Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Not so popular front

· Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · pp 28-29 · 2,122 words

Marxism Trotsky Stalinism

The Democrats' new strategy document. 'Our Different Vision' (a sort of SLD 'Aims and Values'), got at least one rave review recently.

Far more impressive in its intellectual reach and sense of the future than anything that the old Alliance or the Labour Party managed to produce. world, ...'a real feel for that new world, a sense of what it might he

-Tellectuar reach invthing that the viu

sed to

..the real

ar the Lannur Parr

...'it has a purchase on the real

a real feel for that new worlu, a sense

it might he

No. not an excerpt from an SLD press release. Not a sympathetic Guardian review. either. This was Communist Party (CPGB) member and editor of Marxism Today, Martin Jacques, writing in the Sunday Times.

His article went on, under the heading Democrats" vision puts left in touch with the real warld". to promote the SLD 'vision" and to recommend to readers an extension of the cross party debate promoted by Samirdar and Charter 88 in response to the challenge of

Thatcherism. Jacques conclusion" is that the Thatch-r

result of all this could he a re-run of the 1945

ult of all..

Labour revival - or not: anyway. 'something very different could emerge...The left is in a state of depression, but these could yet rum out

Typically inconclusive. But, of course, there's a lot more to this than meets the eye. Be- hind all the talk abour talks, lies the more

mid he a m-n...

.: an way ... emerge The seft es

vet hin

develaped political project frequently put for ward in the pages of Marxism Today: an elec- toral pact, or govermental coalition of the centre-left, anti Thatcherite parties.

So all this talk tums out to be not so vision-

ary, or even very new, after all. The labour

movement has seen this before, sometimes u

different guises and in different forms in par- ticular historical and political situations. What it boils down to is what the Communist Party

par What

ASIC S

Dirty deals and capitalist

coalitions

From 1935, under the direction of the Com- munist International, dominated by Stalin, com- munist parties across Europe abandoned their ultra-sectarian policies of the "Third Period' (which had divided the powerful German workers" movement and thus opened the door for Hitler) and switched to an equally disastrous policy of popular fronts, Faced with the rise of fascism, the Stalinist parties openly advocated. and actually joined in parliamentary coalitions not only with reformist (social democratic) par- ties but also with 'democratic bourgeois par-

lies.

The results were devastating. Sa wide were the CP nets thrown, and so right wing the result- ingattempts at political alliances, that they were frequently denounced from the left by reformist Icaders, including the British Labour Party. Worse, the policy of the popular front when ap plied in practice led the Spanish Stalinists to support not the workers bur the hourgeois republic in 1936-39 as it suppressed the strug

gles of workers and peasants - and the CP itsclf helped carry out and organise the systematic slaughter of Spanish revolutionaries. This un- holy alliance against the key forces in resisting Franco's fascist offensive was hased on 'unity in defence of bourgeois private property: it served only to politically (and physically) dis- arm the workers movement and reinforce Franco's grip on his predominantly peasant base, and paved the way for final defeat in 1939.

In France, the polities of the Popular Frout helped defuse a pre-revolutionary situation un 1936, and also led to the defeat of the working class after two years of intense struggle as well as the demise of the popular front government itself. The popular front policy began not from

any mistaken axsessment of the specific situa- tion in wester Europe, but from a cynical ap- praisal of the diplomatic interests of the Soviet bureaucracy, seeking alliances with the so- called "democratic" imperialist govemments, and riding roughshod over the interests of the working class.

It also fed off the self-seeking interests of a developing bureaucratic layer leading the refor- mist and Stalinist parties and trade unions; they

controlled the apparatus from the top and had

no desire to see the full force of independent

working class unleashed. They knew that if the

working class were allowed to feel their own

strength they might just boor out their own

(mis)leaders as well as the capitalists.

The same politics of Moscow-sponsored

class collaboration dominated the wartime line

of the communist partics in the allied powers,

who became foremost champions of the

capitalist war-effort, breaking strikes and sup

porting anti union laws. The immediate post- war period saw an cqually pernicious revival of popular frontism, with CP ministers conniving

at the imperialist mcasures of coalition govert- ments in Italy and France, until capitalist rule

winn th

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

T Q BA S A C

bad been re-stabilised and the cold war saw them kicked out. The same bankrupt politics were central to the parliamentarist British Road to Socialism in 1951 and its various revised edi- tions ever since, and other CPs have followed the pattern of gradually throwing overboard their historic links to class struggle politics, leninism, marxism and even the pretence of a revolutionary programme.

The preferred path of many communist and reformist parties over the years has been to hope for a short cut to power and respectability, to tum directly to deals with sections of the bour- geoisie in the popular front. This means you lie down, roll over and hope the bosses tickle your tummy. They might of course, stamp on you in stead. More often than not, they do. The most brutal reminders of this in the post-war period brought the mass slaughter of communist party members in Indonesia in 1964, and the murder or torture of thousands of socialists and com- munists after General Pinochet's coup in Calle in 1973.

All this is not to argue that revolutionaries can afford to ignore the fight for fighting allian- ces with non-revolutionary forces, and posture, pure, from the sidelines, simply denouncing the reformist or Stalinist leaderships. Many would- be marxists undoubtedly make that mistake, suffering the inevitable fate of all sectarians - as workers: struggles and self confidence grow, they become increasingly irritating and ir relevant.

The problem of how minority (and often very small) groups of revolutionary marxists should relate to and influence the majority in the worker's movement (often led by reformists or stalinists). remains. In advancing workers" struggles and building alternative left currents, what should the relationship of marxists be to an often open rank and file but usually hostile leaderships in the fight to overthrow capitalism i

The answer: a revolutionary

approach

There is an alternative course, outlined by the early Congresses of the Communist Intera- tional and in Leon Trotsky's writings - and fought for by more progressive sections of the marxist left: the united front.

The theory is laid out step by step simply and effectively by Trotsky in his capacity as a central leader of the Comintern when he as sessed the political situation of France in 1922, in the article On the United Front. He argues for the establishment of a clear, class based party (in opposition to the reformists and centrists) and for joint struggles to draw in those workers still organised by the reformist parties.

He says:

"The task of the Communist Party is to lead the proletarian revolution. In order to summon the proletariat for the direct conquest of power and to achieve it the Communist Party must hase itself on the overwhelming majority of the working class. So long as it does not hold this majority, the party must fight to win it.

"The party can achieve this only by remain- ing an absolutely independent organisation with a clear programme and strict intemal dis

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

cipline...

Where revolutionary currents are not really parties but relatively small currents without real mass influence, the problem of united front work is not posed in the same way. Where the marxists are a big cnough force to command significant attention, or even make a difference,

Trotsky speaks to the Fourth Congress of the Communist International. the united front tactic becomes absolutely cru- cial, argues Trotsky.

"If the party embraces one third or one half of the proletarian vanguard, then the remaining half or two thirds are organised by the refor- mists or centrists. It is perfectly obvious, however, that even those workers who still sup- port the reformists and the centrists are vitally interested in maintaining the highest material standards of living and the greatest possible freedom for struggle. We must consequently so devise our tactic as to prevent the Communist Party, which will on the morrow embrace the entire three-thirds of the working class, from fuming into - and all the more so, from actual- ly being - an organisational obstacle in the way of the current struggle of the proletariat.

"Still more, the party must assume the initia- tive in securing unity in these current struggles. Only in this way will the party draw closer to those two thirds who do not as yet follow its leadership, who do not as yet trust the party he- cause they do not understand it'.

Trotsky's conception is not one where com- munists move politically rightwards to merge with icformists and the 'democratic bourgeoisie', but of tactics which mobilise the reformist-led workers, and thus lead them through their experiences of struggle towards the marxist programme.

What does this mean in practice? Getting down to the specifics, Trotsky continues in a passage which, though long, spells out the ap proach clearly:

"The circumstances make wholly possible joint action on a whole number of vital issues between the workers united in these three respective organisations (Communist, refor-

mist and centrist) and the unorganised masses adhering to them.

The Communists, an has been said, must not oppose such actions but on the contrary must also assume the initiative for them, precisely for the reason that the greater is the mass drawn into the movement, the higher its self-confidence rises, all the more self-confident will that mass movement be, and all the more resolutely will it be capable of marching forward, however modest may be the initial slogans of struggles. And this means that the growth of the mass aspects of the movement tends to radicalise it, and creates much more favourable conditions for the slogans, methods of struggle, and, in general, the leading role of the Communist Party.

Nothing could be further from the miserable defeatist drivel chumed out by today's Com- munist Party", Marxism Today, and its echo in the 'new realist policy reviews and anti-left witch-hunts of Kinnock's Labour leadership. Trotsky's bold assertion of class struggle methods to win support might almost be a specific blast against the likes of Brian Gould and today's TUC:

"The reformists dread the revolutionary potential of the mass movement; their beloved arena is the parliamentary tribune, the trade union bureaux, the arbitration boards, the min- isterial ante chambers.

"On the contrary, we are, apart from all other considerations, interested in dragging the refor- mists from their asylums (places of refuge, Ed.] and placing them alongside ourselves, before the eyes of the struggling masses. With a cor- rect tactic we stand only to gain from this...?

Marxists, argues Trotsky, therefore belong not in a cringing front with Liberals and wet Tories, but in the thick of every struggle, alongside the best sections of the working class:

Unity of front consequently presupposes our readiness, within certain limits and on cer- tain issues, to correlate in practice our actions with those of reformist organisations, to the ex- tent to which the latter still express today the will of important sections of the embattled proletariat".

At least, if nothing else, the politics of Mar- tism Today are consistent. If you abandon the class struggle, the popular front is as good a front as any to hide behind. Those who want to fight to defend and advance the working class- and also to fight as marxists for the leadership of the mass organisations - will look to forma- tions that provide for unity in action and allow them to retain political and organisational inde- pendence: the united front.

JANE WELLS

Further reading

The first five years of the Communist International,

Leon Trotsky, Volume 2, Monad. (Ch. 8 - On the

United Front"s The Struggle Against Fascism in Germany Trotsky,

Pathfinder. (especially Ch. 7 and 14) Theses. Resolutions and Manifestos of the First Four

Congresses of the Third International, Inklinks.

1980. (p.395-397, "The United Front Tactic" and

p.400-409 "appendix - Theses on the United

Front ")

Page 27

← The Phillipines: 3 Years after the 'February Revolution' · Stalinists — or national communists? →

Something wrong on this page?