Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Afghanistan

Socialist Outlook no. 13, March 1989 · pp 12-13 · 776 words

Afghanistan Russia and the USSR United States

Afghanistan to the USSR. Arguments of Soviet 'expansionism", whether raised by pro-Stalinist supporters or by op

made no effort to impose collectivisation or forces of "progress". (the Soviet artillery and in- other measures on the arcas they controlled: on tantry, napalm and heucopter gunships), would the contrary, the Karmal regime installed by help civilise or even bring a form of socialism Moscow made a continual series of overtures to the "backward" Afghans. and concessions to the islamic forces, culminat-

But many socialists who had opposed the in- ing in the new constitution at the end of 1988. vasion still had serious doubts over the effects

Those like the British Socialist Workers of a Soviet withdrawal - and were for various Party who argued then and now that Moscow's reasons profoundly reluctant in lake up the line was 'imperialist", and who now argue that demand for troops out. socialists should 'welcome" the Soviet "defeat"

The most credible argument for this point of ... view was that the Soviet invamon

had substantially changed the status

quo in 1979, and that in the aftermath

of a Sovict withdrawal the progres-

sive forces - largely grouped around

the divided Communist Party

(PDPA) - would be the victims of a

bloodbath. Unfortunately for this

point of view, the Soviet presence

could only be maintained through

the continuation of massive

slaughter and destruction, forcing

millions of Afghanx from their Courtesy of Uncle Sam: Mujahedin arms spree in Pakistan. show how far they have strayed from a class analysis. In a major article, Socialist Worker declared that:

"Defeat in South East Asia was a blow which US imperialism took a decade even to begin to recover from. Despite its victory in the Gulf the Pentagon has not yet fully erased the memory.

'Gorbachev faces a similar nightmare. The repercussions of this defeat will echo way beyond the borders of Afghanistan.

"All socialists should welcome it.

*The United States decision to supply surface to air missiles to the mujahedin was an impor- tant factor in Russia's defeat....

*Inside Afghanistan the cycle of misery wrought by yet another attempt at imperialist subjection can only continuc." (February 4, 1989)

To see the US supply of Stinger missiles as an agency for the type of change welcomed by socialists is a feat of "marxist' analysis reserved for those who share the SWP's bizarre view of the Soviet Union as a state capitalist regime, qualitatively indistinguishable from the USA. few class conscious workers will share the SWP's glee at the mujahedin victory, which they claim will encourage the opponents of Russian rule everywhere'.

Surprisingly, however, the 1979 invasion was supported not only by those who routinely backed the Moscow bureaucracy, but also by some elements from the western ultra left and

A less helpful line of opposition to calling for "troops out" rested upon the fact that Thatcher and Reagan were of course using the Afghanistan events for their own cynical propaganda. However if socialists follow this logic, they wind up gagged on any issuc where a mass popular movement clashes with a Stalinist bureaucracy - as for instance in Poland (where the cold warriors tried to hi-jack the Solidamose struggle, and many socialists got cold feet). It was never the case that by calling for troops out of Afghanistan socialists gave any support to the reactionary mujahedin.

Others, perhaps entertaining illusions that the Afghan intervention might have presaged a more active line of Soviet military support for revolutionary struggles elsewhere, argued (drawing opposite conclusions from the British SWP) that a defeat for the Red Army could trig ger the equivalent of the American "Vietnam syndrome', and thus set back the cause of revolution. Such an analysis rests, in exsence upon a crude view of the world as simply two counterposed 'camps" - with imperialism on the one hand, and the working class (including the Soviet bureaucracy) on the other.

Not only does this eliminate any inde- pendence of the working class from their bureaucratic misleaders, but it fails abysmally to grasp the reality of Stalinist foreign policy. Since Khruschev's one-off adventure with Cuba in the 1960s, Soviet leaders, beginning

Page 10

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 13 March 1989

David Stewart Smith/Inslit

Fighting for reactionary ideology and institutions - mujahedin guerrilla. with Brezhnes ave made it patently stor that new, reactionary, pro-imperialist or stanus

regime on its southem flank, which may in-

impenausm Bumar

Name the Soviet muslim republics.

Socialists cannot argue for a defence of the

USSR which depends upon the permanent

military subjection of neighbouring peoples. raise not a finger in military action to support

In fact the best defence of the USSR against insurgent revolutionaries in

← Gorbachev cuts his losses · Unity and diversity in Central America →

Something wrong on this page?