Musical chairs?
IN AN ATTEMPT to stamp out any opposition at all to his Leadership. Neil Kinnock has manoeuvred to get himself elected as Chair of the Party for the coming year.
This unprecedented step of being Leader and Chair has been taken in order to stop the presumably terrifyi: situation of Dennis Skinner chairing the Party in election year.
What Kinnock doesn't seem to realise is that unless he changes the rules entirely. Skinner will become Chair in the first year of a Labour government - possibly even more a threat to Uncle Neil.
Women
SEVERAL of the "women's debates" Conference appeared to concern themselves with the ins and outs of bureaucratic change, ignoring wider struggles women are involved in. In fact, the debates around women's representation in the Party and the proposed "Ministry for Women" were very much arguments about power.
The overturning of the NEC in the "Ministry for Women" debate showed that delegates were keen for the nex! Labour Government to take seriously its commitments on equal pay, women's rights to control their own fertility, improved child care, and so on.
When Labour Briefing Women fought hard to maintain a principled position in the women's representation in the Labour Party debates, they were denounced as "loony lefties" by the leaders of the Women's Action Committee (WAC), who wanted to hand the Women's Conference over to unaccountable trade union block votes as well.
tactical ineptness and alienated their defenders even further by refusing to address conference — on the pretext that they were only allowed 5 minutes each without the television cameras. This only went to support the right wing claim that the far left are only out for publicity. Only 300,000 votes (including those of FTAT and the
cast for their FBU) were reinstatement.
The tactics of those who argued that Amir Khan and Kevin Scally could reinstatement by distancing themselves from Militant fared no better. The band-wagon behind the witch-hunt, combined with the desire not to rock the boat of "NEC recommendations" , Is moving so tast that conterence rejecied their reinstatement by 4.4 million to 3.7 million. Even if the promised "review" of their case should reinstate them, conference could not be seen to openly support opponents of Hattersley.
In the NEC elections, the hard left clearly lost out with the defeat of Eric Heffer. Targeted by the right and the soft left LCC for years, attacked for walking off the platform in disgust during Kinnock's speech last year, and finally threatened by his sponsoring union UCATT in the week before conference with withdrawal of support for defending Militant and opposing Kinnock, Heffer was as much a victim of the witch-hunt as Militant itself.
Those "hard left" (Campaign Group of MPs, Socialist Action, Socialist Organiser and the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy) who supported Tam Dalyell rather than the second Black
Narendra
candidate, Sections Makanji, got their answer at the first meeting of the newly-elected NEC on the Wednesday. Dalyell's first vote was to side with the right to vote in Kinnock as Party vice chair against Dennis Skinner.
Where there seemed a chance of
bureaucracy controversy, cyncially attempted to incorporate and defuse issues. Thus, on the first (Sunday) evening although the NEC recommendation was nominally to reject the demand that a future Ministry for Women be given full cabinet status, this was moved without enthusiasm and rejected. Although this was a victory for the left and women's rights, those who campaigned for this are fully aware that even should Kinnock as Prime
Minister agree to this the fight would continue to ensure that crucial issues (health facilities, equal pay, abortion
rights, etc) are not buried in the
general "austerity programme" as
happened under the "Socialist"
government in France. It would also
require that the Parliamentary
Labour Party elect at least one
woman to the Cabinet, a major step
forward from the present gang of
white middle class men.
November-December
Last year, despite opposition from the platform, the resolution on Lesbian and Gay rights won a simple majority at the first time of being discussed at conference. Given the stage management and sharpness of the right wing, it is hard not to be cynical about the unanimous (!) decision of the NEC to recommend support at this year's conference, which left it up to the EETPU and AUEW delegations, together with some hard right constituencies to uphold the traditional backward line and vote against.
The resolution got 79 per cent of votes cast, ensuring it should go into the manifesto. However, the amount of work still to be done in the movement is shown by the refusal of Labour-controlled Nottinghamshire County and Glasgow District Councils to implement a basic equal opportunities policy.
Another attempt to defuse an issue produced probably the biggest ruckus in conference itself. It has been a long-standing demand of women in the Party that the national women's conference hold its own Rules Conference - something that has been denied it by the bureaucracy.
This year the Women's Action Committee supported a resolution which would allow NEC involvement in the restructuring of conference. The only revolt against the "fixing" of debate by the chair was organised by Briefing women, which resulted in women gathering round the rostrum to demand the suspension Standing Orders in order to let their opposition be heard.
To win such a suspension of Standing Orders after the NEC spokesperson has summed up on a debate is unheard of, but they managed it, egged on by the patronising remarks of the chair. The resolution was passed, but the argument against was heard, and the criticism received by the Briefing women is all the more surprising when one of the present tasks of the left is to defend the LPYS against precisely such interference in its rules.
On nuclear power, the anti-
nuclear composite got 66.28 per cent of the vote, just short of the two-thirds necessary to become manifesto policy. But, assisted by a noisy lobby of BNFL workers outside the enference, the NEC's • fudging statement was also passed, giving Kinnock a free hand.
re-affirmed its
Conference
unilateralist position on nuclear arms, together with a demand for a real campaign (passed before, but where has the campaign been?), but
resolutions calling for withdrawal from NATO and closing down US
bases were heavily defeated.
In a cleverly stage-managed
production, other controversial
Social Ownership
"SOCIAL OWNERSHIP" has become the polite, "red rose" term for nationalisation. The composite carried at Conference did not demand the return of privatised industries to the public sector. The composite demanding renationalisation was only given half-hearted support by sections of the Left (such as Labour Left Liaison) because it called for renationalisation to be carried out "without compensation". The policy backtracking by Kinnock is as strong in the economic field as elsewhere.
Ireland
THE BRIEF IRELAND debate was focussed on a strong composite motior from ten constituencies which condemned the Anglo-Irish Accord; supported self-determination and a United Ireland; and demanded British withdrawal "as an urgent priority'. Richard Stanton, the Brighton delegate who moved the composite, recognised the importance of tackling the nature of imperialism and believed this to be one of the ways to challenge the Party leadership.
debates were whittled down in time or
called for times when no TV cameras
were running.
Ireland and Black Sections barely
got a look-in. Militant prostrated
themselves in front of the witch-
hunters and disgusted many of their
defenders when Frances Curran
(LPYS rep on the NEC) volunteered
to sum up against Black Sections on
behalf of the NEC. There is nothing
the right like more than to see two of
their most hated opponents fighting it
out.
The debate on troops out of
Ireland, taken after all, was so brief
and so heavily stage-managed you'd
be pushed to notice it happened.
Current industrial disputes and the legacy of past ones never reached
conference floor. Despite a lobby by
News International print workers, the
motion from their unions was simply on restricting foreign ownership of the media - as if the nationality of the press barons made the slightest difference to the redundancies hitting the industry.
Durham Miners (at present engaged in a series of one-day strikes) lobbied in support of their jailed and victimised comrades, but the NUM chose not to put a resolution on the issue - on the spurious grounds that it had been won last year and they didn't want it to be defeated. Kinnock of course said last year he would not reimburse the NUM. The issue should have been put to conference and the movement not allowed to forget the miners' strike.
Opposition to state interference in Union rule books came in a motion from TASS, who then agreed, on the advice of the NEC, to remit, missing an important opportunity of identifying the size of the opposition. A similar manoeuvre saw COHSE and NUPE conspire to withdraw a motion on democratisation of the NHS.
The debate on the economy never got off the ground. Speaker after speaker rallied behind the NEC's proposals, with the one resolution calling for re-nationalisation buried under a sea of red roses. It was obvious that beyond a few knee-jerk responses the left has not even started a serious discussion of alternatives to the rubbish that is coming out of Hattersley's word processor.
If the class struggle and serious debate on left alternatives to Kinnock were kept out of conference, they were certainly not missing around the fringe.
The Campaign Group, Labour Herald and Labour Briefing all held large rallies at which speakers more OI less clearly differentiated themselves from Kinnock's programme. The class struggle refused to go away, with the persistant pesence of the strikers from Silentn ght (who also picketted
THE VOTE to expel supporters of Militant (5½ million for, - 325,000 against) was even worse in terms of constituency support than it first looks. The FBU and FTAT both voted against the expulsions - which means that Constituency Parties voted 2-1 in favour of kicking out Militant.
Bearing this, and the overwhelming support for the Kinnock-Hattersley leadership, in mind, the campaign to
Blackpool Co-op) (Spam) in the USA.
The National
Justice for Mineworkers held
packed, enthusiastic lunch-time meeting after which it was clear to all that not only was the issue not going to go away, but also that the role of the labour movement's "leaders" in the strike had not been forgotten.
Hormel
LIKE most delegates, we were pleased to see LCC break from the habit of a lifetime and invite a worker in struggle onto their platform. Could this by any chance have anything to do with the fact that the striker, from JE Hangers, is on strike in Peter Hain's Putney constituency?
Black Sections held one of the most inspriring meetings with speakers from a whole range of struggles, making it clear that the fight is not simply about constitutional change but the labour movement being forced to recognise the particular oppression of black people and take up their demands.
Tommy Carroll, Sinn Fein
Councillor, gave and received greetings from more fringe meetings than some thought humanly posible. The attempt by Stuart Bell, the front bench spokesperson on Northern
Viewpoint
November-December
!Labour
reinstate Kevin Scally and Amir Khan from Birmingham did well to secure major union support, including that of the TGWU.
The urgent need now is to organise broad-based campaigning against the expulsions through Labour Against the Witch-hunt '86. LAW "86 is organising a conference in November, and can be contacted at 39 Talia House, Manchester Road, London E14 9HB.
Ireland, to condemn violence and oppose Troops Out at the debate organised by the Labour Committee on Ireland fell flat when faced with the arguments of Carroll and Bernadette McAlliskey. He did himself no favours in denouncing sectarian violence by reading out the names of 10 people murdered; Ken Livingstone in the chair promptly pointed out that nine of the ten were Catholics!
Emerging from the conference was a new sharper level of debate about how the left should relate to the fact
that the "new realist" right has clearly
managed, under Kinnock's leadership, to reverse most of the gains made since 1979.
Nigel Williamson (editor of Tribune) and Ken Livingstone bemoaned the fact that their project — the "realignment of the left" — has failed. Having argued for the last two years that the left had to build bridges to Kinnock to keep him out of the clutches of the right, they now recognise, belatedly and in a confused way, that Kinnock is very much the leader of the right.
Having led retreats and sell-outs and given Kinnock all possible assistance in the marginalisation of any serious left opposition, they now find themselves out in the cold. Redundant to the requirements of the
Labour Party
Black Sections