edi torial of 3 June says 'an Assembly will not transmure base metal into golas this is obviously so. But it certainly can transform the political situation in Scotland and become the focus of op- position to Thatcher. That's why the Tories will only concede an Assembly under the pressure of a massive Labour-led campaign. Limiting in ad- vance the powers of that Assembly, therefore will cupperLabour's chances of building effective opposi tion to the Tories.
Does establishing an Assembly
mean taking the fust step towands the
"slippery slope of separation? Yes and
no: the narth/south divide doesn't run
parallel with the Scottish/English paraller barder. Not only are there no Tory
MPs in Glasgow - they've also been MP:/mitasgs kicked our of Liverpool, Manchester and Newcastic. A Scottish Assembly that organised rexistance to the Torics would be likely to gain increasing sup-
port from the English labour move- ment.
the nottin»
land..
The alternative for Labour in Scot-
land is to sit it out despite having five out of every seven MPs. The left in the
Party must make sure that, if the leadership gocs for this option, they
commit political micide themselves
and don't take the rest of us with them.
This means quite simply that the left
must become the most consistent ad-
vocates of a Scottish parliament that
Pan. leadership gocs for this option, they
anu won t take the This means quur must become Inc vocate - tellects the aspirations of the elec-
-the cle. torate. The powers of this body and its
pody and in relationship to Westminster are ques tiuns thar must: or settled: democras tically in the cause of political struggle. not decided in advance by the Exccut- ive of the Scottish Labour Party:
The thousand and one problems raised by the constitution of a Scottish
« a Srottish Assembry must www. he-stand.asan excuse for fudging and manoeuvre to oppose campaigning for it, or to side- track the issue into a Royal Commis sion. Labour fought this campaign as the only party capable of providing a Scottish assembly (Neil Kinnock, Do- maid Dewar, et all and thcy should not be aided in their attempts to wrigele out of this commitment by confused elements on the political left, who arc "not interested in Scottish devolution, but British revolution". Kinnock and Dewar must be kept to their word. They have the legitimacy to demand an Assembly and organise a campaign to force the Tories 10 concede it.
Those who reject this position, those who raise xpurious arguments about the abatract unity of the British labour movement, or the need to build an alternative to Labour, or the sover- cignty of Westminster being sacro- sanct, are in effect the same people who are prepared to Ict Thatcher. rule the roost unchallenged for the next five years when the basis for a real chal- lenge has emerged in Scotland Jim Niblock & Tony Southall
SOCIALST OUTLOOK no 2 July/August 1987
shi~ goi
aslini.an-
ISIDA
ation torate. The powers of this body and its
E C TE there are now no
I dozens of scats in the north did not yield carra sears, bur the crushing of the Tories in northern industrial towns was remarkable:
Tory MPs ar all in Manchester, New- castle, Glasgow, Liverpool and Lei-
The results in Liverpool, where the anti-Militant crusade had been enorinuus, were striking. Militant MP Terry Fields substantially increased
Me ei 33t3i0101 130
a focus o' oppos... In thesc arcas ar least the Labour
their campaign than did Labour. The Alliance had more women candidares than the Labour Party (although of
campaign was able to mobilise an enormous rejection of Thatcherism. inner-city constituencies, like Perk-
de Lar course a lot fewer elected): made speci- obilise fic proposals to boost women's rights
- for example they proposed that all
public bodies should have 50 per cent
However, in some of the
ике women on them within ten years; and
culls held one of their morning
cies, the voter turnout was only in the
region of 55 percent, as opposed to a
very uniform national rate of around
the
his majority in Broad Green. Pat Wall won Bradford North from the Tories.
region of 55 percent, as opposed to a
despite his association with Militant. elections to the Labour NEC, nine per cont swing in his favour in Liverpol Walton, taking nearly 65
were
Eric Heffer, deleated in last year's
areas the Labour
substantially in-
creased, and Alan Meale even won in
where
'the arithmetic of seats had a ist and gained obscure!
the results' real
meaning"
per cent of the vote
In the mining
majorities
hamshire-based
asca Mansf
the Notting
JDM advised its members to vorc against Labour.
75 per cent. This was repeated in
inner-Birmingham constituencies. Ir
shows that some of the poorest sections of the working class, especially black
ynuth, were disallected with the whole
electoral process and saw the clection
as irrelevant to their interests.
itself is an indictment of weaknesses in Labour's campaign.
clection
press conferences around the thenie of a better deal lor women. The spectacle of David Owen proclaiming a better deal for women may have been less than credible to some of us, but it did cxpose the lack of campaigning on this issuc by the Labour leadership — a failure which undoubrodly cost many
The riction campaign waged by the Latwur leanership was undoubt- edly the slickest and most professio- nai campaign wayed by the labour Teadership for decades. Concentraring
TV presentation and the presin- ential-style build up of Kinnock as a
votes:
Bryan Gould, the rising star of Labour's front bench
the Midlands lie results were more mixed, and the negative offocts of a right-wing Labour council were cer- tainly felt in Birmingham.
Coventry there was a substantial sw- ing to Labour, the biggest being in the constituency of Militant MP Dave Nell-
All these results of course represent i working-class swing to Labour in arcas of high unemployment and social deprivation. Bur perhaps the most remarkable results came in Scot-
right-wing Labour council were cer-
wett
But in
Coventry there was a substantial sw-
1ST.
All
land. Of 72 Scottish Mis, 50 are now Labour, and only 10 are Tories. In this clection the SNe were not the beneficiarics of the anti-Tory tide, los- ing three seats to Labour and gaining two from the Tories. The result of this of course will be a widespread feeling
question in Scotland is likely to come to the fore, and the campaign for a Scottisli assembly, with powers to raise
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/Augur 1987
in Scodand that the governmental question in Scotland is likely to come
to the fore, and the campaign for a
YOUTH BETWEEN the ages of 18 and 25 were the only age group in which
Lahour beat the Tories. Overall La-
IWEEN ATTICE
which ill La-
bour won about 39 per cent of the
youth vote as oppused to 36 per cent
for the Tories. But here there is a
sexual disparity. While more young
mei voted Tory than Labour (42 as
opposed to 37 per cent), among young
women under 25 the Labour lead was
remarkable - 42 per cent for Labour
as against only 31 per cent for the
Tories. On a sex/age basis, young
women were the oniy social category
in which Labour beat the Torics. This
Labour Icad among the youth of
course reffects both youth uncmploy ment and the fact that the Tory pro- portion of the vote increases the higher
you go up in the age range (with a slight derrease among pensioners). But it seeme unlikely that the sexual
disparity simply reflects the addition of
the caregories "youth" and "women'. Te
scems to reflect a specific radicalisa-
Tatn...
Labour's right wing
campaign failed to maximise its potential
vote
tion of young women around a wide range of social issues.
Labour's
cent
ral
gain among
It. as opposed t among men. But the about cam
JUWE Ua0 number = Allras
O Worle"
made the theme of thare prominent in
Piers CavendishiRofes
ernie sront, newcomer on Labour's backbenches
credible leader, it owed its inspiration
nut to socialism but to American-style packaged politics. Kadical it wasn't.
The "high' point of the celebrated party political broadcast which con-
packaged politics. Kadical it wasn't. The "high' point of the celebrated
centrated on Kinnock and his family. was the conference speech excommu- nicaring Militent and the hard left.
Livingstone, that the Labour mani- festo was the most radical since 1945'- It was less radical than that in 1983, or
It is not true to say, as did Ken
indeed in 1974 when Labour promised
wealth to working people and their families". It was a campaign that not only had no anti-capitalist content but also failed to convince many workers that Labour would increase living
standards. In addition the campaign was undemocratic in the way it was
a 'fundamental
shift in power and
controlled from the top, as Scargill's revelations about being kept off La- bour platformus demonstrates.
velat
adas continued on page 22
19
KL
KL: General election results have always followed a
definite goographical pattern — highlighring the
eng non-nrosperous.ar
But this clection seems to have deepened this process?
DM: The north/south, Labour/Tory political divide is
not new. It has been plotted since the early 1950s. What has happened this time is the deepening of a divide that was already getting worse. It's not simply north-south though. There is an almost equally sharp
divide between urban and industrial areas on the one
divide between urban and industrial areas on the one hand and more rural areas on the other. Labour is
clearly strengthening its hold in the urban and industrial
areas, with some obvious exceptions, And the Tories are
consolidating their domination of less urban areas and
more nural parts of the country. This is true within both
north and south so you get divides within the regions as
20
well.
Why do you think thas is?
It seems that it's to do with the general prosperity of an
- ..in the general nrosperit o* an area and whether poople feci, almosr, that their area is going up or down economically. That's not just how they feel about employment cither. It involves factors like housing. If you're a council house tenant in the south, the temptation to buy your house, and what you
would make out of buying it, is a completely different ball game from if you are a tenant somewhere in the
north. So a lot of the politics that the Thatcher
witice that the Thatcher
goverment has implemented have had quite different
cffects in different parts of the country and they are
going to tempt people over to her pohtics in different ways.
anlemented ard
se ver 10.
What happened this time is not simply a class divide.
There were the geographical polarisations. But also the
best predictor of how pcople voted seems to have been whether they thought they were doing, or going to do, reasonably well out of Thatcher. It's a kind of very immediate self-interest and that's where your council
16at3cs
SA SAY 12 15. But aso th sto have beer
going to de
reasonably well out of Thatcher. It's a kind of very house tenant, for instance, comes in. The same stratum
vela
of the population will fecl differently in different parts of the country preciscly because of the overall economic
So you could say that some unctions of the employed terking
dass haze done teell under Thatcher?
Yes, particularly if they are home-owners, though
Labour did pick up votes amongst both working class
and middle class home-owners over 1983, so some of
that cffect appears to have boon muted. All in all it's
quite a complicated picture. You've gor class and social
structure criss-crossed by what's going on in a given
area economically (not just in termus of employment).
Then this is criss-crossed by the differences herween
local polirical culture. What worries me is that, becanse
of the way local areas are organised, quire large
stretches of the south are losing the whole notion of a
political culture constructed around socialist ideas.
feeling in their arcas.
aullere
Milot:
Over the past right years emplogmess and manufocturing in the
Weat Midlands have declined farter than in many other regions. Yet there was still trong support for the Tories in the election in Birmingham and the West Midlands. How do you account for
this?
It's almost as though the Midlands have become the
hattie ground between north and south. In 1979 one of the crucial sections of the vote that Thatcher scems to
id south 'nat Thatch anioniere - Millande
197x.on. ~ scems to
«kill That was t down to + that thes isrupter
real triumph for her. At the time it was put down to
things like the winter of discontent (the fact that these
trades unionists were consumers of those disrupted
the workers
Britain's changing political geography and class structure, clearly reflected in the
• Open at the (
Enterprise Board, discusses the issues with
services and not the low-paid workers themselves) and
De-industrialisation had not hit the West Midlands in quite as severe a form then as it has subsequently. So
reater L
sex the
general election she has not noticeably strengthened that position but neither has Labour won it back. That's what is awful. Labour's vote amongst skilled workers as a whule nationally went up by its national average percentage as far as one can tell. So Labour's position among them has been consolidared this time round. Yet it is still astonishingly low and still low compared with,
That'
080r
Why hasn't Laboar been able to re-conguer this lost ground? Lots of reasons. Some segments of the population, as we touched on carlier, think they are doing reasonably well out of Thatcherism. Fundamentally, whar Labour did in this clection was to strengthen its traditional bases. Interestingly, its growth of support in the hearrlands has been mainly among women who are now voting Labour
as much as men. Now that's an achievement. However, overall, Labour is left with a situation in which it as al
against the skilled worker problem such as in the West
Labour's election campaign came across as seeming to say that Labour would take money from employed workers to help unemployed. Wasn't thir a problem in inning the support of
It's true that in the end Labour's campaign was mainly about redistribution. The argument focussed on collecting taxes to pay for services particularly for thore who are losing out under Thatcherism. That ought to
Jught to
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/August 1987
ELECTIO
be done. But until Labour has a project for organising
the economy in a different way, a way that dues not produce the polarisarions in society, we will never get
workers who are doing relatively well under Thatcherisen even listening to us.
challenging to capitalism.
Thuse people, and
faultie
ire th lot mot
In London, the 1.6 per cent increase in Lahour't note weas helore the national acerage initease. Do you think this is related to the changing class stractare of London or war it more to do
i think it's both. London didn't do as badly for
increase in Labour's vote was higher than its increase in
hand, because large chunks of london are inner city
areas, and because of factors like the inheritance of the
CLC, it should have done better. To explain this, I think
we have to stand our very strongly against a gencralised notion of a "London effect". We also have to look a lot
with the campaign against the so-called loony left? Labour as the rest of the south. The percentage
BERNIES the south west, south cast and cast anglia.
percentage
«an its incre mila. Or "
w.1SC 111 othe
atT 1o
cE. i should havr uon
deepr suffered because of the campaign against the 'loony
er In Barr in these constituencies it was changes in the social
deeper than simply saying that the London Labour vote
left'. In Bartersca, Purney, Fulham, Bow and Poplar and in Newham South it didn't. As far as one can tell.
These changes relate to Thatcher's economic strategy, a strategy that says Jorget manulacturing industry, let it gu as the international division of labour will take it, focus on the Giry and on producer services for industry. broadly defined. This has had an enormous impact on the social snucture of London, Ieaving many people marginalised and the old labour movement decimared
wain.. Uv
structure which were the main cause
JOUr
while a large swathe of the population now enjoys a lot
Another important ciment in the election in London was the CLC. The cue did give a kind of coherence to
Tharcherland, I think thar if the leaders of the Labour Party were really radical they would have defended the CLCa lot hetter than they did. And they would have run an election campaign on a London-wide basis for the re-institution of metropolitan government — not
London and to Labour polities in the middle of
necessarily for Ken Livingstone — but for a set of
policies and politics that have proved popular, Tris
1 2UE S
FacE for
dear, however, that the Labour leadership doesn'r like
What sort of twure du your see for Landon with its creer of grear wealth and the Gity on the one hand and the largest mumbers of unemployed of any industrialised caly of Western Exrope on the other? Will there be geeralised prosperity for London or do you thank it is destined to hecome more like New York with hearily
I found it quite astonishing that Thatcher started her
those policies and it backed off frum thar.
quarded eclanes of spectacular mealth and huge areas of clection campaign in the Isle of Dogs in the London Docklands Development Corporation. She cicarly
deprivation?
believes that is a success. She sees the inner city problem as a problem of property development. Her kind of strategy is going to lead to a highly divided population: we can see it happening already
translarable to ather cities? A few urban development corporations, an attack on public sector housing and education. What is that going to do to the cities of the north? It won't produce the Isle of Dogs effect because private capital is just not as interested in these cities.
SOCIALIST OUTIOOK no 2 July/Augur 1997
2C 81 21
/alm of the
The two
There has been a lot of discontion aboat the sambelt strip — the verster corridor stretching from east anglic to the wat country zhere sew electronic and computer indostries are centred. Mary of the inorker in these un firms are not well paid yet there was a high note foo the l'orier in these areas. Isn't this a paradox? Is it related to the loco feel of unionisation in these industries?
Is it related to the loco feel of unionisation in these industries?
There is low unionisation and abso high unemployment in many towns of the area. I think we have to make a distinction between the smaller towns and the more rur towns. What I find most difficult is that we didn't win towns such as Slough, manutacturing tow..
councils. Although Labour's vote went up in those places it didn't go up enough to win. Also, a swing from sor to T 10 sit down and think why. It relates to what we were sayiny belore ahour the nood for new economic strategies for the future.
In 2955 the Tones zwn 50 per cent of the cole in Scotland What is the significance of the dramatec long-term decline in
Before we get tou excited, the percentage that the Tories hold in Scotland, 24 per cenr, is higher than
have to make a distinction between the smaller towns and the more rural parts of the sunbelt strip - and the towns. What I find most difficult is that we didn't win
Basilion or Harlow — manutacturing towns with, in many cases, local Labour
suen Labour's vot places it didn't go up enough to win. Also, a swing from Sup to Tary there was often evident. We just have 10 sit down and think why. It relates to what we were
Labour's percentage in the south cast, cast anglia and the south west. So to talk about a wipe-uur of the Conservatives in Scodland is a bit over the top. particularly as there are four parties in Scotland Nonetheless in terms of representatives in parliament iley do look extremcly weak. Also Scotland is a different nation, with its own political and cultural history and its own insritutions welded together in a
different way. It therefore presents a different kind of political problem frum, say, the absence of Labour in the south cast for any future Labour government.
The hughest percentage of the vote regionally for Labour is now in the north, It isn't in Scotland. I hope that the Scottish MPs, as well us raising quite legitimate questions about the Tories" moral authority in Scotland. will lead a harle that Labour people in the north and in Wales can also be part of.
Do sos thank it will roer be pocsible for Laboar io unn the south or cor to assemble a majority gun the changing cless struzte you te talked alout and the decreaning mumber of
many ways it means heing more radical, certainly as far as cconomic policy is concerned. Economic policy this time didn't hold together. For example people aren't
interested in another National Investment Bank that is
going to fill in the gaps thai the private sector cannot fill. We have to show that there are ways in which an economy can be revitalised which don't involve the polarisations of Tharcherism. If Labour sticks to the
21
22
continued from page 19
ne
ELECTION
The 'moderate" and right-wing cha-
racter of the campaign disarmed La-
bour in the face of Tory attacks, and
was a material factor in Labour's de- Icar. Defence is a good example. Kin-
nock adopted the strategy of saying as
lirtle as possible about it, while the
Tories hammered the time that La- bour WHUA
would leave Brican defence-
or wasting E15 billion on the Trident missile system? Where was the at- tempt to mobilise popular outrage against spending billions cach year on defending the sheep in the Malvinas?
Where was the artempt to show that resources wasted on useless military hardware could be used on socially useful projents? Of course, there could
he no such artempt, because Labour
had promised to spend all moncy saved on nuclear weapons on conven-
tional defence!
But despite the banishment of radi
calism, or any reference to socialism or
real anti-capitalist measures, there is
no doubt that this campaign streng
thened the authority of Kinnock as
leader of the Labour Party, to such an
extent thar he is less vulnerable as
had promised to spend all moncy
weapor
leader of the Labour Party than
Thatcher is as leader of the Tories — at least for the time being. No matter whar criticists the left makes of the
campaign, the conclusion that many in the Labour movement will draw is that, within limits, it worked and was credible. After all the Labour vote
went up; more seats were won. It is casy for the Labour Icadership to pres-
ent the outcome as the "first step" in
the defeat of the Tories, which will be
al the
rounded off with a resounding victory
at the next clection. This is going to lead to a very difficult situation for the
left in the Labour Party,
-his 1
despite the attacks on
them, Labour's left MPs were not defeated'
Ki.
- will lead to new attempts to
shift the policy of the party further to the right and to further marginalise,
with. spit tas
A first stage of this will be a cam- paign lo reverse the constitutional gains made inside the party in the
early 1980c. Selection of parliament- ary candidates by a postal hallor of all Labour Party members, rather tin by local us, seems likely to be the hrs move. In the longer term, sume aiters tion in the non-nuclear defence policy is likely, bur this will take time. The
witch bunt against the left will mus however, be slow in coming. The Kal- nock leadership will usc every bit oft*
Onc parados of the inner-parte situarion is however a new influx at
lefr-wing Labour Mrs. A swall group
like Par Wall, Alan Meale
authority to attack the left.
of these, and Mi.
and Mildred Gordon, can truly he said
to be of the hard left, while another kind or another. The clection of Kes
and to a much lesser
undboubtedly
much
Livingstone,
situation inside the parliamentary Ta- bour Party.
Livingstone will
present himself as the new leader of the
his project for breaking down the dis F sions between the 'soft! and the bard left. Of course greater unity on the Labour left is desirable in itself, hut the question is whether it can be
achieved on the basis of class strucele politics, without the hard left tannely tucking in behind a new accommora- tion to Kinnack
THE LABOUR right will no doubt try to exploit the fact that the Labour volu only went up by one per cont in Len don, and that three London scams wors lost. This result cume after a ceaseless
SOCIAL
the
house?
parliamentary Labour party is the most left wing ever. it can overthrow Kinnock and replace him with a left wing leader. I know, Fread it in the Daily Mail. The trouble is Kicn Livingstone and sections of the "left" seem to believe it too.
So what is the reality? Will wo sce a new left wing in parliament dedicated to the overturn of socicty as we know it? Unkey A quick glance ar the people on the list of "101 damnations" shows that half the people on it want to sce the other half expelled. People who have supported the witch hunt and amposition a candidate at Knowleu Nortr like Micnael Meacher and Tam Dalyell are on the same list as those thee would like a see thrown out of the Labour Party. never mind parliamen-tike Dave Nellixt and Par Wall.
Others on the list include leading DCC supporters like Ken Livingstone, who sees his role as reuniting the Tribune and Campaign groups.
Others: in the 101 who were successful include dedicated Kinnock- ses like Keith Vaz. new MP for Leicester East, and Joan Ruddock. now representing Deptford
The class struggle wing of die Campaign group of MPs: will undoubtedly be strengthened by a lew
- Bob Crver, new addlirions
returning unscatted from the
winelakes of Strasbourg and Par
Wall, ar his second attemps, also
representing Bradford; and at least two of the new black MPs. Diane
Abbor and Bernie Grant, are likely to
both join and ar least shake up the
group
But it is the soft left to centre Tribune group that will benefit most from the
new intake of Scorrish LCU-influenced
Stalinists led by George Gallowav. tbe
undoubted shift to the right of 10-20 of the previous Campaign group, and
several of the new London MPs. The
Tribane group will, of course, act as loyal defenders of Kinnock and the
new-style, image-conscious party.
While there is no doubt that the
"loany left" came up on the doorstep
throughout the country, the biggest
danger now could be that sections of
the left themselves believe in it.
CTION
liance challenge. Where Labour lost seats, there were particular local factors. In Waltham Forest the disas- trously high rate rise imposed by a Labour council certainly lost the seat. In Battersea and Fulham, the lost seats could well be due to social changes in these constituencies
argaret
CONSERVATIVE KI
FINCHLEY
MAGGIES
- a result of gen- trification and an influx of 'yuppies".
Despite the attacks on them, left- wing MPs in London were not de- feated. In arcas Labour councils, the Labour vote held
up — with the exceptions of Waltham Forest and Ealing, Hilary Benn being hammered in Ealing North because of another giant rates increase. In Cam- den, there were swings to Labour in
were
where there are left
both the local constituenoes, as there
several other left-wing
The point remains, however, that London, although having areas of
in boroughs.
great prosperity, also has the highest number of unemployed people of any city in Europe. Labour should have done better and the fact that it didn't must be partly due to Labour's failure to counteract the savage media cam-
Margaret
Thatcher
CONSERVA
paign against the "loony left".
The main responsbility for this lies with the Labour leadership, which not only failed to defend left wing councils against a harrage of press lies and distortions, but on numerous occa- sions joined in with their own reaction- ary attacks
media campaign of several years duration against the "loony' London left-wing Labour councils, and their anti-racist and anti-sexist policies. This campaign reached a crescendo in the wecks leading up to the election.
But the pattern of the vote in Lon don is complex and contradictory. In
some Labour constituencies the majo- ritics increased - for example in Is-
Jeremy Corbyn's
In Islington South Labour held on against a strong Al-
lington lor nearly doubled.
and without doubt influenced the vote.
THE ONLY REAL Josers in the north of Ireland seate were the leadership of the Official Unionists and the Democratic Unionists. They saw their total vote drop considerably and suffered the embarrassment - Insing Ence" Powell's scar in South Down to the constitutional nationalisr Fadie Mr. Grady of the Social Democratic and Labour Party,
The SDEP now have three seats at Westminster whereas at the 1983 clec- tion they had only one. They fatled, however, in the main aim of their
serton campaign - to unscar Gerry Adams of Sinn Fein in the West Belfast constituency. Adams percentage vote actualy increased from that of 1983 and there was also a swing from the SDEP to Sinn Fein in the North Belfast constituency. Overall, the Sinn Fein vote fell 2.4 percent, a decline which can be attributed to nationalist voters in South Down plumping for the SDLP candidate in an attempt to get Powell out. and divisions within Sinn Fein over the choice of candidate in another rural constittiency The general pic-
The carefully leaked "Hewitt letter' was just the moss obvious proof that
ship amongst their normally rabid supporters
But just as the unionist icaderships faced something of a crisis they have been thrown an amazing life-line in the bizarre figure of John Stanley, the new second-in-command in the north of Ireland in the Thatcher govern- ment. Stanley is a former minister for the armed forces and as such favours, according to the Trish Time, "more stringent military acton against the IRA. But the really extraordinary: incet of Stanlev is that me is an cyanger lical protestant and as much is of the same religious ilk as lan Paisley. The final insult to northern Irish catholics is that Stanley replaces Nicholas Scott who is a catholic and has been the chief tanget of Tan Paisley's ire for the last five years. Many unionists will be thinking that the loss of the rathcr unreliable Enoch Powell is more than offset by the arrival of Stanley. A new attempt to set up a devolved parlia ment in the north of Ireland is now likely to followe Geoff Bell
Unionist vote drops
33C6 20002
ture on the nationalist side is of Sinn Fein slighdy increasing its support in Belfast working class areas but dropp- ing votes elsewhere:
The drop in the unionist vote re- Nects a double dissatisfaction amongst unionist voters. The first was consi derable anger within the ranks of Tan Paisley's Democratic Unionist Parry over the insistence of their leader that the party continue its alliance with their old rivals in the Official Union- ists. DUP members and voters have been taught for twenty years to dis trust the more upper class Official Unionists both because of their suppo- sedly shaky unionism and their conser- vative cconomic and social policies. Now the person who has been teaching that lesson — the more populist lan Paisley — has been the strongest advo- cate within the DUP of a united front with the Official Unionists over oppo- sition to the Anglo Irish Agreement. But that this opposition has itself run into somcthing of an impasse provided the second reason for a growing lack of confidence in the unionist twin Icader-
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2
23
ECTIO N
24
Labour scorns the women's vote
WE NOW HAVE the highest-ever number of women Mis - a total of 41 cotapared to 25 elected in 1983 (which later rose to 28 in by-elections). Out of these 21 are Conservative, 17 Labour, two Alliance and one Scottish National Party, But how much does this really mean for women? The sow's radical rabbi, Julia Neuberger claimed that this was the first election in which
are being women's issues scriously and have actually got into the manifesto. Labour's Diana Jcuda was ust as excited w'e extraoranarv Something has changed: it may be as simple as that expediency requires that women be taken seriously, but these is no question that it's happened. Yes. we've gor women on the agenda at
12SE.
But though getting more women into parliament undoubtedly reilects something, women can be forgiven for not popping the champagne corks just yet. The ruling party is set on taking things in the opposite direction. Un like the other parted the Tores did not target women as a group at all in the election because, as vice-chairman, Emma: Nicholson daimca. we're trearing women as equals!
The record of the Torics in govem- ment shows what a lie this is. This government abolished the universal maternity grant, imposed a tax on workplace nurseries; and child care allowances. It has been taken to the European court If times on issues like cqual pay, retirement and married women's access to the carer's allo- wance, While its European counter: parts in West Germany, for example, pay some lip service to feminist rheto- rie the Tory Party doggedly reject any notion of equal opportunitics at work and Nicholson admits that such ideas "have not really formed a part of our thinking
Women may have succeeded in getting women's issues onto the agen- das of the opposition parties bur it would be overstating the case to say that these issues were pur clearly be- fore the voters. The proposal for a ministry for women for example un- doubtedly reached some and one poll showed over 60 per cent of women in favour. But the same poll also showed that 90 per cent thought it was being put forward by the Alliance.
In fact the Alliance are opposed to such a policy propoxing instead a ministry of justice (similar to the mini- slere du droit de l'home which the right wing French government set up in place of the Socialists" ministry for womens. The Alliance put forward a programme for strengthening the equ-
ality legislation, for contract comp- liance: (whereby employers with gov- ernment contracts are forced to.com ply with certain targets for equality); for paternity leave, cqual educational opportunity and so on. But the main plank of their platform for equality was to emphasise the demand for 50 per cent women on all public bodies In other words equality is to be achieved from the top, hardly, when it
comes down to it, a real alternative to Thatcherite policies.
The Labour Party's programme on the other land, did have the makings of such an alternative. Even the Trade Unionists for Tabour booklet given out to Tabour canvassers as a guide included all the muin planks of this and sing mosr Labour Party activists pro- bably did not realise what was in it. There was the demand for a national minimum wage, for equal pay and conditions and job security for part time workers, contract compliance, for nursery places for all three and four year-olds, for well wornen dinics, for parental leave and for a ministry for women's rights even with a suggested figure of 10 million for its budger
Noticcably dropped from this list was any demand for abortion rights, a lynchpin of women's struggles in the labour movement lor over a decade and therefore all the more frightening for the Labour leadership.
Nevertheless this programme, if im- plemented, would have very far reach- ing effects. Perhaps this is why the election campaign itself on these issucs was so especially anodyne. An article in Labour Party News cotitled Listening to Women was at pains to point our that any programme would take a long long time to implement and did not even mention the more attractive parts of that programme at all.
While it is trac that all Labour pross conferenoes had at least one women on the platform, the overwhelming im
pression from the part pourical
broadcasts, apart from the one on
women, was of grey suited men sport ing red roses. It was as if the Labour Icadership belioved that the only way they could show they were a match for Thatcher was to wheel out the men The caring side war dealt with by
Glenys and shots of Kinnock going one
better than must politicians, not just
kissing babies but also changing nap-
pies.
In the aftermath of the election de feat pundits inside and outside the Labour Party have been quick to ar gue that resulis prove that the Tory vote will nut budge, Labour's cam- paign was slick and professional, the
the
argument goes, and still they did not win If we examine women's voting patterns however, we find that the Tory vote ir budging and, who knows. if the campaign had been a little Inse slick and a little more definite in putt- ing forward the policies on women, it might have budged even more.
Labour have a great deal of catching up to do where women voters anc concerned. It was the Tories who gave
women the vote and the Tories who women tn- had the first woman MP and now have provided the first woman prime min- ister. The Tones have therefore u- ways had the lion's (sic) share of the wumen's vorc and still do today.
Yet since the late 1950s the Tories
share of the women's vote has been
steadily declining
The shift is not as dramatic as in the United States hat it
Women are now an longer 1e ther Wro
more likely to vote Tory and just as
likely to vote Labour as men. Accord- likely."
ing to the Times of 13/6/87, in this ing to te clection L
Labour nearly halved the
Conservative's lead among women of
20 per cent to I1 por cent, a 4.5 per 20 per cent te
This was particularly true cent swing,
among young women where the Tory
lead was reversed to an 11 point La-
Labour did better among older and
younger women than it did among older and younger men. Much of this changr has occured rough weaknesses on the Tory side. Accord- ing to one poll taken in April this year the main issues which the majority of women saw as important were educa tion and the national health service Given these figures it seems almost
criminal that women were not more targetted in the labour campaign. A further poll taken in April shows that the Torice still have 53% of their support from women, the Alliance 149 and Labour only 305.
So, in relation to women the lesson we must clearly draw is not that the Tory vore will not budge nor that we
must aim for the middle ground by must am. improving Labour Party
Pariv pontical broadcasts. The way to accelerate the increasing trend of women turning away from the Tories is to put forward Labour polices wud and clear including on abortion rights and to actually organise to defend women from attack under this next term of a Tory government. Women are 52 pr cent of the voting population and are just as likel so vote as are men. It 19 about time that the Labour Party woke
up to this fact and rather than purport-
ing to listen to women', actually did something about it.
Jude Drury
bour lead
Sr..
iF alan.. older
improving Labour Party
SOGAIST OUTLOOK su 2
ECTIO N
WREST single snapshot the whole preceding
politica: development. The
we 1981-3 miners strike was
a whuch the Tory advance
ne miners strike was tne
• the last Tor government
receive a new boost. The trade union bureaucracy will back the right in the Labour Party in a new against the left, goat the left for the electoral defeat. In
a situation in which it is more difficult
to launch working class struggle, it will
-fe.
witch hunt attempting to scape-
at In
which it passed only because the lea- dership of the labour movement failed
secuuse the lea- movement raven strike nad enues without an must-
it. Even if the miners' strike had ended with a compromisc, without an out-
right victory for cither side, Thatcher
however, is that it is
would have heen decisively weakener
The defeat of the miners' strike, of the printworkers' strike and of subsequent
• of tre
hardly credible any more to argue in favour of holding back a fight in order to wait for the next Lahour govern-
struggles, has also conditioned the out- come of the political changes inside the
Un DOUBL inans incide-en
labour movement.
sation, redundancy and closure or specd-up, there is no prospect of res- cue by the next Labour government. Workers faced with such attacks will either fight now, or go down to defear.
The open question is whether the
If Thatcher was the mam winner of tie miners' strike, then in a lesser way
so was Kinnock. The defcar of the
mincrs strengthened the grip of the
right wing in the trade union move-
ment and the bureancracy as a whole.
and dealt a blow to the left leadership
in the labuur movement, particularly
that associated with Benn and Scargill
vas Kr
The open question is whether the cectoral deleat proves such a major
blow to working class morale and con- fidence that such a fightback against Tory atracks cannor be mounted. No
vale
De... hie at
•* Kinnock is rmharrassed by and op- posed to most equal opportunities. anti-racist and anti-discriminatory policies which he leels may alienate sections of the white male working class. This endorsement of Tory pro- paganda has compounded the pro- blems created by Kinnock's capitula- nion to the Tories over rate-copping
Labour MPs
disappointment, but it would be wrong to expect one of the most massively trade-unionised work- ing classes in the world meckly to bow down in front of these attacks.
In this article we have gone into
are de disappointment, but it
Thatcher has now been given carte
blanche to press ahead. It goes without
saying that bitter new arracks on every section of the working class are in the
pipeline. Those who were influenced
by Tory tax cuts are now going to find
IC 111
In this article we have gone into
some detail about what happened in the election itself. There exists an ultra-left belief that elections are 'irne-
VAT increased on all goods, maybe including food.
SCU 11 but in our view clections do
and the abolition of the CI.C.
FOUR BLACK representation of black peopic, and a testimony to the success of black ser- tions inside the Tabour Party: Bernie
especially the youth, are going to be
met with draconian new.schemes.to- make them work for their dole.
The unemployed,
levant. reveal something important about the relation of class forces at a particular point in time. The Tory victory does set the framework for the class struggle
wert
Privaca
ment services, water Obviously. will proceed immediately.
elected, a major breaktirough for the
Grunt's vote in Tottenham held up. despite the major press campaign against him and his motoricty for his criticism of the police after the Broad-
uprising: bluck people in Tottenham vorod for hun in large numbers. Diane Abbott won in Hackney North, after a vicious racist campaign against her, as did Paul Boareng in Brent South: Keith Vaz defeated the Tory nighrwinger Peter Bruinvels in Leicester South.
Politically Vaz, Abbott and Roateng are on the soft left. Nonerheless, the winning of scars by black Mis will rightly be scen as a step forward by
Far
in
black people, and aid the fight to link the labour movement to anti-racist and black struggles. Ic is unlikely that such a breakthrough wuuld have been made without the fight waged by black sections, in the teeth of opposition
from the Kinnock leadership. The declaration of continued support for black sections made by Bernic Grant after his clection is a promising sign that the clection of black MPs will not be the end of the struggle for black representation of black people in the
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/Augur 1987
labour movement. SOCIALIST r
the health service. Major new powers will he taken to divest local authorities of their functions, which will increas
" the wellure state www attack.exce
to come, but it cannot, in itscif, deter- mite the outcome of that struggle.
A major new round of struggle in-
ingly be taken over by national gor- emment. Privatisation of local govern-
ment services, water
21 WE I? oflocal go and clectricity
VerI ricit
side the Labour Party is inevitable as the right pushes home its altack. The hard left cannot shirk that struggle, and must determinedly resist disillu- sionment about participating in the
18В.... на - на 24.-
translate 100l
ON 10hs ming stan-
« Inton orpanication pat-* the working-s% will fo foron. ne Thatener's victory bork
riTepeace and in their porkers
45 will
the represent
are the Tories and the class which they
determined to crush
delenailey 1 al the worki. ...sand el.
ir quest lor
totally lee markes era- the depin at th crononu.
crisis, and the impending new world
recession compel them to do so. That-
cher's victory is a victory for the City
every perry hoss and burcauerar and for every police thug.
spIrs. for
defensive. then so is the left of the labour movement. In the unions 'new realism', the philosophy of class colla-
If the whole of the organised work-
ing class is now pushed onto the
SOISCO WOr
rett ost tl
water
301005130
wass culla- unon deals will
debate within the Labour Party. But
in the next period of hard struggles the
hard Jelt can only create the basis for
extending its influences if it can make
itself a marcrial factor in the outcome
of working class struggles. If Marxists and others on the hard left lave no- thing to offer in the way of solidarity.
and leadership in the
coming struggles, then they will not be
able marerially tu modify the relation- ship of class forces.
Thar is the perspective that the left must set itself, to base itself firmly on
women
must set itself, to base itself firmly on the struggles of working poople, of
and black people. Through building these struggles and
by fighting to lead them, the left can
the forces to strike back. Thatcher's election victory was but
one act in a prolonged drama of class conflict which has been raving in Bri- tain since the late 1960s. In this drama we have hardly reached the interval —
• Bri-
25
26
ELE 0
The good, the bad and the ugly
kick out the Tones) was THE LEFT wing linc-up in the 1987
clection ranged abstentionists (who saw the whole af-
Editor
from the
fuir as an occasion for sideline com-
and
varied degrees of opportunist and principle to the outer right wing f inges of the cross-class voting" Communist Party
The problem for the abstentionists - especially those running propagan- da candidacies → was that the most class conscious workers saw the elec tion as a serious malter: a crucial op portunity to throw our the most savage
government since the 1926
stunts unle
poses) through
"designer
bosses" general strike. Left protest votes at most a rare occurrence in freak
British by-clections — would be fow and far between
The
Socialist Workers Para recognised this. Their election slogan vote labour but build a fighting
socialist alternative" represented an instinctive desire not to fall too far out of step with the mood of most trade union militants. Bur of course it left two glaring questions unanswered: • Since the SWP recognises every clec-
tion the political centrality of the
Labour Party, why does it abrain bet- weet clections from any political fight for alternative policies and leadership
inside the labour movement?
"fighting socialist alternative actually
*Socialist Worker says vote Labour without illusions. Be prepared to fight.
or what does their
abie
Be prepared to arguc
Fair enough: bur there is fighring and arguing to be done by Marxists inside the Labour Party: Supporters of Ladour Brifing, for example, spelled out a bold socialist altemative to Kin- nock up to and during the election. Even SWP theoretician Chris Harman admits that "vast numbers" of Labour Party members fought inside the party for solidarity for the miners. What help were the SWP?
To be a serious revolutionary it is not sufficient to seck an easy niche in a relatively small party like the swe
.. smill pan. made up on. everthi..
-1al- 11 13 nichie ma
it is necessary to fight the much harder battles to take revolutionary policies into the mass organisations and living
h harder policie
struggles of the working clams.
One grouping which does not even
pretend to be interested in such a fight is the Revolutionary Communist Par- ty. Yet much of the RCP, leftism" is
- EVER such a feb munist Par
barely skin deep bravado.
Their 1987 election intervention,
thinly disguised as the Red Front" of 12 candidates showed yet again how
LIVe HErr
Denis De
No socialism please, I'm Kinnock
disoriented and remote from working class politics the RCP has become
An artozan wchoolmaste
lectured workers on the similarity bet-
ween Labour and Tory policies, and insisted:
Once this simple fact is grasped (?).
erasped a rollow nar supportine Lab makes no sense.?
But anyone looking to the RCP for a revolutionary programme would be more than disappointed. A skimpy four-point text put forward no lighting
policies whatever to mobilise, organise or give leadership to the working class. There was not one word from the Red Front in defence of halth, education, housing or social services: no policies to defend johs or wages; no calle for expropriation or nationalisation; no reference to socialism or revolution; no demands for workers control or
even strike action (indeed no policies far the trade unions); nor was there even an explanation of the role of the capitalist state and the need to smash it: instead the timid Red Front 'favour the widest extension of civil liberties and equal rights for all'
So after all the swaggering, the RCP ran on policics to the right of many Tribunites, and as relevent to the working class as the Monster Raving Loony Party!
The increased majorities for can-
dirates associated with Militant -
Terry Fields and Dave Nellis - and the strong showing by John Bryan in Bermondsey were the outcome of campaigns which certainly stressed old-fashioned class instes"; but which gave as little voice or control to local Labour activists as Walworth Road campaigns did elsewhere.
Meanwhile Socialist Orguiser (vote
Terr Fin-
ive Nellier by Tobi Br th- restauney: *
Ro
barely even critical of Kinnock, reduc-
ing itself to retailing surgid anti-Tory propaganda while explicitly renounc
any intention of presenting socialist alternative to the party pro-
and guru John O'Mahony set the tone in a lengthy
ing
gramme. article which concluded:
For now (Neil Kinnock and his team) stand against the Tories for the
interests of the working class. When a
Labour government begins to act against those interests, we will have to fight it. Right now every scrions socialist should use the remaining
stu
weck of the election period to do everything he or she can to kick out
pur in a Labour
the guyernment."
Socialist Action has certainly evolved rapidly to the righr since the days of the miners strike, when it was the most slavish supporter of cycry pro nouncenient by Arthur Scargill. It has come under new influences since it started carrying briefcases for some of the Campaign group of MPs. the Campaign gmup's union links include bureaucratic opponents of Scargill,
like the NUM Scottish area's Eric Clarke. This has helped colour the
whole politics of Socialist Action, whose clection slogan "vote Labour in every constituency" was shared with Com
It tuay scem strange that a paper regarding itself as part of the hard left should feel obliged to devote such pro-
paign Group Nies.
aro Ic much no.
minence to a polemic against tactical voting: but no doubt Socialit Action knows its readers and supporters well
enough to recognise what message was
Meanwhile the Communist Party,
which long ago expelled all those who still thought they were communists, and which apposed class action throughout the miners' strike, con-
most necdod of votes cach.
tinued its decline with an advocary of
czuss-class tactical voring in Marcism
Today. Predictably the handful of CP
candidares, redundant leftovers from
the none-roo-glorious history of their
collapsing party, won only a handful
The central issue highlighted by the
events of the last eight years remains the acure political crisis of working
class leadership. If it in this contest that the slogan of Lubuur Briefing (vote Labour - and fight on, coupled with an alternative socialist manifesto), and the slogan of our magazine's first issue ('vote Labour, bur fight for socialist policies) correctly spelled out the
Lan
an
tasks ahead. Harry/SI
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 2 July/August: 1997