Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The 9-month fight they couldn't kill!

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 14, November 1986 · pp 4-6 · 2,871 words

Trade unions Britain Stalinism

-The politics of thei

you By BILL PETERS

4001

SOLIDAR

CIAACOUNCIL

Perhaps the first attempt at an objective and coherent political analysis of the miners strike and its lessons for the workers' movement. 44 pages, 80p, including postage, from Socialist Viewpoint, BCM Box 3956. London WCIN 3XX.

featured in the media. Scenes from Wapping or Kinning Park rarely appear on the television in the way the miners strike did. The other papers have a vested interest in keeping it quiet and in seeing Murdoch win... they will then be in a strong position to impose similar terms and conditions on their workers.

The printers, now out for nine months, are largely determined to win this dispute. They lack the rank and file leadership up till now to force the arguments into Fleet Street. The way to win is clear... Fleet Street out. Sloganising about it is easy. Giving the support, both practical and political, to the printworkers who are arguing for it has proved harder. All SOGAT, NGA and NUJ members who are still handing News International titles must be picketed. And a strategy must be drawn up for mass picketing the other papers in order to stop them publishing.

The endless sectarianism or total apathy of the left has meant that the strongest of the printers have been left with little support. That has to change now.

Support revitalised mobilising their areas

groups need to be

to take a lead in the labour movement in to get down to the pickets

and physically support the printers. They should set up public meetings and have the printers who are arguing for Fleet Street out speaking, not the "Wapping personalities" like Hicks and Freeman who have been at the front of stopping any kind of discussion on spreading the strike.

A support group structure should be reformed bringing support groups in Regions together. But it needs to be a structure which is accountable and not a sectarian group which preaches about the way forward without mobilising for it and which patronises the strikers.

Nine months on strike changes people. The tactics for winning - the boycott, the weekly demos, the flying squads — advanced at the beginning by the bureaucrats, and supported by the Communist Party, have failed. There is nothing wrong with them as tactics for supplementing supporting strike action. But they are not in themselves separately or together capable of winning this dispute. That was difficult to argue at the beginning with about 90 per cent of the printers. Nine months in struggle has changed some of them and the arguments need to be put now, put strongly, acted on and maybe the trade union movement will see a victory instead of a defeat.

he 9-month fight

they couldn't kill !

THERE was no real debate about the News International dispute at the TUC. Everything was geared to play it down.

Like the 1984 TUC conference which was debating support for the miners, a resolution was put which could get maximum backing but had no teeth to it and called basically for the TUC affiliates to do nothing.

The state of the dispute was summed up when Michael Hicks, leading member of the Communist Campaign Group came out of the conference with his ever present megaphone - which he needs like Linus needs his security blanket and announced the TUC had just given fantastic backing to the printers.

There were cheers and clapping. In the crowd was a print worker who has been fighting since the beginning for Fleet Street to come out, for effective picketing, and against the tactics of Dean - which Hicks and the CCG promote, He just stood there head down, arms folded and shook his head.

He knew that the TUC vote ment

absolutely nothing and far from backing the printers the TUC, Kinnock, Dean, Dubbins and Willis want to wash their hands of this dispute, negotiate it away.

The role of the leadership of the NGA and SOGAT has been crucial from the beginning. Brenda Dean is clearly (and justifiably) hated by many of the print workers.

She is the villain of the piece. Because she is a woman leading a very male dominated union the slurs and criticisms of her politics degenerate into attacks on her because she is a woman ( and by implication clearly not up to leading a strike). Her role from the start has been to try to negotiate. Her most terrified thoughts were that a strike with similar tactics and strengths of the miners might materialise and she has done everything possible to stop that.

She has deliberately defused any attempts by other sections to get involved in the picketing and has personally phoned up NUM leadership figures to ensure that no official NUM presence has been on the Wedensday and Saturday pickets on a regular basis.

Dubbins on the other hand gets rapturous applause and standing ovations

from the printers. The Dean and Dubbins double act are a bit like classic police officers' methods during interogation. One is hated and the other gains your confidence under pressure so you trust him. Dubbins is now the "one who is okay" '. He has done nothing to further this dispute and has been just as much of a traitor to the worker as Dean but becasuse she is so awful he seems better.

Whatever happens in this dispute the print unions will never be the same again. The crucial question in the trade union movement which comes out in any strike or struggle is the question of leadership. Nowhere has it been more apparent than in the printworkers struggle.

It was clear from the beginning of the strike that the SOGAT NGA leaders did not want a fight and would block any attempt to get effective action. The fact that not even all SOGAT and NGA members handling Murdoch titles were called out was a clear indication of the lack of will to spread the strike at all.

The fact that many SOGAT members were working on News International titles and that Fleet Street was working normal; made it virtually to get any response frc= TGWU l members driving the scar

Socialist Viewpoint No. 14 November-December 1986 p4

OGATI

82

HEVISERS ВЕЛА

PHOTO: Andrew Viard (Report)

THE SUN

NEWS "Te WORLDL

Logg

ESTEREO CHAPEL /

Iwo days after the ballot result: printworkers and supporters march through Wapping. The fight goes on!

lorries, though this does not excuse Todd and the TGWU from their role.

Because of the very bureaucratic and federated style of the print chapels and branches there was very little organised unity between the different strikers even within the same union. It was three weeks into the dispute before there was a joint union committee meeting to discuss the dispute. Workers were turning up for Saturday night pickets with no plan, no organisation, and no idea of how to achieve the stopping of Wapping.

The Stalinists meanwhile were acting quickly to ensure that they kept a tight grip through the bureaucracy on the picketing and stewarding of the marches. From day one of this strike the CP and the Communist Campaign Group were determined to be in control. They have had a very strong presence in the print unions for many years now. The CP split had just taken place and there was disunity amongst the Stalinists, which left a slight chink in their armour but not enough to allow a strong challenge from non- Stalinist strikers.

Anyone attempting to intervene in the strike who was known to be hostile to the CP was attacked. Support group members from Tower Hamlets were threatened by Communist Campaign Group members both at meetings and on the picket.

Printers who were critical of the organisation of the strike and particularly the role of the CCG and CP were physically threatened. Most important of all was the need of the CP to ensure that the question of bringing the rest of the Fleet Street workers out was never raised in chapel meetings or mass meetings and that sacked NI workers who did raise it were discredited and shut up.

They were the first to adopt the pathetic excuse that any Fleet Street strike would increase Murdoch's circulation because

his would be the only papers on the stands.

The print chapels, although very good at winning economic demands for their workers, have not developed many political perspectives within the unions. The leaders, FOCs and MOCs, had negotiated through strength excellent working conditions which were now threatened by Murdoch. But the bulk of the sacked members were not well equipped enough to argue effectively against the Stalinists and against the stactic of the boycott campaign.

Gradually more and more of them, however, were looking for a method of raising the issue of bringing out Fleet Street, and a small but strong group of printers have been at the fore of trying to gain control of the aspects of the strike from the very powerful and mafia-like CP.

The Fleet Street Support Unit, consisting mainly of printers, was set up about three to four months into the dispute. It is an attempt to loosely organise those printers who are trying to spread the dispute to the rest of Fleet Street.

The Fleet Street Support Unit is now organising leafletting and lobbying outside the other papers. The Observer with 550 NGA members with redundancy notices was the first target. Organising the left in unions with structures like the print unions is an extremely difficult job — but it has begun.

The Stalinists on the other hand can be seen at Wapping every Wednesday and Saturday leading the marches away from any real confrontation; announcing on their megaphones that they must be peaceful and orderly; winding the police up, and then leaving so others get the brunt of the police violence.

Not long ago one of the marches was proceeding down Commercial Road, the main road that the lorries and scab coaches take once they leave the Highway.

November December

A scab coach came towards the march. People surrounded it. There were not enough police to control the situation so the CCG stepped in and regrouped the march to go down a side road away from the scabs and the lorries! They were literally doing the police's job for them.

The wonder of Wapping is not that the marches are small now but that people continue to come week after week despite such demoralising tactics.

Living in Tower Hamlets where the plant is situated, the strike is part of everyday life. Every time you go to work you see the scabs and the lorries. The coaches are parked outside the tube, picking up and dropping off their filth.

The roads are blocked off at least twice a week. If you refuse to show identification you don't get home. Police on horses in riot gear ride through working class housing estates on their way to and from the plant.

The plant itself dominates the landscape throughout much of Wapping and every time we look at it the anger rises. The Tower Hamlets Support Group has been active since day one of this dispute.

Is evolution is probably a miniature of what has happened with this dispute throughout the rest of London. The first meetings were packed with 60 to 70 people from all political groups and trade unions. It was a new and exciting dispute on our doorstep.

The first meetings got little practical support work organised, as everyone was keen to make a speech about how they saw the dispute being run and won. The sacked printers who attended (and who are still with us) must have wondered what they had walked into.

Now, nine months later, the support group is a core of 6 to 10 activists and the printers. The polemic has stopped and so has the influence of almost every other

political group general feeling dispute is going so why bother?

The left press still write about it every week and the papers sellers are on the picket — but only to sell their papers and not really to give any practical support and solidarity to the sacked workers.

The left generally seems to have learned little from the miners' strike. It cannot get itself together to support workers in struggle unless they are clearly onto a winner.

The most militant and political of the printers know that this stirke will be sold out. But they are still in there fighting, picketing and marching — and where its the trade union and labour movement support from the rest of London? Sitting at home or at a newer picket somewhere with more prospect of winning.

Supporting the printers has always been different from supporting the miners. London's labour movement raised thousands of pounds for the miners. People were travelling to and from the coal fields.

But this strike is different. A mass industrial struggle in the heart of London. Supporting it was never about organising collections of food and money. It was much harder. It is about getting other workers who are low paid and work in terrible conditions to listen to what the well paid printers are saying about losing their jobs. It was about a continual presence outside the Wapping plant every week for eight months. Not just one or two romanticised trips to a striking pit village every week.

It is about going down to Wapping and being infuriated by the sexism. racism and anti-gay sentiments of

in the borough. The

seems to be that the to be sold out anyway —

Mattson/Frame

many of the workers you are there to support and having to confront that all the time. It is about constantly talking with the workers (and not just the rest of the left) about the need to get Fleet Street out...

It is a dispute right here on our doorstep and it is being ignored. The May local elections took a lot of people away to canvass and to work in their boroughs. Many of those never came back.

Possibly living in Tower Hamlets we get more involved in the emotions of the dispute than others. There are scores of printers who we recognise now and they recognise us. We don't know their names or anything about them except that they are there every week on the marches and outside the plant. They are comrades in a fight which daily gets harder to win.

The women in this dispute have been incredible. Some of the strongest and sharpest of the strikers are the women clerical workes - in marked contrast to Brenda Dean. Always at the bottom end in terms of the union's organisation but at the top in terms of the strike. They have been excluded from having any organised say as women in this strike by the bureaucrats.

Even the women's demonstrations have been fronts. The last women's demonstration in July was tightly controlled by the officials to ensure that none of the anger of the thousands of women on it could be effectively expressed.

It was the first demonstration to be held after the high court injunction banning the right of the marchers to proceed down the Highway. The atmosphere was lively and good. Unlike the usual marches, there was loud singing and chanting. Many of us were glad that the timing had coincided with the women's march, feeling that

Viewpoint

November-December

women would be less controlled than the men.

But as the march got to the plant the leaders of it (Stalinists) halted it 150 yards away from the police and made no attempt to insist on our right to proceed down the road.

The rally which should have taken place a half mile away started exactly where the police told the chief stewards to stop. Women had been betrayed. To add insult to injury we were supposed to stand there and listen to Brenda Dean tell us all about the "fight for our people"

Marching through the streets of London on a day time march with the printers in July when the sun was shining and the atmosphere was strong and solid was a moving experience.

As we walked past the Times building in Grays Inn Road scabs had put copies of the Times and Sun in the windows. One woman — who has been on every march, always with her placard and a strong voice — stood there. She was not going to move until the papers were taken down. The whole march came together and determined not to move.

The police went into the building and removed the papers from the windows. The woman was jubilant. It was a small victory. A tiny victory. But for people who are fighting with everything they have against the might of Murdoch, the Metropolitan Police, Thatcher and her thugs, the cusioned union leaders and the right-moving Labour party and TUC, it was a significant victory.

That woman is what struggle is about. She will not give in even if she is beaten to the ground. She will get up and fight again. The left has a lot to learn from women like her.

likely

← Ballot result hardens attitudes · Is Kinnock promising a rose-garden? →

Something wrong on this page?