Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Miners win at TUC

Socialist Viewpoint no. 7, September 1985 · p 16 · 1,166 words

Transport workers Unemployment

As readers will know, the traditional steps taken by bosses cutting lobs are "natural wastage" first, tollowed by early retirements, voluntary redundancies, and finally compulsory redundancies. It is difficult to ight natura wastage and early retirements, and if those are conced ed it becomes more difficult to fight redundancies. The railways are peculiar in that the wages, hours and conditions are so dreadful that until very recently many have given up jobs on the railways for any other jobs they could find; consequently there are still many new people being taken on despite thousands of jobs lost overall.

The offer of early retirements might also have persuaded older quards to vote "no" for tear of losing pension rights, etc., and in the hope of getting generous pay-offs to retire.

Secondly, many quards - even those who voted "yes - saw DOO as unstoppable. The threat of DOO has been hanging over us for at least nine years. DOO has already been introduced on some lines of the London

Underground, on the Tyne and Wear

Metro, and in 1983 on the Bedford to

St Pancras ("Bedpan'") line. In addi.

tion, management have for the last 20 years used modernisation - such as new signalling methods, and automatic sliding-door trains - to reduce the responsibilities of guards. To all this the NUR have acquiesced, the result being widespread fatalism about DOO. Some quards who presumbaly voted "no - were arguing that the union should just negotiate the best terms of defeat possible. And many who voted "yes" did so out of loyalty to the union and hostility to management rather than out of any real conviction that a strike would stop DOO

A further problem was the attitude of many drivers. On the positive side was the wonderful solidarity shown by drivers put on the spot" by management. Drivers refused to work freight trains converted to DOO at Margam and Llanwern in South Wales and at Immingham in South Humberside, and drivers at King's Cross refused to attend DOO training schools; all being sent home with loss of pay for doing so. And the co operation of NUR and ASLEF at leadership level through the Rail Union Federation is in marked contrast to the rivalry and hostility that has traditionally existed between the two unions.

But on the negative side, there is still considerable hostility at local level largely a result of the 1982 ASIEF strike against flexible roster ing, when the NUR conceded flexible rostering, and failed to support the drivers. Sid Weighell then General Secretary of the NUR operly opposed the ASLEF strike. For many drivers -including some of the most militant of ASLEF members the bitter reaction to overtures from guards was "you were all quite happy to report for work and o tolle

ASLEF leader Ray Buckton: improved links at leadership level are marred by memories of NUR scabbing in 1982.

get paid for doing nothing in the 1982 strike - why should we respect your picket lines now?" To add to this, drivers have been offered a bribe of

£7.32 per shift by the BRB for accepting DOO.

The course of events during this summer, and in particular the sacking of over 200 guards on strike, showed how wrong was the decision of this year's NUR Annual Conterence to accept the Tory laws on ballotting before strikes. This decision was pushed through by Knapp using the justification of the bungled

London tube strike earlier this year.

A ballot of quards was called (initially for August 29 but then brought forward by a week), When guards started taking strike action against the attempts to impose DOO on selected freight trains - starting with quards at Margam depot in South Wales on July 15 - it became clear that the ballot was a hindrance to spreading strike action from depot to depot and region to region.

Alter these guards at Margam, and others at Llanwern and Glasgow, were sacked there was immediate 1-day unofficial strike action on parts of the Southern Region, and occasional 1-day strikes elsewhere.

But many quards depots were waiting tor the ballot rather than try. ing to get unofficial strike action off the ground.

Without the ballot, it might have been possible for unofficial action to become widespread after the sack ings, and for the union to call official national strike action on that basis. As it was, the effect of the sackings and the lack of response to them served to "nimidate many guards into voting

The BRB had used the "get back to work or you're sacked" threat suc cessfully to end the 1982 ASLEF strike, and had now carried out the same threat against striking guards. They were undoubtedly going to use the same threat in the event of a national guards' strike.

Further intimidation by the BRB was the threat of a lock out: sending Socialist Viewpoint, No. 7, September: 1985. Poge 16 home without pay all railworkers in the event of a guards' strike. The BRB were obviously willing to sit out a long strike, and the government through mobilising private lorry and coach firms — to outflank a strike.

The general fear of unemployment and of being sacked that now extends through most of the working class, and the failure of the union movement - with the exception of the miners — to fight for jobs affected the ballot. In this atmosphere, management's intimidation was probably the crucial factor.

This intimdiation could have been answered if rapid and widespread or national action had been taken in defence of those guards sacked. But the union leadership. having tied their hands by the ballot, refused to organise official action and did little to encourage unofficial action.

Given that, a crucial failure of the NUR leadership was that no strategy for a strike was advanced. Indeed, the proposals tor an overtime ban, a work to rule, and selective strike action that the union leadership was going to call if the ballot had been won, showed their own lack of confidence in all-out strike action. What was needed was a serious drive to link up our dispute with driver-only operation on the London Underground and the threat of removal of conductors from buses in order to try to extend strike action to other areas of public transport.

Despite the defeat in the ballot, we can't give up and let management do as they like. The sacked guards still have to be fought for. We will have to fight over the details of implementing DOO, for the best conditions and job protection for guards affected and guards transterred to other jobs. A key task of militants now ls to maintain the strength of trades unionism in their depots and to build regular links between depots, so as to be able to take effective industrial action when necessary.

If the ballots of workshop workers and S&T (signals and telegraph) workers vote for action, they will need the support of all railworkers.

← Teachers press on with class warfare · TUC backs miners' call: Scargill gets it right! →

Something wrong on this page?