Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Debating Gorbachev's proposals

· Socialist Outlook no. 2, July–August 1987 · p 8 · 1,205 words

Russia and the USSR War and peace Stalinism Labour Party

PEACE

END CONVENTION

The only people impressed by slick advertis ing and media coverage were the advertisen

and the media people themselves. The whole

idea of mose of the same with some oppor-

tunist jettisoning of unpopular policies like anti-nuclear peace policies, must be resisted. After all we already have one Tory party - who needs another? The only way to con- vince the 'middle ground" is to step up extra- parliamentary activity to show them that you mcan what you say. To flatter and parronise people cynically means you get treated with

The major issue ar the convention will be Gorbachev's disarmament proposals. There will be different views on what the atritude of

and those who

THERE HAS BEEN a creative tension at all END conventions between those who believe

below

the contempr you deserve

peace convention takes place in

Coventry this summer from 14

latter stress

The sixth END international

ilv. Over

towards them. are experted trom over

..000 peace

the western peace muvement shmald be

Aiready there have been threats of splits in the END international liaison committee over approaches to the of

dialogue with those polirical, trade union or other leaders who have state puwer. access to

stare power or expectations of state power.

In the early 1980s, the Europcan peace movements grew in protest ar the planned deployment of cruise missiles. Peace camps like those at Greenham Common in the UK

opportunity for us to find out

gruups — whether.

30 countries. This is a unique

ficial peace movements of castern Europe as

compared to the dissident independent peace

how and where cach should be invited to spcak. It will be very in- teresting to assess from informed contribu- rions cartly what is happening 118 the Stalinist states and how far glassost" is a real or a cosmetic exercise. From pass con- ventions those who want to make the western

into cheet leaders for soviet peace policies will be treated with

need for political

what is really happening in

deployment of cruise missiles. Peace camps like those at Greenham Common in the UK and Comiso in Sicily caught the imagina-

Links were forged with the women's movement, with national liberation strug

different countries. Previous

conventions have been held in

orussels. Wrst Berlin. Pe

gles, with dissident groups in the Stalinist states, with ecological and third world con- cerns, The principle of detente from helnw

iterdam and E

peace movements

- Nex

convention will be in Sweden. Here DAVE SPENCER,

seepricism.

There is a glaring

With the arrival of cruise in Enropean bases, many peace activisee saw the need to take a more traditional, political road and put pressure on the mass parties. The con- cept of detente from above has guined

main

'nor "e the local l

answers in the peace movement hased on the principles of 'derente from below and in dependence from the mass parties of social democracy and Stalinism. should of course work with and within these parties but we should not tone down our pro- gramme on their say so. Our priority must be direct action and solidarity with the op- presend. As Karl Tribknecht said in world war one, 'the only way to peace is by uniting the oppressed against the oppressors and, again, that 'the chief oppressor of the prople is in its own country

Unfortunately the bureaucracies of social democracy and Sralinism have too often in the past became part of that oppression. And therein lies the problem with detente from above'. For the sake of short-term alliances and influence with these burcaucracies, it g nores or prevents direct action by the up- pressed. In the contest of the peace move-

intion organısin:

Peace activists

problem here however, that the leaderships of the Euro- pean socialist and Stalinist parties have tried lo control and to usc the western peace movements for their own purposes. Perhaps the most obvious example was Gonzales'

which lought a

general clection on the hasis of "ao to NATO

«'kgro has beeti,

committee, gives some

nd

expected to be discussed.

the French chair of the convention was mor

ed to say perhaps we shwuld keep Audrey as

a hostage here in France to make sure that

the promises are kept

The convention is in Britian this year and

must inevitably conduct i post-mortem en

the general clertion and the role of the Labour Party and the CND leaders, There is

a major credibility gap between the en-

then promptly switched its position during

Another ob-

otten in- nic trum siliances

vious cxample is the strategy of the Soviet and Warsaw pact governments to influence the western peace movements either directly or through their agents in the leaderships of the western communist parties: It is hardly

a major credibility gap between the en-

thusiasm declared by most CNI) leaders for

the Labour Party's defence policy and the

actual presentation of the policy by Kinnuck

non-nuclear

15:

hent on self-destruction.

•SY SETER

Timer And afer the cection? Who knows? Even 1be Lahnur l'arty campaign was a failure

surprising that the most radical clements in the European peace movemenrs have been the Greens and even church groups like pax christi who are not prepared to surrender in dependence or direct action for short term gains;

Among peace activists there is a healthy scepticism rowards social democratic and Stalinisc Icaderships. This was shown last year at the Evry convention, where Aisdrey Wise, speaking on behalf of the NEC of the British Labour Parry, promised a Labour government in 1987 with a full-hlnwn anti nuciear policy The majority of British delegates applauded enthusiastically: the rest ot the convention looked on silently Al Hungarian Independent tiest to me said *oh, 1 undentand. this is befor the dection.

no the upi A 33P.

maron oftle poli

and cu. The debate during the clertion was low key and stressed commitment to NATO and to increasing conventional weaponry

ment I take the oppressed to include all those who feel alienated, terrified and angry in the face of nuclear weapons and nuclear power over which they have no control. It is a feel- ing, hased of course on the reality of the in- ternational balance of class forces that the world is like the Titanic caprured by people

In the first section of the transitional pro- gramme of the fourth international Trotsky

without a socialist revolution in the next historical period. a catastrophe threatens the whole culture of humanity. "The historical crisis of humanity is roduced to the crisis of the revolutionary

This was written in 1938 before the horror nE nuclear warfare, it is a thousand times

SOCIALIST OUTDOK no 2 July/Augur. 1987

before anything anri-nuclear. The Financial

defence policy parr of the Labour manifesto, *it has been toned down to the point where it is almost an apologetic foomote

commented Party policy

the

Worse still was the Labour Party's in- sistence on silence and inactivity from its pur the matter sharply. supporters, Trade union leaders called off industrial and strike action because of the election. The CND leadership rancelled the Essex CND May 15 demonstration and made no public criticism whatsnever of the labour leadership

le must be stated londly and clearly thar

more truc in 1987

← Letters · Testing the Tories' plans for schools →

Something wrong on this page?