Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

'Neither maids, nor nuns, nor idiots'

· Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · pp 21-22 · 1,700 words

In late 1988, France was shaken by a series of massive public sector strikes. To the fore were health workers, and among them nurses took the lead. ANNE MARIE GRANGER interviewed a number of nurses who had been active in the strike (which won many of its demands) including members of the strikers' national co-ordinating committee. The following extracts from her article (in the French marxist journal Cahiers du Feminism) show how they felt about their public 'image' - as women and nurses - and how they started to fight it.

'We want recognition' Nadia maintains. "When they say 'nurses' people immediately think of putting on bandages or washing patients. They forget our three years study, and the knowledge we have to have... When (prime minister) Rocard talked on TV about 'under- qualified jobs and put us on the same level as prison officers - well that really stuck in my throat! We're not just patient minders': our qualifications should be recognised.

In making that demand, the nurses are challenging the whole social

loved, we would have to give all our time to it - not work to set hours.

Workers like any

others...

That is just what the nurses don't

want any more. Stuff "vocation" and "dedication", we are nurses!" said the hadge of the strike coordination.

Ick in the name of these ahatrac- tions like 'calling" and "vocation' that nurses are always exploited and

under-paid says Nadia. "Because we help suffering people they insist on the

title "vocation": they say to us "your

Deward is to save lives. Well, we agree, hut saving lives doesn't give us

anything to eat! Using the excuse that

we do a 'social" job, pay is considered

image of their job. "The whole image of the devoted nume, always ready to sacrifice, that's an image inherited from the past when nurses were from religious orders, and practised their

Af the da

unimportant.

"I's true that we do the job with the aim of helping people, hut it's neces xary to be realistic. We are like other people, we also work for financial reasons - to live. We don't want the aura of being "saints'. We want our job to be considered as important as other

jobs which involve training. We want

occupation as a 'calling' " replied Valerie. "Ar training school", she said 'they prepared as for this approach of

hecause we had an occupation we

nCUP Valerie

'they pre "sacrifice

repeating endlessly that

12 February 1989

lo be on the same level as other Peopic "

Lene, for he part, talked about the malaise in the profession. "There is the idea that we are not real workers. That's without doubt because we are women nurses. We inherit two problems: being women and being nurses."

All the traditional banalities about "typical women's jobs' reach their apex when it comes to nursing. A typi- cal example was the ideas expressed by male nurses in a letter to Le Monde

(25 October 1988) "It's a woman's profession because qualities of sym- pathetic understanding are essential': "women have more dexterity: or

again 'a sick person is in a dependent situation, he expects a certain amount of mothering. Male nurses are there to

them in cnable them to get past that stage."

In short. according to these gentlemen (who are in general tech- nicians, the better to express their

'skills") the joh of nursing is only an extension of the 'matemal function of women!

"We are like

other people, we

also work for financial

reasons -

to live...

Page 19

REPENT MAGGIE

E EN

denly removed and replaced...

the telly!

lohn Hards AR

A lead to Europe: the Manchester nurses' strike which triggered the British protest.

And when it's not the mage of of 80 or 90 per cent women. This ex- "mother" it's the flip-side - the image plains some of the specific features of of the 'randy nurse says Valeric. the struggle. Entering into struggle is anked under her white coat and who never the same thing for a woman as sleeps with all the doctors and interns. for a man, not heesuse of any biologı- Whichever way it is, nun or whore, cal reasons, but because in the main for .. te never recognised as somcone women its never possible t. complete- yunified like technicians. People ly separate their working lives from think "feminine intution: 1s enough their "private lives. Even during

for this joh. Old cliches die hard!

strikes they continue to curry the

Bin the nurses movement started weight of the home on their backs: as

ment.

vive thix old idenlogical claniran a Clande nut it. "The nurses' drike wax

... we speak of a double

work-day for

working women, but women on strike faced a triple work-day!"

good helting. Under the slogan of 'neither maids, nor nuns, nor fools' they demanded the right to dignity and equality. They wanted an end to being

docile orderlies, there to simply bandage wounds; they demanded the right to think. It's just as much their place as women in a very hierarchical universe (85 per cent of doctors are many that they are questioning.

In February 1988, on the other side of the Channel, British nurses, often called angels" took strike action on a massive scale, to gain recognition of their training and responsibilities. "Why not do the same over here too?" said many French nurses... The result was the massive March 25 demonstra- tion, and then the birth of a national co-ordination of nurses, That was the emergence of a movement which gradually overturned the rules of the political game.

A large part of the strength of the movement of the nurses and other medical personnel came from the foel- ing that the struggle really helonged to them: the method of organisation which they adopted (local, regional and then national co-ordinations. based on general assemblies in cach hospital, with mandated delegates) showed the desire to guard and main- tain their control of the struggle, and involve the maximum number of

people. Thir was all light years away from the "days of action" called by the union leaderships, without any con- sultation with the 'hase"

A 'base composed, let'snot forget,

work at an emergency cover level; but it was also the kids in the house in the evening, the housework and the iron ing - even if the "husbands" did a bit more for a while, even if the housework was left to one side, even if frozen food and sandwiches con- stituted our daily fare'.

Irene emphasised: "the women who mobilised had to assume multiple tasks: we speak of a double work day for working women, but women on strike faced a triple work-day!

Everyone talked of the constant tension between their work at the hospitals, the general assemblies and demonstrations, and their family responsibilities: however interesting it all was, it was still a burden.

Fortunately,' notes Clande "most of the men at home lent a hand, other- wise it would not have been bearable. But Sylvie has reservations - "they un- derstood, more or less. " She says they accepted it well at the beginning, but after a month of the strike began to find it a hit too much...

However, there are those who regret "not being able to do all that they could to support the strike because of the children. And there were those who disentangled themselves from family commitments to immerse themselves in the movement. but found that part of themselves felt guil-

Like Marie-Francoise: "Ineglected my daughter during the stnike: I didn'l think any more about her homework; I pushed her aside when I could: she got

insomnia, a terrible sore thmat, even

boils ….' Or like Irene: "I felt enor

mously guilty, not towards my hur

band, but towards my kidk. Imagine what it's like for a four year-old who is close to his mother to have her rud.

mv hum- Iningine -old who

- xud.

with

ican problems ex-

tven from the stan

anisation of the auly places they Ined to

ree responsibilitic-

so that no one had all the burden. They

tried to hold meetings at 2pm to max.

imise the number of women who

could come. They even tried to adopt

forms of struggle which meant that

they could bring their children - for example when they occupied the of fice of the director of the hospital at Agen!

A breath of fresh air

It is peekihle to give lots of difterent examples. All the women we inter- viewed said that during the weeks of the strike they did things which they didn't helieve they were capable of. These are experiences they won't for-

get, long-term gains for the move-

nat no onc nad sirte aurach. t bey

They talked as well aboul how the

struggle had changed things for them

at a personal level; that total

disconnection with their normal daily

routine - like 'a breath of fresh air'

the discovery of solidarity among

women, the pleasure of being

together: "during the struggle there

was a different atmospherc, even be- twcen many of the girls who thought they didn't have much in common I was told.

There were also the changes which the experience provoked between couples -there were a lot of collective discussions on that subject. Everybody had the same conclusion in one way or another: things can never be the same as they were before. With a qualification from Marie-Francoise, "Arthe hospital yes! But at home- well, I'm not so sure..?

The struggle of the nurses was nothing less than the expression of a resurgence of women's struggles. Is importance goes way heyond the hospitals: it has relevence for all women, because it directly confronted

the problems faced hy all working

women, especially those in the public

sector. Other women's struggles are

likely soon. Leaming the lessons of the nurses snuggles is at the same time to prepare for future oppor- tunities. The outcome will be decisive for the construction of a women's movement.

We leave the last word to Jsabelle: "Our struggle is histone for the profes

sim. Perhapealso for all women...

Page 20

SOCIALIST OUTIOOK no 12 February 1989

← Cultural revolution in the coalfields · El Salvador: FMLN calls electoral bluff →

Something wrong on this page?