Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Mexico in turmoil

· Socialist Outlook no. 11, December–January 1989 · pp 19-23 · 3,206 words

Latin America

LATIN AMERICA

164

PHOTO: Piers Cavendish/ Reflex

City has a shortage of millions of ni

As the political and economic crisis unfolds in Latin America, eyes have been turned to the sharpened situation in Mexico, one of the most industrialised, and one of the "big three' in terms of debts to western banks.

The crisis of the ruling Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) has been intensified following the recent generai election, in which the PRI resorted to blatant ballot-rigging to defeat a breakaway bourgeois candidate.

The radicalisation has also opened the door for rapid growth of the Mexican Revolutionary Workers Party (PRT), which is now one of the largest organisations of the trotskyist Fourth International. To find out the PRT's analysis of the situation, THERESA CONWAY from Socialist Outlook spoke to a lead- ing PRT member, HEATHER DASHNER.

Can vor

Can you say something about the economer situation in the country?

Over the last six years what used to be chronic unemployment and under-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK nn 1* Decen

employment, characteristic of an un- derdeveloped country, has increased enormnusly hecause of the policies the goverment has introduced to try

and deal with the economic crisis. Wages, which once accounted for 42 per cent of Gross National product have been cut back toonly 27 percent, and there has been an enormous con- centration and centralisation of capi tal. People who were already living on what would he considered poverty level in a developed country are now at the level of serious malnutrition.

In Mexico, one of the most in- dustrialised countries in the sub-con- tinent, government investment in health and education has gone down to 17th and 25th place in Latin America. This is because of the government's "modemisation policy. which aims to foster massive foreign private investment and to open Mexico to the world market.

Page 17

LEM EN

BIENVE

HAUNTEN DEN

PHOTO: Julio Etchard/Reflex

Cardenas, the renegade presidential candidate, echoed mass sentiments

Imperiousm and the leadine fac capacity was destroved. and 25h

tion of the government party, the PRL. think we should he able to overcome

the crisis and pay the debr. by produc- ing goods for the world market rather than for consumption at home: this is the generalised policy of imperialism all over Latin America. Minimum wages have gone down enormously

over last I0 years and the average family in the cities (which has 5.3 members) hastolive on the equivalent

of E12 per weck. The minimum wage in Mexico City is 8000 pesos per day which is about L2. The real wage bas dropped hy 50 per cent - a brutal change over a period of 10 years.

In terms of housing, there is a shortage of several million homes in Mexico City, with a population of 18 million. There are enormous sections

of the city which we call land in-

vasions - places which have heen

taken over by the homeless, on which

they huild shanty towns. The first

fight is to remain on such land -

whether it is govemment or private.

Then there is the fight for services -

"The minimum wage in Mexico City is 8000 pesos per day which is about £2."

then electrium and roads

marker- transport and

All of this has been going on for

many years since the agricultural

crisis of 1965 which meant an enor

mous migration to the citics. It has ac-

celerated after 1985, when the carthquake struck central downtown Mexico City. There were 400,*)

people on the street from one day to

the next. One third of hospital hed

schools.

What was already an enormous housing shortage was increased by that crisis. The International Year of the Homeless decreed by the United Nations in 1986 provided some fund- ing to replace some of the homes. The movement that arose in Mexico City had to fight hard for this funding and maintain its independence from the state. This movement changed the urban political spectrum, because it fostered the creation of organisations where none had existed before.

There has been a crisis in the countryside since 1965, but it has in- creased hecause of the moderusation programme and cuts in subsidies: guaranteed prices for agricultural products fell way below production costs. That has meant that peasants have fumed to production crops and there is a deficit in com and beans which we have to import, although the country is perfectly capable of producing them.

In the recent period there has been quite a conflict over raising the guarantee prices for basic grains. The products are priced by decree below even what the PRI-dominated peasant organisations consider they should

and Dean: though the anable of

The only category where gover- meat spending has been increased is in population control, where they

have heen able to keep promises made

to IMF in 1975, and lower the birth

Page 18

rate from 3.5 to 2 per cent year. Bet-

ween 1970 and 1982, 1.3 million

women were sterilised, mainly in the urban areas. There has also been some evidence of sterilisation in the nimal areas but news of this has been sup pressed. The goal is to lower the birth

rate to 1 percent by the year 2000. This will require spending a lot of money persuading younger women not to have children or to get themselves sterilised.

Except for that, health spending ir in crisis. If you go to hospital. in Mexico City you had better take a relative with you, because the nurse will say "I don't have any cotton wool. go to the comer and buy some: Idon't have a syringe, I can'1 give this man an injection". There is a basic list of

medicines that the public health sys-

tem has - and it's getting shorter and shorter.

employment

imtethnga ahout fin

situation?

«e uroan popmation es red. and w hat percentare

We have a population of 80 mil-

lion. According to govemment statis-

tics, approximately 15 million of

those we in what we call the informal sector. Over half the population 15

under 16, so there are lesx than 40 mil-

Lion pcople who are in the labour market. More than half the population

lives in the cities. Twelve million people list themselves as housewives

in the censusand many of those would be a part of the 15 million. Ten mil-

L1 December 1988/January 1989

Lion of those in the informal sector are women. In the 1970s several studies estimated unemployment and under- employment as being from 40-60 per cent - it's a structural thing.

Can you say something ahout the political system that operates in Mexico?

The Mexican system is based on a semi-corporatist, semi-police control of the mass organisations. in the 1930s, after the revolution of 1910- 1917, the state was consolidated through the populist nationalist policy of President Lazaro Cardenas who basically formed the state as it is today. He divided the working class organisations from the peasant or- ganisations and incorporated both of them and the army into a mass party whose pillars were those three sectors.

The PRI has been in power for 60 years - since it was founded in 1928: it is all-pervasive in the state institu- tions and controls all areas of social and political life. However the PRI has been based not only on populist and police control but aiso on conces- sions. The population has heen in- creasingly disaffected from it, both because of the PRI's octopus-like ex- istence which has smothered all sorts of democratic openings, but also be-

cause over the last ten years it has been almost completely incapable of giving any economic concessions.

Although it considers the Mexican economy a mixed economy, hased on the social role of the state and on private capital, it is very definitely a watchdog for private capital which it has fostered for over 50 years. The new policy means de nationalising cnormous numbers of very important productive industries. This is being demanded by the strengthened bour- geoisie, which had very little political role over the last 40 or 50 years bat has increasingly acquired one.

The Mexican capitalist class now feels sufficiently strong and suffi- ciently related to American im- perialist interests to start to make its own independent expressions ax class. Until now, the weight of the PRI bureaucracy and of the state has al- ways been stronger than of any sec- tion of the bourgenise.

Now the bosser are also clamour- ing for a re vamping of the union structurex. This is very difficult for the PRI because the unions, along with the peasant organisations, are the two major levers for their mass control over the population.

The bourgeoisie wants unions which are geared to 'modernisation', organised to increase production rather than defend workers. In order to make such changes the government need in attack one of their own sup-

porters. The PRI union bureaucracy is not going to sit back and allow them just in do this - they would sacrifice their financial privileges and their power. The oil workers' union leader is one of the few people in the country who can defy the president.

This conflict of interest creates an insoluble problem for both the government and the union leaders. They can't go back to the patemalist state bocauxe the cconomic crixis and the foreign debt proclude that: but neither can they go forward to the modernised state without a total and compicte defeat and revamping of the PRI union hureaucracy - jeopardising the Party's domination of the masses.

So they are in gigantic crisis, and this has been best exemplified by Cuauhtemoc Cardenas (son of the former President) leaving the PRI in September last year after making an unsuccessful bid for its presidency - and running as a breakaway candidate under the banner of a small satellite bourgeois party. Basically his project and outlonk is to return to the old PRI tradition. He ix not yet moving hack towards the PRI but aims to revive the policies of the "Mexican revolution". arguing for a return to the kind of state his father fashioned.

From the bourgeoisie's economic point of view that is extremely dif- ficult. But Cardenas has also come out against the anti-democratic behaviour of the PRI. This echoes and gives voice to sentiments among the mas- ses, who have identified with this man and came out in the elections, crealing a snowball effect in favour of his can- didacy.

This is a very complicated and con- tradictory process. Many millions of people who voted for Cardenas, voted for him breaking with the PRI, and that represents a step forward in their conciousness. They are supporting an alterative to the PRI which includes. championing a higher minimum wage, a higher guaranteed price for agricultural products, some sort of change of policy on the foreign debt, and all sorts of questions of basic democratic nights.

However this boureeois democratic populist policy and programme has also attracted socialists, as well as an important part of the university youth which would normally be an important breeding ground for socialists, and in that sense in that part of the movement from my point of view it is a step backwards in conciousness.

It has also attracted sectors that were previously independent from bourgeois politics, who now identify themselves with Cardenze project, from differing points of view, and with differing emphasis. We are talk-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 11 December 1988/January 1989

ing here ahout one of the major sec- fors which rose out of the 1986 year of the bomeless, and other sectors in the provinces of urhan and peasant movements, as well as trade union people who were originally socialists but now consider that unity of the mass movement has to begin with unity under Cardenas's programme and banner.

So as I say this is a very contradic- tory movement. However, we would say that in general it has heen positive. in that it has meant the defcat of the PRI in the ballot boxes for the first time in 60 years. The PRI has always practised fraud, but it never had to practice fraud in order in win the presidental clection. Il practiced fraud refore in order to secure a bigger majority, or in orderto lower the num- ber of absentions, or in order to legitimise itself - but not in order to say that it had won the presidency.

This is a major defeat - and it has accentuated the intemal crisis in the PRI to an unprecedented extent. So deep is the crisis that we think the PRI could actually fall apart. There is another democratising current within the PRI of people who were original- ly with Cardenas but didn't leave the PRI.

There is enormous conflict be- (ween the oilworkers" union and the president. The union has accused the governor of the state of Mexico of fraud when he was the director of PEMEX, the state oil company. So we see members of the PRi attacking a PRI govemor: this is unheard of in Mexico!

Can vou say something about the perspectives and priorities of the PRT itsell?

We recognised Cardenas win al the polls and came out in immediate defence of it as soon as it became clear. Many of his supporters said we can't be sure, we don tknow, we have to be responsible, but we said very clearly that the man has won at the polls and the PRi is not allowing him to take charge of the administration. Now the movement has more or less been unified round that question.

But the PRI has implemented the fraud, blatantly insisting that they won; they have fixed the votes by use of the computer, and invented votes in more than 25,000 polling stations mainly in the countryside where there were no oppostion ballot watchers.

The movement against the fraud was quite strong for a couple of months hut has now begun to docline This is not only because of the natural tiredness of the movement, but main- ly because the PRI has held firm and imposed its pyhric vitory. Though Cardenas's supporters consider the

"The PRI

has always

practised fraud, but it never had to

practice

fraud in order to win

the presidental

election."

"The PRI

has been in power for 60

years -

since it was

founded in

1928: it is all-pervasive

in the state

institutions and controls

all areas of

social and political life."

Page 19

PHOTO: Julio Etchard/Retlex

PHOTO: Julio

15 million A

15 million Mexicans depend upon the informal' sector new PRI "president" Salinas to he a usurper, and Cardenas has as much on several occasions, the fight to stop Salinas taking office on Dee Ist has not been as strong as it could have been.

When Cardenas made the call for a new party, the PDR (Party of the Democratic Revolution) he made no reference to the usurpation. In spite of that the mass movement has been enormously revitalised. There is huge potential for united action around democratic, economic and sectoral demands as well as the question of the usurpation.

Our policy is to continue the strug- gle against the usurpation bocause we consider that this is a basic question around which the Mexican masses have made major steps forward, and to leave it out is unacceptable. However we are also trying to unify

Page 20

the mass movements that already exist, especially in the urban and peasant movement.

It ismore difficult in the unions, hut we try to do work there, as much as our forces will allow, working for unity around the question of salaries. At the end of each month the mini- mum wage is reviewed because of in- flation, and we are trying to make the struggle for the minimum wage coin- cide with the struggle for the contract wage as the reviews on this are dne toward the end of this year. This of course would be combined with the Fight for democracy in the unions. We think it is quite possible in have a unified movement.

The same is true in the peasan movement, around guaranteed prices, and it seems possible to involve the forces whn support Cardenas in such a project. The urban movement can

also he unified around all sorts of demands; for public services, for ex-

ample.

If we unify these organisations that

are independent from the PRI we can also attract the organisations that arc breaking from the PRI: we can start a

whole dynamic. We think that there is a change in the entire period: the PRI has never been in this sort of situation

un start t titere»

before

mansome it a pole

Our perspective ixto strengthen the

1 event t

400n а н

irde

ar.

MYC AISO

the creation of a political front with Cardenas and his new party around

democratic demands, including the

fall of the usurper. I we can extend

this to raising of salaries and the inde. pendent organisation of the unions ne are in favour of doing this.

1:30BaP

While we are in fanur of working on aunified basis with there forces we consider it ahsolutely necessary to

• necessary ..

maintain an independent political

focus, This is where the majority of

socialist forces in Mexico today de

not agree: they have been so attracted

to the Cardenas project they are now

discusing dissolving themselves into

his new party. Therefore we have.to

DED00S Al 'unny onentation sor sent and unt ca politi.

tv clear

rotile of

cal action, but keeping a very clear socialist and revolutionary profile of

Our Own.

Within the mass movement this has

been well understood. Many

socialists said that we would he

pushed to one side when we refused

to withdraw our comrade Rosario Ibarra as candidate for President: they said we would be seen as divisive. When it came to defending the Car- denas victory which Rosurin and we did, we found that this was wrong

People were quite abile to under- stand that we did not agree with Car- denar but that we were democratic fighters. I can give you an example where five days after the elections there was a demonstration where one of our comrades was a speaker. There were forces there who had never heard us before, and our speaker said 'we are not Cardenistas, we are socialists'.

She explained what our programme

was, and why we were fighting for

democracy; she was the most ap-

de

plauded.

Normal people who are taking up political action for the first time are in- terested in what we have to say. It is the cx-socialists who are the most

critical of us. We think there is not only a historical need to maintain an independent socialist profile, but a big

opportunity to do this and bulld the

11 December 1988/January 1989

UPPE ME N

Thatchent- this base.

H5ID22U100 Economic

bourgeoisie and the military.

growth on Thatcherite lines has benefitted

On the other side, the Con- vergence for a 'No' vole is made up of many parties. In the elections in 15 months time it

·214 NG

NO

No NG FAKO

MEN On len

PHOTO: Julio Etchard/Reflex

Placards from the successful 'no' campaign against Pinochet

← An action charter for Education · Chile: a difficult struggle ahead →

Something wrong on this page?