"Our memorial is not a ritual remembrance of the past but a persistent challenge to face up to the demands inherent in our own share of a shared task" - Istvan Meszaros
IN EARLY February, more than thirty people gathered in Leeds for a memorial meeting in honour of the late Bob Pennington. John Archer spoke about Bob's period in Leeds in the fifties and Keith Sinclair took up the story in later years.
Archer explained that Bob had been a colourful, energetic and ingenious character, devoted to building the Fourth International. After a spell in the RAF, and then working in a coal-mine, Bob had come into contact with Trotskyism in Blackpool in 1949. He joined the Revolutionary Communist Party just before it broke up.
He moved to Leeds in 1951 and worked there intermittently until 1957. Bob was active in the Harehills Ward Labour Party. John recounted how, at a meeting in the
local park, Aneurin Bevan had defended the Chinese Revolution. "Has the Stock Exchange been abolished? Have they got rid of the landlords?" The audience had no alternative but to agree that these were positive achievements.
Although American imperialism had restabilised after the war, Bob (like many others) was confident that the revolutionary epoch had not ended and that eventually the FI would gain a mass base.
1953 split
At the time of the 1953 split in the Fourth International, Bob had helped to ensure that the majority of the Trotskyist "Club", supported James Cannon and the American SWP, and all those forces that went on to form the International Committee.
Using a striking image, John suggested that "1953 is in this room" and, later in the meeting, tentatively floated the idea that one of the legacies of the split was a lack of clarity in handling alliances.
Bob played an important role in the early and mid-fifties, helping to lay the basis of the Socialist Labour League and recruiting many to its
ranks.
He eventually parted company with the SLL in 1960. In John's view there were no obvious political reasons for this. Although he had fallen out with the "deeply insecure" Healy and had not been paid his wages as a full-time worker for the organisation, it was likely that there were also other reasons.
John recounted how Bob had lived in the Archer's attic for a while and had been very good to their two sons. Bob had once made a study of the Daily Express to learn how it could get across its ideas so clearly. Bob had combined what John described as Anglo-Saxon scepticism with a certain impatience with theory. He had a good sense of practicalities.
Keith Sinclair spoke first about Bob's assessment of the dockers' breakaway from the TGWU in the fifties to the National Amalgamated Stevedores and Dockers Union (NASDU - the blue union), with which Bob had been closely involved.
In a 1960 article, Bob had taken an equal distance from the bureaucracies of both the TGWU and the NASDU, and argued only for the
building tees.
But by the eighties his attitude to the blue union had changed. Noting in interview in 1982 thai what became the SLL had been very cautious about the move to the blue, he concluded that nevertheless it had been right to leave the TGWU at that stage.
But when the 1955 NASDU recognition strike was defeated a few years later, he considered in retrospect that the dockers should have returned to the TGWU.
After a brief flirtation with the Solidarity group, Bob was linked by the mid-sixties with the International Group, the precursor of the International Marxist Group.
Reasssment
He moved away from the positions he had held in the fifties. An article published in 1986 - "The fall and fall of Gerry Healy" - critically reassessed that tradition, writing of the opportunism, catastrophism, hyperactivity and antiintellectualism that characterised Healy's organisations.
In the early eighties, during a period of serious factional struggle in
rank-and-file
the Socialist League (successor to the IMG) he was one of the leaders of the tendency which emphasised the centrality of events in the Labour Party.
He always stressed the key importance of the labour movement, of the trade unions and the Labour Party.
Bob was a militant who made a contribution over a long period, with a leadership role stretching over decades. He continued to be active until the end of the eighties, and many of his articles in later years stand the test of time.
From the floor, Len Hodgson remembered Bob as a man of tremendous courage. He played cards and was well known in his local pub. At one time he had worked as a bookie's runner for a Leeds councillor. He had been a "hell of a recruiter".
The meeting was a fitting tribute to a fine socialist, with comrades mainly from Leeds, but also from further afield. After the meeting ended, most stayed to renew old acquaintances and exchange reminiscences of the man they had come to honour.