Armed German workers demonstrate in 1918 - betrayed by social democrats
Marxists and the
Labour
Party
Is social democracy in its death agony in an immediate as well as a general historical sense? Is its demise foreseable within the next period? If so, what will replace it as the mass political expression on the main steam of the British workers' movement?
These questions have real a
JOHN LISTER looks at the current situation of the
Labour Party in a more historical context. significance in today's situation: depending on how they are answered, the tactics and strategy of Marxists might take widely different courses.
They are not new questions. Since 1914, Marxists have always been keen — over-keen — to pronounce the incipient or imminent death of social democracy, which first gained Socialist Viewpoint No. 15 February 1987 p29 mass proportions through the opportunist degeneration of the parties of the Second International, culminating in the "social patriotic"
collapse of 1914 in which each major
"socialist" party voted war credits to its "own" imperialist bourgeoisie.
The first two Congresses of Lenin's new Third International, under the influence of the massive upsurge of revolutionary struggle which flowed across and beyond Europe following World War I, issued ringing denunciations of the reformist parties and proclamations of the death of the Second International.
Yet after the defeat of many revolutionary struggles and in the absence of adequate revolutionary leadership or mass Bolshevik-type parties, the social democratic parties were to emerge once again, in alliance with conservative sections of trade union bureaucracies, potent force for reaction and class collaboration within the workers' movement
Noske and Scheidemann in Germany, the murderors of Luxemboug and Liebknecht, may have been the vanguard of social democratic counter-revolution: but the whole apparatus of German social democracy proved itself in 1918-1919 to be a major obstacle to the struggles even of a mobilised, armed and insurrectionary working class. The defeat of social democracy was again shown to be a political and not an organisational question or one that spontaneous movement by te could solved working class.
The Third and Fourth Congresses of the Comintern were forced to make a more sober analysis the immediate outcome of the post-war upsurges, and to recognise the
continued existence and influence oi social democracy as a major obstacle to revolutionary politics.
From this assessment necessity tor much more tactics for work, particularly in the unions, with the Comintern insisting upon the need toI involvement in even the most partial and limited economic struggles by the working class. In rejecting the "Infantile Leftists" who wished simply to go round the social democratic parties, the Comintern pressed for the tactic of the united front and for a programme of transitional demands designed to make the link beween the revolutionaries and the layers of workers. The concept in each instance was to put forward demands and initiatives which could advance the day-to-day struggles and the political demands of the working class, while leading workers through their own experience to beyond the limitations reformist programme, break from the various wings of social democratic leaders, and embrace programme and perspective revolution.
Of course despite this, and despite the victory of the October revolution and the miserable betrayals of social democracy elsewhere, the World War I period saw not the death agony of reformism, emergence.
This was due not only subjective weakness of the forces of revolution (who nowhere Russia had developed parties comparable to the Bolshevik model, which had come through the test of 1914 and fought tenaciously for internationalism and class independence throughout the war period); but also to the continued existence of the objective base on which social democracy rests.
Large, bureaucratised, independent reformist trade unions provide a basic support for social democratic politics, while pressures of bourgeois society direct resistance along reformist Parliamentary channels, corrupting and sucking in oppositionists.
Mass social democratic parties exist only in the imperialist countries.
This reflects a fundamental fact about social democracy: its material base lies in its ability to make material gains for at least sections of the working class through collaboration and reformism. Social democracy thus rests not only class collaboration in the workers' movement but also on a willingness of the bourgeoisie to engage in class
This material base means that in today, the relative position of the | Lenin's the arose detailed
Communist broadest move of the the of post but its reto the outside vanguard working imperialist experience material but still bourgeoisie.
It the revolutionary and vigorously applying
"socialist"
created.
ultimate
Communist Parties, class on in Britain power has been greatly weakened social democracy, tod
Comintern.
massive persistent crisis as it finds itself less and less able to deliver reforms and itself comes under attack from the is not guaranteed that these union crises will have a positive outcome.
Tove canaly be artistrong due defeat in the British General.
Marxist movement,
Strong
Though there were substantial
Bringing a toil do 107, emergence of mass neither of the nearly a to where (as in France) its dominant
1927 broken over the working class was in
Nor did leaderships capable of of only 7,500 tactical line
3d and 4th lingering
Congresses emerge within the new
Soon afterwards came
Stalin's
Socialist Viewpoint No. 15 February 1987 p30
Lenin with delegates to th stranglehold on the CPSU and the
Under Stalin, the CPs were still less able to break the grip of social democracy. The rank opportunism of
1924-27 period brought disastrous adaptation to "left" trade bureaucrats and helped hunting Conference ban on dual membership of the CP and Labour Party. In December 1925 a National Left Wing Conference heard that hundred divisional and borough Labour Parties had refused implement the Conference decigor thor the sidelite en the CP-led Minority Movement also reached its peak despite a still small CP membershij
• combinatio of ectarianisn sections of the British leadership and the catastrophic "Third Period" line
th Icond Congress of the Communist International of the Comintern finally killed the momentum of the National Left Wing Movement in 1929. Under the politics of the "Third Period", Communists once again began pronouncing social dead" as a current of the working class, now characterising it instead as "social fascism"). This turn left the British CP stranded and capitalise upon the Labour crisis and MacDonald's split of 1931.
By the time of the "Popular Front" turn to cross class alliances involving "progressive" sections capitalist class in 1935, the CP had actually swung to the right of the Labour leadership and militant rank and file workers position repeated in the election of 1945; again during the Bevanite movement of the 1950s; and again today.
In short, at each historic turning Point where a substantial split in the british Labour Party movement, and the emergence of a hard, centrist/revolutionary current has seemed possible, the British CP had missed the opportunity, and confirmed its own isolation.
have failed correctly to analyse developments in social democracy and taken an incorrect line.
movement and currents arising from it have sectarian and an opportunist towards the Labour Party — which in most cases have been derived from excessive an numbers of comrades to diagnose the
"death agony" of social democracy.
there were the attempts to build the
RCP as a small mass party outside the
Labour Party at a illusions massive government.
the RCP and the Healy group's turn did not to entrism problem, however: instead, there was an opportunist deep-entry in Britain, pinning hopes on the evolution oi the
Bevanite current in revolutionary direction.
of the Nottingham group/IMG, tied to the International Secretariat, was led to opportunism by the concept of the
"replacement leadership"
which the to become a "current" within the official left, only breaking with this left when it had defeated the right wing.
upshot of this was the politics of Ken
Coates' Institute for Workers' Control and of
Chartist adaptation to reformism.
drifted into the Labour Party in the
1950s, members who were expelled from the
Labour Party. They tended to put
Labour their before the interests of struggle, and to become increasingly sectarian. Their break with the USFI
1965 and burial in in milieu produced a steady rightward prematurely evolution of their politics as democracy late 1950s, become the SLL-WRP, having won unable to important forces from the CPGB after
Party building of a trade union base and to the youth as a force for change in the
Labour Party. But it then drew false of the conclusions from the success of this separated from the fight within the the most
Labour Party.
post-war expulsions of 1964, despite an initial period in which the organisation still orientated demands and campaigns towards the Labour Party, Healy moved to entrench that separation and embark on the one-sided "partyand labour building" exercise which abandoned any involvement in the Labour Party.
Healy's material from the late 1960s announcements of the death
Socialist Viewpoint Vo. 15 February 1987 p3l
But it is not only the Stalinists who imminent democracy,
Since World War II the Trotskyist been divided between a line enthusiasm of tiny shop
In the immediate post-war period, the Trotskyist time of truly
Labour she subsequent split in intoxicated organisations resolve the social practice a centrist
OI
In the 1950s and 60s the entry work attacked abstentionism
', according
Trotskyists must first
The
- a systematic
The founders of Militant, having scabbed in 1964 on the SLL
Party membership the class the CLP/YS they
Labour Party correctly to the struggles abounds with premature demise of social
The tendency around Tony Cliff, expelled from the Healy group in 1950, continued entry work (mainly in the youth) on an opportunist line until 1967, when, along with the IMG, it turned to the student-youth milieu radicalised around Vietnam. In the early 1970s the International Socialists rank and fileist line won this group a significant base amongst stewards which led it to proclaim itself The Party in 1975.
The cases of Healy and Cliff illustrate how the older militants of and semi-Trotskyist movement, used to the conditions of tiny groups in the 1950s, can become by the creation of grouping few hundred or thousand. militants, and imagine that the death agony of democracy is at hand. In this triumphalist sectarianism (now the pessimistic secatarianism of the SWP), almost a parody of the Third Period of the Comintern and the "infantile leftism"
by Lenin, leads to on many actual struggles in the workers' movement. Callaghan: his treachery led to 1979 revolt.
But errors have also been made by currents within the Labour Party. In the exuberance of the "Bennite"
for democracy and accountability in 1978-82, many tendencies drew up schemas for the wholesale "renovation" of the Labour Party, which all leaned excessively upon the "objective" dynamic of the left wing opposition and paid little attention to the subjective political weaknesses of the Bennites, or the specific contribution which Marxists were required to make to the fight.
In particular, most schemas failed to recognise the unique conjuncture which had rallied certain sections of
"left" and not-so-left union bureaucracy behind the unlikely and unaccustomed banner of inner-party democracy. They then failed to
detect the change in that conjuncture after 1982, and especially since the 1983 election, which has produced a predictable but dramatic weakening Labour conference. weak and confused as it Benn current — itself merely a "left" social democratic current - could strode without interruption from victory to victory against the right wing establishment in the unions and the Parliamentary Labour Party. For that reason, most recent version of the predicted "death agony of social democracy" was also mistaken.
Though it did not reprsent any definitive answer, Bennism clealy reflected a growing preoccupation of sections of the left wing of the labour movement with the problem of social democracy and its consistent betrayal of the independent interests of the working class. Its emergence as a more left-wing policies and inner-party democracy under the considerable new possibilities for the
The fact that some sections of the Trotskyist movement broke from well over a decade of ultra-leftism and sectarianism in seeking to relate to Mobilising Committee was a positive development. opportunism impressionism meant that the result was _ nor a healthy growth of Marxism fragmentation as various each sought to tailor their political line and practical activity to The present period Since Thatcher's 1979 victory, the ruthless employers' offensive (which had already begun to take shape under the Edwardes regime in BL) has set the scene for the class struggle in Britain — forcing to the surface the political weaknesses of the labour movement (not least and the shop stewards' which developed during the "boom" conditions of the 1950s and 1960s). The highest point of this offensive was the class confrontation of the Miners' Strike, followed now by the hell-for-leather reteat by neatly all wings of the labour bureaucracy.
So is this, now the period of the death agony of social democracy in
It is certainly a period of traumatic crisis for social democracy political and trade leaders. The Kinnock leadership has since 1983 had to repair the damage done to the Party's credibility by its crushing electoral defeat. That is no
But we must be clear that Kinnock has set out to achieve this objective not by abandoning but by reaffirming the political collaboration, machinery of the capitalist state, and seeking to reverse the democractic and political gains made by the left in
Egged on by the Euro-Stalinists of Stalinist witch-hunters of the LCC; and backed to the hilt by his sponsors - the 'new realist" majority of the groping his way towards a possible new accommodation with the SDP by the Labour Party to the political line it had when Owen, Williams, Rodgers et al. were in the
A basic component of this is to
The betrayal of the miners was no flash in the pan; the hounding of Liverpool is not simply becaue of the Militant connection: these are Kinnock's ritual sacrifices to bourgeois media in his trantic quest for acceptability to "public opinion"
The almost uninterrupted series of betrayals and defeats suffered by the trade union struggles in the period since 1979 has sapped one avenue of possible resistance to this line, and reinforced a drift towards passive electoralism among former elements of the Labour left. Kinnock's careerist bandwagon has lured on board many former prominent figures of the Bennite resistance, while sections of the Socialist Viewpoint No. 15 February 1987 p32
"hard left" (Socialist Action!) have been further divided over perspective during and since the Miners' Strike.
Kinnock's campaign to roll back the progress made by a radicalised rank and file in 1979-83 has not been without contradictions and problems. Nor indeed has it by any means wiped out a vital layer of working class militants (as the Miners' Strike confirmed) or a hard left layer within the Labour Party which will remain committed to class struggle politics, is ready to challenge capitalist legality, and at least questions some basic tenets of reformist orthodoxy (the "viability" argument in the Miners' Strike). Though this challenge has never itself broken from the framework of reformist politics, these class fighters are a crucial building block for the fight for conscious opposition to the Kinnock-Hattersley economic policy.
But this crisis can only develop to the point of the "death agony' social democracy under conditions where a coherent and conscious new left-wing leadership can be constructed. to enable a distinct class-struggle current to take shape and break from social democratic politics and methods. Problems with the "death agony" It vastly understates the strength of Kinnockism and of the trade union bureaucracy which spawned While it has become commonplace for Marxists to argue the organic link between the Labour Party and the trade unions generally in order to make a case for Marxists to be active in the Labour Party - we must remember that the link is a two way connection. Just as the Labour Party leans on the unions for resources and for bureaucratic block votes, so the unions need the Labour Party, to give political expression to the reformist politics Hence the decision even of the EETPU to re-establish that link through the (albeit limited) campaign for political levy ballots.
For many union leaders there is not even a contradiction between social democratic politics and a coalition with the capitalist parties of the Alliance. The task of drawing a clear class line on that issue, and rallying the working class to fight the inevitable attacks that would be mounted by a coalition government, will fall to the most militant minority of the rank and file and the hard left opposition to the union bureaucracy.
So long as the main union leaders are able to conduct their collaboration free from a seriou challenge from any organised har left with shop floor support, they will preserve the Labour Party in the way their forebears created it,
as a parliamentary vehicle for reformist politics.
While understating Kinnock's strength (even while Marxists face a growing threat of expulsions), the "death agony" analysis also tends to overstate the strength and political independence of "Bennism" and the demoralisation of the Labour Left it is not yet certain that by the next election the hard, class struggle left will politically stronger than was the left in 1974 when Wilson came to power women's rights and gay rights have established themselves on the left agenda).
Time dulls the memory of the bitter Labour's "left" battles in 1973, and steel a militant left wing in battles like the Pentonville 5, Cross, pay strikes by postal workers, builders and healthworkers, miners' strikes, and other bruising
Under Heath militancy remained very high, the level of shop various opportunist (Socialist Action, sectarian-opportunist (Socialist Organiser) tendencies of the left, in failing correctly to fight for the political and organisational development of the Bennite forces.
Of course Benn's left wing reputation can be traced to his involvement with these struggles. But his immediate role under Wilson was not to spearhead the working class opposition to wage controls, speed-up or the Tory anti-union laws, but to join the government. He became the figurehead for Wilson's collaborationist Industry Bill, and threatter remained a minister through four phases of wage control until the 1979 election.
In this way "Bennism" showed even at this early stage its acute political limitations as a left social democratic current, unable to offer a coherent working class policy to challenge Wilson/Callaghan.
When "Bennism" moved into opposition after 1979, it did so as part of a major upheaval involving not only the rank and file who had fought Wilson/Callaghan, but also sections of the bureaucracy who had only recently turned against them. Partly because of this, Bennism did little or nothing to organise a current within the Labour Party!. With the exception of Scargill's (unorganised) popular base of support in the NUM, Bennite politics have for this reason always found much stronger support in the conterences, campaigns and gatherings of activists such as Broad Lefts than on the shop floor.
This weakness has continued today. Advanced workers respect and
Labour
Hattersley: no innovation, logic of class collaboration support Benn and Scargill: but Benn and Scargill do nothing to organise any support within the unions. The
See patrol time ready bag,
economic strategy Kinnock-Hattersley.
Some even continue to cherish the illusion that Kinnock can somehow be "pressurised" adopting more radical policies — for instance on the reinstatement and amnesty for victimised and jailed miners. This kind offers instant fodder to the cynical pro-Stalinist forces of the LCC and others who would lure unwary leftists into the Kinnock camp. Even now the "Bennite" wing of the movement is shot through with these type of illusions, lacking any scientific grasp of the role of bureaucracy or of the politics of reformism.
As a "current". Bennism can have Socialist Viewpoint No. 15 February 1987 p33 just the old no viable existence outside OI separate from the Labour Party. It depends for its support upon the CLPs, and other structures of social democracy: lacking any real alternative programme, it can only survive or appear as a coherent opposiwithin the social democratic milieu.
Its demands may be more radical, from Parliamentarism, upon which it is wholly dependent in its schemas for "socialist policies". Bennism is not revolutionary or even centrist in character. Cut off from the routines and structures of the Labour Party, it followers drawn backwards into the camp of Kinnock-Hattersley social democracy, and a comparative hand ful making the break towards Marxist perspectives and programme.
SKINNER'S VIEW
Potential within the "Bennite This is by no means to belittle or ignore the potential for development contained within the Bennite current. Under this extremely wide and loose heading can be grouped nearly all of the most class conscious activists in today's labour movement.
But we reject any notion that this potential strength can or will simply and of itself crystallise spontaneously into a more organised, coherent current or tendency. we recognise the largely role being played by the sectarian (SWP), propagandist (Militant) and various opportunist (Socialist Action, tendencies of the left, in failing correctly to fight for the political and organisational development of Bennite forces.
We face the task of fighting to correct this historic weakness, sectarian abstention and develop a healthy practical orientation which SAID to be still the best "turn" on the Labour circuit, DENNIS SKINNER MP was in the Yorkshire coalfield recently. Socialist Viewpoint was there to report on the main points of what he had to say. THE "beast of Bolsover" began talking about the triggered by vicious sacking of the 300 artificial limbmakers by BTR:
"These are people who should be the last in the queue for sackings. Tory-MP Peter Temple Morris is paid £5,000 by BTR subsiduary J.E. Hanger in addition to his £18,000 MP's salary. He has four jobs, and
Cecil Parkinson has ten directorships. There are 250 MPs with directorships -
The government says they can't intervene in J.E. Hangers dispute, just like every day, arrested their wives, their famlies - but they weren't interven-
So they can't intervene in Hangers, and
5,000 patients are prevented from receiving their artificial limbs. Just imagine if the union had callled them out on strike.
wouldn't have been Myra Hindley on the front page of the Sun, but those men and women, scum of the earth, that had prevented all these poor disabled people from getting their artifical limsb
It would have been on every BBC proenables us to fight alongside the best Labour Party and the unions.
The key to future development must in our view be the adoption of tactics and a strategy to mobilise the broadest possible layers of Bennites to fight now and under a Labour government on class issues (defence of jobs, wages, no hand-outs to big demands for new jobs, internationalism, etc.), on democratic racism, for women's and lesbian and gay libration, etc.) and on transitional demands geared to the certain economic crisis that would tollow the return of a Labour (or a Coalition)
The experience of such struggles can deepen the understanding of the olitical nature of social democracy
Class struggle and begin to establish workers' control demands through
FIRE EXIT costa then. We would have said the t Tebbit
We would have said the the TUC
'Stand up for these people! and Willis would have stood up and run away, like he did in the miners' strike!
Isn't it sad? So much action, but when it reaches the top of our movement these people are in retreat. You can't find them eading, and you could never have a betSocialist Viewpoint No. 15 February 1987 p34 which the labour movement can find alternative to reformist capitulation in the face of capitalist and struggles must be taken into the ranks of the trade union movement, breaking out of the stifling narrow routine of much Labour Party work, and fighting to workplace exploitation into the more parliamentary arena of the wards, CLPs and circles
In this way the task of Marxists is seen clearly as one of finding ways to challenge and (through serious mass immediate issues) break down the political limitations programme for action, designed to connect at every level with the needs of working class, must be developed, and fought for in practice through very possible avenue in the unions he Labour Party and in the variou campaigns of the oppressed and the ter chance than during the miners' strike: 12 months out. That means every union in Britain had a pay claim in during that
Mrs Thatcher couldn't handle more than one dispute during the miners
You're bound to come to the conclusion that some people were engaged in a conspiracy. We had a great chance. We don't need academics from the woodwork telling us why we lost the strike, these people who never went anywhere near Orgreave, who probably think it's an Australian footremember those glorious moments when the dockers were out; all it needed was for a pay claim to be put in to bring those out at Dover and Felixstowe. It just needed someone in the T&G to say
'We'll get them out. We'll put a pay claim in! The deputies had it there, with a ballot wonder when we'll peerages and knighthoods.
We don't need academics to tell us why we lost - we lost because there were people in the trade union didn't deliver when they had the chance.
You don't need a 300 page book to tell you
Those of us who were brought up in the crude conflict of battle and struggle know the signs of defeat. It was written over the face of Norman Willis as he waddled out of
Transport House.
But I'm not one of those people who believe it was all downhill. I believe a lot of things came out of that strike that were valuable. It destablised Mrs Thatcher.
cost £8 billion. She's now down to borrowing money on a grand scale. In September
1985 she borrowed $2.5 billion the largest sum ever borrowed by Britain at one go.