Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Miners are back in action for jobs!

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 14, November 1986 · pp 13-15 · 2,690 words

Miners Trade unions Scotland Wales

Miners are back

in action for jobs!

By BILL PETERS

The decision of the Scottish Area Executive of the NUM to support the loss of almost 2,000 jobs in the Scottish coal field is the worst decision taken in the coal mining industry since before the year long strike.

In the course of one week last month they supported:

*the loss of hundreds of jobs through voluntary redundancies at Killock and Barony in Ayrshire;

*the closure of Comrie coliery in with the loss of 480 jobs;

*and the link-up of Bilston Glen and Monktonhall in Lothian with the loss of 900 jobs.

The decisions have reduced the labour force in the Scottish coal field to less than 5,000 and the number of pits to nine.

Commenting on the decision to support the closures, George Bolton, national chair of the Communist Party, and Vice President of the Scottish NUM, said that the closures were taking place because:

"'The Coal Board are trying to rationalise the industry to meet the current situation."

He went on to stress the "positive side"

o H9n°,2000 "The positive side of the picture was

of the decision:

that f20m was being invested in Monktonhall and that deep mining was being retained in Ayrshire... There are also good prospects for future developments at Musselburgh, Happenendon and Canonbie."

A few days later Bolton was stressing the point again:

"In the short term thère are job losses, but in the long term there is a very good prospect for Bilston Glen and Monkton Hall. It's a step backwards to take a step forwards."

Scottish Area NUM Secretary Bric Clarke said:

"We are recommedning acceptance of the proposals for Bilston Glenn and Monktonhall because the alternative was the complete closure of Monkton Hall and the loss of all reserves in the Musselbough basin."

He went on to say:

"We are reluctantly accepting term expediency for long development."

These statements are utterly cynical, since the track record of the NCB is that they will follow up every unresisted closure with more closures. Before long they will be questioning the viability of what is left of the Scottish coalfield.

The Scottish decision has compounded the difficult problem of defending jobs in

short-

term

FREE

TERRY

JUSTICE

FRENCH *TERRY FRENCHI

FOR

MMERS STAND ALONE STRIKING MINERS

MLL NOT

MACCAR AND SON NEST

STAND ALONE

* YESEN

Terry French's candidacy for NUM Vice President highlights issue of victimised miners.

the rest of the coal industry, yet the Scottish Area bureaucrats are completely unrepentant in their right wing stand. At the last meeting of the Justice for Mineworkers Campaign held in Bolton Lancashire, they proudly announced that they were defending the victimised miners and that they had been to Balmoral to petition the Queen on their behalf!

Any illusions which may have existed that the departure of MacGregor and his replacement by Haslam have been quickly dispelled. In fact the pit closure programme had been speeded up, and the hard line in the pits maintained. The

Viewpoint

November-December

national membership of the NUM is down to below 100,000 from almost 200,000 at the beginning of the strike. Over 30,000 of these are due to pit closures and redundancies.

The strength behind Scargill's speech at the NUM conference, where he reminded the union that ultimately industrial action is the only way to defend jobs can now be clearly seen. Yet Scargill remains under pressure from within the NUM, particularly from Area leaderships like Scotland and South Wales, and the Communist Party is organising against

PHOTO:

PHOTO: Stefano Cagnoni (Report)

him along with the right wing. There have been rumblings from McGahey and others who want to do a deal with the UDM. Within the trade union movement as a whole, Scargill's class struggle approach is under ever greater attack.

Last week the South Wales Area decided not to oppose the closure of Nantgarw colliery near Cardiff, and Cwm colliery near Pontypridd, with a loss of up to 1,300 jobs. At a meeting at the pits only

miners voted to use the review procedure and resist the closure. It this is contrasted with the determined attempt to prevent the closure of Lewis Merthyr in 1983, the dramatic change in the situation can be seen. The South Wales coalfield is now down to 14 pits, from 28 before the strike, with a loss of 8,000 jobs.

South Wales NUM Area President Des Dutfield said in the Morning Star that he would not recommend fighting the closure through the review procedure since wouldn't want to raise hopes by using this procedure, which is a farce.

It is true that the defence of jobs under the current conditions is difficult and it is also true that the current tactic of the NCB in juggling with redundancy payments have made it even more difficult. The present redundancy scheme ends in April and long service miners could lose in excess of £20,000 it they are made redundant after April rather than before. Intended redundancy would need to be known by December 1986 for the three month rule to be valid. At the present time the miners receive !1,000 per year's servie in redudancy payments. Now, those not notified for redundancy by December will only receive money under the new scheme; those under 21 years service would receive £250 per year, 21 to 30 years of age £450 and 30 to 50 year olds £700 for every year's service.

To put a pit in the review procedure now would take the closure date beyond April, and up to now every pit which has gone into the procedure, with the exception of Darfield Main in Yorkshire, has been closed in the end - including pis like Bates where the review procedure was

Even the militant Kent coalfield have conceded the closure of Tilmanstone under those conditions. A meeting of the 475 miners there voted not to use the review procedure but to accept the closure.

all this is taking place under conditions where there is a revival of militancy amongst the rank and file of the NUM, expressed most clearly in the 2 to 1 ballot decision of the Durham Mechanics to begin a series of one day strikes at selected pits each week.

The Mechanics were balloted for strike action on four issues:

1) to reinstate Geoff Hartnell (a Durham Mechanic sacked two months after the end of the strike) and all the sacked miners;

2) to force the Coal Board to pay back the money stolen from the miners;

3)to restore the conciliation machinery in the industry;

4)to stop Colliery.

Following this decision, a ballot of Durham NUM members voted by a 66 per

majority to ban all mid-week overtime.

The first of the one-day strikes was held on September 22 at Murton coliery and was a resounding success. In a remarkable

display of solidarity, the only people to

cross the Mechanics picket line were a

handful of deputies, and two members of

the UDM. 18 of the 20 UDM the pit respected the picket, NUM members.

Dave Temple, delegate for Murton Mechanics described the radicalising effects of the strike in an article in Workers Press:

'Two mini-bus loads of police were qucikly rushed to the scene but in the absence of the huge numbers they were accustomed to, they were forced to take the taunts and jibes of the pickets and could only passively appeal for 'common sense to prevail.

The atmosphere was further electrified as wives, girlfriends and well-wishers joined the men on the gate and stayed talking till the small hours of Monday morning.

One mechanic summed up his feelings when he said: 'I am two years younger than when I turned out tonight'

As Monday progressed, the pubs and clubs of Murton filled with high-spirited miners discusing old times and future action.

Not a defeatist soul to be seen.

members at with all the

The second strike took place on Tuesday of last week, this time Westoe colliery was the target, where seven NUM members have been sacked since the end of the year long strike. Only recently the pit was brought to a standstill when miners refused to cross a picket line put up by the sacked men.

In last week's strike the action was again absolutely solid. There was never a question of the NUM members going in but there are 130 UDM members at the pit and they had been urged by the scab union to cross the Mechanics picket line. In the event only a dozen went in, and the pit came to a standstill.

The third took place at Wearmouth pit on Monday October 21. Production was at a standstill and only UDM members and some NACODS went in.

This overtime ban linked to the one day strikes has shaken the Board and may have been a factor in the decision of Haslam to offer to pay the back pay in an attempt to buy the dispute off on that one point. If this is the case the lesson of this is to build on this success by maintaining and stepping up the action locussing on the other three demands.

Successful action of this sort demonstrates that a fightback can be organised even at this stage in the coal industry. It creates new conditions to fight for the reinstatement of all the sacked men and to defend the industry. The pay issue is important as well. The wage offer, for

example, includes a clause on pensions under which a strike of more than a week would effect future pension rights.

At the same time the 1986-7 pay round is due to begin next month. That is expected to include the so-called "Doncaster Option". There has been little information on this coming from the NUM but it is expected to include a non-negotiable pension scheme and a new bonus set-up which is seen by many militants as an attempt to divide production workers from the rest of the workforce. Under this face men would be paid on "target achieved". the rest would be paid on a "tonnage achieved". . The scheme doesn't pay out unless the tonnage achieved is more than the colliery break-even point.

All this raises the matter of a coherent strategy to be fought for across the industry by NUM militants and the construction of a broad-based rank and file movement which to organise around such a strategy, however, remains an unresolved problem.

Not that there is a shortage of those presenting themelves as a national rank and file movement of miners: the most recent of these is a "National Miners' Broad Left" , which held its first meeting in Barnsley on September 21. Although organised along sectarian lines by Militant it attracted 120 miners from right across the British mining industry.

The main debate at the meeting showed the need for a discussion on a strategy for the miners to meet the present conditions. It recognised the gradual re-emergence of combativity amongst rank and file miners since the end of the strike, and the need for a clear direction if it is going to be developed further. The problem was how to go about it. In fact the meeting could hardly have been more confusing.

The strategy advanced by Militant was to call for the extension of the overtime ban which has been in operation in South Wales for the past two months — which is a ban on production overtime - into a national action in its present form. They argued that this would further develop militancy in the pits since the present ban in South Wales was costing the NCB large sums of money and this could be repeated in other areas.

The main debate therefore was between this proposal and a call by other miners from the SWP, the WRP and Socialist

Viewpoint for a full overtime ban covering

production and non-production overtime (although the SWP didn't want a national overtime ban to be called by the national union but to extended from area to area. Militant argued that this would be going too far tor fast, and that miners were only ready for minimal action. The

Militant policy prevailed with a motion calling for a complete ban being defeated.

The platform of the meeting resisted a

proposal calling for the extension of the

Durham Mechanics selective strike action into other NUM areas, and it wa not until a

delegation from Durham arrived at the

meeting - late because they had been

organising a strike for Monday morning —

that emergency resolution was

accepted by the platform. The resolution

was then carried despite

recommendation from the platform to vote

against.

The meeting went on to pass a resolution calling for the defence of pits, but it did not address itself to the very difficult

question of how to defend the threatened pits and how to deal with the April

redundancy pay deadline; what do you say to a miner who says that he will lose

November-December

PHOTO: John Harris (IFL)

PHOTO:

£20,000 if the closure of the pit is resisted and he ends up losing his job anyway? Unless that question can be answered there is little chance of resisting the present round of closures since the miners themselevs will demand that the closures are accepted. In some pits which are faced with possible closure but where no closure has yet been announced there are miners pressing the NUM to negotiate closure in order to meet the April deadline; what is to be said to them which will give them a real alternative?

Scargill points the way when he says that ultimately the only way is to defend jobs is by strike action — however difficult that may be. The problem is that as time goes on the situation gets more ditticult. There is a gun pointing at the heads of the miners and that gun needs to be removed if jobs are going to be effectively defended.

An attitude has to be developed that it is possible to ge strike action - in the directly threatened pits as well as in the ones which are seen as more sate. The stronger pits have to be linked more directly to the ones faced with imminent closure. At the same time it has to be recognised that no pit is safe. Cm was seen as a "safe" pit. The April deadline itself is designed by the NCB to divide the miners. This situation has to be challenged by the development of direct action. A strategy of this sort needs thrashing out by the miltitants in the NUM and must be advanced throughout the union. Time is very short. Threatened pits should meet together nationally and formulate a policy to be put to Area Conferences of the Union. The limited action which has begun points the way to this it is adequately developed.

iraditinns of the great ctrika ana haina

LAE GLE VEILE LEVIVEU LI VIE

In the solidarity campaign there have been some positive developments with the National Justice for Mineworkers Campaign. After the friction caused by the bureaucratic removal of the original secretary, who was doing a very good job, in order to replace him with someone who was less critical of the right wing of the labour movement, the recent meeting in Bolton was far more constructive.

It is important to build the Regional Campaigns, such as the inaugural meting of the South East Region Campaign to be held in London on November 8.

Although there are now only three miners in prison — Terry French from Kent and Dean Hancock and Russell Shankland from South Wales - the support for them must be maintained. The two Fryston miners recently released from prison show the problems these miners face. Their pit was closed whilst they were in prison. Three out of four pits have now been closed in the Castleford area with the loss of 2,500 jobs.

At the same time the sackings are still going on. - Mick MacGinty, the vice president of Nottinghamshire NUM, a miner at Ollerton who played a leading role in the

← They shall not pass! · Traditions of the great strike →

Something wrong on this page?