A T UR E
South Africa
The early years on the 1980s were years of great turbulence in South Africa. Tens of thousands of people took part in massive struggles against the apartheid regime - in the townships, in the factories, mines and workshops. The trade union movement con- solidated itself, led successful strikes and increased its poten- tial influence by the building of two national trade union federa- tions - COSATU and NACTU.
The state's response was to declare a state of emergenev, banning 90 or 1 ganisations including the United Democratic Front and youth organisa- tions. From the regime's point of view i this has had the desired effect.
With the mass political organisa-
WAI APHT
PHOTO REFLEX
Supporters of Buthelezi's Inkatha movement have murdered ANC and UDF activists, but are now courted by Mandela and the ANC
tions banned, theirleaders detained for indefinite periods without trial, and, when released, subjected to severe restrictions, a down-tum in the intensity of the struggle was. perhaps, mevitable. Il recalle the imr aftermath of Sharpville when, for nearly a decade after the banning of the African Nation- al Congress (ANC)and the Pan African Con- gress (PAC) the masses seemed to slumber - only to awaken into insurrectionary-scale activity with the Soweto uprising, and the birth of the new hlack trade unions following the rash of spontancous strikes which hit Durban in 1972.
The uprisings in the Iownships in the 1980s. the formation of street and area committees. People's Courts, and the massive increase in support of the hanned organisations, particular ly the ANC, led to speculation that the revolu tion was just around the comer. The oppressed people had given notice that they were not longer willing to tolerate their condition: ac- cording to some, the declarabion of a state of emergency showed that the rulers were no longer able to go on ruling. These era particularly argued by the ANC and the Com- munist Party leaderslups.
In 1985, a regular contributor to the South African CP's joural African Communist, who uses the pen-name "Comrade Mzala', could write that South Africa was on the threshold of the revolution'. The whole tenor of his article was around the quesiton: "How should we raise the question of the armed insurrection?. ANC and CP propaganda continually spoke of 'People's Power" and 'People's War'. rade Mzala winte of the street commitlees and communal organisations as organs of self- govemment on the one hand and organs of in-
d, when ctions. a gle was amediate nearly a 3 Nation- can Con- lumber - ıry-scale the birth g the rash urban in
le 1980s. amittees. crease in articular- e revolu ppressed were not tion: ac i state ot
were no he Con
mutt
who
ald
article
ANt
Com-
SOCIALIS: liternat
surrection on the other.' ANC President Oliver Tambo spoke of "dual power".
Today there is a completely different atmos- phere. Policies which would have been cas. tigated as treason of heresy a couple of years ago are today discussed openly in the pages of the ANC's publications Sechaba and African Communist. "Negotiation" and "dialogue" have now become acceptable for discussion in the policy making hierarchies of the ANC and CPSA.
In Sechaba in August 1988. Alex Mashinini, in an article entitled 'People's War and Negotiation", wrote: A relatively new concept, that of a negotiated scttlement of the South African conflict, has already won itself a prominent position in the political vocabulary of the country'. He gnes on to argue that, "Since we are confronted with conditions under which absolute victory is impossible, conditions in which both sides must necessarily make com promises on certain positions, we can conclude that the outcome of any negotiations that can be conducted must end up in partial victories for the warring parties. Both sides would havr failed to defeat cach other absolutely, and we would have to be content with partial victories.
Elaborating on what he meant by "partial victories, he writes that it would 'impose some Eimitations on our programme of social eman- cipation. In practical terns, this means that the concept of partial victory implies the de jure abolition of apartheid, and says less about the de facto abolition.
On what does he base this argument? He seemsto believe that the sn-called 'reforms" in- troduced by President Botha have created 'an infra-structure of democratic transformation -
within the womb of the apartheid system, and within the process of the struggle to destroy it"
Can he, perhaps have in mind the Tri cameral racist parliament? The fact that this in now openly being discussed within the ANC does not, of course, mean that the ANC leader- ship has already changed their position on the need for armed struggle. Not yet! But Mashinini does give more than a broad hint that there is a faction or tendency within the ANC who are thinking along these lines:
..if we have introduced a new element. that of the negotiated settlement, and if we shared the belief that transition in South Africa will have in come through negotiations, then it is imperative to address and review the strategy of the people's war." A far cry, indeed, from the heady days of the carly 1980s.
Mashinini himself is only a very recent con- vert to the concept of a negotiated settlement. In April 1986, he argued in the pages of Sechaba, that the highly developed capitalism of South Africa has given rise to a large black working class, relatively highly organised and class-conscious, with a political expericnce and maturity arising from half a century of mass political mobilisation.
He emphasised that this as it could be con ceived of in any highly developed capitalist
country brought to the fore of the struggle the issue of insurrection. (Quoted by Bundy in Transformation, No. 8) What are the forces which are causing this "new thinking' in the
ranks of the ANC? It cannot simply be the
abolition of petty-apartheid. The main founda-
tions of apartheid: the Group Areas Act, the
Land Acts and the Registration of Population
Act, are still firmly in place, with no sign that
Lan-
Page 23
FEATURES
they will soon disappear. The mass or-
ganisations remain banned. Detention
without trial or severe restriction on the without trai
political activity of those released con- tinues. Anti-trade union legislation is on the statute book. In what way, then, is apartheid aborting itself? Clearly this is nonsense, and we must look elsewhere.
There has always been more than onc source of developments in South Africa in the ANC - a reformist and a revolutionary wing, with shadings in between. There are
ther reinforced by the statement issued by the ANC from Lasaka on April 19. In this the ANC gives its full support to the peace conference which is being proposed by. among others, the Roman Catholic Archbishop Dennis Hurley, Professor Pete Booyssen, Principal of the Univer- sity of Natal, and by Buthelezi to try and end the black against black violence in Natal.
The statement from the ANC reads:
"Members of Inkatha, the UDF.
COSATU, businessmen, clergymen,
doctors, lawyers, social workers, youth
and women, people of all races, you share
the responsibility of ending apartheid -
he root cause of all the conflicts. Jain
forces and present a formidable front
against the violence of apartheid.
COSATU and UDF affiliates issued a
press statement giving full support for the
proposed conference.
These are all indicators showing the
direction the wind is blowing.
But this wind is not only affecting some elements in the liberation movement. Speaking to a National Party conference, the new party leader, F. W. de Klerk also said that the time for negotiations with all South Africans has arrived. Paiticipants in this great indaba would he 'free" to put their full view- points and counter-proposals. Talks could be
concentrated on how the aspirations and expec- tations of all the people could be reconciled, and he proffered a new onstitution which
would allow "full participation to
all South Africans and without pre-
signs that the reformists, who see the way
has always been a strong petty-bourgeois TO: Aull BraSow/Retla
forward through negotiation and dialogue have been strengthened. Why is this?
Ever since its foundation in 1909. there
element in the ranks and leadership of the ANC, but in the years of violent confronta-
shadowed by younger elements and PHOTO:
tion with the state, this sector has been over-
workers. But they are still there and they have gained sustenance by the growth of a National Party leader FW de Klerk - 'time for black trader class and a black bourgeoisie. negotiations
Now Moscow has added its not incon- siderable weight and prestige in support of a less intransigent approach.
In an article in the Weekly Mail (March 23- 30), Alexander Devitt, political analyst of the Novosti Press Agency in Moscow, quotes Uri Yukalov, head of the African Administration of the foreign ministry of the USSR. The inn- guage in diplomatic and guarded, but there is nough in it to encourage the "moderates' in the ANC
and the ANC believe that the climination of apartheid by political methods would be in the interests of all South Africans, black and white." He did, however, add that the elimina- tion of violence depends on Pretoria rather than the ANC or the Soviet Union.
The pro-negotiation tendency must have been further strengthened by the letter from Nelson Mandela to the British Ambassador to Pretoris, Sir Robert Renwick, in which he cicar- ly hinted that he would like talks, and
Joint platform with Buthelezi and UDF against repression Mandela's almast effusively friendly letter to Mangoshutu Buthelezi, leader of the right wing Inkatha movement It is considered of great significance that he addressed Buthelezi by his tribal name "Shngi" and signed with his own tribal name 'Madiba"
Buthelezi has long been Pretoria's favoured candidate for negotiations, but he has always insisted that he could not take part in discus-
sions until Mandela is released. The question arises: is Mandela preparing himself to play a Tole in secking a way out of the impasse in South African politics? Of great significance is the passage in his letter to Buthelezi where he expressed his "fervent hope (to see) the restora
tion of the cordial relations which existed be- tween the two organisations ANC and Inkathas in the seventies.
Yet in the June 1987 issue of Sechaha, one of the leading CP theoreticians,
Theodoropolous, referred to Buthelezi as a
"quisling" and a "traitor"
The pre-negotiation position has been fur-
The Soviet Union, said Yukalov, preferred a political settlement and a political solution to the apartheid problem... and struggle is not the sole
means (of fighting apartheid). There are means (ot righting up others including sanctions.
"The isolation of apartheid will con-
Paddock/Ret
in dealing with the verne ~ Soun PHOTO: Bly Pad:
tinne as long as it exists. But this does not mean that we shall only use our fists
Vukalow then cited the An-
Yukalov ines alted the An- gola/Namibia peace process as an ex- ample of the drafting of agreements in wheih there are no winners-. wets sides stood to gain", he said.
The striking simuaritv hetweer ogy used by Yukalov anu Mast entirely so «deltar.
Fine wonders » the No cer. nolabl SWAPC. Wanch had:
nrocess would i
• And has the Kr-.
i. Ber this does
¡the phraseo!
cannot bee
vu 10T.
..th ..is sa-
guine view. similar procedure Do
In Moscows view of " .. Africa, as interpreted bv Yukaur. will be played, we by forces but by multilate. abandoning or attitude tion: This would dener. consensus among perti.. United Nations Security Council.
Most ominous of su the position of favouning pou rational solutions for South a the Soviet Union shared with the ANC. are no differences in our nr.m.
lover.contmon- a was one tha
ANG "Thete
The USSR
requisites.
These fine words have been met with scom by the black majority. They would want to see some sign of scriousness of intent behind the beautiful promises - such as an end to the state of emergency; the release of all political prisoners uncondi- tignally, the lifting of restrictions on political activists; the un-banning of the mass organisations; the abolition epression - censorship; and an end to capital
But, nf course, the National Party leader was, in the finst instance, addressing his white
ance, addresung his white constituency, which he will be facing in the general elections later this year. He has writ- ler off the far nght-wing Afrikaners. Their
vote will go to the Conservative Party. Now he
is hoping to win over a section of the 'liberal"
English speaking white voters, thus undercut-
ting the newly-formed Democratic Party.
De Klerk, like P.W. Botha before him, is
aware that old-style Verwoerdian apartheid is
no longer on the agenda. He is secking a way
out which will safeguard the privileges of the
white minority and save capitalism. One caris
cocked to the emergence of "moderate voices
among the oppressed. Pretoria's succes in
finding a solution to the Namibia problem, with
the assistance of Angola, Cuha and the Soviet
Union, has raised hopes that it can also find
hitherto unlikely allies in the black liberation
punishment,
But. n°
Engli
De Kraro
hithere movement.
Charlie Van Gelderen
Page 24
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 16 June 1989
F UR E
PHOTO. John HarriNFL.
Muslim men opposed to Rushdie - and women's rights
'Your
weapon is
fear - ours
is courage'
Over the past month twe new groups have been formed which aim to break new ground in the debate in the wake of the Salman Rushdie affair.
On May 27, Women against Fundamen- talism organised a picket on the theme •Religious leaders don't speak for us' against the demonstration called by Islamic fundamen- talists; it was scarcely noticed by the media. However Women against Pundamentalism was Taunched as a network which seeks to challenge the rise of fundamentalism in all religions. Coverage in the June editirin of Spare Rib looks not only at the growth of Islamic fundamen- talism but at the development of Sikh
* the deveipment of Sikh separatism, at the role of the Bible-thumpers of the anti-abortion movement, and of Jewish fun- damentalism in Israel's campaign against the intifada.
The Islamic fundamentalists have portrayed themselves an the spokesmen (sic) of the Mus- lim community in Britain - and it is no surprise to Asian women who have been organising for some time on a secular basis that the organisers of the anti-Kushdie demonstration explicitly stated that they did not want women and children to participate!
Inw nave portrayca
visha Mr
Both