Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Understanding Trotsky

· Socialist Outlook no. 17, August 1989 · pp 15-22 · 7,817 words

Trotsky Russia and the USSR Stalinism Marxism

TROTSKY SUPPLEMENT Leon Trotsky (left) chatting with Lenin and Kamenev, May 1920

Mandel on Broué

a capacity for expressing deep affec- tion. His ability to communicate with huge crowds reached heights rarely equalled in this century. But he also knew how to win and keep longlast- ing individual friendships and affec- tion, the best-known being that of Christian Rakovsky.

Like all the classic Marxist thinkers, his interests were not limited to politics and economics but were universal. He was keen on literature, philosophy, history, the natural scien- ces, military theory, technology, psychology and painting. One of Marx's favourite Latin dictums 'I am a man and nothing human is foreign to me certainly applied to Trotsky. One of the less obvious merits of Broué's book is to bring out Trotsky's deep humanity and get it across to the reader.

Infallibility does not exist in this world. Trotsky was mistaken more than once in his analysis and especially in his political decisions, just like Lenin, Rosa Luxembourg, Engels and Marx before him. There were chinks in his armour - as with all men and women. But his was still a golden armour inspiring our admiration. It will continue to do so for suc- cessive generations of activists, intellectuals and ordinary readers.

This great revolutionary steps out from the pages of Broué's biography as an extremely attractive, human per- sonality - much more so than in the legend presented both by his enemies and his unconditional admirers. He was not at all the authoritarian, ai- rogant martinet of a leader portrayed by his friend Lunacharsky, even though he was a man completely ab- sorbed by his successive political/or- ganisational projects. Trotsky was very sensitive, often inclined to com- promise, and his reserved manner hid

II

Trotsky was a weaker tactician and politician than Lenin, the bom leader. Lenin was better at drawing around him broad teams of capable collaborators, keeping their specific contributions but integrating them into an increasingly effective collec-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

tive. This was one of the fundamentall reasons for Vladimir Ilyich's spec- tacular success in building the Bol- shevik Party. On the other hand Trotsky was the boldest revolutionary theoretical thinker and strategist produced by the workers' movement in the twentieth century. Even today one is dazzled by the depth of thei analysis in Results and Prospects, written in 1906. All the history of our century is summarized in thisi analysis.

Alone among Marxists, Trotsky' foresaw that in the imperialist-deter mined framework of uneven and combined development, the proletariat was going to lead the first socialist revolution to victory (we might say today the first socialist revolutions) not in the most advanced industrial countries, where it was al ready numerically hegemonic and culturally stronger than elsewhere, but in a relatively less developed country, Russia, where it was politi- cally the most advanced, and where the correlation of social-political for-l ces was most in its favour due in par- ticular to the weakness and

Until now,

Isaac

Deutscher's

'Prophet'

trilogy has

been the

seminal work

on the life of

Leon Trotsky.

Now it has been overtaken

by Pierre

Broué's masterly book (Fayard, Paris,

1988), writes

ERNEST MANDEL, in an

extended

review

(originally

published in

Quatrième Internationale

magazine).

Page 13

"Trotsky was the boldest revolutionary theoretical thinker and strategist produced by the workers'

movement in the twentieth century"

"The Left Opposition from 1923 had a correct idea of the danger of bureaucratic degeneration in the party and state. As Marx and Engels put it, there was a risk of the full time officials of the working class becoming I its oppressors" 1

• 3: Page 14

SUPPLEMENT

decrepitude of the ruling class.

This victory was going to unlock a process of international revolution which would eliminate the subjective weakness of the workers' movement in the most advanced industrial countries. If that did not happen, then holding on to proletarian power in Russia would become practically im- possible. We can see that all the suc- cess and tragedy of the Revolution

of history and therefore of the class struggle that has been definitely opened up by the imperialist epoch.

As a class the Russian bourgeoisie had been smashed and to all intents and purposes eliminated by its defeat in the civil war. It could not return to power. Capitalist restorationist forces could only emerge from the new society created by the October revolu- tion. They could only win out in an

The Left Opposition from 1923 had a correct idea of the danger of bureaucratic degeneration in the party and state, As Marx and Engels put it: there was a risk of the full time offi- cials of the working class becoming its oppressors. That is what obviously happened and can be summarised by Trotsky's later formulation of the politial expropriation of the proletariat (which brings with it many

over the last 70 years was thus an- ticipated.

However the loss of direct power by the Russian proletariat following the defeat of the first wave of intema- tional revolution did not take the form of capitalist restoration but the usurp- ing of power by the bureaucracy. Trotsky had not predicted that variant in 1905. It haunted him already in 1922, as it did Lenin from the same

period. This is why the idea of "Thermidor' dominated Trotsky's thought and action for 15 years, if not right up to his assassination by a Stalinist agent. [The use of the term "Thermidor' refers to the French 1789 Revolution, being the month of the

alliance with, and totally subordinated to, imperialism. But imperialism had itself gone into a profound, irre- versible crisis with the First World War. It was challenged by successive waves of proletarian struggle in the industrial centres, by severe economic crises, by exacerbated inter-im- perialist conflicts and by increasingly extensive uprisings by the colonial and semi-colonial peoples.

The fate of the remaining gains of the October revolution is therefore necessarily linked to the outcome of the class struggle - more precisely of all social-political conflict on a world scale. The question of Thermidor is inextricably combined with the

consequences on the economic level).

But such a counter-revolution is not a social counter-revolution, and does not involve the restoration of capitalism, just as the French Ther- midor did not imply the restoration of the Ancien Regime (the power of the semi-feudal nobility and absolutist monarchy). It was a political counter revolution on the basis of a society created by the victorious

revolution.

For the Opposition this key dis tinction was not clear in the first period of its struggle. For a quite a lot of its leaders Thermidor and capitalist restoration were seen as the same thing, or at least were put together in

revolutionary Jacobins, led by Robespierre, were overthrown a wing of the revolution which was reaction- ary but which did not restore the old feudal regime. Incidentally this anal- ogy and concern was raised by Lenin before Trotsky].

But like the forecast of the Oc- tober victory as early as 1906 and the intuition of the universal value of the permanent revolution strategy for all the less developed countries, the Thermidor concept is not simply a transposition of the French revolution experience to the Russian revolution.

arn

counter-revolution. Practically alone among communist leaders, Trotsky understood this as early as 1923. It is correctly one of the leitmotifs of Broué's book. This is also one of the reasons for what Trotsky saw as the decisive importance of building the Fourth International during the final period of his life. Nevertheless the significance and content of the Soviet Thermidor remained a central ques- tion in the factional struggles of Rus- sian communists between 1923 and 1933. On this Broué's book gives us more details and some important con-

process of world revolution and

ma v struggle on three fronts against the bureaucracy, the Nepmen (the new medium scale urban bourgeoisie) and the Kulak danger, the Opposition was subjected to a stern test when Stalin and his faction made a brutal ultra- left turn in 1929 with forced collec- tivisation of agriculture and breakneck industrialisation. One sec- tor of the Opposition, Piatakov then Preobrazhensky, Smilga and Radek, saw this turn at least partially as a vindication of their ideas. They used it to justify their capitulation. The other sectors of the Opposition who

an over-mechanical way. Then in the

It only has any sense within the clusions compared to Deutscher's tril- kept fast to the fundamentally framework of the internationalisation ogy-

proletarian, anti-bureaucratic and in- "Isaac Deutscher is a more bril- over polemical approach to his sube 1938, recognising the necessity to Lant writer than Pierre Broue. His jection all the questions in dispute be continue the work begun in 1933 of language is more striking, he has tween the two men in the 1930s. An patiently building new revolutionary

a more lively style that is easier to cogs with the infim of we gave nuclet both nationally and interna

tionally and of Consolidating this read and he has a gift fordsum- today leads us to the conclusion that work as far as possible against the marising ideas and events in an it Was Trotsky's analysis and not pounding it would receive from the original way. But Broué is a bet- Deutscher's that was right on most of effects of World War. tet historian. He uses quotes and them Two important examples bear On these questions and on many backs up his sources. He avoids this out. First of all the scope of the more, Broue, who is obviously polti- ready-made judgements. And social/political crisis in France in cally closer to Trotsky than now, unlike the time whene 1934, culminating in the June 1936. Deutscher was, in also a more objec- Deutscher was waiting, the has * General Strike and the subsequent ative historian. He writes as i sup been able to have access to and a defeat of the 1938 General Strike, porter of Trotsky but not as an a criti use supplementary documentary Deutscher elearly underestimated cal or awestrick adminer. He never

this even if Trotsky's June 1936 for hides his immense admiration and sources and a secondary litera- mulation The French revolution has love for his subject sentiments we ture.

begun' is debatable. Then there is the understand since we share them. But

Above all Deutscher's thard question of the foundation of the he does not mythologise some guru volume was marked by the author s Fourth International in September or infallible politician

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

S UP PLE ME NT

terationalist reasons for their struggle against Thermidorian

degeneration, continued their

urgenciann, сошники шоц battle ander Trotsky's leader- ship. This meant they had to clarify the content of the Soviet Thermidor. Broué takes us step by step through the development of the thinking of the Opposition and of Trotsky on this. It is a key part of his work.

Deutscher's hesitant and contradictory analysis on this does not hold up to an overall * historical examination. How can one speak of a 'revolution

from above', as he describes the forced collectivisation, when the counter-revolution was carrying all before it in all areas of society? Trotsky illustrates this in a striking way in Revolution Betrayed, and his general analysis is backed up even more pungently by the radical criticism of this period in the glasnost of the Soviet Union today. The great development of French industry, made possible by the Jacobins, did not really begin until the Consulate and the Empire. But does that justify calling this period the "second revolution'? Were the Five- Year Plans the product of October or of Stalinism?

Today, when we can draw up a final balance sheet, little doubt remains. Anything positive built during the 1929-39 period was the product of the October revolution. But the mass assassinations, the famine, misery, oppression, wastage, and absurd inequalities which accom- panied what was constructed were the product of Stalinism, the bureaucratic dictatorship and the power of a definite social layer. Deutscher seriously underestimated all this. The proletariat and true communists do not claim any co-responsibility for all those disasters. We have to relentless- ly struggle against such crimes, as Trotsky and the trotskyists did.

The victorious political counter- revolution in Russia can only be over- thrown by a political revolution. However there has always been a debate about the possible self-reform of the bureaucracy. Also on this ques tion Broué is generally right against Deutscher. The falsely defined 'revolutions from above' like those of the archtypical Emperor Joseph II of Austria or the abolition of serfdom by Tsar Alexander II of Russia are characterised by the fact that they do not radically eliminate all vestiges of the decrepit regimes, which have to

Trotsky in exile: speaking in Copenhagen, November 1932

he swept away if progress is to be guaranteed. Such 'revolutions' can be radical. They can liberate important progressive forces. But their function is through certain changes to prevent popular revolutions. Precisely be- cause they cannot be as radical as real popular revolutions they can at the most hold these back (sometimes they even facilitate the development of a popular revolution). In the long term they cannot stop popular revolution. What was true for Alexander II or Bismarck will prove to be true in the light of history for Khruschev and Gorbachev - whatever the differences with our historical examples.

It is important to understand the particular dialectic between radical reforms initiated from the top and the mass struggles below. This dialectic is even more important and specific in post-capitalist societies, where the bureaucracy is not a class, unlike the nobility of the Austrian court with their civil service, or the Prussian Junkers. This dialectic is more accen- tuated due to the fact that the proletariat has an enonnous potential socio-economic hegemony in the USSR, beyond comparison with that of the popular classes in the societies of our historical examples. It would have been useful if Broué had made this point clear.

Despite all its weaknesses, Deutscher's trilogy (which has reached an audience far greater than Broué's ever will) did have the his- torical merit of breaking the wall of silence and slanders that Stalinist and bourgeois historians, as well as fellow travellers and opportunists of all sorts, have tried to erect for a quarter of a century around the leader of the October insurrection and the founder

of the Red Army. Outside the small Trotskyist movement and its periphery, where this book was ob viousiy not necessary, it marked out al path to the truth for hundreds of thousands of readers. Far from being, as Broué at one point suggests, an apology for Stalin, it was an essential stage in the demystification of Stalin for this part of world opinion.

The same comment applies to thes Khruschev report at the CPSU Twen- tieth Congress. It would be quite irra- tional and historically blind to define it as a 'subtle apology for Stalin'. For millions of communists throughout the world it marked the end of the Stalin cult and not the subtle con- tinuation of his authority. Ninety-nine percent of people at the time saw it this way too - even the strongest defenders of Stalin understood it.

The unjustified and injust attempt by Broué to systematise his criticism of Deutscher comes apart in iwol chapters where the polemic is stran- gely absent : the chapters dealing with 1920-21, tellingly entitled "The Crisis of the Revolution' and 'The Retreat'. We entirely agree with Broué's judgement on the Kronstadt events - it is nuanced and solidly backed up by documents from the im- perialist archives which Trotsky him- self was not aware of at the time. But we think Deutscher explains the tragic role of 1921, the watershed year of the revolution much better than Broué does.

The historical background is well known: there was a catastrophic fall in production; famine; numerical decimation of the proletariat; downturn of the first revolutionary wave in the West with the capitalist counter-offensive; but also the defini- tive defeat of the White armies in the Civil War and the end of imperialist

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

"Anything

positive built

during the 1929-39 period

was the product of the

October revolution. But

the mass assassinations,

the famine,

misery,

oppression,

wastage, and

absurd

inequalities

which

accompanied

what was

constructed

were the

product of Stalinism, the

bureaucratic

dictatorship and the power of a definite

social layer"

Page 15

"In a period of enormous material difficulties for the working Class, to institutionalise the apparatus's power and its methods of command, reducing and then snuffing out workers? democracy, means contributing to a sharp decline in working class political activity"

SAN ...you cannot

•..you canne stop the growth of bureaucracy simply by defending trade union autonomy against the managers"

Page 16

SU PP LEM ENT

military intervention against Soviet 'underground" counter-revolution. by history and repeated by many Russia.This is the context in which Again, given the economic context people today in the USSR although the Bolshevik Party, with Lenin and the Bolsheviks should have under- not by Broué (yet), be characterised Trotsky at its head, decided on the stood that the number one danger was as a veiled apologist of Stalin? Ob New Economic Policy, organised the not the bourgeois counter-revolution viously the accusation just does not retreat, and took a position in the but the alienation and political pas- hold water.

There is another argument that Comintern against ultra-left adven- sivity of the working class, which in turism and the theory of the tum would open the door to the politi- goes along the following lines. While 'offensive' put forward by Zinoviev cal counter-revolution, to Thermidor. Lenin and Trotsky made the same

The upturns and downturns of the political error of the bans in 1921 and and Bukharin. Against them, Lenin and Trotsky supported a united front revolution in the last analysis depend while Lenin did in fact nominate policy giving communists a line for on the correlation of social forces and Stalin for the post of general the masses and a way of winning a not on what happens in the two main secretary, nevertheless Trotsky is majority prior to any struggle for political camps. Within this correla- more blameworthy because of his power. All this was logical, coherent tion, what happens inside the working anti-democratic positions on the trade and based on a correct understanding class is at least as important if not union question. By doing this he of reality, the relationship of forces even more important than what hap opened the way for Stalin. The and the tendencies of the situation. pens among the bourgeoisie and its latter's new post meant the removal Broué (like Deutscher) correctly high- allies.

of Trotsky's supporters Preobraz lights all this.

In a period of enormous material hensky, Krestinsky and Serebriakov

But at the same time the difficulties for the working class, in- as party secretaries following the Bolsheviks' attitude to the forms of stitutionalising the apparatus's power Trotsky/Bukharin bloc's defeat on the exercising political power in Russia and its methods of command, reduc- trade union question. took an absolutely unjustified and il- ing and then snuffing out workers

However we should nuance the logical tum. Instead of saying 'the democracy, means contributing to a judgement made of Trotsky's error civil war is over, and the class sharp decline in working class politi- on the trade union question. Here enemy has received a decisive blow cal activity and to its political Broué tends to follow Deutscher's in- and will not recover quickly so we weakening, therefore changing the complete position on the matter. In must decisively broaden soviet relationship of forces at its expense. fact the trade union question as dis- democracy, particularly in the Trotsky and Lenin did not understand cussed in 1920 can not be reduced to party, in the trade unions and in this in 1921. They understood it one the problem of the (relative) inde the soviets', the Bolsheviks, in their year later. But meanwhile the damage pendence of the trade unions from the great majority, including Lenin and had been done (we are not saying it state, or of the extent of working Trotsky, made a tum in precisely the was irreversible). The one-party class action autonomous from the opposite direction, saying: 'since the regime was made official. Factions managers of industry (who were civil war is finished the were banned inside the single party (a more and more bureaucratic). Lenin proletariat's political energy and nearly inevitable consequence of the was right and Trotsky/Bukharin were dynamism will ease up, along with one party principle since each faction wrong on this issue. But the trade its idealism and commitment, so is a potential second party). Stalin be- union question also involved the form there is a mortal danger that the came general secretary of the single of management, the problem of 'who economie retreat will grow into a party. At the same time there was an manages'. poltical retreat; hence we must step ultra-rapid, monstrous growth of the

On this aspect of the trade union up discipline, control from above party apparatus - a few hundred full- question, Lenin defended the prin- and centralisation. Political timers just after the October revolu- ciple of management alone being in democracy must be radically tion but 15,000 in August 1922.

charge. Trotsky/Bukharin, while not

reduced'.

Furthermore this schema of analysis served as a model - we should say a justification - for generally accompanying measures of economic liberalisation with a politi- cal tightening up. This went on for

cal ugleg up. mis well vu sui decades, contradicting all the forecasts and predictions of Western liberal dogmatists

In fact the analysis was false. It led to disastrous political conclusions.

It it hard to show that the threat to Soviet power of the NEP men was

worse than that of Kolchak or Wran- gel. It was even more difficult to ex- plain how a working class that was absent from political decision making and increasingly reduced to the role of a passive supporter of the ap paratus, was more capable than an ac- tive, consciously intervening one of struggling against the rampant' and

Deutscher's book has the merit of showing the radical, decisive nature of this turn. This is not reflected in the pages of Broué's book. Moreover, Trotsky, in Revolution Betrayed, did not mince his words. In one of the most important self-criticisms of his

clearly raising the question of self- management (the Workers' Opposi- tion were for management by the trade unions, as stated in the official party programme) did propose decisive moves in this direction in

most important self-criticisms of his political life this is what he said:

"The prohibition of oppositional parties brought after it the prohibition of factions. The prohibition of fac- tions ended in a prohibition to think

uocuments inal Broue, шке Deutscher, does not take into account or is unaware of. We already referred to them in 1955. (1)

With hindsight it is clear you can- not stop the process of bureaucratisa-

otherwise than the infallible leaders. The nnlire-manufartner

autonomy against the managers who were separate from the mass of

Struggle against producers. bureaucracy must be carried out on at least three fronts: defence of workers' immediate economic interests; socialist democracy, (working class and soviet) and its institutionalisa- tion; and workers' management of the workplaces and the economy as a

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

monolithism of the party resulted in a bureaucratic impunity which has be- come the source of all kinds of wan- tonness and corruption."

(New Park, 1967 pp 104-5)

How in the world can a writer like Deutscher, who gives over a chapter of his book to this mechanism, the analysis of which has been confirmed

tion by simply defending trade union

antonomer arinet tha mananata tolun

SARACE

SUPPLEMENT

whole. On this last point at least Trotsky was in advance of Lenin in 1920.

IV

Broue's hesitations on the central question of political pluralism and on the watershed year of 1921 are particularly surprising, since one of the main merits of his book is precisely the way he brings out the con- tinuity of Trotsky's thought and action as the intransigent defender of working class self-ac- tivity and self-organisa- tion.

Trotsky was the first theoretician of soviet or- ganisation, from 1905-6.

He foresaw even then that soviets would spring up all over Russia in the next Russian revolution.

Lenin only took up this key idea, which also comes form Marx and Engels, with his book State and Revolution,in 1917. The Com- intern generalised this idea in 1919- 1920. It was made into a universal principle applicable to all revolutions with a predominantly proletarian character, all over the world. Rosa Luxembourg, Gramsci and other revolutionary Marxist thinkers further elaborated this concept in 1918-1920.

theoretical "breakthrough' with such

made a

with such an idea in 1906.

While he was the theoretician and practical leader of working class self- organisation, Trotsky had to refine his conception of the organised workers' movement, especially after the division between communists and so cial democrats crystallised after 1919- 20. Lenin had come down the same road in his fight for the united front, starting with Left Wing Communism, an Infantile Disorder and then the Cominter's Third Congress. Trotsky's more precise focus on the workers' movement led to the con- cept of the organic nature of this movement as a contradictory whole. On the one hand there are political differentiations, conflicts and some- times quite hard struggles, and on the other hand there is a continued reflex of class solidarity, common struggle, unity of action against the class enemy against common dangers and in pursuit of common interests. If this is obvious from the economic point of

Lenin In full flow, May 1920

vetw are suuy jusules the une of a ciple or workers, selt-organisation, single mass trade union confedera- which is at the heart of all Trotsky's tinn it is panallo trise on this nolitinal. anlitionl antivit

tion, it is equally true on the political level.

Trotsky's analysis of fascism, his definition of the vital role of the workers" united front to stop the rise of the Nazis in Germany, his tactical proposals and his tireless campaign around the mortal danger which Hitler's taking of power would repre- sent for the German and international workers' movements, are among the most brilliant contributions of Trotsky to revolutionary marxism. Broué shows an intimate knowledge of his subject here. Trotsky's writings on fascism are an indispensable com- plement to the general theory of working class self-organisation. Through them it is possible to under- stand how the soviets (workers' coun- cils) are both the most effective and natural instrument for unitary struggle and the most effective instrument for the exercise of power by the working class. In one of those breathtaking in- sights that crop up regularly in Trotsky's writings - Broué does not like to call them "prophetic' which sounds a little religious when it is really a case of combining scientific analysis with intuition - he predicted, years before the event, that the soviets would emerge in Spain first in the form of anti-fascist militias. This is exactly what happened in 1936.

This obviously does not mean that the intransigent defence of the prin-

political activity - with the tragic ex- ception of 1921 - was absolutely without any weaknesses. Broué re- lates in passing how Trotsky, like Lenin, was an ally of Kautsky against Rosa Luxembourg around 1910, when the latter campaigned in favour of the mass political strike. Her suc- cess would have been of supreme im- portance for the future of the German workers' movement and the class struggle of that country. The question is closely linked to that of workers' self-activity and self-organisation.

History confirms that the workers' "average' class consciousness is very much connected to their experience of concrete struggle and therefore to the concrete forms of struggle they have lived through. It would have

been useful if Broué had emphasised

this point more.

We should be thankful to Broué for having the courage to lift, at least partially, the taboo that still exists in out ranks on the writings of the young Trotsky - Our Political Tasks.It is a very uneven book, very unfair to Lenin. However to find there, as certain historians have done, the seeds of Stalinism and the bureaucratisation of the party and soviets is to make a mockery of a whole concrete and complex histori- cal process that produced Stalinism stretching over two decades, involv- ing three revolutions and two.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

"Trotsky was

the first theoretician of

soviet organisation,

from 1905-6.

He foresaw even then that soviets would

spring up all over Russia in

the next

Russian

revolution"

88888888898889838

Page 17

"Real working class self organisation, a network of soviets with effective power involving the whole of the working class or at least its

great majority,

is only possible on the basis of

party pluralism"

30 ES

•..only Trotsky presented not only a denunciation of Stalinism but also an explanation based on the marxist tradition, of the bureaucratic dictatorship. Inevitably this made him the main enemy of the regime..."

Page 18

SUPPLEMENT

counter-revolutions, the fluctuating activity of millions of men and women, the varying relationships of forces of colossal social forces and their inevitable repercus- sions on the thinking of leaders including Lenin. This is particularly mis guided, since Our Politi- cal Tasks is a declaration of war against such bureaucratisation.

It is hard to deny that the Lenin of 1905-7 or of 1917-19 had rectified some of the excessive formulations of What is to Done? concerning the radical, centralising, lead- ing "jacobin' role of professional revolutionaries. He had obviously bent the stick too far in one direction, and he rapidly bent it back the other way when he insisted, notably in the Preface to the collection In Twelve Years on the broadest application of democratic principles, the need for the election of leaders, for public, transparent debates in a

11°

passive tailending and

then bureaucratic

obedience. The masses'

consciousness and intel-

ligence decline. Finally

generalised indifference

and cynicism replaces a

living workers

democracy.

The great Rosa

Luxembourg first under-

stood this problem,

despite her passionate

support for the Russian

revolution and despite

the fact she was not in-

formed of the particular

circumstances of the

civil war raging in

1918-20. From 1921 on,

her warning (issued

three years earlier, before she was brutally

murdered) was shown to

be legitimate and alas

confirmed by historical

experience:

"If political life is 4 suffocated throughout

the country then

paralysis will necessari-

ly take hold of the

soviets. Without general Trotsky, returning to Russia in May 1917, urges proletarian elections, without revolution: soviet organisation has always been the key.

freedom of the press, of

unlimited right of as sembly, without a free battle of ideas,

legal and public mass party. On a more theoretical level he stated:

'Of course the primary reason for this success [of the party of profes- sional revolutionaries| resides in the fact that the working class, whose best elements are in the Social Democratic party [ie. the marxists], is different for objective economic reasons from all other classes in capitalist society by having a greater aptitude to organise itself. Without this condition the organisation of professional revolutionaries would have been a plaything, an adventure, a mere facade. The pamplet What is to Done? on many occasions em- phasises that this organisation's only reason for existence is its liaison with the really revolutionary class which goes spontaneously into battle.

Collected Works, Vol 13, [trans- lated from French] our emphasis.

This seems to us to be the correct formulation of the problem of the relationship between the vanguard or- ganisation (as a specific task to be achieved), mass spontaneity and working class self-organisation, al- though Lenin's term 'in liaison with' could be further developed.

Having said all that it is neverthe- less the case that Our Political Tasks does voice concer and war against the risks any party runs where one of the components of this doctrine, and especially the practice of democratic centralism, is developed in a one- sided way, particularly when the party exercises state power and there is a decline of the masses' self-ac- tivity. Broué has done a good job is bringing this out into the open. The taboo needed to be lifted.

Our conclusion is self-evident. Real working class self-organisation, a network of soviets with effective power involving the whole of the working class or at least its great majority, is only possible on the basis of party pluralism.

This is not only true because the working class in practice follows dif- ferent parties and political currents. Stifling or banning them is not the same as restricting the rights and powers of the bourgeoisie or im- perialism but is rather an attack on the rights and political initiative of im- portant sectors of the working class. Without free political debate and struggle working class political education and activity will rapidly degenerate. First you get a system of

sembly, wilout a uce value ut lucas, then life will wither and vegetate in all the public institutions, and the bureaucracy will remain the only ac- tive element."

Russian Revolution, October 1918 (Maspero, Paris, 1969) [translated from French]

Broué's book helps us answer a question that arises from the history of the USSR in the 1923-1940 period, which historians and young people (not to mention the workers' van- guard) ask (and will increasingly ask in that country) - how do you explain Stalin's persistent hatred, the im- placable persecution against Trotsky, his family and friends?

We can leave on one side the purely psychological aspect of the

phenomenon - personal rivalry, jealousy, envy, feeling of intellectual inferiority feeding a strong sense of guilt, endemic paranoia developing finally into a universal and monstrous paranoia. All that is true. But it is ab solulely insufficient to explain how an individual with such traits was able to express them in a nearly un- limited way in a big country that had emerged from a spectacular revolt-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

S UP PL

tionary expenence, which had not only liberated economic energies but also the potential moral and cultural emancipation of millions of human beings.

We get closer to a scientific, coherent explanation if we focus on the political role ot two protagonists in this drama as the repre sentatives, in an al- most concentrated way, of the interests, traditions and "values' of the two antagonistic social forces the proletariat and the bureaucracy.

Stalinist hatred was shared by a good part of the bureaucracy for a long time. Trotsky's anti-bureaucratic struggle was seen as basically correct by a good part of the workers' vanguard, to varying degrees and at different times - that is the tragedy - by nearly all the old Bolsheviks, including those who had first supported Stalin.

As the powers accumulated evolv- ing towards 'personal power', and as Thermidor led to the bonapartism and Stalin's dictatorship, so the survival of anything or anyone who incarnated the programme or ideals of October, or even the emancipatory tradition of marxism, became unacceptable to the lackeys and spokepersons of the political counterevolution. Since it was a political and not a social counter-revolution the umbilical cord with Marx and Lenin could not be to tally cut, so the regime cloaked itself in the monstrously deformed mask of 'Marxism-Leninism'. It presented it self as the legitimate follower of a tradition that it desecrated increasing- ly each day. Hence it was not enough just to suppress the main person speaking out against it: all potential opponents also had to be condemned to permanent silence.

Among these opponents only Trotsky presented not only a denun- ciation of Stalinism but also an ex- planation, based on the marxist tradi- tion, of the bureaucratic dictatorship. Inevitably this made him the main enemy of the regime since his writ- ings undermined it from the inside, albeit only in a theoretical way. Con- sequently the systematic persecution,

Trotsky with Lett Opposition leaders: as revolutionists, they posed a speclal threat to Stalin

the attempt to totally wipe out Trotsky's memory and ideas, cor- responds to a reflex of self-defence and self-justification of a privileged caste made up of hundreds of thousands of individuals. Stalin was only the most effective and most un- scrupulous executor of such criminal acts. Already this is a more credible explanation.

This explanation is still insuffi- cient. It does too much "honour' to the bureaucracy in general and to Stalin in particular if we present them as obsessed with ideas, programmes, denunciations, critical analyses or even of the need for self-justification or identity. All of this played a role in the persecution of Trotsky, of trotsky- ism and then of the whole Bolshevik party. But there is more to it than that.

What made Trotsky and the Bol- shevik-Leninists of the Opposition public enemy number one of Stalin and the bureaucracy was the unshake- able capacity and will of Lev Davidovich (Trotsky) and his com- rades to translate criticism and denun- ciation of Stalin, stalinism and the bureaucracy into political activity oriented to the working class. These were revolutionaries, educated, hat- dened by two experiences of activity in a non-revolutionary period, before 1905 and between 1907 and 1913, where they had learned, in smaller groups then the 1928 or 1932 Opposi- tion, to look out for the least sign of revival of working class activity. They had learned how to intervene and to insert their ideas into the most limited and moderate struggles. They

had learned the art of underground

organisation, patiently building up the links, even if with only two op positional workers in a workplace or three rebellious students in a univer- sity or two hundred workers involved in protest action or a small scalel strike.

Stalin had gone through the same school and knew the same techniques and he was obsessed by the idea that what Trotsky and the Bolsheviks had succeeded in doing against the Tsar they would sooner or later do against him. He could find some com- promises with everyone on certain conditions (look how he dealt with the successive waves of capitulationists between 1928 and 1934). He could find no compromise with propagandists and agitators with an intervention aimed at the working class and youth.

He was not wrong, at least fromi the long term historical point of view. One just has to consider the question - What would have been the destiny of the 1956 Hungarian revolution, what would have happened with Solidarnosc if there had been in these countries a nucleus of organised Bol- shevik Leninists? Even if they had been only a thousand strong, even without a "Trotsky', they would not only have been able to represent and concretise the communist tradition of that country but also be identified with every popular protest and workers' demand over the last 10-15 years. In this way we can understand the difference the life or death of Trotsky and trotskyism in the USSR

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

"Since it was a

political and

not a social

counter revolution, the

umbilical cord

with Marx and Lenin could not

be totally cut,

so the regime

cloaked itself

in the

monstrously deformed mask

of Marxism' and Leninism""

Paqe 19

38388 "What Stalin and the bureaucracy hated in Trotsky is what the Russian workers and youth are going i to admire and imitate in the years to come: his intransigent defence of workers' politicai and material interests...

Photographs from the splendid photo- biography Trotsky by David King (Basil Blackwell)

Page 20

SUPPLEMENT

represented for the long-term chances of survival of the bureaucratic die- tatorship. Stalin's hatred and persecu- fion of Trofsky and trotskyism was therefore not only hatred and persecu- tion of ideological enemies. It was a hatred and persecution against the only communists capable of helping the Soviet working class to under- mine and overthrow the privileges and power of the bureaucracy.

What Stalin and the bureaucracy hated in Trotsky is what the Russian workers and youth are going to ad mire and imitate in the years to come: his intransigent defence of workers' political and material interests; his identification with the anti- bureaucratic struggle, for socialist democracy; his persistent struggle against social inequality, against privileges, against untrammelled power, against injustice, for the rights of women, young people and minority nationalities against dis- crimination and oppression.

Broué helps us relive in a meticulous way, month by month, year by year, one of the lesser-known aspects of Trotsky's life as the in- spirer and leader of the Opposition after his expulsion from the CPSU. It is one of the greatest contributions of this remarkable book. Thanks to Broué this impressive political-or- ganisational continuity is not exces- sively personalised around Trotsky.

There was not just Trotsky and his son Sedov. There were numerous other outstanding activists who are brought to life again by Broué. He gives them a name and a political identity. They are among the purest heroes and heroines of our century. They never bored or gave into the "inevitable'. They never lost faith that this nightmare would end. They were killed to the last person. As one eye- witness said: They were felled like great oaks, with a curse for Stalin and a slogan for soviet power and the world revolution on their lips. We are proud of them. In the future all the workers of the USSR will be proud of them. Thanks to them our current is the only one who can look the Soviet people in the face without a sense of guilt, without shame or complexes. These heroes saved the honour and continuity of communism.

In his final speech before his "judges' at the Third Moscow Trial, the unfortunate Bukharin said (per- haps covering up some regrets) that one had to be a Trotsky to propose and do all that. Indeed. You had to be Trotsky to tirelessly continue the fight for the emancipation of the Soviet

and interational working class in midst of Hitler's and Stalin's terrors, when it was midnight in the century. Thanks to Broué's book thousands of contemporaries will better understand it now and understand it was not at all a lost cause.

VI

Broué's book covers a half-cen- tury of world history. It is inevitable that he could not cover everything. We can all have our ideas on what should have been developed more, on what could be left out and what could not.

We regret that Broué does not mention Trotsky's role as a precursor in the analysis of the black minority in the United States (2). We also regret he did not mention the fact that alone among marxists, Trotsky predicted in 1938 that if there were a new World War, all the Jews of Europe risked being physically liqui- dated. Broué also does not mention the first important political defeat of stalinism, the trial of the Spanish POUM, whose representatives were at first accused of collaboration with Franco — a vile lie - but were finally sentenced for having tried to establish the dictatorship of the proletariat.

We are sorry that after emphasis- ing the role of comrade Badovsky in introducing Trotskyist ideas in Poland in the 1950s, he does not mention the role of our comrade Petr Uhi, the most respected figure of the Czech opposition, continually attacked by the bureaucracy for his Trotskyism and who spent six years in a Stalinist prison.

We are particularly surprised about the way Pierre Broué dealt with the question of Trotsky's rehabilita- tion and the ongoing campaign on this, not just among Western jour- nalists looking for a scoop, but among important currents of the international workers' movement.

We have never asked for USSR governments - the political repre- sentatives of the bureaucracy - to politically rehabilitate Trotsky. We concede no competence to them on this matter. The judgement of Trotsky's political role and his ideas is a question of history and of the Soviet and intemational working people. We have never doubted their verdict. At the end of the day it will reach into the CPSU itself.

On the other hand we have demanded the penal and judicial rehabilitation of Trotsky and we must continue to do so. Trotsky and his son Leon Sedov were accused of terrible

crimes by the prosecutor and judges of the first Moscow Trial. They were found guilty in their absence in the sentence of this trial.The verdicts at the second and third trials confirmed this judgement. This is the basis on which Trotsky is judged to be an 'enemy of the people" and has had his writings banned in the USSR.

• Moreover the USSR supreme court has solemnly rescinded the ver- dicts of the three Moscow Trials. It has rehabilitated the old Bolsheviks who were sentenced on the basis of totally fabricated accusations. Is there to be an exception made for Leon Trotsky? What else but a Soviet tribunal can judicially rehabilitate him at this time.?

The question also exists on a more directly political level. Thousands of courageous men and women are cam- paigning in the USSR for the judicial rehabilitation of all the victims of the Stalinist purges, including Trotsky. Isn't it our elementary internationalist duty to support this struggle? Broué has probably already changed his position on this. If he has not yet al- ready done so let's hope he will do so soon.

But all this scarcely alters our overall judgement on this book. It is a great, a very great book because of its objectives, the verve it conveys, the scholarship and the conclusions it comes to which we share. It is and will remain an indispensable instru- ment for the education of cadres and for the recruitment of sympathisers. We will have to wait a long time for a better one, perhaps after all archives in the USSR are opened, and possibly a while after that.

Footnotes:

(1) E. Germain: The discussion on the trade union question in the Bolshevik party (1920-1) in Quatrime Internationale 1955, No.1

(2) George Novack has correctly em- phasised Trotsky's contribution on this to the development of marxist thought, clarifying a central aspect of the political tasks of revolutionaries in the United States (George Novack: Leon Trotsky's Contribution to Marxism in Proletarian Politics, Baroda/India, 1980, No.1/2). The same article contains a succinct and lucid presentation of the law of uneven and combined development that Trotsky first formulated, and a defence of the theory of permanent revolution which is based on this law. George Breitman developed the marxist (trotskyist) conception of the black question in the United States in more detail.

← Interviews with Tony Benn and Hilary Wainwright · 1969-1989: No British solution →

Something wrong on this page?