Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Poll Tax and the enterprise culture

· Socialist Outlook no. 11, December–January 1989 · pp 42-44 · 1,655 words

Britain Labour Party Russia and the USSR

Enterprise Culture Susanne MacGregor; Centre for Local Economic Strategies, 1988, 66 pages, £3.95.

Reviewed by FINN JENSEN

I think, in terms of local authority services. people shouid be paying for what they get. It has nothing to do with how rich you are. In this country, we are too sold on the idea that the rich should be made to pay

for other people's

services.'

THIS STATEMENT from Nicholas Ridley, the minister in charge of the poll tax, sums up the ideas behind the enterprise culture. The consensus around the welfare

state is to be replaced by idea of setting a market price for services like education, street lighting, housing etc. As Norman Tebbit, the former chair of the Tory party, argues: why should the rich pay more for, for example, a council's street cleaning services, when the rich do not pay more for washing powder or bread in the local supermarket?

Susanne MacGregor argues in her well written and informative little book that to build an

enterprise society you have fist to demolish the welfare state".

She correctly explains the pol!

tax as part of an overall strategy. not just to undermine Labour's

strongholds in the inner-cities.

but a radical change in the social

but a raak fabric.

The book not only looks at the rating system but also at privatisation, education, housing inner city development and social services, as part of that Tory strategy. In order to carry out such social engineering

December 1988/January 1989

E TE R S

SMASH

DIK

'effectively in rupid time a strong. centralised, authoritarian state which brooks no opposition and makes no concessions' is required. Hence the noed to attack the work force in the public sector in order to open up for the privatisation of public services and to undermine the standard of living for the working class hy weakening the trade union movement.

The book gives the history of the poll tax but does not deal with the strategy to defeat it. It notes that neither the Lahour Party, or anyone else, has come up with alternatives to the old rating system. which is also unjust and unpopular.

*Proposals for local income raxation are now receiving more sympathetic consideration by those looking for an alternative to the "poll lax"." But a local income tax will only be another way of redistributing the poverty within the inner-cities.

Only a national progressive tax can take the money from the really rich (individuals and companies). This should be ombined with a sharp increase in government grants to the regions without any strings on how local authorities can use the money. Such a radical tax reform still has to he developed and campaigned for by the lahour niovement.

EEC: Maggie right for wrong reasons?

Commission is a collegiate body with a

centre-right majority among its 17 members; they would never allow their president to issue such statements on their behalf.

The Treaty of Rome has undoubtedly been changed in recent years, but not to make it any more conducive to socialism: on the contrary. its ultimate aim of removing all barriers to ie trade by 1992 makes it a perfect charter for big business to shift goods and capital to suit their le interests, not those of the peoples of Europe.

The Common Agriculturi Policy (CAP) has emerged virtually unscathed from all the changes provoked by the Single European Act, and CAP payments still command an excessive percentage of the total EEC budget. The CAP also represents a threat to the environment, by encouraging the denaturing of the soil through excessive use of nitrate fertilisers: the paltry EEC directives on petrol lead or acid rain can hardly compensate for it the environmental damage caused by common th market food policics.

It is wishful thinking to believe that all these disadvantages can be eliminated even within the lifetime of a Labour goverment. To do so would require a convergence of socialist governments in every EEC member state, since the Treaty can only be

i real and enduring

consensus among the

peoples of Europe.

The next Labour

government must

therefore reclaim its

sovereignty by repealing

or amending Section 2 of

the European

Communities Act, which

gives effect to the Treaty

of Rome and BEC

legislation in this country.

This will enable it to

select those areas of EEC

law which are in the

interests of this country.

Such a step would be

erfectly legal, since EEC

law only operates in this

country by the consent of

our parliament, which

may be withdrawn at any P) time the latter chooses to

do so.

Walter Caims Labour Common Market d Safeguards Committee

not absolve Hearse from indicating in more positive terms the direction in which he thinks the answer might lie.

The Common Market is back on the political agenda: - but once again this is no thanks to the Labour Party.

The reason is rather Mrs Thatcher's speech at the College of Europe in Bruges, where she set out her "vision' for future European cooperation. For her, the EEC is a common market, and that is how it should stay. The Brussels bureaucrats should keep their noses out of domestic affairs and let cach member state retain its sovereignty.

The problem for many of us in the Labour Party is that Mrs T. has undoubtedly focussed attention on an issue which can pose problems for the left as well as for the right.

When the Labour conference repeatedly confirmed its policy of non-participation in the common market, the main reason advanced was that the Treaty of Rome and the legislation issued under it would prevent a Labour government from implementing the industrial policies which it deemed necessary for the regeneration of the British economy-

Thus the issue also revolved around the question of national sovereignty, but from a totally different perspective from the Prime Minister's free: market ideology.

Some would have us

To its credit MT is (on its own terms) trying to develop its programme even if one may disagree with parts (or all) of it. Comrade Hearse's article fails to spell out SO's counter-hegemonic strategy to effectively challenge MT's theses concerning the conclusions which may bo drawn from new developments in late capitalism.

Yours contradely Chris Madoc

Dear Editor

Thank you for Phil

Hearse's interesting and

informalive article on the

USSR (Gorbachev's

Gamble, Socialist

Outlook, no. 9). However,

there was one issue he

neglected to discuss: how

will the reform process

affect the relationship

between "communism'

and the Social Democratic

parties in the western

world. It may he too carly to make a judgement, but

there are already signs

that Moscow may apply

some glasnost to the Y historic breach of the

Second and Third

Interationals. A more conciliatory attitude

towards right wing social

democrats - in cast

curopean publications like

World Marxist Review —

is bocoming increasingly

evident, much to the

Any answers?

Dear Socialist Outlook

Phil Hearse's article (SO

October 88) on the latest

redrafting of the

Communist Party's

programme ("Facing up to

the Future ") is far too

complacent. At the

descriptive level, Hearse * writes 'we can agree with te MT that "Capitalism is

changing, the working

class is being • recomposed, the economy

is being restructured —

therefore... the old

post-war consensus is

useless. we need a new

way forward.' Fine. But

while MT attempts, from

its own viewpoint, to

develop its neo-reformist

programme, we are

offered up only negative

believe otherwise. We are amended with the told that Mrs Thatcher is trying to prevent european unanimous consent of all socialism from gaining a its signatories.

This is not to deny the foothold in this country.

Statements made recently desirability of European I by Jacques Delors, the cooperation in certain

areas, such as EEC President. to the TUC Congress held out environmental matters,

concation, and consumer the prospect of building a "social Europe' within the Protection. Such

cooperation must secure next decade.

However M. Delors the full-hearted consent of made it clear that he was the participating nations if speaking in a personal it is to be effective.

capacity and for a very National sovereignty is

therefore the best good reason. The EEC

mechanism for achieving

offered up only negative criticisms which fail to indicate any fresh thinking on the changes which we are confronted with.

Unfortunately, Hearse article is far too brief to offer much of an alterative, hut equally the conclusion could be drawn that there isn't one on offer!

Of course, there isn't a completed alternative (anymore than the MT thesis is adequate or complete) but this does

consternation of a numher

of 'pro-Moscow" parties.

parties.

attempt to end the historic division between Social Democracy and 'Conununism' then revolutionary marxists may well henefit from the political differentiation that such a move would create. We should watch, and where possible, he involved in facilitating this process.

Jeff Richards South Australia

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 11 December 1988/January 1989

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK is committed to the develop- ment of a real socialist alternative both to the ravages of Thatchersim and to the grey tide of Kinnockism and new

realism.

SOCIALISI OUTLOOK has in its first ten issues provided in-depth analysis and debate on developments in the trade unions, the struggle in the Labour Party, the recomposition of British politics and many international

issues of crucial importance for socialists.

Annual subscription rate (ten issues): €8.50 for inland subscriptions €17.00 for inland multi-reader subscriptions €13.00 for European subscriptions €18.00 for all other international subscriptions (US $ 25.00) E54.00 for overseas airmail multi-reader subscriptions (US $ 75.00

Name......

Address....

Subscription to start from issue number.

Retum to SOCIALIST OUTLOOK, PO Box 705, London, SW19 IHA, England.

SPECIAL

CHRISTMAS

OFFER!

Give a friend a subscription to Socialist Outlook and get a copy of Twenty Years On, edited by Michael Farrell, for E4.50, including postage and packing.

if you want the book sent to a ditferent address, please indicate here:

← Northern Ireland: the political economy of conflict · A revival of student militancy? →

Something wrong on this page?