What price masculinity?
SOMETIMES I seems as if the impetus that the women's movement gave to the discussion of sexual politics and gender relations in the late sixties and early seventies has been dissipated that the issues raised then have lost their focus. There are no longer the same certainties, the sense of direction
A woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle' , defiant feminist graffit: used to pro claim in the loos at political venues. That meant that if you went to the loo to sob your heart out over your bloke going off with someone else, you could cry a little harder with self- recrimination because you knew you were a failure as a feminist as well. 'Abolish the family! enjoined left-wing agitators, perhaps with the thrills rather than the spills of the sexual revolu tion in mind.
Today this all seems somehow inadequate: anyway it no longer reflects the mood of the times. There's still the perennial battle of the sexes, but few of us are quite so sure how and where the lines are drawn. Separatist feminism has lost a little of its charm, and gay liberation fell short of abolishing the emotional and ever sexual traumas of straight society. The upsurge of our expectations only made the disappoint ments harder and the unfulfilled needs more bewildering.
The counterpart of defiant feminism was the self-blaming mode of men against sexism, but angry feminists and guilty (therefore resentful)
men didn't make a very productive partnership
either politically or as individuals. Many men on the left ridiculed attempts to set up men's groups, claiming that 'oppressors' didn't need self-help, or would just sit around con- gratulating themselves and each other on how self-critical they were. The benefit of this at titude was that the critics were able to feel superior politically (quite important for male revolutionaries) as well as absolving themselves of any responsibility to do anything (also quite important if you don't want to confront anything that makes you feel insecure). The task of these men, then, was to support women's demands as vocally as possible, and try to remember about the washing-up.
The discussion of sex showed this most stark ly: it was for women to discover and assert their sexual identity and needs, and for men to learn how to give better sexual satisfaction to women. Men's sexuality and their ability to find satisfaction, according to this approach, was unprobiematic: they were assumed, even by themselves, to take their pleasure at women's expense, up to the point of indulging in por- nography, prostitution and rape. Men's needs and feelings weren't part of the discussion, and if men felt they didn't conform to the stereotype they were more likely to feel inade- quate about that and keep their mouths shut than own up about it. Women researched their needs and feelings and gave them voice, while men remained in a wilderness of silence and ig norance of themselves. Learning to feel asham
RICA
FLEGG
ed didn't teach them how to emotionally open or self-aware
These observations may be a simplification, but most of us now in our thirties will recognise them as part of the experience we went through in the 'counter culture' and on the left. The same attitudes still affect us today, but
they don't provide enough answers any more.
We are looking, for new answers, better answers, to the old problems; and that entails a reappraisal of some of the more glib positions that we adotped a decade and more ago.
This reappraisal, and new initiatives, have again come mainly from women. Landmarks have been books Ike Sex and Love, in which some brave women said how they really felt in- stead of how they thought they ought to feel, and What do Women Want? by Luise Eichen- baum and Susie Orback, which came out of the experience of women's therapy. Shere Hite, after her world-famous Hite Report on
women, brought out a report or male sexuali ty. The Hite report on men may have failed to make the same popular impact as the one on wornen, but in many ways it was a more pro- found and path-breaking study. It allowed men to say, in their own words, things they had never said before; no-one had ever asked
Reading the Hite report on men, a fat tome of over 1,000 pages, I was struck that a woman, rather than a man, should have been motivated to undertake the study, and that 1, as a woman, was more motivated to read it than most of my male friends and comrades. Reading it in public places like the tube, or the pub during a lunch-break at work, I caught enough odd looks from men to feel almost too self-conscious to concentrate. A woman reading a large, serious volume on men ana their sexuality: it unnerved them. If I'd been reading the Kama Sutra, or even Masters and Johnson, they might have leered or offered to buy me a drink. It isn't yet accepted by men - although they have the most reason to know better that it is interesting or worthwhile to study and understand themselves. This, indeed, is a large part of the probiem
What is happening today, then, is not that the debate on sexual politics has petered out Whie it may not be as prominent a discussior
as It used to be -and needs to be I believe that it has reached a new level, a higher level, that will prove more fruitful in pointing the direction in which we need to look for the answers to some of these old problems that af fect us all, whatever our gender or our sexual orientation, in our everyday lives.
Pluto Press' book The Sexuality of Men, published last year, reflects this new process: as Susie Orback says in the frontispiece, the essays 'provide us with a new stimulus for the desperately needed dialogue...' Dialogue. because in the past there has been no real ex change of insights and ideas between men and women on this subject, desperately needed because without such a dialogue there can be no real understanding, and consequently no real change.
For men to read What do Women Want? (the question posed rhetorically by Freud) must, I imagine, be an enlightening more than a guilt- inducing or threatening experience, because it helps to explain. It apeals, I belive - although it is addressed to women - to something in men that might enable them to identify with women. Something similar happens for a woman reading the Hite report on men or passages in The Sexuality of Men: it seems as if. at last, we might become more intelligible to parh ather Nur omntional neare de himan
beings, are after all not so different; it is way that those needs are experienced and pressed that is so different between men women, because of our socialisation.
At last, mutual understanding, commur tion, seem possible. Most importantly of this dialogue points up the possibiltiies change, for men as well as for women: possibilities for transforming the quality of lives, our relationship with each other, and v children. It points up the costs, particularly men, of failing to take the opportunity change.
This, perhaps is the most radical of the sights emerging from this new movement: t
Hall the ex and
al., for the our vith for for
men, despite their apparent social power and privilege, are in many respects impoverished and inhibited by their masculinity. Most simply put, their opportunities for emotionally in- timate and rewarding relationships with other people . each other, women, children — are constrained by the social construction of their gender. They are not the stronger sex: as Tom Ryan, a therapist, argues in his essy on 'Roots of Masculinity', 'masculinity, not femininity, is the weaker of the gender constructs.
Ryan's experience of men's problems as they emerge in therapy has led him to view masculinity as a 'defensive construction' developed to emphasise men's difference and separate identity. Many men, he says, deny feelings of need or dependency, which they ex- perience as threatening sell annihiliation; they develop an 'exaggerated virility' which is parad ed as autonomy. The result is a fear of in- timacy, which can have a completely destruc
International, No. 2, January/February 1986
-UI hat
tive effect on the man's central emotional
His most recent relationsnip. Ryan writes of one of his clents, survived for several years, but repeated discord and separations left him feeling lonely, depressed and despairing. Away from his partner he felt love and affection for her, but while with her, esperally during moments of in timacy, he experienced feelings of irration and anxiety. A pattern developed whereby when he elt entrapped he behaved in a contemptuous or rejecting, manner, nducing, ms partner to reject and leave him. ihe patter of rejection separa- tion and reconciliat on was repeated inm merable times until Dave partner finany de ded •. disengage hersel om the relationship
: effect itionships:
The conradic
and confused nature of masculinity, then, can nave a paralysing effert on the man and make it impossible for his part- ner to love or help him. In this contect, while it is the woman who is the most emotionally abused in the relationship, it is really the man who is most the victim of the situation, as long as he can neitner confront, nor escape, himself.
Vic Seidler, in his essay on Fear and Intimacy takes this argument a step further. 'Socialist men,' he writes of the 1970s, 'were learning that they could analyse the fate of the interna- tiona capitalist economy but they were speechless when it came to talking, through issues in their sexual relationships... The power men carry in the structure of capitalist society is at a considerable cost in terms of our own emotional capacities, understandings anc desires...' He describes the angry. spiteful ana jealous' reaction many men have had to being challenged by women in sexual relationships: 'We did not understand why they were bring ing up pain from the past ... we didn't unders and the need for the past to be opened and the pain shared if it was to be purged... We could only think that women wanted to hurt and punish us. Instead of working to resolve the problems of such a relationship. Seidler says, the man is mpelled to seek another lover. 'If we feel hurt and rejected the only solution we know is to find another partner who ap preciates us. It is because, at some level, we have never learnt to take responsibility for our emotional lives that we automatically assume that if things go wrong we have been with the wrong partner...
Seidier also identifies male strength as an illu sion, being based on "brittle foundations' Feminists, he says, have often overestimated it 'even though they have experienced its con tradictions'. However, seeing this more clearly won't enable women to change men: only men can change themselves. Seidler offers no easy solution, but he shows that change can only come through men becoming more self aware
...learning to take more responsibility for ourselves. Therapy, he says, can play an im portant part in bringing men into closer contac with their own emotions, and must be linked tr
2. January: Februars 1980
a "collective practice challenges institutional masculinity
Again, many on the left partkularly men are critical of psychotherapy, which they see as self-indulgent and/or only available to the relatively privileged. It won't provide any political answers, they say.. Yet, many of the most valuabie insights that have been •developed on the subjec of masculini and gender relat ons have VUl OI ex- perienc of therapy. Goldbe The
(a polit power
UllIci terb
cal practice) that and definitions of
Hazards Being Male, published nearly ter years ago, talks piecisely from the experience of private practice for the executive class in California, but nevertheless it points to most of the same problems elaborated in The Sexuality of Men. Goldberg also gives the statistics on the price of masculinity: death rates, suicide rates. institutionalisation for psychiatric disorders, stress-related problems, behavioural symptoms.
The Sexuality of Men and the other books referred to give must of their attention to heterosexuai relationships, but not excusively so. Another advance in the last decade or so has been to draw away from seeing the heterosexual and homosexual forms of sexual behaviour as separate or exclusive worlds, and to look more closely at the construction of gender and social relations. Oddly enough, however, it is the essay on gay sexuality in The Sexuality of Men that has the most limited focus n this respect, and does less to explore the problems of homosexual relations than is at- tempted in What do Women Want? or Sex and Love. Another book published by Pluto last
year. Gay Liberation in the Gough and Mike McNair. go abolishing the division in 'Beyona Heterosexuality. however, is more concerne sion of society than of perso it is critical to bring both le bear on the study of what 'the personal
Eighties, by Jamie es much further in its discussion of The latter study. a with th. discus nality; for the left. vels of anaiysis to is experienced as
vve spen me sevenues denning men as trie probiem. but analysing women instead. Perhaps in the eighties we will come at last to analysing the social construction, and the ex perience, of mascuinity as a social problem that is oppressive not only to women, and to children, but to men tnemseives, for men will never change purely out of guilt feelings or under pressure from the women's movement they'll only be motivated to understand and change themselves when the price they pay in terms of the impoverishment of their own I ves begins to seem too higt..
The gain of such pressure for change represent a gain not just for men but for socie ty as a whole. In that sense, The Sexuality of Mer is an important book for the British left. particularly since it attempts to integrate its analysis with a political critique. The questions addressed in these essays are at the heart of our lives, where too many of us never look... or else we feel that our personal experience is not subject to analysis, it is isolated from our politics. It is to be hoped, then, that this book will enlarge and widen the dialogue that it has helped to start: that depends, in large part, on the ability of the left to respond to the challenge to open the discussion that is so badly needed.
Andy Me Sexualty
alf and Martin Mer. Pluto Pr
Humphr es ess 1985,
ds.. .50.