Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Interviews with Tony Benn and Hilary Wainwright

· Socialist Outlook no. 17, August 1989 · pp 11-14 · 3,498 words

Labour Party Trade unions

interviews, GILL LEE from Socialist Outlook discusses with two key par- ticipants in the Socialist Movement, HILARY WAINWRIGHT from the Socialist Society and TONY BENN MP their assessments of the Shef. field Conference and what they see as the key steps forward over the next period.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

Page 9

FEATURES

themes for which we stand and practical priorities over the year.

Q: How do you see us overcoming the rela- tive weakness of the Sheffield conference in attracting people who would primarily identify themselves as trade unionists?

HW: We have to put much more emphasis on just finding out how workers are express- ing disaffection, how they are resisting in ways we wouldn't recognise as political. While being programmatic in our internal dis- cussions we've goi to be more innovative in our campaigning. There are many new initia- tives which do not hit the headlines, such as organising casual and part-time workers or campaigns linking workers and commuters on health, safety and environmental issues.

We need to work more systematically on iwo levels: through national political debate by using the media more cunningly, and through popular resistance. We in the Socialist Movement, and we who have been politically active for most of our lives are ig- norant of those networks of people who are disaffected and potentially rebellious, but don't identify with the left; people who voted Green if they voted at all. We've got to make contact with them, not initially by recruiting them, but by getting to understand their con- cerns.

We've got to be more than a solidarity movement; we've got to be putting wider ar- guments and finding ways of reaching a popular audience. Sometimes, because the unions are necessarily sectoral, wider issues don't get brought out. We've got to be more than supplementary pickets, we've got to take on an ideological and political role. Q: One of the strengths of the Socialist Movement so far has been the link be- tween people in the Labour Party and people outside, struggles in the Labour Party and struggles in the unions and cam- paigns. Do you see it continuing to develop in that direction, or in the direction of the formation of a new political party?

HW: I see the first path as the future. Be- cause of the union/party link there is a sense in which the Labour Party is a coalition. It's never really been treated as one, because the Labour leadership has a kind of monopoly over it. I think the Socialist Movement is about asserting that the labour movement is a coalition and claiming the right to organise within it O: Perhaps one of the weaknesses of the Socialist Movement as revealed at Shef-

field was the relationship to it of the Can-

NUR

VEST HAM

DRANGN

INDIR

Graeme Cookson

NALGO and NUR demonstrators; solidarity is important, but not enough

Wainwright: "the Socialist

Movement is asserting that the

labour movement is a coalition and claiming the right to organise

within it"

An interview with

HILARY

Q: What is your balance sheet of the Shef- field Conference?

HW: The conference indicated a solid base of people who look to the Socialist conference to provide a national political focus. It raised the first phase of the income we need to pay for a full-time organiser. The policy papers represented an advance, several of them were the result of a year's work by well-organised policy groups. Our first attempt to draw up a coherent strategy statement provided a useful focus and in most policy workshops the dis- cussions were more productive than in the past.

The press reports indicated that the overall message of the conference got through; that we intend to campaign for socialism throughout society, not just in the Labour Party.

There were negative aspects 100. The num- bers were down - an indication that organisa- tionally we have not adequately consolidated people's initial enthusiasm. And we did not clearly enough convey the change from being a conference to a movement.

Page 10

With hindsight, we should have prepared the sessions on campaigning priorities more thoroughly. This would have given a more practical feel to what a movement is about. In some workshops there was still a depressing degree of sectarianism. I don't mean political disagreement; there will always be that and that's healthy: I mean a destructive desire to block any movement in the discussion, a refusal to listen, a constant barrage of single transferable speeches.

Q: Some criticism has been made, for ex- ample in Labour Briefing, of the fact that there didn't seem to be adequate channels for democratically discussing, amending and adopting the policy documents. Do you see this as a problem?

HW: I don't think you can start having votes and ammendments before you have a membership structure and the resources to get documents out well before the conference. In the policy workshops, people could indicate areas of disagreement with the main strategy documents so that these would be continuing areas of debate. I don't think all the convenors made that clear and that was a failure in our organisation.

The preparation of the conference - policy work linked to campaigning - must become a priority. We won't be able to agree on every- thing, and it would be stupid to try, but we must aim to agree, with votes, on the main

mela was the relationship to i or sue caus- paign Group, who had a relatively weak presence. How do you see that link evolv- ing?

HW: The Campaign Group of MPs are the parliamentary spokespeople of the Socialist Movement; or at any rate they should be.

For the national profile of the Socialist Movement to be developed we need to estab-

lish a working relationship with the Campaign SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

.332W:

FEATURES

Group, where they take on particular areas of work: for example, a Campaign Group MP could be assigned to each of our campaigning priorities, and make the most of their role as spokespeople.

Q: There has been a Green policy group in Chesterfield since its inception. How do you see that evolving after the Euro-election result?

HW: I think the impact of the Green vote could be very positive. There are problems with the weight of Labourism on the socialist left.

change. I would hope that this would build up now. But you have to be critical about it The Socialist Movement (SM) hasn't got a strong enough trade union representation, espocially in the organising committee.

We're trying to go about correcting it by spreading the word in the trade unions; you try to raise it at trade

Although the Green leadership is quite anti-left, many Green activists and voters are raising is- l sues which challenge the old Cold War politics and many are explicitly anti-capitalist.

The Association of Socialist Greens was formed as a result of the first Chesterfield con- ference, though at times they have felt mar- ginalised. The result of the vote will be to make the socialist greens stronger in the Socialist Movement. Eco-socialism,like socialist feminism, is leading us to redefine many aspects of our vision. The Socialist Movement can be a means by which the insights of these different movements are debated and woven into a whole, while at the same time these movements retain their autonomy.

you wy lo raise it al traue

union conferences; there are

strong lefts in the trade

unions now, and we need to

draw them in; and you or-

ganise in solidarity, like the

meetings I spoke at in Hull

and London around the

docks dispute.

Q: You've talked about

the SM as a co-ordinator

of struggles, and one of its

important roles has been

to bring the left together

in a discussion forum; but

do you see a role for the

SM as a body which gives

political leadership to

struggles too? For ex-

ample, as well as building

solidarity with the dockers,

should the SM try and give politi-

cal leadership to their struggle?

Yes. I think the Labour Party

should do that, and the Campaign

Group, it's not confined to the SM.

The term leadership can be inter-

preted in different ways. Some

people say you should tell people

what to do, tell them to come out.

I've always taken the view that your

function was to explain how these

'battles were won, which is by strug- gle, and then when people do decide to act you support them 150 per cent.

But I've always been doubtful of going around telling other people what to do, be- cause I think they don't appreciate it. They have to make a decision themselves, and un- less you're part of the struggle you're not put- ting your own neck on the block. In the miners' strike, when I did something like 222 meetings around the country, I would never tell them what to do: but I was always there to assist, and raise the issue in the House.

Piers Cavendish

Tony Benn: "people don't want to be told what to do... Benn: «We're spreading the word in the trade unions; there are strong lefts in the trade unions now, and we need to draw them in and organise in solidarity, like the meetings I spoke at in Hull and

London around the docks dispute"

An interview with

TONY BENN MP

Q: What do you see as the political base, strengths and weaknesses of the Socialist Movement?

TB: I think it's important to stress it isn't another electoral organisation, it isn't a sec- tarian breakaway, looking for some purity under some discipline of a particular ideologi- cal bent. It's a place where people can actually meet and speak, rather like the peace mov- ment or the women's moment or the black organisations or the Greens and so on; that's the purpose of it.

We had two socialist conferences which were very much bigger and more successful than we thought, and we tried to broaden it out; so although 80 per cent are probably Labour Party members, there are also people from other groups - the Socialist Workers

Party, the Greens, the women's movement, Women for Socialism, and so on. The Move- ment has taken off because a vacuum has been left by the policy review.

It's not very strong at the moment on the trade union side. That's not really the fault of the Movement, but some trade unions were suspicious of it because they thought it was ultraleft or something, and therefore they haven't played as big a part as I would like to have seen them play. It's got good internation. al links, and it's trying to develop a Solidarity Network, so that it doesn't become a talking shop. The Campaign Group is the tip of the iceberg, one eighth visible above the water, with seven eighths below water - being the struggle outside parliament.

O: How do we overcome the reluctance of trade unions to get involved? You have a very strong personal base in the trade unions...

TB: Remember that the trade unions have gone through ten years of despair, and it's when hope appears that things begin to

During the miners' strike I did say we should give serious consideration to a general strike: that's the nearest I have ever come to breaking my own rule, but people should be able to know they can rely on you. When you're in a struggle you've got to be able to come and see people in your local Labour Party or whatever and know they'll help you.

Certainly it's true that if you're not in- I volved in giving solidarity, anything you say about political direction is completely mean-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

Page 11

ingless.

Q: Fiow does this relate to saying the only way in which struggles can be won? For ex- ample if we take the dockers' strike, I would say that the only way in which it can be won is by people deciding to break the law. It cannot be won in any other way.

TB: I can understand that, and this is where my analysis comes into play. You can't tell someone else to break the law; but if they do, you support them. Supposing a docker did break the law because he heard a speech by me telling him to do it: it would have a qualitatively less effect than if he decided to do it; and as trade unionism becomes literally illegal - because this new trade union legisla- tion is going to take us back to before the Combination Acts - the argument becomes clearer and clearer.

What I do is go around and tell people all our rights were won by breaking the law. That's just a step back from saying "break the law": but if they do, then you support them. You're more welcome if you operate in an educative and supportive role rather than tell- ing people what they should do.

I feel the same on the poll tax. A member of parliament not paying the poll tax will just have it taken off his salary: but somebody who has already got a loan off the Social Fund is going to suffer personally; we have to be responsible about that.

Q: But isn't someone who is unwaged even more in need of a leadership role being taken by someone who will say Millions must not pay the poll tax'?

TB: It's a big question but you'll have to ask me whether I've ever been criticised for this other than by intellectuals of the left groups. I've never ever been criticised for not telling the miners to go on strike. On the other hand there was tremendous support when the five dockers went on strike and I moved at the National Executive a motion that was agreed unanimously - that unless they were let out by Tuesday, the Labour Party would support a General Strike.

That was fantastic, and that was what they wanted; they didn't want me to tell the five dockers what to do. It's a difference of analysis about how leadership should be exer- cised. People want backing, they don't want lectures, that's the basis on which I've worked for a long time. Leadership doesn't necessari- ly mean you push yourself out, it means you back the people who are taking the lead. The people whao are taking the real lead are the dockers, the Pergamon Press strikers, those are the ones who are giving the leadership. You mustn't assume that leadership is the spe- cial prerogative of MPs.

Q: Hilary Wainwright said yesterday that the Campaign Group of MPs should play more of a role as the parliamentary spokespersons for the Socialist Movement. How do you see the link between the Cam- paign Group and the SM being developed?

Page 12

FEATURE S

TB: It's an important question because the roots of the Socialist Movement are various. There's a group who were set up after the 1981 deputy leadership campaign who sup- ported me, and that was really the grandfather of the Campaign Group, set up formally after 1983. Then you have the Socialist Society, set up after the Great Debate of 1980 with Tariq Ali, Hilary and myself, Sheila Rowbotham, Stuart Holland. The Socialist Society was formed and had a tremendous start, and then began to shrink a bit. Then the Conference of Socialist Economists (CSE) was set up; so there are a number of contributing elements. One thing we have decided to do recently, after widespread consultation, we've decided to change the name of the Campaign Group to the Socialist Campaign Group of Labour MPs.

The Campaign Group itself has lost a few people over the years - for a variety of reasons, one being that if you join the Cam- paign Group and then denounce it, you go straight onto the Labour front bench, and the power of patronage is very strong. The House is a very individualistic place and people are incredibly busy. Once a week we gather and we have all kinds of people coming to see us: from El Salvador, the Pergamon Press strikers, workers from South Africa; and we perform this function of a collective surgery.

We have considered whether we should reform the Campaign Group on the basis of being a kind of shadow Party, but the Group doesn't want to do that. We work very well together but I think to try and over-structure it might not work. I was disappointed that more Campaign Group MPs didn't come to Shef- field, but then they are all very busy. I think the Movement will continue to grow and con- solidate, but it still is a movement in an embryonic stage. It isn't a major political force.

As the SDP dies, the Socialist Movement is born; as Labour picks up Tory votes in a shift to the left, the Greens come along and pick up votes at that end; and as Thatcher declines, the Wets get stronger. Wherever you look, you can see the whole thing shift to the left. I think the 1990s are going to be wholly different. The policy review was written in the winter of despair and published in the spring of hope, and they are absolutely out of time. The policy reviews are the last events of the pessimistic 1980s and the 1990s lie ahead of us: what we're doing and saying is going to be very influential.

We're trying to tilt the direction of think- ing about politics: we've had twenty years of Thatcherism in Britain, not ten, and our objec- tive must be to build a consensus for socialism.

Q: At the Morning Star fringe meeting at Sheffield you called for the Morning Star to become the daily paper of the Socialist Movement. Given that the SM is made up of different currents - including ourselves, the SWP, and Labour Party people who

wouldn't necessarily support the politics of the Morning Star - is that a good Idea?

TB: I said it would be a good thing if the Morning Star did become the daily paper of the SM. The Morning Star is the only daily paper which provides the news items I want to read: it tells you what's happening in all the strikes, and on the whole its news items are not so bad. I think we've got to get over this historic argument between Stalin and Trotsky - they're very important streams, but to sug- gest that this is going to be the touchstone is a sectarian approach.

Q: But if we were going to have a daily paper of the Socialist Movement, wouldn't we want one that was democratically ac- countable to the SM itself rather than con- trolled by one party or another?

TB: Another socialist daily paper would probably be a good thing. The Morning Star is actually accountable to its readers.It's not really, as some people in the left groups tend to think, tied to Moscow and the old Moscow line. You have to encourage all the left papers, but if people could get hold of the Morning Star as a daily paper they would be better in- formed.

Q: At the second Socialist Conference we had the Benn-Heffer leadership challenges and at Sheffield we had the Socialist Policy Review. We seem now to have about 900 people who attend regularly; what focus can we use over the next year to turn the conferences into a Movement and keep people together?

TB: The Benn-Heffer campaign - and it was a campaign - was a very exhausting thing to do, and a lot of people were critical of it at the time. We went round the country; that played a notable part in building up a network of people, and the organisers of that campaign are now asociated with the SM. I think it deferred the policy reviews for twelve months.

What will happen next year depends a lot on other ihings. If the industrial militancy continues, the Labour conference will have a very different flavour from the one that was anticipated when the policy reviews went through, and then there will be scope for developing the argument in a way that is per- suasive and influential.

Q: Do you feel that the vote for the Greens has strengthened the left within the Labour Party?

TB: Yes, the Greens got 15 per cent with unilateralism. It's always been the Labour leadership's historical argument that there's nowhere else for the left to go. I'm not in favour of people voting Green; but I know that now there is somewhere else to go, and when you get Green pressure instead of SDP

pressure on the Labour Party, that will tilt it in

a direction that's good. An environmental

policy is as incompatible with capitalism as a

socialist policy.

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 17, Summer 1989

← Building the Socialist Movement · Understanding Trotsky →

Something wrong on this page?