Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Epic struggle by "an ordinary man"

· Socialist Viewpoint no. 10, February 1986 · p 12 · 794 words

Epic struggle by "an

-Socialist

Bookshelf

ordinary man"

The case of the Legless Veteran: James Kutcher, (A Monad Press book distributed by Pathfinder Press). "IN most repects, I am an ordinary man. I have no special talents. I never showed any capacity for leadership. In school my marks generally put me in the middle sections of my class. sometimes lower. I never rose above the rank of Pic. in the army. Often, when I get into a dicussion. I don't think of the right point to make until hours afterward. I was active in a political organization for over ten years and never made a speech in all that time. I am a "Jimmy Higgins' by nature, the fellow who collects tickets at the door and sweeps up the hall after the meeting. People like me usually get their names in the papers twice - when they come into the world and when they go out. And yet I have become a public figure of a sort. A thousand separate items about me have appeared in large newspapers and small mimeographed bulletins from New York to California. Hundreds of organizations representing millions of people have taken time out from their regular business to discuss and pass resolutions about me. Lawyers have labored long hours drawing up involved legal documents for or against me. The highest court in the land may some day hand down a ruling that will have important effects not only on my future but on the liberties of the whole American people. I, who used to be too shy to make a motion to adjourn, now have made hundreds of speeches at meetings and over the radio; and the astonishing thing about it to me is that while I still have no special oratorical abilities, people have shed tears, lost their tempers or risen to their feet cheering when I talked to them about my struggle with high officials of the government of the United States."

Witch

Hunt

News

& bulletin detailing the extent of the use in trade union and Labour Party witch-hunt in the Labour Party. For branches. Produced by Labour Left ( ordination in conjunction with the ampaign Group of MPs. Availabl

O copies for £1 - from LLC. 57. Lofting Rd. London NI IES.

Please send any information you have on local witch-hunts to the same address to keep future issues of the bulletin up to date.

HOW this change came about, why it was worth writing a book about and what happened in the end are the subject of the 200-odd pages which follow these opening paragrapns ames Kutcher lost both his legs it World War II. As the witch-hunts of the post-war McCarthy era mounted he was sacked from his clerical job with the Veteran's Administration because of his membership of the Socialist Workers Party (USA) and it was 8 years later (1956) when he finally won his campaign for reinstatement.

The book shows the importance of using such openings as are afforded by the bourgeois courts, while never relying on them for a satisfactory solution to a campaign. It shows the Importance of building a defence movement around the point at issue and not a set of political positions not immediately relevant.

It shows the importance of not confusing the defence of those victimised Socialist Viewpoint No. 10 February 1985 p12

Reviewed by Keith White.

the need to endorse their with political outlook, and it underlines the importance of avoiding the "special case" argument.

Perhaps most importantly it con firms the old slogan "An injury to one is an injury to all" - through an examination of the record the American Communist Party which refused to fight (and indeed supported) the witch-hunting of Trotskyists - and thereby weakened the defence of themselves when their comrades' turn came round.

You don't have to agree with so-meone or a particular organisation before you defend their right to exist and organise for their politics.

These lessons are vividly ilustrated in this most accessible and moving account of one revolutionary's fight against the witch-hunt.

The promise of the opening paragraphs (quoted above) is more than fulfilled in the rest of the book — and yet when the first edition was ready in 1953 no American publisher would risk taking it and it had to be published by the British Trotskyist movement. Such was the fear generated by witch-hunting.

The story is told in a simply straightforward style, but if this is one of the "easiest" books you are likely to read, this fact does not detract from the seriousness of the issues with which it deals or the important political lessons it can teach us.

• NETSTEN-

HE AT PERE vicaragua Solidarity Campaign.

20/21 Compton Tee.. London NI

← Fighting on for victimised miners · Fightback against the witch-hunt! →

Something wrong on this page?