By TONY RICHARDS WHEN Neil Kinnock made his shabby Conference speeches attacking Liverpool Council and the miners, his line of argument echoed a common attitude in the labour movement towards solidarity.
Kinnock Insisted that the miners could not be supported because they had not held a ballot: and his criticism of Liverpool Council centred on their tactic of Issuing redundancy notices.
I think the tactic of redundancy notices was wrong, while the NUM was right: but that is not the issue.
The fact is that Liverpool Council has been lighting in defence of jobs and services: for this reason they must be defended against the Tory attacks in the media and elsewhere, while reserving our right to criticise particular tactics. Even those who disagreed with the NUM tactic on the ballot had a class duty to defend the miners against the Tories.
This Issue which side are you on? - must be the first question in front of the labour movement whenever a struggle erupts against the employers or the government. As socialists our opposition to British imperialism means that we have an obligation to delend those who fight for national liberation, oven If we disagree with some or with all of their tactics and
The first question is: "Which side are you on?"
policies. If you do not solidarise with the struggles of the oppressed you have no right to be taken seriously in your criticisms.
The same is as true for organisations as it is for individuals. For some sectarian left groups, the issue is whether any particular campaign or struggle fits entirely with their political analysis: only if they are satisfied in this way will they support. Many go on to picket lines or demonstrations, or intervene in campaign conferences simply to further their own particular line or attract members to their own current - ignoring the interests of the class struggle as a whole. Strike support committees can be thus turned Into sterile debating chambers which alienate militant workers and produce Ittle in terms of practical support international solidarity is likewise turned away from mobilisation and action, towards polemics and wrangles. aet in this sectarian fashion. Milton
Miltant supporters for example in many areas refused throughout the miners' strike to join the miners' support committees: Instead they set up their own -seeking simply to raise the profile of Militant and recruit members rather than solidarise with the miners.
For the first four months of the strike the SWP did the same. Yet it was the non-sectarian support groups -embracing a wide range of political views- which made a real Socialist Viewpoint, No 8, November 7986, Page 36 contribution to the miners' strike.
Yet. as Kinnock shows, the sectarian approach to solidarity is by no means the exclusive preserve of the left. For rears. solidarity work on South Africa as been hampered by the dominant ole played by the Stalinist-led exiles n SÁCTU, who have continuall opposed any form of links with the rising black trade unions which did not go through SACTU Itself.
There are many who believe on the other hand that in engaging in international solidarity work - on Ireland, Nicaragua, South Africa or elsewhere - socialists must abandon any criticism, and simply endorse the tactics and politics of the existing leaders of the struggle - Sinn Fein, the Sandinistas or the ANC.
Just as we cannot abstain from struggles because bureaucratic leaders will try to sell out. we should not abandon our right to criticise and argue for our point of view. Solidarity does not mean subservience. "March separately: strike together" remains a healthy guide both to united fronts and to basic solidarity.
Unfortunately the sectarian and bureaucratic traditions have long histories and are deep-rooted in the labour movement. There is little hope of arguing "Militant" into a change of attitude.
But many on the left can larn the lesson. When we rightly attack Kinnock for scabbing on the miners. let us also ensure that we approach struggles in a principled way. First we get into the fight on the side of the oppressed: and from this position of active commitment and solidarity we raise our criticisms. put forward our tactical suggestions, seek to advance the class struggle and construct within it a new leadership which can push aside the likes of Nell Kinnock
Want to
know
more?
CUBA
Radical face
of Stalinism
Copies available (E5.00 including postage)
Box 3956, London WCIN 3XX
The politics of the
MINERS' STRIKE
e By BILL PETERS M
Perhaps the first attempt at an objective and coherent political analysis of the miners' strike and its lessons for the workers' movement.
44 pages, 80p. including postage, from Socialist
Viewpoint, BCM Box
3956. London WCIN 3XX.
in touch with your nearest contact.
Name
Address
Trade Union
Labour Party
Telephone
SOCIALIST
VIEWPOINT
Who
INSIDE:
the miners deluge of sell-.
TGWU ball
Please send me.
I enclose f
Name
Address ..
Socialist Viewpoint has supporters and sellers in many towns in
England and Scotland. If you wish to find out more about our politics and our work in the labour movement in your area, contact Socialist
Viewpoint at BCM Box 3956, London WCIN 3XX, and we will put you
Please send me details of Socialist Viewpoint.
WELFARE will be
Subscribe to the
STATE monthly "
.. SOCIALIST#
NHS under VIEWPOINT
Keep up with events - from a Socialist Viewpoint!
Our monthly magazine carries analysis and background coverage coupled with reviews, historical articles and comment.
Make sure of your copy each month - take out a subscription at the bargain rate of 12 issues for £10 including postage (or £12 overseas). Or take several copies to sell: contact us for bulk rates.
plus a donation of £
SOCIALIST
VIEWPOINT
70p