Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Do German Greens have working class roots?

· Socialist Outlook no. 20, December–January 1990 · pp 31-32 · 2,108 words

Ecology

DEBATE

laid the foundation for the emergence of private property and SO social classes. However, although the oppression of women precedes the development of private property. once set in motion the dynamics of gender op pression and other social differentiations are entwined. The oppression of women provided a means of differential appropriation among men, which in tum gave some men special ac- cess to the labour and reproductive power of women, as well as to the services of other men.

The privatisation of property ran alongside an alteration in the form of the family unit. The loose associations that existed within the collectivist environment of patrilocality were stabilised and broken up into smaller, tighter units as property became increasingly private property.

Patrilocality eventually gave way to patriarchy, institutionalised through the fami- ly. Male dominance became structurally em- bedded in society. It is a gradual, but powerful process by which such changes are formalised and ideologised in a systematic way.

Clearly then women's labour provided the material basis for a complex of interrelated processes that ended in their subordination to men and the cleavage of society into social classes. Ruling classes emerged that controlled the production of society as a whole. The ex- ploitation of women gave way to class ex- ploitation as the primary motor of social development. But this change did not sudden- ly free women from their oppression but dragged it deeper and deeper into a complex and ever shifting pattern of subordination and domination.

The search for origins begun by Engels and pursued with such ardour by successive generations of socialists and feminists is not merely an academic exercise, or intellectual self-indulgence. It is a crucial part of under- standing the situation facing women today and formulating a realistic strategy for liberation.

For, as Stephanie Coontz and Peta Hender- son say in their contribution to the book Women's Work. Men's Property, *Anthropology and history offer no justifica- tion for the opposition some political activists make between the struggle against class and the struggle against patriarchy. Rather, they underline the fact that class and gender ine- qualities are historically and materially in- separable.

However, the factor that is omitted from a discussion about origins and which is over- looked by Marx and Engels in their works concerning women - in a way that is not over- looked in their other writings - is the subjec- tive factor. The central importance of women's struggle for their own liberation has been clearly demonstrated by more recent events, and central to the programme and political ac- tivity of revolutionary marxists today.

Rebecca Flemming

German Greens: no

roots in the working

class?

Issues 18 and 19 of Socialist Outlook have carried discussion articles on the emergence of green politics and its significance for socialists. Continuing the debate, HANS-JURGEN SCHULZ presents a critique of the politics and organisation of the longest-running and strongest of the Green parties.

Many people think that the Green Party in West Germany is a socialist or at least a radi- cal party with a strong socialist current and influence in the working class. However this is not the view of the Greens themselves.

All of the currents of the Greens point out that their party does not belong to the workers" movement, because 'left socialism and the workers movement have failed (declaration of the former left" central leadership).

According to Rudolf Bahro, when he was the main theoretician of the party, the Greens do not represent "special social interests", but are the "organ of all common interests'. Even radical eco-socialists in the party agreed. Ac- cording to Jutta Difurth, the Greens are "not a left party, but a party which tolerates left politics". Ebermann argues that "It is absurd to transform the Greens into a socialist party*.

To understand the rise and the political character of this party we have to understand its class base.

Rise of the intelligentsia

In the last thirty years the intelligentsia has become an important sector of society. _ 2.4 million attend colleges (Oberschulen) or universities, and 4 million have academic degrees. Those with formal education do not constitute a class or even a single layer: among them are capitalists (owners of important com- panies) and the bourgeois intel- ligentsia (leading personnel of com- panies and the state apparatus, and the self-employed, like lawyers or physicians) numbering 800,000: there is a salaried intelligentsia of some 1.5 million, composed of the leading and lower echelons of com- panies and the state apparatus and specialists (engineers. architects, teachers).

These are privileged, earning more than double the income of a worker, and their working conditions

are far better. In ideological terms many of them adhere to elitist and corporatist views, while others are democrats or reformists. But the chances of a career in these sectors are very limited.

The crisis since the 1970s hit not this es- tablished sector of the intelligentsia but the young. Many of them did not get these privileged positions but had to take what jobs were offered to them. Others were for a long time unemployed, and set up 'alterative" in- dividual projects, running pubs, craft shops or other services. These all formed a new proletarianised intelligentsia, which is usually oppositional-minded and progressive. These people, including social service workers (hospitals, kindergardens, etc, altogether some 800,000) and many teachers and stu- dents make up the social base of the Greens.

Unlike workers, who collectively ex- perience daily conflict with capital, and develop a nearly instinctive collective and trade unionist consciousness, the proletarianised intelligentsia thinks in ex- tremely individualistic terms. They have no common social interests. Their criticisms may be very sharp, but are usually without serious conclusions. They have no idea of an alterative society, and

coherent programme other than a bundle of often very fine proposals on this or that.

Sometimes they take the road of radical struggle, even bloody clashes with the police; some caucuses even call for armed struggle in the big cities. But soon their hopes are dashed and they relapse into sub-cultural as- sociations, Not only conservative, but even mystical and magical ideas are spreading. All but a few show an individualistic scom for

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90

Page 29

DEBATE

organisations, or reject discipline in the organisations they have formed. This

proletarianised progressive intelligentsia was the base of the so-called social move- ments (ecology, peace, women) from which the Green Party has sprouted.

Members and voters

The Green Party was founded in 1979 as a bloc between conservatives, nationalists and even reactionaries on the one side and independent left wingers, socialists and communists on the other. They agreed on a radical-sounding but in reality flexible programme. The result of this compromise was brutal faction-fight- ing, which ended with the majority of the conservatives and reactionaries splitting off, while the majority of the left moved towards liberal positions.

Today the party has at most 45,000 members (compared to Social Democrats and Christian Democrats with around 1 million each); most Green Party members are teachers, social workers or proletarianised

Green theoretician Rudolf Bahro

the Greens, most activists from the move-

intellectuals, with very few workers or trade unionists. Only 10,000 members are active - of whom more than 3,000 are as members of parliaments of all levels, while most of the rest are active in giving them assistance. This is why at the rank and file level there is a complete lack of political discussion, with debates concentrated around special technical and tactical questions.

•It is a culture of specialists and intellectuals", complains one of the Green Icaders, a culture which excludes all others. There are now 1,500 full-timers, either as parliamentarians or party employees: these constitute an informal but decisive and un- controlled apparatus. It is they, and not the few active members, who make Green Party policy.

A look at the social base of the Green vote is very instructive. Nearly 60 per cent of sup- porters are under 30, and 70 per cent come from the intelligentsia (including students). Only a tenth of the votes come from workers, and in working class districts the Greens usually get less than 5 per cent. Only one Green voter in seven defines his/herself as a left winger.

Programme and politics

The image of the Greens as a left party is not unfounded - but not the whole truth. Politically they are consistent democrats, anti-imperialists, defenders of the rights of women (their leading positions and par- liamentary fractions must be composed of at least 50 per cent women; their representatives in the Hamburg parliament are all women) and minorities; they back the peace move- ment, ecologists and anti-fascists. But be- cause of their lack of active members and the low level to which Green activists identify with their party, they are not visibly present in all these movements. Radical conscious- ness is formed by the movements and not by

ments do not join the Green Party.

Of course there are socialists among the Greens. But there are also eco-liberals who are conservative or reactionary. They deny the necessity of a programme of mass ac- tivism. To save the environment they call for a lowering of living standards, and the break- up of the "state monopoly of welfare'. Their main support is in southem Germany.

Dominant are the so-called "realos" (realistic politicians), who define their posi- tion as a party of the centre, and their aim as an ecological capitalism. They are reformists only in the sense that they are for a better functioning of the present system, They argue that the social and ecological problems are

not due to capitalism or bureaucratic "socialism" but modem technology and in- dustrialisation. They are ideal parliamen- tarians: in the last session of the federal Bundestag they had five percent of the seats but made a third of all proposals for new legislation, and put 50 per cent of the demands on the govemment for information. This was very admirable: but not one of their proposals was accepted.

They are interested in the contamination of milk, but not poisonous gases at the workplace; in the death of the forests, but not battles for the 35 hour week or defence of jobs in the steel industry. They are not anti- capitalists, and not interested in any alliance with the workers" movement, which is quite alien to them.

If Greens are accepted as partners in a coalition they become very responsible, and in reality a junior partner with no real in- fluence. Some years ago in Hessia they dropped all their ecological proposals; now it is the same in West Berlin.

Declining socialist current

The majority of German maoists and centrists took part in the foundation of the

Page 30

Green Party or quickly joined it. Their aim was to form a socialist wing, to radicalise the Greens and transform them into a socialist or even a revolutionary party. They failed com- pletely, because they could not develop a socialist policy, only a series of radical demands in green clothing. For a long time this enabled them to swam into the leading bodies of the new party; but the real policy was being formulated in the parliamentary fractions, and here the socialists were in a declining minority.

As a radical, democratic, but bourgeois party, the Greens attracted radical (and often not-so-radical) democratic non-socialists, so the old left cadres were swamped by the new- comers, who were not educated in the socialist way. This was compounded by the pressures from the "realism' of parliamentary life and personal ambitions. Last year the socialists lost their majority in all leading party bodies, except for their last stronghold in Hamburg.

A survey in 1987 showed that of the 300 leaders (members of parliament in Boon and in the states, and the central and state leader- ships of the party) only one in six was a former member of a revolutionary organisa- tion, while at least half were now 'realos".

This year the socialist remnants in the Green Party split. The radical wing (Jutta Dit- furth, Ebermann, Trampert) lost their last hopes for a radical policy with the Greens. Formally they still remain in the party, but they are calling publicly for the founding of a new one, and are engaging in discussions with revolutionaries and former stalinists.

The other wing is the left forum', a loosely organised group which includes the former trotskyists of the 'Horizonte" group. which dissolved itself last August. This forum may have more than 100 activists and 300 sympathisers: but it is too small and too diverse to change the character of the Green Party.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 20, Dec-Jan 1989-90

← Nothing 'natural' about women's oppression · Namibia forced to walk the tightrope →

Something wrong on this page?