Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Communist Party: 60 years of misdirection in the unions

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 2, November 1984 · pp 24-29 · 4,673 words

Trade unions Britain Russia and the USSR Racism and anti-fascism

Communist Party: 60 years of misdirection in the unions.

ONE organisation which has gained in membership during the miners' strike has been the Communist Party. With many of its best and most active rank and file NUM militants travelling outside their home areas to work with local Support Committees, the CP has been able to project the image of a solid, working class organisation.

But new contacts and recruits may be excused for wondering exactly what Party and what politics they are signing up for. The Communist Party's daily paper the Morning Star has been more conspicuous in recent years for its plunging circulation obituary column and knife-edge fund appeals than for any political leadership or clarity. And the past 18 months has seen an ugly public faction fight for control of the Star and its editorial line.

On the one side are ranged the "traditional"

Stalinist advocates of unapologetic the "Moscow" line - a minority in the present-day Communist Party, but still clinging on to a majority control of the formally "independent" more openly who have taken a majority on the CP's Executive Committee but have been unable to assert their control over the Morning Star.

Yet on most major issues of policy regarding the British class struggle, both wings of the Party share a common approach. The differences are sharpest on international issues, such as Poland and Afghanistan — where he old guard doggedly defend the

Moscow Stalinists, embarrassment in aid this o secure a "broader" base for the Party amongst liberal thinking sections of the middle class.

on the central issue of class-struggle politics today, the miners' strike, there is no real division between the main CP factions. Both wings are committed to a policy of preserving the Party's longstanding "peaceful co-existence" with the "left" wing of the TUC General Council, and the trade union bureaucracy as a whole.

yearsone has moonged to old bee policies over to a quite disproportionate number of official positions and influential posts in the unions, even though the Party's membership has dwindled year after year to below 15,000.

The CP's refusal to challenge or put demands for action which might bureaucrats — even though the TUC itself has moved steadily to the right under the blows from the Thatcher "lefts" have shown themselves unwilling to take any firm stand against the right wing -in the miners' strike.

Himself influenced by CP politics, accompanied in maGahey and Peter Heabetield, ict thur Scargill's attitude towards the TUC itself, and the union leaders at the Labour Party conterence, been one which has repeatedly let the bureaucrats off the hook. Socialist Viewpoint, No. 2, November 1984. Page 24

By HARRY SLOAN

At the Brighton TUC Congress, the NUM leadership wrongly opted for the hollow facade of "unity" around the empty formulae of the General Council's resolution, and made no real attempt to fight for and demand real action from the other unions. The result: despite paper pledges of lined to operate aeratie fun.

supplies are being accepted across NUM picket lines; and the Tory government, encouraged by the pro stration of the TUC, has given High Court judges the green light to seize national assets. Yet the Morning Star hailed the TUC decisions as a victory for the miners.

Likewise at the Labour Party conference, where the seizure of the union's national assets and even jailing of NUM leaders was immediately hreatened, NUM leaders agreed t he withdrawal of the TGWU resolu tion endorsing their retusal to go to the High Court. Despite the NUM restraint, they did not even receive in

1926 General Strike: CP line was all power to the General Council" — which sold out after 9 days.

return the "unity" of a speech or two by other unions pledging to defend the miners against further court action.

There is reason to believe that this line is more that of the Communist Party than Arthur Scargill, who in the early days of the strike set a healthy precedent by going out of his way to put other union leaders on the spot, and calling - sometimes over their heads - for solidarity action from other sections of workers.

Yet now The Miner, edited by longstanding CPer Maurice Jones, facing the question of seizure of the whole union's assets, makes no ap. peal for action to any other union, and despite the headline "It's War!" brushes aside the sequestration.

And the CP policy of peaceful coexistence with the right wing of the union bureaucracy has also made itself felt on the question of picketing. A clear example of this was to be seen during the for a mass picket of Didcot power station, near Oxford, on October 24.

When a delegation from the Oxford Trades Council and the South Wales NUM attended the South East Region TUC support group to propose backing for the picket there was very great reluctance to do so. They quoted the TUC Congress resolution which required the unions inside the power stations to agree before a picket can be placed on the gates. They argued that there was a danger that such pickets could alienate the officials concerned and the stewards inside. A week later and after much debate the decision was taken to support the Didcot picket and promote other mass pickets of power stations in the South East Region.

Nor was the opposition a chance thing. Most of those opposing the picket to one degree or another were CP members clearly acting on party lines.

Behind this attitude of the CP lies a view of trade union work as one of collaborating and preserving "unity" with the right-wing TUC "establishment" — even where this is at the expense of the rank and file struggle. Cers saw it as pe tuds to uphton

Brighton resolution than to take action to shut down a power station.

This political approach is not new. It has a long and undistinguished history period of the 1926 General Strike.

The British Communist Party was formed in August 1920 in the aftermath of the Russian Revolution; it attracted many of the most class conscious and militant workers, as well as elements from the small, divided and politically weak groupings of British Marxism.

The motive for joining such a party was plainly the need for a clear, revolutionary political leadership in the British workers' movement, where the class collaboration of the stillemerging Labour Party and its leadership was a mirror image of the largely conservative trade union bureaucracy.

But the early Communist Party lacked a coherent policy or perspective for relating to the exising labour movement. As the inheritor of many of the sectarian methods of the early British Marxists, it did not begin a serious attempt to implant itself in industry until 1922-23 — by which time slump and mass unemployment were major obstacles.

The CP did after a while become involved with a growing rank and file movement which, in the light of repeated betrayals by the official union bureaucracy, began to spread through the trade union movement trom 1922 onwards. Miners, engineers and transport workers began to organise their own "minority movements" - so named because

AH

Socialist Viewpoint, No. 2, November 1984. Page 25 of the complaint by "minority of union bureaucrat over the troublemakers". In 1924 these rank and file groups came together to form the National Minority Movement.

Rather like so many of today's more radical Broad Lefts, the NMM — like the CP itself — was stronger on propaganda for action than on organisation in workplaces. But the conference called for the setting up of factory committees. And a key resolution called for a strengthening of theil, to enable it to Call outeral

, to enable it to call out the whole movement in a general strike While warning that such a change by no means guaranteed that the General Council would become any less rectionary, the resolution argued thalle guard against the General Council becoming a machine of the capitalists, and can really evolve from the General Council a Workers' General Staff only by, in the first place and fundamentally, developing a revolutionary class consciousness amongst the Trade Union membership, and in the second place, = deneral councel constitution of the as to ensure that those elected thereon have the closest contact with the workers. A far cohe is mi this militant spirit of hostility to bureaucracy, from today's cosy links between "communist" union officials and the TUC right wing. It was on this albeit rather risky - basis that the Communist Party of 1924 argued the slogan "More Power to the General Council". And the Communist fraction at TUC Congresses took up the fight for control over the General Council, making the minor but significant breakthrough of ensuring • that the Council's annual report was issued to delegates a week in advance

Tanks on the street during the General Strike of Congress rather than on the day!

Minority Movement successes in working with the many militants involved in a wave of strikes in 1924 seem to have been a major factor in provoking union bureaucrats to hit back against the CP, throwing union block votes behind Ramsay MacDonald's moves in 1924 and 1925 to bar Communists from individual membership of the Labour Party.

But at the same time a "left" element of the union bureaucracy began to emerge, seeking to adapt to the militancy of the workers, and using the issue of friendly relations with the USSR as a handy means of proving their "radical" credentials without disrupting their stance on the class struggle in Britain.

In 1924 the TUC sent a delegation to the USSR, a group of whom Purcell, Hicks, Bromley and Swales - began to speak out in favour of unity between British and Russian trade unions as a step towards international unity.

This hollow gesture was sufficient to win the enthusiastic applause of Stalin and the emerging vative, bureaucratic leadership which took complete control of the Soviet Union after the death of Lenin in 1924.

In that same year Stalin had revealed his conservative, nationalist "theory" that in a situation of "stabilised" capitalism on a world scale, it was necessary to look not to the spread of revolution but simply to build "socialism in a single country" With this narrowing focus came readiness to reach out for well-placed "friends" of the Soviet Union in the capitalist countries: and among the first objects of this new affection were the "Lefts" of the TUC General Council.

With Moscow waxing eloquent on the importance of these newlydiscovered "Lefts" — who at home significantly steered well clear of the Minority Movement, and made no attempt to defend the Communists against witch-hunters in the Labour Party - the British CP also began to drop its initial public distrust.

Increasingly the CP began to look for action to the bureaucratic "Lefts" already ensconsed in the General Council rather than to the building of movement and forcing General Council to respond to the demands of the workers. "More Power to the General Council" was increasingly detached from any cautionary qualification.

This was the background to the bankruptcy in the General Strike of

As Baldwin's Tory government utilised the breathing space obtained by their retreat on "Red Friday", June 1925, to prepare an all-out offensive against the paap should have been and conditions of the redoubling its efforts to mobilise the rank and file of the trade unions through the Minority Movement for the necessary General Strike. Instead

Party and its press Council "Lefts", failed to challenge their retreats, and peddled illusions in the General Council as a whole.

The same CP which had prepared and argued correctly for revolutionary mass action in the run-up to Red Friday turned - partly through pressure from Moscow - to propaganda work and cheer-leading for the TUC "Lefts" by May 1926 Even the Councils of Action for which the Minority Movement called were viewed by CP in 1926 as bodies which would "see that all the decisions of the General Council and the union executives were carried out...

As George Hardy, CP secretary of the Minority Movement admitted after the General Council's 9-day betrayal of the General Strike:

"Although we knew of what treachery the Right Wing leaders were capable, we did not clearly understand the part played by the so-called 'Int in the unine leade to bo. In the main they turned out to vindbags and capitulated to the light Wing. We were taught a majo lesson; that while developing a move to the left officially, the main point in preparing for action must always be Socialist Viewpoint, No. 2, November 1984. Page 26 to develop a class-conscious leadership among the rank and file.

(G. Hardy, "Those Stormy Years")

The Anglo-Russia Committee proved to be no more in practice than a mechanism for hog-tying the Communist to the bureaucratic "lefts" who were to sell out the General Strike and leave the isolated for many months more before they were starved into defeat.

The Party itself was gaining in size ind in political influence at the time of the General Strike. The jailing of some of its leaders in October 1925 growth of the Minority Movement and the sharpening of class division had all helped create a situation where a sharp line in opposition to the "Left" betrayal could have won the CP truly massive support. Instead the Party shared responsibility for the betrayal.

Of course the treachery of the TUC "Lefts" was not entirely unexpected. Leon Trotsky, in casting a critical eye over the policies and orientation oi the British CP, had consistently warned of the danger of overestimating the TUC "Lefts" and underestimating the British working class. A Marxist analysis of these leaders was not impossible even in the heat of events: but no such leadership came from the British CP or from its Moscow mentors.

Today's Communist Party, cosying up not only to the Bucktons, Knapps and Todds on the General Council, but also to the Basnetts and Lairds in its search for "unity" at the 1984 TUC, with all the compromises that entails at local level, is simply confirming that the lessons George Hardy learned so hard in 1926 have been set aside.

The search for influential "friends" in the union hierarchy at the expense of political compromise is not the exclusive perogative of the "Euros" or the Moscow-liners: it is a common heritage of Stalinism from the mid 1920s. It is the unfortunate hallmark of the Stalinist movement that its bureaucratic structure and opporunist motives prevent the assimila ion of political lessons or the health correction of past errors.

While George Hardy in his look back at 1926 was to stress the need for class conscious leadership at rank and file level, this was not to remain CP policy for long. Indeed clear advocacy of class struggle has been only the occasional attitude of the Communist Parties in the last 60 years.

Some newcomers to political life may believe that the political line put forward — most stridently by the Euro wing of the CP, and particularly in the Party magazine Marxism To. day which they control - is a "modern" adaptation to the realities of the 1980s.

But when today's CP - both its rival wingsliancall foga cross-chass alliance" against "Thatcherism", reaching out — with particular gusto in the case of the Euros - to the SDP and "progressive"

Tories, it is simply reverting to the mainstream of Stalinist politics since the mid 1930s. Then it was called the policy of the "Popular Front". Now it rides again.

The run-up to last year's General Election coincided with the CPinspired and dominated People's March for Jobs. Not only did the organisers and CP marshals on the various leas of the March rigorously and violently suppress any political slogans — even at the level of basic anti-Tory calls for "Thatcher Out" but their efforts were backed up by the arguments of the "Moscow-line" Morning Star.

While militant unemployed youth who wanted to fight the Tories and their system were ruthlessly gagged, the doors were thrown open to "liberal"-minded from local Chambers of Commerce, or in the words of Star reporter Mar'tin Gostwick:

"the churches, the liberals, the nationalists, students, teachers, factory workers, unemployed workers, yes, and even Tory farmers, businessmen

Star, March 25 1983)

In fact it was in pursuit of the Thatcherite Tories" that young militants and socialists were muzzled by the CP - at the height of a General Election campaign!

Both today's "Euros" and the Moscow liners can look back to the tradition of the CP to back up these poltical positions. Despite its name, and despite its pretensions to Marxism, the Communist Party of Great Britain is no stranger to class collaboration: and the collaboration began under the directions of none other than Joseph Stalin, gravedigger of Bolshevism, and what remained of the Communist International in the

Alarmed by the military threat from Hitler's Germany after 1933, looked for detence of Union not to the European workers' movement, but to alliances with the governments of Germany's main imperialist rivals, principally France. In wooing these governments, he was at pains to downplay any prospective revolutionary threat posed by Communist parties. At the same time,

La strong groundswell of working class militancy and pressure for unity against a growing fascist threat. The outcome of these combined forces was a deformed offspring: France in 1934 and adopted as policy of the Comintern at its Seventh Con-

Under the Popular Front policy, the CPs obediently abandoned their 7-year policy of shrill and ludicrous denunciations of social democrats and reformist leaders as "social fascists" (who they claimed were worse than overt fascists because they operated under cover within the workers movement)

Now the CPs opened their embrace not to the social democratic workers

SO much as to their bureaucratic trade union and political leaders; and to the various "anti-fascist" parties of the capitalist class and Liberals of yesteryear, as well as political platform bourgeois forces could be united with "Communists" was a bourgeois platform. The CPs accordingly set aside revolutionary slogans, and embraced instead the reactionary values of class collaboration and nationalism. In France and Italy this reached the extent of peals to fascist movements for tional unity".

This was presented by the leaders of the Communist International as a transitional approach to socialism" in reality it abandoned any revolutionary perspective in the search for the "broadest possible alliance".

The results on a world scale were disastrous: most shattering of all was the impact of Popular Front politics in Spain, where the abandonment of calls for nationalisation of the land, and other socialist policies which could have attracted the peasantry, the advantage to Franco, whose army depended upon peasant forces. A similar "Popular Unity" line brought crushing defeat to the Socialist Viewpoint, No. 2, November 1984. Page 27

Chilean workers 34 years later in

In Britain, the politics of the Popular Front were grotesque. The Young Communist League appealed for the convening ferences of all social, Christian and political organisations in the depressed areas". It staged "keep fit" ferences involving Scouts, Ramblers Association, Bible Class and Girl Guides".

Communist Parties jumped through bourgeois political hoops like performing circus dogs in

"anti-fascism", Stalin behind the scenes was striking a new diplomatic deal with... Adolf Hitler!

August 1939 came news of the Stalin-Hitler Pact. healthy break from the Popular Front line, which brought the British CP to take at first a line of oppositioin to the British war effort between September 1939 and June 1941. And it was Hitler's predictable invasion of the Soviet Union, not any change in the class struggle elsewhere, which brought about an abrupt reversal of policy class collaboration by the go in Bri and a period of tain setting the scene for CP politics up to the present day.

In the first phase of the war, CP anti-war propaganda insisted that:

"This is not a peoples wate

war in the interests capitalists against the interests of the people... The Labour leaders have been given subordinate places monopoly capitalism's war machine, serving on Government Committees of all kinds. the purpose of camouflaging the real character of the war and become the of monopoly capitalism on the labour movement...

(Trade Unions and the War,

So effective was this political stand and so much did it link up with working class opposition to the exploitation forced upon them by pro-

- that the CP's aily Worker was banned in 1940 b lory-led coalition aovernment

Yet by May 1942, the reasons given by a CP Conference as to why the government should allow the paper to publish once more were:

"If the Daily Worker were allowed to appear, we could count on certain very important results taking place. First, there would be a greater unity ot the people behind the there would greater drive for increased producdidates would not be defeated in by-elections. Fourth, the demand for the Second Front would be stronger. Fifth, the working and fighting morale of the people would be increased. And sixth, the bonds of solidarity between the British people and the peoples fighting fascism all over the world would be far stronger.

Britain needs the Daily Worker the lack of it deprives the people of one of their most powerful weapons in the struggle for victory this year.

("The Way to Win")

The nationalism of periods of Popular Front policy was stepped up to a jingoist hysteria, as the CP argued for an anti-fascist "national front" (yes, really!):

"The Communist Party, vanguard of the working class, is striving for working-class unity and for the peoples' anti-fascist national front, in order to drive the existing Government forward and for more greasy Those who orose this action against Nazi are hankering after a line that would involve us turning aside from the mobilisation of the people to force the Government forward now, and would mean that we concentrate our energies in mobilising a certain section of the people [the workers!] in an attempt to drive the Tories out of the Government.

This could make it much easier for those reactionary appeasement instill in and around the Government who, no longer confronted with the united pressure of the people, could further their policy of passivity and inaction.

, but a big in

Advisory

They serve

AND

MLY WOR

PEACE

January 1940)

FOR RE

JADE UNIO

READ

Only

ICTORY NE Worker

БЕЛО TE

TOGETHER agamsh infinitely against previous for Tory candidates in by-elections:

as the to be a Tory

Government Conservative

FOR SOMALISM

TURN IDA80 RACING TE IT CATTO DOO TII D1 GRADE ALL LE TE organisation,

TLER

vience following

DNPRIT KC.MP

And with the goal of boosting the the CP energetically fought

"The stand taken by our Party in regard to by-elections has been firm and clear: to support the Government candidates whatever their personal shortcomings, as an expression of unity behind the Government, at the same time as conducting our own campaigns for our victory policy. on the The correctness of this stand has already been and will increasingly be demonstrated by the course of

We want to deal with some of the difficulties that are said to stand in the way of our Party members when they take part in by-elections and recommend the people to vote for a Government candidate who happens

Clearly it is not an easy task to patriotic for the CP's taste. But worse. Workers were far from keen to vote for Tories - and had to be urged on by. What is said to be the biggest obstacle in winning Labour workers Socialist Viewpoint, No. 2, November 1984. Page 28 support our policy where the is a Tory? That they refuse to vote for a Tory?'

Aside from their unpaid labour as members took over from Labour the tasks of camouflaging the character of the war and acting as the watchdogs of monopoly capitalism — tasks which the CP had correctly condemned in 1940. CPers became archstrikebreakers, and defenders union legislation, glorifying the increased exploitation:

"It has been magnificent. In spite of excessive overtime, low wages for especially the women workers, long hous spent in inconvenience and caused by the black-out, food difficulties, imposition of an unjust scale of income tax and method of deducmanagements and chaotic they have turned out tanks, guns, planes, shells, ships and coal to a marvellous extent."

(The Way to Win)

While the immediate motive for adopting the policy of total subserto Churchill's National Government had been the new requirements of Kremlin toreign policy

Hitler's invasion of the Soviet Union, there is no doubt that the extreme level of class collaboration involved, following on years of Popular Front policy, had a major impact on the Communist Party itself — and particularly on the members recruited during the war years.

Far from seeing the cross-class "national front" as a temporary expedient forced on the Party by the circumstances of the war, CP leaders plainly began to enjoy the prospect of a long-term liaison with the British imperialist bourgeoisie. In 1944, CP leader Harry Politt began looking beyond the end of the war: his vision was restricted to one of reforms within capitalism:

The Communist Patty o

WAY

TO

A WIN

Decisions of the National Conference of the Communist Part) of Great Britain, MAY, 1842.

"It will be possible, even though capitalism remains,

(How to Win the Peace, 1944)

Three years before the Cold War, ind with China still in the grip of the iciously anti-communist Chiana Ka Shek, the dreaming Pollitt mused on

"peace-loving" imperialism:

"It is, moreover, a world in which there is a firm resolve on the part of

Soviet Union world security...

... affords a real basis for systematic planning on the speed-up would need to be maintain- Britain's (!) industry and trade...

In Pollitt's the post-war capitalist reconstruction:

production and creasing development of the productive forces is an absolute necessity for even the most modest schemes of social reform. A mere re-distribution of the national income on a more just basis is enough to guarantee freedom from want, even in Britain and America, countries and the devastated areas of

Every man and woman, therefore, who is prepared to fight for freedom from want must regard the war-time of production, menace to be feared, but as a great ally on their side, cutting the ground from beneath the feet of those who claim that we cannot afford Bevercannot afford to build four million houses, cannot afford to raise secondary education to all.

We believe that the whole of Bri-

How To Win

The

Peace

by Harry Pollitt

WORKER the war-time tain's productive far more fully used even under the capitalist, their "vested interests" in questions like wages and conditions, and prais-

Anthony Eden for wage controls accordance with the people's needs, on a basis of complete co-operation and recognition of our obligations to

"There will be

Pollitt urged workers to put aside ed the implicit call by (Tory) Minister rupt

"It cannot be done if left to the free play of employers; it can be done by vested Production, demands with those from abroad in

British by

Labour.

devastated Europe and the Colonial

It demands a complete called the sident and tod

Socialist Viewpoint, No. 2, November 1984. Page 29 dependent interests of the working class. It is reformism - but a reformist perspective that arises not from the unsophisticated illusions of militant workers, or the established reformist apparatus of the unions and the Labour Party: it is a cynical reformist line argued in the interests of a corand degenerate Kremlin bureaucracy, while brandishing the stolen colours of "Communism"

It flowed, naturally enough, into a CP position of calling for a continuation of the National Government in the 1945 General Election — at which workers were in fact to register their distaste for the Tories giving a landslide victory to

Policy

for Britain

REPORT of the

A8th National Congress

The Communist Party

November, 1945

One Shilling

← Another rebuff for Labour's women · "Peace" and political revolution in Eastern Europe →

Something wrong on this page?