NEWTECHNOLOGY
32
THE RECENT announcement of a further 1,500 joh losses at the Scout Lithgow shipyards on the Lower Clyde and the evenmal
at the •eventuall latest in al
serics of major blows to traditional industrics and consequently employment levels in Scotland. Scotland, however, need nor fear industrial decline and decay, according to the Scotrish
sequents Deer • Scotrish
Development Agency (sna):
It is indicative of the Scottish narure that a country which
for years led the world in the heavy industries of steel work and
shipbuilding is now at the forefront of new technologies. Today.
after 30 years of research and development, Scotland is the base for many internationally renowned electronics companies, The
skills which once triumphed in the days of heavy engincering
have been redirected into the areas of semiconductors, informa-
tion systems, defence and industrial electronics... The Agency
believes that the capacity of the clectronics industry to create
sidina.
have been redirected into the areas of semiconductors, informa- tion systems, defence and industrial electronics... The Agency believes that the capacity of the clectronics industry to create wealth is a crucial factor in the economic regencration of Scotland and its desclopment is therefore a fundamenral compo-
ramental compo-
nent of our strategy uperarica ski rochasingine arma
The she presents a picture of extensive job creation,
* 011 iram of the arr
technologies from overscas multinarionals; yer there are doubts
over the clectronics industry's ahility to provide new jobs in
significant numbers or even to sustain existing jobs. Worse.
there is little evidence of any great upgrading of skills within the
industry; and there is little indication that Scottish firms are
making any inroads into the more advanced, high-rech and pro- sperous sectors of the industry, which are dominated by large.
The sne also place great emphasis on the reliability and co-operation of the Scomish workforce, arguing
technologies from overscas multinarionals; yer there are doubts over the clectronics industry's ahility to provide new jobs in significant numbers or even to sustain existing jobs. Worse. there is little evidence of any great upgrading of skills within the
that there are few labour problems in Scottish electronics. Yet many companies in the industry do not recognise trade unions,
and are under no pressure from the agency to do so. Workers'
*an
flexibility.
workforce artuing tush ectronic. Yer
de muonis.
Vorkk.
sognise tra
probiems are highlighted by the fact that uccording to the sna those companies which do recognise trade unions have few criticisms of trade union activities; on the contrary, many com-
panies have welcomed the co-operation of the trade unions -
even where that has meant the breaking down of traditional
craft demarcation in the quest for flexibility, acceptance of the
use of secondary labour (on the promise of protection for the
primary labour), short term working and so forth.
Electronics appears to be the home of the new realism" in industrial relations in Scotland — a far cry from the traditional image of Red Clydeside: Electronics companies certainly play an important role in providing employment in Scotland, par- ticularly jobs for women; but what are the facts behind the hype of the development agencies? Trade unions with workers direct- ly or indirectly employed in the industry, should be aware of the direction of its development.
Since todav's electronics industry itself is the destination of much of its own most sophisticated production, we must look at the possible effects of changes in technologies on employment levels, skills and unionisation
In many respects, the very idea of the electronics industry
craft demarcation in the quest for flexibility, acceptance of the
reaking "evihilit
Electronics appears to be the home of the new realism" in
Since todav's electronics industry itself is the destination of
80188018880 500
*=nange
whole exhibiting similar misleading. The industry roughly splits up into six sectors:
waty respe
sesit- Consumer, 2.5% Subcontract, 7.5% Information systems, 22.5%
imilar
ICULTURIES
= six sc
marine
Semi-conductors and other components, 17.5%
Industrial, Commercial and
Fach of these sectors is quite distinctive:
Defence Electronics, 25.0%
Industrial, Commercial and Telecommunications, 25.0%.
• Defence electronics dates back to the establishment of Fer- ranti in Edinburgh shortly after the second world war. This sec- tor is dominated by a few large British companies (for obvious rcasons), and is similar in many respects to many parts of tradi- tional manufacturing industry. The work requires a large pro- portion of skilled designers, engineers, programmers and craft workers - consequently there are few women workers in the
apan #isn
ogran
ament of Fe war. This sec narts of tradi- ners and cralt
orkers in th-
• industr.
poses new challenges for the labour movement. JANE McCORMACK argues that
unions must attend to the needs of women
workers in particular as part o
a strategy for
the industry.
defence sector. In recent years rapid technological change has affected the role of skilled craftspeople by promoting moves
The industrial, commercial and telecommunications sector
28003 223la0!
TEE allo
HAS SUDDENE
contains a mix of British and foreign owned companics, and older and newer firms, although older firms predominam; employment levels have fallen substantially with automation. Skill levels vary, with women a large proportion
• Information systems and semiconductors are dominated by large (mainly US) companies, and it is in this sector that we see many of the alternatives to traditional mangement practices and industrial relations. Skills have become more divided in recent years, between programmers and designers on one hand, and
S8E**)10**
of the
many semi-skilled — mainly women - workers on the other
Subcontracting and consumer clectronics involve small. mainly Scottish firms, carrying out mostly semi skilled assembly
However, most of the sectors have one feature in cotion: falling employment levels. With the possible exception of semiconductors and subcontracting, cach of the sectors is on a downward trend in employment from a peak of 49.000 jobs in 1970. The most widely quoted figures tell us that 42,000 people are employed in clectronics in Scorland, that is. 9.9% of all
SOCIALIST OUT:OOK no:2
manufacruring employment. about these figures for two reasons:
All
they are likely to be optimistic;
However, we must be cautious • All published figures come from the sna and the Scottish Office, and given their interest in selling the industry abroad.
Electronics has increased as a proportion of manufacturing
but also due to
employment in traditional dustries. In the decade from 1970 to 1980 cmployment in the in-
not only due to new electronics employment.
dustry fell by more than 10,000, u net decrease of 225. was nor solely a Scottish phenomenon — job lusses occurred in the industry in Britain as a whole and in Europe. Rationalisa- tion, alonside a general economic recession and a world over- penduction of mier-circuits were a stringent reminder that cler- unics is not exempt from technological and market changes.
The growth in employment from the carly 1980s onwards is mainly due to the influx of semiconductor fabrication companies
large increases in investment in semiconductor production will lead to fewer jobs than similar expansion would have brought a few years ago, and since 1985 there have been reports of a slowlown in semiconductor production, with layofis, redundan- cies and complusory shutdowns taking place in the lin and in
What is tost common across all of the sectors is the trend towards the replacement of labour by automated production, bringing furtlier loss of both jobs and skills. Mangement argue of course that in order to compete in the world market it is con- tinually necessary to keep up with "state of the art lechnology. Whatever that may cost in terms of jobs losses and skills. Conse. quentiy, in many companies there is a conflict of interest bet ween the design and development jobs (mainly held by men)
SUBLELS WE
w onwards ex
like Motorola and National Semiconductors.
™Ven
production will
sport. at a ..... -din
DHAT
ML.... Further, in many companies there is a trend towards pur-
and the mainly female production or assembly jubs.
keeping only highly skilled corc functions within the
chasing the same product at a lower price elsewhere
research, however, has shown a rather different picture. While only a small numher of electronics plants are unionised (which is
workforce in Sectrish electronics work in companics where trade
magnient
UK manufacturing as a whole.
this is nor so surprising — one quarter of electronics employment is in defence, which has been (up until
ting our peripheral, less skilled activities to subcontractors.
plant. The savings arise because subcontract companics tend to offer wages and conditions which are vastly inferior to those of fered for the same work in the large companies. Large producers are thus able to reduce their own employment costs while pur-
Until recently, many people assumed that the cicctronies
industry was a barren arra for trade union recruitment. Recent
research, however, has shown a rather different picture. While
only a small numher of electronics plants are unionised (which is
Britain as a whole), almost two thinds of the
workforce in Sectrish electronics work in companics where trade
unions are recognised. This figure is roughly similar to that for
research also true for
parcat
Un
now ar least)
this is nor so surprising — one quarter of dominated by unionised, skilled craftwarkers.
ch has been (up unt skilled crattwarkers
Similarly, many of the plants which are now classed as elec-
arr
tronics planes were once mechanical engineering firms, which tended no he unionised, and which in the transition from electro- mechanical to electronic production processes, have retained
The split between unionised and non-unionised plants is
o related to the nationality of companies and the date of their
location in Scutland. The bastions of non-unionism are the semiconductor industry (which is US-dominated and non-union worldwide), large American
systems arcise (like 14M and culet-Packard) and the seviller
Scottish companies involued in sub-contracting and component
These sectors present major problems for the labour move- ment. Not only are their current employees not unionised, but employment in the non-unionised plants is growing three times
ment problem is likely to be exacerbated in the future rather
which electro-
Information the smaller tailotito)
faster than employment in the unionised plants. than overcome, unless serious attempts are made to organise these plants, The smaller size and more recent establishment of the Scottish companies has uffected the ability and desire of SOCIALIST OUTLOOK 102 July/Augur 1987
but The recruit
1 at Прете rif
unions to organise them. However, the less favourabic terms
and conditions they offer provide potential opportunities for
(CITI
On the other hand, the large American companies involved in computer and chip production have been in many respects
succeseful in "buying off, unionisation. no lay-off policy where possible, pay higher wages and salaries than other firms in the arca, offer substantial financial and non financial bencfits, offer single status working conditions (same toilets and canteens for management and workers), and en-
red They tend to operate a
courage management to be more flexible and responsive to the needs of the workers (or employees, as they prefer to call them). On many issues, these companies are willing to offer in excess of what the trade unions are able to gain. Where few opportunities
which offers the same pay and conditions, most workers will not mck the boat by struggling for trade union recognition.
strug:
the part of the unions holds little attraction.
represenration. In many big electronics companies, employee represenration and grievance and disciplinary lelt to individuals, with the workers having little support in any conflict with mangement.
The uninns may be better rewarded if they stress their representation role futher; and also if they take up some major
A purcly wages-and-conditions approach to recruitment on fruitful avenues for advance, not least in terms of collective represenration. In many big electronics companies, employee
tundus
CCUUTE
me
210
issues which they appear to have ignored. In the Usa and Canada, gains in organising clectronice workers have been made around fights on health and safety. In Scotland, fights on health and safety are noticeable by their absence. Yet wubsran- tial evidence exists that electronics production involves the use of high levels of carcenogenic substances, which cause short term illnesses and can be fatal in the long term.
There is another important issuc which must be tackled if unions are to make any advances in Scottish electronics. As
-van
pointed out earlier, many semi-skilled electronics workers are women. Some of them have been far from passive, as the oc- cupation of the Plessey plant in Bathgate in 1981 showed.
However, many companies scek out young women with no previous industrial experience in order to pre-empt trade union
To overcome this, the unions must actively com mit themselves to the needs of women workers. This means a
break from the past: as one trade union official pointed out: It's harder to organise women, they don't go to the pub at lun- chtime and talk about terms and conditions." Maybe the unions should be recruiting outside Tesco's ar lunch breaks?
The unions must face up to new problems too:
employment in electronics is falling, there are some new jobs be employmentin clectronic.m ing created, mainly as technicians. If semi-skilled women are to have any access to these jobs, they need their trade union to campaign for their retraining in the necessary skills at the com- pany s expense.
This means opposing any management at-
tempts preferentially to allocate these jobs to men, most ob- temper preferentialls
viously the time-served craftsmen whose skills are becoming in- viouslv the time-served
creasingly redundant in the industry, This could mean a real creasinglv no undant in conflier between porential or actual union members.
.... members.
The unions have failed to present any coherent response to
The unic
the challenges of the industry. While in principle other unions
challenge
are unhappy with the collaborationist strategy adopted by the
Bam, they can see few alternatives. Most have adopted the Wairing for a Labour government' strategy — as if this would
enen witn Tit F trade union
At run-
viously the time-served craftsmen whose skills are becoming in-
the incusri
• altopted by the
adopted the
if this would
do anything to resolve the crisis of the industry.
Of course, the straregy is suspect in another respect -
semi-skilled production jobs are rapidly being automated out of existence, with job losses unchallenged in most cases by any form of collective working class resistance. The jobs which are left will be even more difficult to unionise. The problem is not only one of recruitment — it requires that the unions, having
OICIR as nC ane lbwving
achieved recognition rights, do something for their members. If the unions wait too long, the problem will be solved for them. and the opportunity for labour to influence the future develop- ment of what is and will continue to be a crucially important in-
them. velop ant in-
Ip