Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

When is a "Broad Left" not a Broad Left?

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 16, April–May 1987 · pp 10-11 · 471 words

Miners Stalinism

When is a "Broad Left"

not a Broad Left?

THE BALLOT for the Vice Presidency of the NUM took place at pit heads on March 18th. As this magazine goes to press, it has just been announced that Yorkshire candidate Sammy Thompson has held off a challenge from Scotland's Eric Clarke.

Scargill, while Clarke has been closely identified with Communist

Party attempts to oust him from the Presidency, our special correspondent WILLIAM HEAD argues that there is little to choose between the two candidates.

Though there were four candidates, it was clearly always a two horse race between Eric and

Sam, both presented as left contenders: Eric Clarke comes from the peripheral Scottish coalfield while Sammy Thompson is based in the central Yorkshire coalfield

Clarke is a star pupil of the old

"Stalinist State School of Scotland", coached personally by headmaster

- a post formerly

Mick McGahey held by Mick's dad.

Previous pupils on the same roil of honour have included Lawrence Daly: but there have been Stalinist star turns in Yorkshire, too, including

Davey Miller, who sold his job and his "left"

credentials when he quit

Kellingly at the end of the strike (he is now rumoured to be managing some sort of NCB enterprise project on a former pit site). Another old time

Stalinist is Yorkshire's Morning Star circulation officer Frank Watters (not a member of the NUM, but appearances can be deceptive); though he was retired from his post during the CP split,

Watters has for some recently made been an reason

Honorary Member of the NUM

- a he with

Nelson status shares

Mandela! There are five or six other

Stalinists at Yorkshire lesser-known pits such as Shariston; and there is a newly-launched group of "Selby Star

Readers" in the super-pit complex.

Mick Appleyard, from Shariston, writing in the Morning Star last

September, pointed out regretfully

Eric

Clarke that unless won

McGahey's job it would be the first time a leading Communist or CPGB not been part of the member had

NUM leadership.

The "Selby readers" are part of an inside club the

NUM, exclusive misleadingly called the "Broad Left"

NUM Vice President election

Though Thompson clearly enjoyed the support of Arthur

Sammy Thompson at David Jones memorial march

Remembered for ever!

Colliery.

was prepared to march.

were up on previous industry.

Socialist Viewpoint No. 16 April 1987 p10

McGahey, Daly,

Clarke and Ap-

Kim pleyard are members; so is

Howells, the research officer who helped orchestrate the South Wales moves to end the Strike. Frank Watters is a member, even though not a member of the NUM. Membership of this "Broad Left" is only offered to those who can deliver branch card votes, or to prevent someone making waves. It is nothing more or less than

← What's behind the Margam proposals? · Right wing gain in Yorkshire area NEC elections →

Something wrong on this page?