January 1649: the revolutionary English bourgeoisie execufes King Charles I: four months lafer they crushed the radical Levellers of
British workers and deEmingh ant Block Sent 2-0gre greward cold. nel Hacker F. De terre Bel D. Counte Tomeanirort Burford. aware and resolute elements of the British labour movement -particularly of its revolutionary wing - have always rallied to the cause of the Irish people, A sure litmus test of British working class consciousness and ideological independence from its ruling class has always been and remains its attitude to Ireland.
Those workers who clearly identified their own exploiter did not slander or assault the Irish immigrant. Those who understood the nature of their own political and overlords did not condemn the Irish rebel.
08188)
Ireland: Part I
THROUGHOUT history the most England's difficulty was not people against enemy. Conversely.
Ireland then strengthened at home.
the case today.
England's Bourgeois
Revolution and Ireland.
military the 17th Century.
of
BANCKET only Ireland's opportunity - it was also the chance for the
British working class to seek ponents liberty in alliance with the Irish
•common previous if the
British state tightened its grip in would
This historical survey hopes to be a reminder that this is still the
Rebellion in Ireland acted as one of the catalysts of the English Revolution
Initially, and
Socialist Viewpoint, No. 7, September 1995. Page 37
While Matt HATS By DAVID MOSS however, it was not sympathy with the insurgents but popular fear that the King intended unleashing a Catholic "Papist army" to massacre his op-
- as the Protestant colonists had been massacred in Ireland the year which compelled many of parliament's supporters to take up arms in 1642
Then, with the final defeat of the royalist armies in Britain, the triumphant bourgeoisie, led by Cromwell and his generals, were free to root out remaining nests of royalists in Ireland and at the same time to complete the subjugation of the province.
The perversion of the revolution to this end became the immediate cause of the rilt between the army Grandees and the tank and file soldiery drawn from the small traders, artisans farmers. Their economic
grievances over conditions of service only aggravated deep dissatisfaction with the increasing authoritarianism of the generals and the failure to attain many of the democratic objectives of the Revolution. Preparations for the Irish expedition in 1649 provided the spark for mutiny and the first declaration of support for Ireland by English radicals, under the leadership of the Levellers, the most committed republicans in the Parliamentarian forces.
A Leveller pamphlet, The English Soliders Standard... produced for circulation in the army, related the conquest of Ireland to the suppression of democratic liberties at home. "For consider, as things now stand," it asked the soldiers:
*to what end you should hazard your lives against the Irish. Will you go on still to kill, slay and murder in order to make (your of. ficers] as absolute lords and masters over Ireland as you have made them over England? Or is it your ambition to reduce the Irish to the happiness of tithes... excise. customs and monopolies in trades? Or to fill their prisons with poor disabled persons. to fill their land with swarms of beggars... to take down monarchical tyranny and set up aristocratic tyranny... before you go... see those evils reformed here, that when occasion shall justly invite you thither. you may carry a good platform in your hands. such a one as possibly they will never fight against."
Another pamphlet justified the Irish rebellion of 1641, posing the question:
*Whether the English would not do as the Irish have if the Irish should dispossess and tyrannise over them? Whether it be not England's duty to repent of the oppressions and usurptions over the rish nation by their Kings and forefathers?"
Condeming all imperialism, it advocated that Ireland be a "free state"
After the execution of a soldier for his part in the mutiny over arrears of "Agitators to present their demands, troops elected a council and one regiment refused to march to the port of embarkation for Ireland. A pamphlet stating their grievances also expressed concern that they were degenerating into a professional and mercenary army.
"What have we to do in Ireland. to fight and murder a people and a nation, (for indeed [the Grandees] are set upon cruelty and murdering poor people which is all they glory in) which have done uS no harm...?*
The defeat of the hard-core Leveller troops at Burford in May 1649 decided the fate of English Radicalism and Irish Nationalism for almost one and a half centuries. Not only was the mutiny ended, but also all Radical opposition to Cromwell's regime was eradicated with it, clearing the field for the rule of the
Generals, the ruthless reconquest of Ireland and the ultimate restoration of the monarchy. Political crises continued, culminating in the "Revolution" of 1688 which established a new King counterbalanced by landowner-merchant oligarchy in terested in developing capitalism at home and consolidating the Protestant supremacy in Ireland
In order to survive, British mercantile and industrial capital had to prolect its markets against the growth of foreign capitalism. Backed by armed might. it had a host of Navigation Laws and Tariff barriers to give the English bourgeoisie the advantage over foreign rivals, including the trade and manufacturers of the colonies.
Resentful of these restrictions and of the raising of taxes for an administration over which they had no control, the manulacturing bougeoisie, planters, farmers and artisans of the American colonies rose against the British government in 1775. Their rebellion and its philosophy as embodied in the Declaration of Independence were to have important repercussions on the political systems of both Britain and Ireland
According to Walpole in 1776, "All Ireland was America mad". Led by the protestant bourgeoisie the bulk of the Irish people involved in trade and manufacture identified their cause with that of the American Sociahat: Viewpoint, No. 7, September 1985, Pager 32
Cromwell: his bourgeote republic reconquered Ireland. revolutionaries. Invasion fears caused by the entry of the French into the war led in 1778 to the formation of a guard, bourgeois.
predominantly whelmingly Protestant and increasnationalistic. While Britain's hands were still tied by the American revolt this armed force was organised behind demands for free trade and an independent Irish parliament, gaining by 1782 major concessions on both these points.
rapid development of the capitalist mode of production had the constitutional settlement of 1688 and the majority of the bourgeoisie of both Britain and Ireland were excluded from governgalvanised by the parliamentary reformers further encouragement from the suc-. cesses of the Irish Volunteers, whom some of them wished to emulate:
"Was it love of Ireland that made Lord North anxious to hurry the Irish bills through Parliament?" need the speaker at one kabire bayonets planted at his breast."
But as the Gordon riots of 1780 and widespread unrest and bread riots of 1783 showed, reform agitation if taken too far would unleash forces bourgeoisie. It was for this reason
also that the French Revolution, greeted with enthusiasm by many Whig reformers in 1789, increasingly terrified them as it became apparant that its main driving force came from the plebeian radicals republicans — the "Sans-culottes" British Republicans and Ireland. The ideale of the Patch editiond especially articulated elaborated by Tom "Rights of Man" published in 1791, gained thousands of followers in both Britain and Ireland. To the horror of the ruling class, common labourers and artisans were politically under an internationalist banner of Liberty, Equality Fraternity which elevated Reason and the People above Church and King. Sedition in all its guises was summed up in one word - Jacobinism.
"Rights of Man" was banned in 1792 and Paine escaped to France from the threat of a capital conviction. A number of his disciples in England, Scotland and Ireland were arrested, some imprisoned and others transported, especially as the outbreak of war with France in 1793 had added suspicion that they were planning to assist an invasion.
Groups like the United Irishmen and the Corresponding Societies in Britain, who had sought reform of parliament and an extension of the ranchise, were thus prevented tron legal agitation and propaganda. The Right to resist Tyranny was one of the central themes of Jacobinism and the more determined elements began to reorganise secretly.
Republicans, protestant chants, professional men, tradesmen, farmers, artisans and labourers and their Catholic counterparts, tegrated with the secret Catholic peasant societies, The Defenders, build the United Irishmen into a military orgnaisation by 1796. By the following year United Irishmen were also active in Britain.
After meetings with Father Quigley (later hung for treasonable negotiations with the French) members of the London Corresponding founded the United Englishmen (or Britons) on the model of the United Irishmen. Under the influence of immigrants wagrantseman from Monaghan and Robert James Dixon, a Belfast weaver, United Englishmen's organisation developed in Manchester and the adjacent manufacturing
Quigley talked about the intention to "revolutionise" England
Scotland.
But it was in the fleet that the
Republicans had their most spectacular successes. In the
Nore and Spithead in 1791 testering grievances about conditions erupted into mutiny. On board some ships the leadership ws assumed by members or sympathisers of the Corresponding
Societies and the United Irishmen.
Paine in his organising and
Republican merinto hung for forming a conspiracy
Plymouth of soldiers and
Society sworn to make England,
Gray, the government were terrified by districts.
and committee them and to direct the mutiny.
ships at ecuted,
(top) Cartoon depicts destruction of feudalism in French Revolution:
(above) A hostile view of the 1798 rebellion.
There were about 15,000 Irishmen in the navy out of a total of 120,000 history sailors and marines and there is evidence that United Irishmen had enlisted specifically to spread disaf.
fection. Robert Lee from Dublin was at among marines
"like France republican:
and Ameria, a free country". Some of the mutineers referred to the fleet as
"The Floating Republic" and discussobliged ed sailing to either France or Ireland.
However the Admiralty and the the mere fact that Republican literature was ciculating in the fleet and that sailors and marines were aware that
He they had "Rights" and were practising democracy by the election of a of delegates to represent
After two months of negotiations
An and mounting tension, with even the
Britons
Thames being blockaded for a while, the mutiny collapsed in mid June.
Twenty nine of the leaders were exas many imprisoned and a number brutally flogged. Although a sister
Socialist Viewpoint, No. 7, September 1985. Page 33 defeat, it marked the first time in when British and Irish Republicans acted together.
Not only were United Irishmen agitating in the British fleet but also United Englishmen were agitating the Irish soldiers. Henry Fellows, executed for his activities at Maidstone, wrote to a fellow
"Citizen, I received your parcel with the regulations, etc.. and am to you for sending the Ulster address. as I think it will be productive to our cause, for they seem to meet the approbation of the citizens here, particularly the Irish soldiers...
also requested 50 copies of Paine's "Agrarian Justice" which advocated land reform. The seeds of social, not only political, revolution were being sown.
"Address from the United to United Irishmen" in January 1798 expressed the common interests of the two peoples:
"Though labouring under the yoke of the same oppression, the countries have been dif-
ferently treated. Ireland always been the object of direct and open violence. England fraud... however resulted from the mutual effect sufferings and mutual commiseration: the prejudice of nations done away and the English burn with the desire to hail the Irish as freemen and bretheren.
Another address to the "Brave and Suffering Nation from the London Corresponding Society, condemned the harsh repression which begun particularly against the Irish peasantry there are few in Britain who do not suffer with horror at a recital of the sufferings of the Irish people...
It included an echoed the Leveller pamphlets of the English civil war:
"Soldiers, we have with the deepest concern learned. that you have, on some occasions, been induced to violate that humanity which has heretofore characterised British soldiers... If you massacre the Irish, will not the Irish in some measure be justified in retaliating upon the British... behave with the manly firmness of British soliders. not the desperate fury freebooters and assassins: conduct will endear you to your relatives and friends by convincing them that their happiness is dear to you: it will restore peace and liberly to Ireland, and consequently to Great Britain.
Faced with arms searches, the torturing of suspects, threats massacre from the Orange Lodges and treachery in high places United Irishmen broke out into a premature and ill co-ordinated insur-
GIELLERS
CIEFFET has rection.
The uprising of inspired organisation banner of a deistical republic!
is terrified many draper Henry Munroe.
rest of Ireland, and inadequately rebels
Ulster in defeated appeal which the United Englishmen were arrested
English republicans materialise.
these serious defeats and growing
French
Buonaparte, the Republic spirit lived оп.
Englishmen and of began to reorganise and delegates such continued to pass between the two countries and France.
The thought in terms of a common strug gle stating their objectives as "The independence of Great Britain and
Ireland political and of manifesto called on Englishmen to be united and reminded them of the exthe ample of Ireland:
her
Socialist Viewpoint, No. 7. September 1985. Pope 34 encapsulated all the contradictory elements of Irish society. An urban-based, Protestantprepared struggle which resulted in a devout
Catholic peasantry rising under the
Liberty."
The social nature of the rebellion of the bourgeois republicans but Antrim rose under released the United Irish leader Henry Mc-
Cracken, a wealthy Presbyterian cotton manufacturer, followed by Down, in under another Protestant, the Lisburn
But as in the evidence partially mobilised equipped, the were bloodily invasion.
Before the rising several leaders of was and the expected support from the did not
A French force did arrive in Ireland, but too late. Despite disillusionment with the course of the rebellion
Revolution under
Surviving cells of both the United
United Irishmen were
United Englishmen clearly under equalisation of civil teligious rights." Its
•.see her fertile plains ravaged hospitable villages
The execution of Robert Emmet. Blundered and barder and Generous Sons chered and exiled for no other crime than the inflexible Love of
One of the leaders of the United Englishmen, arrested in 1798 but by 1800, was Marcus Despard, a former army Colonel and the son of an Irish landowner. He was contact with United Irish emissaries in London and there is that via them coordinated uprising was planned possibly to coincide with a French
In 1801 he visited Ireland and in November of the following year he arrested at a meeting in a Lambeth pub along with soldiers and labourers, some of them Irish, who were accused of plotting a coup to seize the Tower of London and other strategic points. As in the 1278 the signal for the United Englishmen to rise throughout the country was to have been the stopp ing of the mail coaches.
Despard and six comrade soldiers executed and the United organisation collapsed. Undeterred, preparations continued for another insurrection by the United Irishmen
Robert Emmett, but this dissolved in a premature attempt which only attracted the support of a few Dublin workers. Emmett followed Despard to the gallows. Thus ended the first round of Ireland's struggle for an independent Republic and the beginning of a common cause between the Irish and English people through a decade of rapid and profound social and political change.
Republicanism, working class radicalism, and the
Act of Union.
Riots and disturbances were commonplace in eighteenth century Bricats, conscription address wage cuts, conscription unpopular laws and governments. In Ireland agrarian warfare and secret peasant paramilitary societies were endemic.
But with the French Revolution the threat to the ruling class from such violence became potentially lethal.
For the first time since the Revolution of the 1640s, there was a coherent ideology and set of objectives to weld all the diverse forms of discontent together and target them against the state and ruling class.
There was also a new factor - the emergent working class concentrated in the industrial towns of Britain and the small master craftsmen in the manufacturing already feeling the impact of industrial capitalism.
These classes also existed in Ireland where they provided the backbone of a republican movement of which the bourgeoisie formed much of the initial brains and the peasantry the muscie. Thus from its beginning the overriding character of Irish and English republicanism was plebian - a fact which must not be obscured by the origins of some of its leaders like Tone or Despard.
Faced with the fourfold spectre of Jacobinism, social war, French invasion and the loss of their prime colony, it is not surprising that the reaction of the British ruling class was merciless. Apart from the ruthless repression of the '98 rebellion, Parliament enacted a whole battery of laws which served it, or set a precedent for future action, against the popular movements in Britain and Ireland for the next century.
There other consequences of the reaction to the Republican movement which were to affect the whole course of the future struggle: the rise of the Orange Order, and the passing of the Act of Union.
The Orange Order originated in 1795 among Protestant linen weavers in North Armagh who sought forcibly to expel Catholics from the trade. Powerful patronage was soon fortheoming irom gentry in the com. munity who saw the Orangemen as a potential military auxillary against the United Irishmen and Defenders and as an ideological counterweight to republican ideas amongst the Protestants.
Orange lodges were formed and incorporated into the local militias which played a part in the suppression of the rising. But it was not only in Ireland that the Orange Lodges combated sedition. In 1812 Lancashire magistrates recruited their agents and special constables from fellow members in their campaign against the Luddites. Henceforth
Orangeism was to spearhead loyalist reaction amongst the working class in both countries.
There was little support for the Act of Union of 1801.
Orange Lodges either abstained or objected to it because of the strong opposition to
Union from some powerful Protestant interests. It was only conceded by the
Irish parliament after the majority of
MPs were covinced that participation in the British parliament would be
The attitude of the majority of peole in Dublin was described by the
British minister Castlereagh:
"The lower orders are naturally indifferent to the question but will easily be set in motion should their co-operation become necessary to leading opposers of
Once passed, the Union was bound to become the pivot of all political
SOCIALIST
VIEWPOINT
No. 3. Apell 1985.
Who will be the next?
ASIDE
INSIDE: • Alter
• SOUTH AFRICA the miners - a
• LPYS • Black:
deluge of sell-outs
• NHS under the axe
• USFITTE
• GWU ballots
Our monthly magazine carries analysis and background coverage coupled with reviews, historical articles and comment.
Make sure of your copy each month - take out a subscription at the bargain rate of 12 issues for £10 including postage (or £12 overseas. Or take several copies to sell: contact us for bulk rates.
Please send me
I enclose £
Name
Address.
Socialist: Viewpoint, No. 7, September 1985, Page 35 agitation in Ireland, whilst for Britain it ensured that Ireland was no longer merely a colonial and military problem like any other province in the empire, but a factor central to the inter-party parliamentary
For British working class radicals, it meant that the people of both countries had a common interest in reforming the same parliment.
by the same corrupt landed oligar-
"boroughmongers", were responsible misery and social repression in Bri-
NEXT MONTH:
Between Napoleon and the
First International
SOCIALIST
VIEWPOINT
No. 4. June/Taly 1345. 70p
WELFARE
& STATE
• Health werkers strice back
C MARXISM and ECOLOG
Keep up with events - from a Socialist Viewpoint!
issues of Socialist Viewpoint.
plus a donation of €