly contradicts the view that women's subordination is a constant unbroken thread stretching back to the dawn of humankind.

Drawing on the work of the early American anthropologist Lewis Mor- gan, Engels traces the changing posi- tion of women from the matriarchy of "primitive communism" to the patriar- chy of class societies and the poten- tial for liberation created by the ad- vent of capitalism. He ties these developments to the changes in the family form as the economic basis of society shifted.

Thus Engels locates the origins of women's. oppression (his words describe it as 'the world-historic defeat of the female sex") in the period of economic expan- sion ushered in by the developments of agriculture, stock-raising and metallurgy. The sexual division of labour which had always existed, whereby men hunted and women looked after the home and children, meant that the wealth created by these advances in production was controlled by men, who then enslaved women. So the subordination of women is the product of the beginnings of private property and the genesis of the state.

There have always been those who have expressed reservations about the implications and analysis of The Origin. Engels" critics, however, divide into two main groups: on the one side those who agree with his materialist method and' accept the central theses of his work - that women's oppression is not an eter- nal truth, that the family is not an unchanging institution, and that the oppression of women is inextricably linked to the beginnings of class society, and on the other side those who reject Marxist methodology altogether.

The former approach began with the leaders of the (then officially still marxist'")

Who says women aren't cut out to be building workers? German Social Democratic Party (SPD) at the tum of the century, who rejected as "too redolent of bourgeois psychology the high value Engels reluctantly placed monogamy, and the Russian socialists of the same period who took issue with The Origin as mistakenly treating the family as autonomous from society, and continues today among many marxist feminists such as Stephanie Coontz and Frederique Vinteuil.

Indeed it is true that Engels was dependent on the intellectual and social context of his time. His work is shot through with patriarchal assumptions and an inability to break with bourgeois ideology on certain key points. The idea of a natural and universal sexual division of labour and the assertion that heterosexual, monogamous 'sex-love" is the natural and op timum state of sexual relations are just two ex- amples of this. Much of his anthropological evidence, particularly on the existence of the matriarchy and the fact that male dominance has been found in some pre-class, pre-state societies lacking true private property, has since been brought into question or superceded in such a way as to require a substantial

reworking of his conclusions.

However, Engels provides the

solid foundations for any marxist

analysis of the origins of women's op-

pression.

While all the anthropological

evidence militates against the exist-

ence of a matriarchy even in the most

dim and distant past, it clearly shows

that whereas in the first class socicties

(for example slave societies) patriar-

chy was already established, there is

no evidence for it in primitive com-

munistic societies. These societies

were based on egalitarianism and in-

terdependence, and were organised in

very loose and extended kinship

groups that traced descent through the

mother's line.

It was in those social formations

existing before the first class societies

but after primitive communism that

male dominance first arose. Specifi-

cally, it was the combination of "kin

corporate property" (where property

was owned collectively by a kinship

group) which emerged with the series

of transformations known as the

neolithic revolution, and the growth of

patrilocality (a kinship system where

the wife goes to live with the

husband's kin group after marriage)

that created the preconditions for the development of male dominance.

Patrilocality came to be the predominant form of social organisation, supplanting matrilocal and other kinship systems, for several reasons. The determining factor, however, was that because of the greater value of women's labour and reproduction in pre- plough agricultural systems, patrilocal societies had a greater potential for expansion, were more economically dynamic, and so came to be the predominant form of social or- ganisation.

It was indeed this economic dimension, in tandem with the very practical effects of a woman leaving her own kinship group and moving to live in the kinship group of her hus- band, that meant that patrilocality led to male domination. And once patrilocality was wide- ly established, the old matrilineal method of descent and inheritance become unsustainable and incompatible with the emerging forms of social organisation. Instead a patrilineal sytem of inheritance was introduced and fed still fur- ther the dynamic towards patriarchy and private property that had produced it.

In this way the subordination of women

Page 28

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec Jan 1989-90

← Is the family in crisis? · Do German Greens have working class roots? →

Something wrong on this page?