Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Bring war criminal Sharon to justice!

· Socialist Outlook no. 47, July–August 2001 · 1,512 words

World news

Palestine Asylum and migration Middle East

Within days of the screening of the Panorama documentary "The Accused", which demonstrated the direct responsibility of Israeli PM Ariel Sharon for the slaughter by Lebanese militia of several hundred Palestinians in the Sabra and Shatilla refugee camps in September 1982, Tony Blair met Sharon in Downing Street, and expressed his "admiration" at Israel's "restraint" in suppressing the Palestinian Intifada.

The following day, a Belgian magistrate accepted the petition of 23 survivors of the massacre, and opened a criminal investigation into Sharon.

Unlike the contentious Hague indictment of Milosevic, this case is not an example of "victor's justice". It results from a petition of 23 survivors of the massacre, using a recent Belgian law which allows the prosecution in Belgium of any alleged war criminal, regardless of the location of the events and the nationality of the victims.

Sabra and Shatilla are two Palestinian refugee camps in the south of Beirut. In September 1982, in the course of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, Israel's Phalange allies (named in honour of European fascists of the 1930s) carried out a savage massacre of several hundred Palestinian residents of the camps.

Several months later, an Israeli commission of enquiry found that then defence minister Sharon was "personally responsible" for the massacre, and he was forced to resign his post (though he remained a government minister). To this day, no-one has been prosecuted for the atrocity.

After the massacre, Sharon said of the Phalange: "Not for a moment did we imagine that they would do what they did. They had received harsh and clear warnings. Had we for one moment imagined that something like this would happen we would never have let them into the camp."

Most observers find this hard to believe. According to Ben Alofs, a Dutch doctor working in Sabra at the time: "Everybody in Beirut knew what would happen if the Phalangists were allowed into the camps. In spite of this, Sharon gave the green light" (Guardian, 13 July 2001).

I visited Sabra and Shatilla just two weeks before the massacre, where I witnessed the residents' fear following the election of Phalange leader Bashir Gemayel as president of Lebanon. When, back in London, I heard of Gemayel's assassination (apparently on Syrian orders), and of Sharon's decision to invade West Beirut and to send the Phalange into the camps, I knew and warned of the likely result. It is inconceivable that Sharon didn't know what would occur, and it must be assumed that he intended this outcome.

Although the subject of the Belgian investigation is Sharon's most notorious crime, his rôle in enabling or ordering the Beirut massacre, further claims are expected to be submitted to the magistrate.

Many of these relate to the invasion of Lebanon, conducted by Sharon, often behind the backs of prime minister Begin and other ministers. In the course of this war, several thousand civilians were killed, frequently by the use of weapons banned under international law.

These included cluster bombs, which scattered dozens of smaller bombs and mines, causing severe injury or death to anyone who went near them, and incendiary phosphorous bombs, designed as flares but used with devastating effect against civilians.

In his account of that war, Pity the Nation, Robert Fisk notes the experience of Dr Amal Shamaa at the Barbir Hospital: " 'I had to take the babies and put them in buckets of water to put out the flames', she said. 'When I took them out half an hour later, they were still burning. Even in the mortuary, they smouldered for hours'. Next morning, Amal Shamaa took the tiny corpses out of the mortuary for burial. To her horror, they again burst into flames". I was told of similar experiences at other hospitals.

The war was also characterised by the systematic shelling, at close range, of hospitals. During my stay in Beirut, I did not visit one hospital which had not been damaged. Frequently, shells had directly pierced the prominent red cross on the building.

All the evidence indicates that this was deliberate, not accidental, damage. As Fisk notes: "To call the gunfire indiscriminate was an understatement. It would also have been a lie. The Israeli bombardment of 4 August was, we realised later, discriminate. It targeted every civilian area, every institution, in west Beirut – hospitals, apartments, shops, newspaper offices, the prime minister's office and the parks.

"Incredibly, the Israeli shells also blew part of the roof off the city's synagogue in Wadi Abu Jamil where the remnants of Beirut's tiny Jewish community still lived". (When I visited, I found that an Israeli shell had demolished the star of David on the synagogue's roof).

In describing Israel's, and Sharon's, behaviour as a war crime, what must be remembered is that not only the conduct, but the very purpose of the war, was directed at civilians.

It was quite explicitly a war of terrorism, designed to break the civilian infrastructure of the PLO, to turn the population of Lebanon against the Palestinian presence, and to intimidate the Palestinians in the occupied territories, who had initiated a mini uprising in the spring of 1982.

Sharon had planned the war from the moment he took office after the 1981 election, and for six months before the war began the Israeli press had been full of speculation and analysis about its goals and prospects.

Sharon's appointment as defence minister, like his whole career, had been controversial. Begin had expressed his fear that Sharon would "ring the prime minister's office with tanks" if not appointed. From the early years of the state, Sharon had a reputation as a thug and a hothead, ready to carry out the most brutal acts in suppressing the Palestinian struggle for liberation.

As head of the notorious Unit 101 of the Israeli army, Sharon conducted murderous cross-border raids during the 1950s. In August 1953, he led a raid on Gaza's al-Bureij refugee camp, in which about 50 Palestinian refugees were murdered while they slept.

In October of that year, he led an attack on the village of Qibya, where some 70 Palestinians were murdered when their home were dynamited; according to a UN report, "Bullet-ridden bodies near the doorways and multiple bullet hits on the doors of the demolished houses indicated that the inhabitants had been forced to remain inside until their homes were blown up over them".

Sharon's career continued in the same vein, through establishing the Israeli paratroops, 'pacifying' the Gaza Strip in the early years of the occupation, and sponsoring the settlers' movement. Although he has come to symbolise the aggressive policies of the Israeli state, we must recognise that he is in fact in the mainstream of Israeli politics, not an isolated extremist.

Brought up in the traditions of the Zionist agricultural movement, he was originally a Labour supporter and first entered the Knesset as sole representative of a small 'peace' party. He was a close friend, and security adviser, to former prime minister Yitzhak Rabin.

It was his initiative which established the Likud as a fusion of various right wing and centre parties and Labour dissidents. Over the 53 years of Israel's existence, Sharon has emerged as the true representative of the Zionist state.

Nor, of course, is Sharon the only war criminal in a position of power in Israel. Foreign minister and former PM Shimon Peres was responsible, in April 1997, for the slaughter of over 100 Palestinian refugees sheltering at the UN base in Qana in southern Lebanon.

As director general of the defence ministry during the 1950s, he was responsible for the establishment of Israel's armaments industry and nuclear programme. In 1967, he was one of the team which ordered the attack on the US spyship Liberty, killing 34 American seamen.

And in 1986, he ordered the kidnapping of Mordechai Vanunu from Europe and his secret transport back to Israel to face trial for treason, after Vanunu revealed to the Sunday Times the extent of Israel's nuclear arsenal.

In a related development, Danish MP Søren Sondergaard has called for the arrest of Israel's new ambassador to Denmark, Carmi Gillon. Gillon is a former head of the Shin Bet (Israeli Security Service).

In his memoirs he admits ordering the torture of at least 320 Palestinian detainees, and in a recent interview with the Danish media he has justified this, portraying his actions, and torture in Israel generally, as a defence of an open and democratic society against a "sea of piranhas".

Such torture is a breach of the Geneva Convention, and Gillon is thus, by his own admission, a war criminal. The Israeli daily Ha'Aretz reports that, as a result of the controversy, it is now unlikely Gillon will take up his post.

These actions in Europe cannot, by themselves, bring about the liberation of Palestine and the Palestinians. However, by making life more difficult for Israeli thugs and murderers, and by focussing publicity on their crimes, they further weaken the legitimacy of the Zionist state.

Activists in Britain should support similar moves here, while opposing the pretensions of institutions like the Hague tribunal.

← Sniping from the Left · Gothenburg: an orgy of cop violence →

Something wrong on this page?