Dear comrades, John Turkie's article in Socialist Outlook No. 1, 'Anti- zionism and anti-semitism.
particularly pernicious error. To be sure, sections of the zionist leadership may have played a despicable role in
relation to the fight against
anti-semitism. How many
movements does John Turkie
inadvertantly highlights the
ease with which anti-zionism
can slip into concessions to anti-semitism, rather than proving his intended objective
of showing a clear difference between the two. The article is spattered with dangerously wrong propositions which are grist to the mill to anti-
nwing
sartisan character of Judassm,
15 8
dia Marx himself (On the Jewish
'The primarils commercia! and kritage of a long historical past.
This is a nomon which sadly
Queition) and which, if followed
Vil does in thar text, leads to the conclusion that socialists ought to be fundamenrally opposed
through Iogically, as Marx to Judaism "because of its
petty bourgeuis essence". stupidity of this proposition becomes clear later on in Joln Turkie's article, when, in
arguing against a racial definition of Judaism (and T
agree with him on that) he
demonstrates the enormous micrsits
cannot conceivably have an cconomic homogencity any more than a racial homogeneity:
support which have leaderships or lendencies within it whose
hands are dirry and bloody -
many, I'm sur. But on the
ground zionists have been struggles, often laying down
On the been
actively involved in such their lives.
uch ahe dow
John Turkie is correct to say
that there is. ultimately, a defearise logic in the zionist position. What he refuses to
understand is that logic las been imposed by a vast history
4E 301131
reactionary ideas of a few monist philosophers and
Iraders. History seems to be reaching Jews that, wherever we go and whatever we.do. we
have no guarantee of survival
After all, other peoples have been wiped out entirely in
history. Clearly we should stand up and fight for our rights throughout the world,
Stop burying
yourselves in the
Labour Party!
Looking specifically at the context in which John Turkic is making his claim — european Jewry in the period Jeading up to the rise of fascism, we see a wide diversity in the cconomic position in which Jews were to be found. The commercial character of Judaism' is an anti-semitic myth: John Turkie should know better:
Zzonzim capitulates to anti- semitism"
"Acconding to zionim. rather than waste time in a futile fight
Comrade.
Lister is like watching a small
child playing with building
bricks - all the bricks are
there, he touches most of them
bur fails to construct anything The piece he co-wrore with
Phil Hearse in the opening
issuc of Socialist Outlook is no different.
Reading articles by John
Endless academic articles
thar claim "... to provide the kind of analytical and political apprach that is vital for the coming battles against the
hureaucracy" are no substitute for understanding the dynamics of the "various wings and layers' of that
od Dur tal
against anti-semitem, Jews should simply emigrate to a Jeanse
homeland'
There is an ambiguity bere as to whether john Turkie is
saying that the logical conclusion of zionist principles is to abandon the fight against
Much of the article was taken up with bald facts without any attempt at understanding how the left or the working class have arrived at the situation that they are now in. Yet withour knowing
the histonical background it is
anti-semitism or whether he is saying that zionists actually do always abandon this struggle.
IF he means the latter, he is simply wrong and this is a SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/August 1987
KnOW Sunc
ibli.
secure sanctuary dues scem to
be a wise precaution. Ir is the desire for such sanctuary which forms the basis of
zionism's near hegemony of Jewish polinics. Revolutionary ancialism has vet to offer a convincing alterative to satisty that desire.
"The specife feature of sionion websch distinguishes it from all ozter modern settler colonisation
after all, preciscly why they are there! The imperialist powers for whom they are electively a colonial proxy are countries with which most Israelis have no historical connection whatsoever.
This crucial difference
between Israclis and other
colonial peoples dues not
alleviate the plight of the
Palestinian people one iota. It does, however, have profound implications for their national
nos
... Tora
motements is that it wanted.
The indigenous prople were not therefore to be explasted, but totally replaced."
These features are by no means unique to zionist
the
Pass
of North America, Australia
and New Zealand was similar, only in these cases, the colonialists engaged in a policy
ul outright genocide rather than displacement and dispossession.
There is, however, a unique feature of zionist colunisation which John Turkie omits to
the colonial
mention peoples du nor have an imperialist homeland. The absence of any homcland is.
liberation struggle, both in terms of defining objectives and in how it can be
successfully prosecuted
1 am not a zionist. My
opposition to zionism rests
primarily on the terrible
suffering inflicted upon the
Palestinian people by zionist
colonisation and then by the
Isracli state itself. John Turkie
is doing no favours for the Palestinian people by
an itse
EM SUBAI!
ideas taken, however for Jews either.
unconsciously, from the world of anti-semitic myth. Needleess
to say, he is doing no favours
Dave Landau, London
difficult to assess anything for the future. The historical hackground of the Labour Party and the fate of socialists within it is there for all to see
It is only by looking ar the
origins and history of the Labour Party that we can
The fact is that despite its undeniable organic link with
the working class (via the trade unions) the Lahour
idear
Party, frum its inceprion has neser been even a mouthpicce
for militant working class
aspirations and any socialist
thar has stood by working class
It is clear to all but the most
pur
will always be the case. How can it be any different when
the whole machine is geared to the parliamentary road ro reformism? To try and make
the whole machine is geared to the parliamentary road ro reformism? To try and make the Labour Party a socialist
and expecting it to travel by man even if you change the driver it simply isn't going to
The Lister/Hearse article admits that it is possible that
BLE
•assible 11
socialists will "sock solutions outside the (Labour) Party'
.. this is a ney do not sain why this is
srubier..
It is easy to claim to be a
revolutionary socialist, and
with a good education you can write miles of polemics, but to BE a revolutionary you must shink in terras of organising a fighthack that is based firmly in the working class.
The alternatives are quite
clear then: stop being a
revolutionary or come outside
the Labour Party. No amount
of pedantic pontification can
alter that basic fact.
Some good class fighters will continue to bury themselves in
the warmth of the Labour Party and many sectarian
academics will carry on their
and fusing. Meanwhile I shalt continue to help build a fighting socialist organisation - the Socialist Workers"
210325
D. Ham London
5