Farewell to Sartre
KATHY
LOWE
FOR MANY Marxists who have followed the work of French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre, the 1970s was a time when he lost his political bearings, when the intellectual energies that made him one of the century's outstanding thinkers and writers finally deserted him. For Simone de Beauvoir it was a time when she watched her comrade and companion of 50 years confront the anguish of liness and the sudden shrinking of his creative world.
Sartre died in 1980, physical y broken and almost blind. Simone de Beauvo r's latest book Adieux, a Farewell to Sortre is written, she ex plains, for those who would like to know more about his last years. It is divided into two parts. The first is a narrative, largely based on the diary she kept in Paris during the 1970s. This is followed by what she calls her 'Conversations' with Sartre - interviews she conducted with him in August-September 1974
Structurally, the two sections of the book fail to hang together. Some of the Conversations, by her own admission, are disjointed and repetitious. Yet the book as a whole is as disturbing as anything she has ever written .-. at times so frank, so personal, that the reader feels almost an intruder.
In recounting her day-to-day collaboration with Sartre in Paris, the many projects and pleasures shared, de Beauvoir sets the 70s before us... in France the factory struggles, police repression and the lingering influence of Maoism... the Yom Kippur war... the stillborn Portuguese revolution... the gradual disillusion and disorientation of left intellectuals Europe wide.
She describes how Sartre, while working on his massive study of Flaubert, helped to establish and to write for left journals like La cause du peuple, Liberation and latterly his own journal Les temps modernes. He joined demonstrations, spoke at factory gates, cam- paigned for the rights of immigrant workers, for prison reforms, for the cause of the Bas- ques and the Palestinians. Politically, he had for mally renounced Marxism, defined himself as a 'socialist-communist' but was moving towards what Perry Anderson has described as 'a radical neo-anarchism
Insights into his ideological evolution are plen- tiful in this book. But its scope is far wider value of a very different kind.
Increasingly, the account of Sartre and de Beauvoir's daily round of writing, reading, giv- ing interviews, evenings spent listening to music or dining with friends is overshadowed by her anxious references to his failing health. Thus we come to the heart of the matter. How does an
ntellectual and activist so prolific, so long at the centre of things come to terms with 'decline'... with restrictions imposed by sickness and age ing, and with the relative poitical iso ation
those restrictions bring?
Simone de Beauvoir
Sartre suffered a series of strokes in 1970 72. With each setback his friends feared that he would be left crippled. Even more, they feared for his mind. Yet each time, to their amazement, he managed to regain lost ground, sometimes showing sudden bursts of his old brilliance and vitality.
The blindness, when it came in 1973, was quite another matter. It prevented him from reading, writing, and, most painfully, from developing his ideas. He knew moments of profound despair, referring to himself on one occasion as 'a living corpse
He acknowledged his greater dependence on those closest to him without ever being able to fully accept it. De Beauvoir recalls how one day when she picked up a book to read to him as usual he remarked sadly: 'Before, when I was more intelligent, we didn't read, we talked.' So they talked. Still, she started to notice a new detachment in his manner. He would let discus- sion drop after a short time, without asking questions or introducing fresh ideas
Towards the end of Sartres life, many on the European left became disturbed by what they saw as his increasingly erratic political pro- nouncements. in particular, an interview with him conducted by his secretary, Bernard Henry _evy and published in le nouvel observateur on the eve of his death, caused great concern. It was seen by many as a sign that Levy, a former Maoist student leader who later turned to the rewish religion, had 'taken over' Sartre
De Beauvoir, who often voices her own political disagreements with Sartre in the book, was horrified by this interview and told him so. However, she also argues that Sartre's physical disabilities (for example, being unable to read
back over what had been written rather than simply hearing a tape recording) and his troubl- ed state of mind left him more prey to manipulation. Momentarily her stated vow to merely tell Sartre's story breaks down as she gives tull vent to her anger against Levy whom she despises as a political maverick, arrogant and ambitious.
De Beauvoir's relationship with Sartre has been extensively documented, not least in her own four-volume autobiography. Adieux, a Farewell to Sartre testifies anew to the immense reserves of mutual respect and comradeship built up over their half a century together and which they now had to draw on to sustain them.
Through the Conversations in the second section of the book, a series of interviews transcribed from tapes, she sought to help Sar- tre to express himself at a time when blindness had cruelly narrowed his world. The Conversa- tions work best when she abandons stilted in- terview techniques ('What are your subjective relations to your work as a whole?... Let us talk about the literary and philosophical side of your work...') in favour of real debate. They discuss literature, art, childhood, religion, revolution in no particular order. Sartre is by turns self- mocking, reflective, even mischievous. He returns often to his theme of the need for the 'new intellectual' to become integrated with the life of the masses.
Regrettably, one Conversation about nis 'sexual little capers' and his attitude to women strikes a very jarring note. The questions are pointed, challenging to a degree. But the whole exercise turns into one in which they intellec- tualise together about his sexual experiences and discuss almost clinically some of the young women he has encountered over the years.
Most interesting are Sartre's reflections on the course his life has taken: 'Setting aside this period of wearing away - which I don't grieve over, since it's the common lot - I think l've had a period, from the age of thirty to sixty five, in which I kept a hold on myself and in which I was not very different at the beginning from what I became. A period in which there was indeed a continuity during which I used my freedom properly to do what I intended; in which I was able to be of use and to help spread certain ideas; and in which I did what I wanted - that is, I wrote, which has been the essence of my life...'
With his death came the separation, the desolation for de Beauvoir that she had long dreaded. Yet the strongest images of Sartre she leaves us with are not of suffering and pain but of an unquenchable spirit who never ceas ed calling himself into question. Her book is in itself an act of courage, of striving. of question ing. Indeed a fitting farewell.
Simone de Beauvoir, Adieux Sartre. Penguin £4.95.
International. .\o. 2. Jan
\ new year for the
miners' strike
Ja0-
Special on the West E Commu Parties
ISSUE No 59
23 Fobrare INs
• Christmas in
the coalfields
Labour and
Welsh
nationalism
23%..
• Spain
• France
Franci
Italy
Great
• Great Britair
Economic crisis
of Zionism
Grenada':
election
Netherlands Portugal
Subscribe now!
IN analysis pub ernational, in
INPRECOR,
French francs preferred. Cheques to PEC. Postal transfers to PEC, CCP No 2 322 42T Paris. Bank transfers to PEC, BNP Rot:espierre, Account 230179/90
Sterling: Cheques to International Viewpoint. Bank transfers to Williams & Glyns Bank, Accou 14612874, Code 16-00-58, Islington, London.
Mail all subs to: IV, 2 rue Richard Lenoir, 931 Montreull, France.
ADDRESS
RENEWAL IV, 2 rue Ric
LETTERS PLEASE
FIRST NAME
COUNTRY
SUBSC r0ir, 93108 A
:RIPT lontrer
PCP VOTA
TERNATIONAL ished under the ausp conjunction with the which appears on alt
SUBSCRIPTION RATES Surface mail all countries
Airmail Europe, Middle I N Africa, The Americas, A Asia
Exchange
FF 120 135 165 185 200 245 300 340
9.50 12.50 15.00 17.50 18.00 20.00 27.50 31.20
VIEWPOINT ices of the United French language, ernate fortnights.
mths yeal 120FF
200F
135
65 85
Doll
16
19
22
25
31
37
42
47
nternational
A journal of Marxism in the Labour Party
Subscribe!
£5 for 6 (E10 for Name . Address
ssue nulti
Cheques payable Please return
to
reader
¡ternational International
ions)