Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Electoral reformism?

· Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · pp 10-12 · 1,637 words

Britain

STOP THE

RACIST

BILL

Futurisas

Charter 88 Is silent on anti-democratic immigration and nationality laws.

RICHARD JAMES explains his view of why socialists should critically support the Charter 88 campaign for

democratic rights and electoral reform.

The organisers of Charter 88 expect their campaign to have 25,000 paid up members by Easter - fast work for a movement launched in December.

The Charter has already attracted a broad range of signatories from across the political spectrum including leading figures in the Socialist Conference; elements of Lahour's soft left and hard right; and leading Social and Liberal Democrats. They join a host of academicx, writers, actors and others in the

One thing is clear: this document and the

movement it has generated have provoked a

series of unexpected and interesting fractures

and alignments among the non-Thatcherite for-

ces in British politics. It is in the labour move-

ment and within its left wing where these dif-

ferences are sharpest and the alignments seem

Andrew Ward/Repor

Hattersley: right-wing opponent of proportional representation.

strangest.

(PR) is perhaps the Charter's most controver- sial aspect, certainly within the labour move- ment. Eric Hammond, leader of the ultra-right-

wing clectricians union, and National Union of Mincworkersleader ArthurScargill, though not

signatories to the Charter, are both enthusiastic proponents of PR. Tony Benn and Roy Hat-

tersley are die-hard opponents. What oter

political issue sces such a line-up?

As with PR, so with Charter 88 as a whole:

the division between those in favour and those against is not a simple left versus right split.

One reason for this is that while the hard left has been united around many questions of

policy, there is hy no means agreement on

strategy for socialist transformation. The dif-

ferent strategic conceptions lead to different at

titudes to democratic rights in general and to PR in particular.

For those whose strategy is eesentially par-

Championing proportional representation (PR) is perhaps the Charter's most controver-

« representation

4 most controver n the labour mave

shone erne

academicx, writers, actors and others in the public eye who have lent their support to the Charter's call for a new democratic constitu- tional kettlement (see box)

But the Charter har also provoked opposi- tion - from forces more politically diverse than those harnessed in its support. Its demands are of course opposed by Thatcher. Labour's deputy leader Roy Hattersley dubbed it the "charter of despair" in the Guardian. And its al- leged "popular fronr, coalitionist basis" has been attacked by Graham Bash and Bryn Grif-

un uT sti.. Olyr we sundlins

verse than detnands are

Lam "be

"charter of despair" in the Guardian. And its al- "We call...for a new constitutiona] scitlement which would:

i strateg: ..a~ teer

leged "popular fronr, coalitionist basis" has

been attacked by Graham Bash and Bryn Grif- fithr in Lahour Briefing, newspaper of

Das-

The Charter 88 demands

nunerties as the right to peaceful assemb-

trist hy jurv. to privacy and to freedom ore whomsbeven exercised. to tre rule of law. wwwarnment

• Establish freedom of information and open govemment.

sonal representation. Reform the upper house to ei

a democratically renewed parliament and all agent

It Ensure the independence of a reformed judiciary.

I Provide legal remedies for all abuxes of power hy the state and the officials of central and Incal govemment. I Guarantee an equitable distribution of power between local, regional and national govemment.

# Draw up a written constitution, anchored in the idea of universal citizenship, that incorporates these reforms

officials of centrar ans

al sued national grett sEizenshe that in orporate...

er- nath

-tally par

vor left

/LOOK

the chances of electing a majority Labour govern- ment. For marxists, on the other hand, socialist strategy is not reducible to the elec- tion of a majority Labour government. This is without question a crucial task, but it is not a task to which all other considerations are subor- dinate.

The British electoral sys- tem is utterly and indefensib- ly undemocratic. The number of scats won by each party bears very little relation to the votes actually cast. For ten ycars we have endured Thatcher governments with large Commons majorities elected on the basis of a minority of the popular vote (less than forty-three per cent in 1987):

ZHuo

FOR DESTROYIN

PEOPLE!

LIVES

Charter 88's demands ring

ness, where there is a longing DLI

a bell in popular conscious-

for electoral reform. The anti- Thatcher majority of the elec- torate has the entirely democratic and reasonable desire to see its votes trans- lated into an anti-Thatcher WIl majority in the House of Commons.

Left wing opponen - of PR jus

u. veary of Tory nila an the any:

Will Charter 88 supporters take up the defence of trade union rights?

•jeer is the automatic corollary of support ror w Mike Ma these demands.

Wrong. It is perfectly possible to unite with very disparate and broad political forces in a

campaign for democratic rights, including clec- toral reform, without having agreement on the

channels through which they will be carried out.

For marxists, a 'united front' against

Thatcherism founded on electoral pacts is a

castle huilt on xand. The Labour leadership's

steady move to the right would speed up if the

need for agreement with the centre parties was added to its armoury of weapons lo deploy against the left. A Labour centre coalition would be bound to pursue policies of austerity and make further attacks on the working class.

No way should socialists have any illurions that such a government would make dramatic improvements in democratic rights, or even that

it would refrain from further attacking them. For a taste of what such a govemment might mean

in practice, look at the socialist goverment in France, look at the antics of the socialists in Italy's coalition government. These are hardly attractive rolé-models

The pressure towards electoral pacts and

coalitions should he resisted by the left, not as

a matter of dogma or idcological "purity", bar

because it will not deliver the goods. We are not

in the business of replacing Thatcherism with

sub Thatcherism. But that should not drive

socialists away from a campaign for democratic

rights thal crosses party boundaries. It does

mean, however, that when critically supporting

such a campaign we make clear our under-

standing of its limitations and our own inde-

pendent view of how to develop the struggle for

democratic nights.

more years of Tory rule on the grounds that the present electoral system may possibly, at some paint, produce a Labour majority in the Com- mons. This is, to say the least, a high risk option

way the nast al.

ana the lett will find in--lf in increasinglv marginaused if ir. sue it.

Consider how ditterent m would have been " proportionar герте сепано» 1979. Who could argue that minonty goverment - coalit had the political atrength or coherence to inflict the damage done by Thatcherism with its for- midable Commons majority?

Compare the situation in Batair 7en s.* other west Buropean countr democratic electoral systems. There is no doubt that one of the reasons why the austerity offen sive has been most successfu in B- the political system here was 16....r

Another reason why Charter xx the left is the broader poncal. it was tauncned and the political. of its most prominent supporters.

The Charter was presented by cors in the New Staterman... pruty pulitics. But leader unter in the Guaraian and elsewher to link the Charter with . orenalitions between Labour ar ties. In an editorial on 12 December the Guar dian called for a unite tanne vears of Thatcher supremac r pacts".

Similarly, hard le": opponer- and PR have argued that a u..a...

Wel

dan all-

ch a andin ende- *TIK

Thim

The limitations of the Charter were discussed

by Mike Margusce in Labour Briefing no. 75.

He explains that 'on Ireland, racism, leshian and

gay rights, trade union rights, self-govemment

for Scotland and Wales, the police, immigration

and asylum rights the Charter is in effect silent.

These are undoubtedly serious omissions.

Nevertheless it would be wrong to condemn the

Charter simply on the basis of what it does "not'

kay. More appropriate would be an attitude of critical support, pointing out its weaknesses.

Another argument deployed on the left against the Charter is that with its demands for

a hill of rights and a written constitution it sows

illusions" in parliamentary democracy. line of argument is ultra-left. To reject a cam- paign for extending democratic rights, on the basis that it sows illusions in the parliamentary

system, is equivalent to rejecting a struggle for more pay on the grounds that it sows illusions in the wages system! We are for the total trans- formation of the political superstructure in the

context of the transition to a socialint society -

but we do not counterpose our vision of socialist

democracy to the progressive refors which are

the subjoct of a campaign here and now.

More important than criticising the

shortcomings of Charter 88 is providing a clear

counter-strategy on how to pursue the campaign

for democratic rights to that propounded by the

advocates of pacts and coalitions. It is essential

to explain that a coalition government will not

deliver the goods. But we need to do more.

We have to explain that the strength, level of

organisation and degree of political inde

pendence of the working class is the bedrock of

all democratic rights. Basing nunselves on this

understanding, we should aim to build a strong

socialist pole within the broader campaign for

democratic rights and electoral reform.

pendence of the working class is the bedrock of

wights. Bas

12. we should

- within the h

ights and elec

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 13 March 1989

Page 9

A T U CR E

The retreat from Kabul:

← Poland: Round Table? New Premises — Appeal · Gorbachev cuts his losses →

Something wrong on this page?