Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The fall and fall of Gerry Healy

· International no. 2, January–February 1986 · pp 11-12 · 2,076 words

Stalinism Marxism Trotsky

When politics rears its ugly head

The recent split in the Workers Revolutionary Party made squalid fare for the media but Healyism was more than the personal turpitude of its leader. BOB PENNINGTON points to the characteristics that over the years has misled thousands of would-be revolutionary socialists and brought the WRP to its present ignominy and disaster.

Gerry Healy

HEALY MAy have been expelled, but Healyism still thrives in the leadership of the WRP. Neither can a leadership schooled in the WRP's particular brand of opportunism and catastrophism - basing its politics on the belief of some impending event which will change everything - be expected to make a decisive break with Healyism. Militants in the WRP who want to take the road away from the grotesque sect politics of Healy will have to come to terms with the whole history of the SLL-WRP current. It is a tradition which was flawed from the very beginning.

Ever since its formation in the early 1950s, Healy's organisation — then simply known as "The Club' — has been based on incorrect political perspectives and the victim of undemocratic practices. Its malformations date back to the crisis which beset British Trotskyism immediately after the Second World War. The united Trotskyist organisa- tion which existed then - the Revolutionary Communist Party — believed the war would be followed by a massive economic crisis and a weakening of Stalinism and reformism. But the prediction was not fulfilled. The slump did not occur, and reformism in the working class was strengthened.

A collapse of perspective and a decline in membership are sure fire for internal strife, and the RCP got International, No. 2. January/February 1986

steady recipes its full

share of that. But none of the tions could explain what had and there was no majority on next.

In such situations people become sucepti- ble to panaceas and cure-alls. Healy claimed to have the way forward. He forecast a gigantic slump, which would split the Labour Party. ' Only an entrist group, he said, could take advantage of this. He com- bined his schema with demagogy against that faithfull old scapegoat - the 'petty bourgeoisie' , which meant anyone who disagreed with him. He claimed that these elements, with their endless discussion and interminable bulletins, were paralysing the RCP and stopping it getting on with its work.

This denunciation of intellectuals struck a chord in sections of the ranks who had been attracted by the simplistic theories of Healy. Anti-intellectualism is in reality anti-theory, which is a deeply rooted tradition in British bourgeois society. And unfortunately it is a virus from which even the Marxist left not immune.

internal fac- gone wrong

what to do

'Since its formation Healy's

organisation has been based

formation Healy organisation has been base

on incorrect perspectives

and the victim of

undemocratic practices

Healy's analysis combined with activism seemed to many to offer a way out of the political ghetto of the RCP. The practices which have bedevilled this grouping were put down therefore at its very inception. For you cannot have an organisation which is made up simply of 'doers' — somebody has to provide a political line, somebody has to work out long-term strategy and immediate tactics, and this can either be done collective- ly or by individuals. Once the membership put aside the 'petty bourgeois indulgence' of discussion and debate, the more they vest all authority in leaders. That is exactly what happened in The Club.

Prior to 1953, as long as the British section stayed in the Fourth International, there was always the chance that with the aid of other sections a change of course could have been effected. But that was not to be. Healy in 1953 along with the American Socialist Workers Party led a split from the FI accus- ing its leadership of having 'gone soft on Stalinism'. This was really ironical

For some years previously the Club's paper Socialist Outlook never used the word 'Stalinist' once and studiously avoided criticism of the Communist Party. This was because on entering the Labour Party the group had found a different scenario than the one outlined in Healy's perspectives. The traditional social democratic left was almost non-existent, its leaders and most of its ranks had been won over by the apparent- ly sweeping reforms of the 1945 Labour Government. The only left dissidents of any account were CP fellow travellers, and it was to these people Healy turned to build a left opposition.

The soft approach to Stalinism was die- tated by Healy's need to make an alliance with this left. It was a practice which over the next 30 years was to become a constant feature of the organisation's politics. Later, when a left social democratic current did emerge around Bevan, Healy switched tac- tics, turning towards them and breaking from his old allies — Stalinophobia' became legitimate once more. Then The Club played down its criticisms of the Bevanites, and the members sold Tribune. Healy even informed one open-mouthed session of the central committee that: 'Michael Foot will join this movement'

From the beginning the members were trained in opportunism. First The Club had subordinated its politics to get an alliance with the CP and its fellow travellers, then it did the same again, but next time to ally itself with the left reformists. It was thus not difficult in later years to make an alliance with the Arab bourgeois states in the Middle East. This time there was an added reason to ditch permanent revolution so they could laud Gaddafi, the regime in Iraq, and even the Ayatollah, whom the Newsline of 10 April 1979, described as 'the man who symbolised the revolutionary aspirations of the Iranian people'. Now money was available from the oil producing countries, money which could finance the WRP

When an organisation discards its political principles for an expedient alliance it has slid into political degeneracy. When it does that for financial gain it has slithered into the pit of corruption. As soon as money starts com-

ing in through the back door to pay for political favours, and its distribution lies in the hands of an individual - invariably justified on the grounds of security - bureaucracy has got a firm social base. This is why Newsline 31 October 1985 asked Healy's supporters 'to explain why he secret- ly purchased a £15,000 BMW car and main- tained a secret fund of £20,000 in liquid cash.' We can be confident that Newsline's revelations of flash cars and secret cashhauls is only the tip of an iceberg of malpractices.

Just as opportunism led the WRP into its unprincipled alliances with the Arab bourgeois states, so did its catastrophic politics strengthen the bureaucratic regime. Catastrophism is not without a base on the far left; it appears to offer small groups the chance to catapault into the leadership of the mass struggle and bypass all the awkward in- tervening stages that have to be gone through if a wide based Marxist movement is to be built in Britain. The impending end of the capitalist order calls for strong leader- ship and frenetic activity at the base. After all, if Armageddon is down the road that is hardly the time for the ranks to be bothering about discussion. Instead the time has come to treble the sales of the paper, mortgage the house to finance the revolution - via the WRP treasurer of course - and denounce all those petty bourgeois groups which do not understand the police state is nigh, or that Thatcher is going to introduce a Bonapartist state that very day.

workers press

MILITARY

REVEALED

forkers press

LONDON RAD PAGES 4 & !

•ICE-MILITARY CARLY ORGAN OF THE CHILE... ULSTER.

HEATHRO LOTLETS

ECE....

TORY ELECTION POLICY CLEAR FROA

WAS

TRY JAILS FOR TI

EYTREMISTS

RISE HEATH FIGHTS

BANKERS'

PROFITS

INFLATION WITH

DICTATORSHIP

Wage values workers press

€10 000 ELECTION DREPARE FOR

FUND MAS

REACHEC C801 15

HEATH AVIL URGED

ON BY

MONDAY NAR CLUB

moters dress

HEATH IS RUN OUT BY SCOTTISH WORKERS

AS TORIES CENTRE ELECTION POLICY ON POLICE-MILITARY

DICTATORSHID

HIT

Workers press

SEMIND THE HEAT IROW EXERCISES

ARMY-POLICE

JUNTA

I Marmig NDEDARES iatastrophism Healy

than on apart to co the ratest or che HEATHROY WORKERS

'When a political organisation discards political principles for ar ‹pedient alliance it has sl into political degeneracy

When it does that for

financial gain it has

slithered into the pit

corruption.'

Such a regime with its emphasis on the im- mediacy of the revolution cannot brook any opposition, either within the organisation or without. Its sectarian party building tactics have no room for criticism - it delays action in a period of 'great crisis' and challenges the idea that the WRP is the sole agency of revolutionary change. The members are there just to carry out the line, whilst the other leaders are there to organise the members along the line of Healy.

This messianic concept ceded the ultimate power and decision making to Healy, who in turn ensured that his lieutenants had no in- dependence from the political line and the apparatus which he controlled

Those leaders who refused to tolerate such a regime joined the long list of 'police spies', 'CIA agents' and 'members of MI5' . Such a method innoculated the members against Marxist critics of the WRP. Over the years the deviations of opportunism and bureaucratic practice have worsened to such an extent that they became a built-in part of

from

1

the structures and daily life of the WRP. Healy's sexual abuse of women comrades only mattered when politics reared its ugly head — ie when a new clique inside the leadership decided it was time Healy went and it took over. Significantly these leaders cannot explain their years of silence over Healy's crimes against the membership and against the interests of the working class and the oppressed groups. Only an organisation which had learned nothing about women's rights, and that had not only ignored but at- tacked the womens movement as a 'petty bourgeois deviation' , could have allowed its general secretary to rape and abuse women comrades.

'Once the membership put aside the "petty bourgeois indulgence" of discussion and debate, the more they

all authority

leaders.'

vest all authority in

But we must remember that the present leadership of the Slaughter grouping almost without exception was trained in the Healy school. Like Nikita Kruschev, who denounc- ed the crimes of Stalin at the 20th Congress of the CPSU in 1956, so he could get the mantle of Stalin off his shoulders and take over the succession, so do Slaughter et al want to rid themselves of the mantle of Healyism in order to inherit his organisation.

The disease of the WRP is terminal. It will either go into oblivion or at best be reduced to a small isolated sect on the sidelines. The leaders who for years justified the politics of Healy, were often the leaders who acted as guards at the Summer Camp show trials? They are by their past practices and training incapable of building a healthy, democratic Marxist movement. For those rank and file members who want to build such a move- ment there is no alternative to breaking away from the WRP. They should join in the at- tempt to construct a united democratic Trot- skyist movement in Britain, which can take its place in the ranks of the Fourth International.

Footnotes 1 Staliniphobia means to put the emphasis on the fight against Stalinism above the interests of the class struggle. During the Vietnamese War of Liberation, the most urgent task was to build solidarity with the people of Vietnam in their fight against imperialism. Healy's group, then named the Socialist Labour League, left the Vietnam Solidarity Committee because of its alleged failure to denounce Stalinism, thus weakening the anti- imperialist struggle. This does not mean that Marxists should give up their criticisms of CP policy, but it does mean anti-Stalinism must not be used to undermine united working class action. 2 Robin Blick and David Caldwell writing in the New Statesman tell how at the SLL Summer Camp of 1966 Healy held a show trial of some of its leaders. One of the defendants was a long-time member Bob Shaw who 'Healy kicked ... and knocked backwards onto the ground... Shan simply picked himself up and resumed his seat (r) endure further beatings.

:. lanuarv/ Fe

← The Anglo-Irish accord — the Labour-Tory accord · The split in the NUM →

Something wrong on this page?