Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Marxists and the Labour Party

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 16, April–May 1987 · p 16 · 1,028 words

Labour Party Marxism

A contribution to the discussion

Labour Party

ALF FILER, a well-known activist in Brent East CLP and a supporter of Labour Briefing, replies to our last issue's coverage of the struggle for Marxism in the labour movement and the Labour Party. WHILE not disagreeing with the general thrust of the article by John Peters in the last issue of Socialist Viewpoint. there is however a need to clarify and extend the debate regarding the role of Marxists in the Labour Party.

This discussion, while dating back to the "30s, and in some senses not having changed that much, requires a more detailed analysis than simply commencing with the need to "smash the ideological and organisational hold of the Labour Party over the working class."

The Labour Party does represent a barrier to the struggle for socialism in this country and at the same time is the only mass working class party within which revolutionaries must function if we are to use these class contradictions in our favour. But that also suggests that in winning militants over to our analysis, we must take care in using crude slogans such as "smash the Labour Party"

The emphasis must be to battle against labourism of the economistic, chauvinistic and pro-capitalist form, and counterpose to that our pro gramme of Internationalism, anti-Imperialism and antiCapitalism. Only when we have carried out a thorough struggle on this basis, having won the ideologial battle, can we then project the organisational requirements that must flow from this.

That is not to say there is a stageist approach to building a revolutionary Party, for the two go hand in hand The issue though is that in winning support for our politics we do not want to build up false barriers between Marxists and the militants we are seeking to win over, who do not yet see the need to "smash the Labour Party".

Of course we must argue for a l

Marxist analysis of the Labour Party and not get caught in the centrist trap of putting security of position in the Party above that of programme; but that does not mean either that we overlook tactics, especially when we are being confronted with a witch-hunting NEC who are only looking for excuses to expel comrades.

As the Capitalist crisis worsens, it is even more relevant for Marxists to push forward the slogan "Labour take the power", using this as an opportunity to argue on what basis Labour should take power. (Not to carry out the policies of the IMF and the ruling class but to challenge the power of

While fully aware that the Labour and trade union leadership are both unwilling and unable to pursue a proletarian programme, our sights at those millions who have

We must learn to concretise and update the concept of the tional Programme as the lynchpin to mobilising the increasing numbers being drawn into class struggle at dilferent levels. By providing practical assistance in a non-sectarian fashion, we can then earn the right to offer leadership. else is merely talse posturing which will result in political impotence.

The reality of the modern Labour Party is that there are thousands of militants who are disillusioned with it; many more who won't touch it with a barge pole; others who see it as a vehicle for their own careers, some who are not really sure why they are in it in the first place. Party is relevant, not in the sense that it alters the objective role of Labour, but in terms of understanding how different social and political groups respond to the Labour Party and the challenges that emerge as a result.

issue of representation Lesbians, and other sections must be seen not as just another issue to adapt to, but a need to fundamentally rethink traditional Marxist analysis regarding the nature of the workng class in modern capitalist Britain.

A radical break with a Euro-centric analysis which is both sexist and racist by nature does not mean abandoning Marxism, as some have done. Socialist Viewpoint No. 16 April 1987 p16 but strengthening it in light of the post Second World War situation. We can not just rely on the limited writings of Trotsky & Co. to understand these developments; but we are able to draw on their rich experiences alongside those of the present day. Marxism is not a straitjacket but a scientific method to enable us to analyse events.

This also has relevance to organisational issues, when attempting to break fro a white male dominated hierarchical structure developed by previous groups. In aiming not to replace this with tokenism, we need first to locate discussion on the lessons of the sects in terms of an understanding of the relations between class, sex and race.

Dogmatic crude workerism of the SWP/Militant variety must be 1ejected. We must admit that even the traditional Bolshevik model is inadequate. To do so is not being revisionist in any sense but to advance the cause by advancing the theory based on practice and experience. Any other approach, by its very nature is anti-Marxist.

Revolutionaries in the Labour Party in Thatcher's Britain of the 1980s are a long way off from "smashing the Labour Party". betraying Conference policies but are certainly not betraying Left" (a very unscientific and confusappears to be shrinking monthly after more boring GMCs; desertions are the name of the game at the present.

This puts even more pressure on these small forces who aim to "smash the Labour Party". If we are to provide an alternative pole of attraction to that of the old and new Right and the many varieties of opportunists, then we must present an analysis and a programme based on principles which can capture the imaginations of all those millions looking for a way ouf of the mess caused by capitalism.

We must question the routinistic practice of the Labour Party which often dictates the way many of us politically organise if we are to respond adequately. Il we don't, then that will prevent many women, lesbians, gays, Black people and those of us with children from being able to participate fully in the struggles for socialism.

← No hope for "socialism in one borough" · Students take the lead against apartheid →

Something wrong on this page?