Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Fighting Section 28

· Socialist Outlook no. 12, February 1989 · pp 11-12 · 2,353 words

Lesbian and gay

Later there was a leshian and gay statement against the 'homophobia" of "left factions'; and a delegate who spoke on behalf of overseas sto-

dents ended his specch by insisting that left Factions will not tell us what to think or do". Finally a special roand of applause for Presi dent Maeve Sherlock from the women at the

conference was proposed by a Communist

onference was proposes party member on the executive.

All these episodes say something about the

leadership's political alliances. leadership - stooges and patronage, and desigued to project the pro-Kinnock DL/CP block as champions of the oppressed. This 'big lie" has been used with great effect as a weapon against the left, show. ing possibly the clearest rellection of the oppor- tunist politics of Marxism Today - a direct

counterposition between the struggles of the oppressed and the class struggle.

This type of political block can only be huilt on the weakness of the left on such questions, us seen in Militant's line that liberation cam- paigns are a diversion from the class struggle. the SWP view that only working class women are oppressed', and the crude Socialist Or- ganiser theory of fcmocracy which asserts

that a whole bureaucratic caste of women defends itself purely by alleging "sexism' against all men who politically oppose them.

This latter is important because the Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN) grouping, dominated by Socialist Organiser, has boen the tradition- al apposition to the Democratic Left and the present DL/CP block in NUS. This is by virtue of SSiN's past leadership of various important campaigns around welfare issues, and their sep resentation on the NUS executive.

However SSiN has failed to confront the key political problems in NUS, and their "theory" of femocracy has avoided or blacked any real debale with feminists in NUS. Worse, SSIN have, on occasion, when it scemed to their ad- vantage, resorted to some of the bureaucratic methods used by the DL/CP.

It is unclear whether SSiN's recent oppor- tunist meanderings are relatied to Socialist Organiser s "programmatic review" 0I a simple capitulation to clectoralism. One of the worst examples of this was their alliance last year with the pro-zionist Union of Jewish Stu- dents - the significance of which they have at- tempted to downplay.

SSIN's claim to represent the Labour left in. NOLS has declining credibility, and its future is as yet unclear: but its decline certainly merits discusson by socialists as part of the general

debate on the way forward for the student

movement. SSiN will have to stand on their

political record in such a debate.

What is needed in NUS is a formation of

wis Is a tormation of • with sufficient influence

« shake-up an conscious sweption.and to develop the

sistent with crus strug

arnt with the struggles

of the oppressod

anuunaust polibical out- en/stuar paniser have so

clearly lacked.

are eugagca in Iran the now яс Whatever t

i supporters in the colleges a proic: with such an ain left student bulletin Direction se rest of the academic year sure to ne a stormy year of

ur un socialist students

Trevor Wongsam

Not in front

of the

children?

HARINGEY

SBIANS + GAYS T2

Andrew Wiard/Report

Socialist Outlook has covered the campaign against

Section 28, which prevents local authorities from

'promoting homosexuality, and specifically outlaws teaching that homosexuality is 'acceptable as a family relationship'. In this article, JAMIE GOUGH considers the nature of the prejudice that Section 28 both uses and promotes, and the implications for constructing a socialist society.

Section 28 is being used to weaken or prevent local authorities from taking action to combat discrimination against all lesbians and gay men. But the excuse for doing this, and the focus of the at- tack, has been the issue of the "corruption' of youth: that the "teaching of homosexuality" in schools would lead to school students growing up lesbian or gay. This infringes the right of children to scientific knowledge about their sexuality, and leads to discrimination against lesbians and gay men working with children and young people.

The focus of the campaign against the Sec- tion has correctly been to emphasise the infr-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 12 February 1989

ingement of democratic rights that it involves. But there have been divisions about how to argue for these rights, and particularly how to reply to the 'corruption' argument. Some, in- cluding this magazine, have argued that there is no question of "corruption" since lesbian and gar sexuality is equally valid heterosexuality. Others, notably the Labour Party leadership, have not argued this, out of reluctance to challenge the prejudice that les- bian and gay sexuality is. in some sense Maid These forces have fallen back on the argument that young people cannot be taught to be homosexual since it is genetic, or is established al a very early age. This argument has even been used by some sections of the lesbian and gay movement. In a TV programme made by the

..eeSbian and gay newspaper …hu a psychiatrist' that car-

11.1- necause sexual identitv 1s

fixi

fixed by the age of four.

From birth?

-reame of argument simply does

ster. It penne's sexual desures are

genetically determined, why has there been

mals Vindoll in them between

al societies not just in sexual

wrink an be attributed to cir-

hue evident sexual desires? In

and in much of the world today, though there may be a notion that people can be sexually attracted more to one sex than another, there is not the idea that people are ex-

Page 9

clusively attracted to one sex, that this is as sociated with a particular type of personality and a particular way of life. The idea of sexual identities, that individuals have an inherent sexuality, including attraction to a particular sex, and that other important things follow from

this, ix a modem one.

Sexual identity arises from circumstances peculiar to capitalist and post-capitalist societies. People have some possibilities for living outside of the family, and so it becomes possible to live a "lesbian life" or a "gay life', a life which flows from your sexual desires. But the difference hetween heterosexual life and lesbian or gay ('homosexual") Life still remains crucial, because the heterosexual family remains the norm, and especially remains the proper. place lo hring up children. Thus whereas formerly sexual desires might be judged good or bad but didn't have major con- sequences, in modern times the sex that you desire tends to define the whole way that you lead your life, whether you are inside or outside the hetcrosexual family 'norm'-

Of course, this only happens partially: many people with homosexual desires marry. But for many people their sexual desires lead to a par- ticular way of life. Sexual desire thus becomes a much more important feature of people's per- sonality, so that one can talk about people having "sexual identities'.

None of this tells us how and why some people in present day society grow up heterosexual and others homosexual. It merely shows that this difference is not a biological one, but is socially created. It is therefore quite possible that positive imagex policies can result in more people growing up lesbian or gay. This is especially so because the institutions which shape sexuality - marriage, the tamily, gender roles - are now in crisis. Sexuality is unstabic. The right wing fear of "corruption" has a real element of truth. Biology cannot he used as a defence of "teaching homosexuality in schools. We have to directly answer the charge that homosexuality is an inferior sexuality.

Equally valid?

There are three areas in which lesbians and gay men are thought to be inferior. Firstly, our

sexual acts are thought of as unnatural.

'Unnatural' boils down to 'can't create

children'. This is hardly a major social problem

In the modern world, though not having

children is important to individuals:

Secondly, lesbians and gay men are thought of as having the wrong gender - lesbians as masculine, gay men as feminine. In modem

times, since sexual desire has assumed impor- tant consequences, a central part of being a

'proper woman is desiring men, and an impor

tant part of being a 'proper man is desiring

women: if you don't, you're not properly

feminine or masculine. This gender implication

of sexuality is bound up with the existence of

sexual identities. As long as there are sexual

identities, with one (the heterosexual) con

sidered 'right", and as long as there is a gender

system, there will be this association of lesbians

and gay men with deviant gender.

Thirdly, and crucially, heing leshian or gay

is considered a misfortune "because you can't

have children'. Now, of course, lesbians and

- The idea of..

.. annerent • particuat

dow tron

Page 10

A URES

reasons that people value parenthood are alco

gay men can and do have children. But in present day society this is difficult. It is ditticit for directly social and economic reasons - mar- rage, with its economic dependencies and its predetermined division of labour, provides a predictable framework for caring for children. But a large part of the difficulty is that society

considers it dangerous for children to be ex- posed to leshian and gay sexuality. Section 28 expresses this prolubition for lesbians and gay men working for local authontics; but it applies even more strongly to lesbians and gay men being parents. Thus lesbians and gay men and children living together usually experience hos tility from neighbours, from schools; and, most sharply, the courts regard lesbians and gay men as unfit parents and often prevent us and our children living together. It is ironic that while socicty tells us that we are deviants "because you cannot have children, the courtstell us that we cannot have children because you are deviants'.

The stigma of

'childlessness'

It is therefore frue that lesbians and gay men, especially ones who are open about our sexuality, are less likely to live with children than heterosexuals are. The separation of les- bians and gay men from children is therefore not simply a result of our 'deviant" sexual iden tity, but is part of that identity: our separation from children shows our 'misfortune", and is a reason for preventing children growing up les bian or gay. To a considerable extent, being or not being allowed to be with children is part of what defines heterosexuals and homosexuals.

We have a vicious

circle:..there are

heterosexual, lesbian

and gay identities, and

the latter are

'bad'...children can

grow up into lesbian

or gay individuals, and

this is 'bad'...children

must be prevented

from growing up

lesbian or

gay...lesbians and gay

men are prevented

from living with and

being with children...

Why do poople see childlessness as such a

disaster? The relationships that an adult can have with a child, are to some extent inherent-

ly different from those that she or he can have

with other adults just by virtue of age; this

would be so in a socialist snciety loo. But the

to a large degree specific to class and capitalist

societies. People want children to look after

them in their old age. Inheritance, not junt of property, but of skill, and increasingly of "hife-

nok atter

at must of

style" and "personality" is important: people

want to be perpetuated in another person. Final- ly, bearing and rearing children is a form of

creativity and productiveness. For working

people, alienated from our paid work, raising children is an area of control. In a sense, all

these historically specific reasons involve

alienation for the child, since they lend to con-

struct relationships between adults and children

on the basis of considerations which are alien

A socialist socicty would enable these alienating reasons for 'having" children to wither away. Old people would not be economically dependent on their chüldren; un- equal wealth and skill would not be there to be inherited; and creativity within production as a whole would not require compensation through dictatorial creativity with children. This would open the possibility of real choice as to whether or not to bear and live with children. The withering away of the notion of compulsory parenthood would then be part of the withering away of the heterosexual and homosexual iden- titics.

But there is another reason that

"childlessness" is considered a disaster. The

another Icason that

• visidered a disaster The central feature of the institution of the family in that children, within certain legal limits, belong

to their parents. They have, or are supposed to have, a different relationship to their biological parents from all other adults, and of course they have no choice over who these parents are. In a socialist society, children would have the right, and to the greatest extent possible the means, to choose which adults they live with. There would not he such pressure on adults to live in couples when living with children. Children would nced adults who were committed to them. But the sharp distinction between 'parents" and "non parents" would be much eroded. This would further weaken the heterosexual/homosexual distinction.

The fears people have about "corruption" cannot be side-stepped by saying that lesbians and gay men are bom not made. Nor is it simp- ly a matter of combating "ignorance", inherited prejudice, or even ruling class propaganda. These fears arise from the conditions under which people live their lives: the biological family as the prodominant means of child rear- ing and the gender system connected to it. The social distinctions and real divisions between heterosexuals and homosexuals, between "fit" and 'unfit parents, belween parents and non- parents, are logically necessary parts of how the gender and family systems are reproduced. To create alternatives to the family and gender sys- tems as part of creating socialism will mean eroding each of these distinctions and the way in which they reinforce cach other.

Issues of childhood and parenthood are ex- plosive. But in defending positive policies in schools and combating right-wing ideas about

"corruption" we need to find ways of speaking about, and enabling others to speak about, all these issues.

← A revival of student militancy? · Palestine after the Algiers resolutions →

Something wrong on this page?