Bob Rowthorn and Naomi Wayne, Polity Press, 1988.
Reviewed by JEAN REILLY
NAOMI WAYNE, a London based trade union officer, and Bob Rowthom, a Cambridge economist, have developed in this book a coberent and well argued case for British withdrawal from Ireland. For that reason alone it is a welcome contribution to the debate and a timely one. given that il coincides with the 20th anniversary of the beginning of the present phase of the struggle in the six counties.
The fint section of the book sets the scene in a history of the island from the "plantation" to the present day, It is a brief but thorough account of the historical and political development of Ireland and one which socialists and republicans would have no quarrel with. This is followed by an account of the sectarianism and discrimination, fostered by British rule, which developed in the six county statelet together with an account of the rise of the civil rights movement and the various British attempts, such as power-sharing, to deal with the ensuing ensts.
The core of the book, and what makes it significant, is the analysis of the six county economy and its economic prospects. and the clear and forthright way in which the authors develop this analysis to come to one precise conclusion: Britain must withdraw from Ireland.
The authors provide an abundance of statistical information on the effects of sectarianism on employment, wages, housing, emigration and standards of living in the north.
In the final section of the book
Page 40
the authors take on, one by one, the arguments against withdrawal and present logical and concise counter-arguments in cach case.
On a more cautious note. however, it must be said thai part ofthe argument which Rowthom and Wayne develop on the future prospects for a 32 county Irish economy, depend on the maintenance on both sides of the present border of a low wage. highly skilled workforce.
In addition, the brief description they give of the 26 county economy, for the purposes of comparison with that of the six counties, seems a bit too generous and uncritical. They note favourably that successive Dublin governments have been able to attract substantial investment by foreign based multinational companies. They fail to point out, however, that this has meant that the southern economy is now essentially a branch-plant economy and that, overwhelmingly, the profits made by multinationals are exported and not used to build a strong manufacturing or industrial base in ireland.
More seriously, they make the point very strongly that Britain should continue to give aid for a substantial period after the removal of the troops and the unification of Ireland. They argue that not only would this be Britain's moral duty, but that it would be nocessary, together with guarantees of religious and civil liberties, to induce loyalists to acquiesce in the removal of the border.
To argue this without spelling out how unlikely it is that Britain would give aid without any strings attached is a problem. The authors explicitly argue that Britain, and possibly other imperialist powers, would be willing to give aid in order to guarantee for themselves a stable friendly neighbour in what is a strategic region. This may be true; but it is not the aim of the anti imperialist movement.
This book is an important one and provides anti imperialist with much useful factual infornation and cogent analysis. It is also extremely readable and therefore accessible to comrades unfamiliar with the subject.
PHOTO: Andrew Moore/Reflex
Moore/Re
YOU
ARE NOW
ENTERING
FREE DERR
The book's strength is its call for British withdrawal
Poll tax as social
engineering
The Poll Tax and the