Israel's petty humiliation of Palestinian president Yassir Arafat in preventing him from attending Christmas midnight mass in Bethlehem symbolises the definitive end of the "peace process" started in Oslo in 1993.
Regardless of our views on Arafat's politics, and on the nature of the Palestine Authority, we must condemn unreservedly this gratuitous insult to the Palestinian people, whose leader has been treated like a naughty child confined to his room.
Israeli PM Ariel Sharon has never made a secret of his contempt for Arafat and his disdain for the entire "peace process".
Even the right-wing press in Israel is now questioning his motives and the purpose of his provocations.
Following the assassination of a senior Hamas leader at the end of November, the military correspondent of the best-selling daily Yediot Aharonot wrote:
"whoever decided upon the liquidation of Abu Hanoud knew in advance what would be the price. The subject was extensively discussed both by Israel's military echelon and its political one, before it was decided to carry out the liquidation".
And indeed, within days Hamas breached the unspoken agreement with Arafat and carried out an attack on Israeli bus, killing ten Israeli settlers. Sharon seized the opportunity to stage a series of brutal raids into the PA-controlled areas, and to impose an ever tighter siege on Palestinians.
It is hard, even for mainstream Israeli journalists, to avoid the conclusion that Sharon is deliberately provoking Palestinian attacks.
As many have noted, Sharon repeatedly insists that he will not permit any negotiations with Arafat until there have been seven days without Palestinian attacks.
Invariably, after three or four days have passed without any attacks, Israel carries out a spectacular raid or assassination, leading to the inevitable retaliation and the end of hopes for talks to restart.
However, it would be a mistake to conclude from this that the Oslo process has failed.
In dividing the Palestinian people, discrediting the PLO, and disarming the national struggle for the past eight years, Oslo has fulfilled precisely the purpose intended by its Israeli sponsors, murdered PM Yitzhak Rabin and current foreign minister Shimon Peres.
As Rabin notoriously commented, Arafat would be able to govern the Palestinians "without the High Court of Justice and without the civil rights groups", both of which have acted as a significant, if limited, restraint on Israel's freedom of action.
Believing that such an approach would better enable Israel, through a Palestinian proxy, to rule the occupied territories, Rabin was prepared to make minor concessions to the Palestinians.
Even Rabin, however, constantly failed or refused to meet his commitments and ignored deadlines. Sharon rejected Rabin's approach from the start, and has acted to bury the remains of the Oslo process.
Foreign minister Peres, who remains committed to Oslo, has made threatening noises, but has stayed in the government and taken no action to restrain Sharon.
In any case, he would be unlikely to attract support from his Labour Party, which has just elected the right-wing defence minister Binyanin Ben-Eliezer, rather than the more moderate Knesset speaker Avram Burg, as its leader.
In an apparent attempt to bolster his macho image, Peres (one of the few leading Israeli politicians not to have served in the army) has broken the taboo on discussion of nuclear issues to reveal what everybody already knew.
As director of the defence ministry in the 1950s, he personally established Israel's nuclear weapons programme, as well as negotiating the collusion with Britain and France in the 1956 Suez War.
Another revealing insight into Israel's decision-making process came from a recent newspaper article on the collapse of negotiations between Arafat and former Israeli PM Ehud Barak in January 2001.
Israeli apologists assert (without any evidence) that Arafat rejected Barak's "generous" offer. But Ha'Aretz quotes US conflict resolution expert Professor David Metz, who has been interviewing key figures in the negotiations:
"Barak told Metz that he had decided to stop the talks 'because there was a terror attack that day.'
"Metz: 'Sorry, I checked, there was no attack that day'. Barak: 'So maybe it followed a belligerent speech of Arafat'. Metz: 'I checked, there was no speech at all'. Barak lost patience: 'Okay, what difference does it make anyway. The talks had to be stopped and that's all'." (Ha'Aretz, 27 December).
Like Sharon, Barak (the only member of Rabin's cabinet to oppose the Oslo agreement) sought any opportunity to renege on Israel's side of the deal and to humiliate Arafat.
The past eight years of the Oslo process have enabled Israel to consolidate its control over the West Bank, East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip, establishing what activist Jeff Halper, of the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions, has referred to as its "matrix of control" over the occupied territories.
The key elements of this are massive military actions, a campaign of attrition, creating irreversible facts on the ground, establishing a parallel system of laws, delaying tactics and deligitimising the Palestinian Authority.
As Halper notes, 60% of the land of the West Bank, and 60% of Gaza, are now under the control of some 400,000 settlers in 200 illegal settlements. This is complemented by the construction of 450 kilometres of highways and "bypass" roads, for the exclusive use of Israelis.
Other Israeli tactics include house demolitions, land expropriation, permanent closure and prolonged curfews, restrictions on freedom of movement, induced impoverishment, economic warfare of various kinds (such as clearing agricultural fields, uprooting thousands of olive and fruit trees, prohibiting harvests, confiscating livestock and preventing the marketing of produce), and bureaucratic harassment.
This apartheid regime is the reality of the Oslo "peace" process. It is also, as Israeli activists have noted, the essence of the "two-state" solution proposed by much of the Zionist left – one dominant state ruling a subordinate population through the co-option of a corrupted and compliant local leadership.
Sharon is still attempting to implement the project outlined published by the World Zionist Organisation in 1982 under the title "A Strategic Plan for Israel in the 80s".
This document, which was the political background to Sharon's invasion of Lebanon in June 1982, calls for "the liquidation of Jordan under the present regime and the transfer of power to the Palestinian majority ... it is not possible to go on living in this country in the present situation without separating the two nations, the Arabs to Jordan and the Jews to areas west of the river".
The essential difference between this project and "two states for two nations" project of the Zionist left is the location of the border between the master and slave states, not the nature of these states and their relationship.
In the face of this strategy of division and domination, the PLO and the Islamist groups have signally failed to articulate a strategic response.
Nor has any coherent strategy or leadership as yet developed from the Palestinian uprising. The uprising, however, does show the difficulty which Israel would face in attempting to move to the next stage of this strategy – the systematic uprooting of Palestinian communities.
It is now clear that the approach initiated at Oslo by Rabin, Arafat and Peres has failed. The task now, for the Palestinian and Israeli left, is to develop a strategy which recognises the common interest and future of the peoples of Palestine, and shows the way towards unity rather than apartheid.