Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Stalinists — or national communists?

· Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · pp 30-31 · 1,121 words

Stalinism Asia

STAL IN IS M

DEBA

Chinese and Vietnamese CPs

The last issue of Socialist Outlook published a lengthy reply from Phil Hearse and Dave Packer to my short let- ter on the question of what constitutes a Stalinist party. The debate has been going on in the Trotskyist movement for decades, and needs to continue because the world keeps changing (Gorbacher. Euro-Communism, and so on).

In the debate berween Dave/Phil and I there is a lot of common ground: on the roots for the growth of the bureaucratic power in the Soviet Union and other workers' states, on the need for political revolutions in those countries to cstab lish a socialist democracy: and on the spread of the Stalinist influence to Communist Parties across the world and therefore the need to build new revolutionary parties, We also agree that come of these Communist Parties actually lead successful revolutions in opposition to the line of the Soviet Union, because these parties wanted to abolish capitalism in their own country, hut that the majority of the Communist Parties were and still are opposed to proletarian revolutions.

The debate started in the last issue of Socialist Outlook is on whether one should call Stalinist those Communist Parties which have actually taken power or which are actually trying to do so.

Dave and Phil define Stalinism this way:

*Stalinism, surely, is that group of move- ments and parties which are subordinated to the interests of the bureaucracy of a workers state. or have their origins in such a subordination and today retain the characteristic

Dave and Phil a Stalinist party can be either reformist or revolutionary, if by revolutionary party you mean a group of people who we willing to overthrow capitalism by destroying the capitalist state and replace it with a proletarian one.

Dave and Phil try to explain that it is only under exceptional circumstances that revolutionary Stalinist parties can be found. They mention third world" countries like Yugoslavia and China where all sections of the national bour- geoisie refused to play the role of Stali counter-revolutionary ally in the popular front" - they did not want to collaborate with the Com- munist Party in modernising capitalism.

That has been the case in a lot of countries, without bringing any change in the class col laboration of the Communist Parties. But more important: you cannot explain the successful revolutions (led by communist parties) in China, Yugoslavia and Vietnam by the refusal of the national bourgeoisie to play the role of counter-revolutionary ally in the popular front"

How can you explain the Vietnamese CP's sacrifices in 40 years of war by their inability to involve the nationul bourgeoisic in a counter- revolutionary popular front? They could have established such a popular front in South Viet- nam when they look power in Saigon (it would have delighted the national and international bourgeoisie). But instead they started building

a workers" state in South Vietnam.

Mao won a bitter faction-fight inside the Chinese CP in 1935 against those who wanted to have a counter-revolutionary popular front.

Stalin may be dead - but his methods live on. our relations with such parties.

Dave and Phil argue that those Communist Parties that have led successful revolutions have opposed revolutions elsewhere in the world, and have become as bureaucratic and manipulative towards the masses as the Soviet Union if not more, Lagree. But that is not an ur- gument for defining all these parties as Stalinist. We need different definitions for different categories of parties, simply to avoid confusion.

If we reserve the term Stalinism to those sub- ordinate to the interests of the Soviet

bureaucracy, we could call Maoists all those subordinate to the Chinese burcaucracy. Such

definitions will be independent of what the of

ficial idcology of those parties may be. The CPs

in these two categories will all be counter.

revolutionary, because they subordinate their activities to the interests of a bureaucracy rather

than to the interests of the world proletariat. We can call those CPs which have broken links with

a foreign bureaucracy, but which still have a

reformist line, Euro Communists.

In order to distinguish the above

retormist parties from the reviler-

tionary parties (in "third world"

countries) which are cagaged in a

struggle to take power, one could

call the latter nabional communists.

The national communists do not

have a full programme for the

definitit..

"Mao won a bitter faction fight inside

Apart from the possible cun- the Chinese CP in 1935 against those

who wanted to have a practices of Standy whendie counter-revolutionary popular front."

parties that are fighting to achieve a revolution

anIc cacar: • mie nea

dennition 1F parties that are fighting to achieve a revolution (at least in their own country) and parties which are willing to de almost everything to avoid a proletarian revolution. in other words it calls "Stalinist revolutionary as well as counter-

But in Marxism the question of class power is the most important of all questions So whether a party is a refunnist or a revolutionary

According to

(Mao also continued for diplomatic reasons to pay lip service to the official Stalin line on popular fronts, but that is another matter).

What is important to understand is that al- though all Communist Partiexcoming out of the

Cominter (3rd International) tradition became influenced by Stalinist theories and practices, they did not all become counter-revolutionary partiex. One has to make a concrete analysis of each of them in order to judge whether they are reformist or revolutionary.

That work has already been done on the CP's in the imperialist countries and the workers'

But there we a few CPs in the "third world" countries (like El Salvador, the Philip pines and South Ainca) that need to be studied in more detail. The conclusions of such studies will obviously have political consequences for

have a full programme for the

liberation of the working class in

the world (particularly for a politi-

cal revolution in the bureaucratised workers!

states). Their programme is often national or

regional. But despite their limitations in programme and tactics (some of them have rather advanced tactics) we should develop

comradely contacts with such revolutionaries.

Some of them might become counter- revolutionary parties once they have achieved power, as we have seen in China, Yugoslavia etc. Wecan do nur hest to avoid such a process by gesting involved in solidarity work today with the revolutionary struggles in those

and acvelop

nintee

acmeved agoslavia a proce ink texas in thos marcott

munists as petty-hourgcors nationalists will not be of any help and will only place us on the

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

sidelines.

Finn Jensen

R EV

New feminist literature

Reviewed by

Judith Arkwright

← Not so popular front · New feminist literature →

Something wrong on this page?