WITHIN DAYS of the recent nuclear accident at Tokaimura in Japan, worried workers at the previously secret Rolls Royce reprocessing plant in Derby contacted CND to warn of the danger of a similar criticality accident there.
The Nuclear Installations Inspectorate inspectors issued a report earlier this year criticising procedures, particularly emergency and evacuation plans, at the Midlands plant. Roland Rance looks at the issues at stake for all of us.
The Tokaimura incident is yet another example of the inability of a profit-led industry to deliver safe working and environmental practices. For reasons not yet clear, workers brought together more than seven times the permitted quantity of enriched uranium, setting off an uncontrolled chain reaction.
Unbelievably, they were not wearing protective clothing, and carried the uranium in simple buckets. Although radiation levels up to 15,000 times normal were later recorded two kilometres from the site, warnings were not issued to local residents for several hours.
Directors of JCO, the company which runs the site, accepted formal responsibility, but attempted to pin the blame on the workers, claiming that they had breached safety regulations.
The likelihood is that inadequately-trained workers, operating new systems, and under pressure from managers to improve efficiency and profitability, simply cut corners and ignored – if they ever knew – the safety regulations.
The fact is that it is impossible to eliminate human error, which has been the cause of most previous nuclear accidents. Greenpeace has published a calendar of hundreds of such accidents.
They explain that at Chernobyl in 1986, technicians were apparently carrying out unauthorised experiments which led to the disaster there. In 1975, technicians seeking the cause of a power failure at Browns Ferry, in Alabama, crawled under the reactor with lighted candles, and set light to the station. In 1998, contractors at Dounreay in Scotland accidentally cut a power cable.
In fact, these incidents should not be refered to as "accidents"; they seem an inseparable part of the running of nuclear power stations.
The Rolls Royce plant in Derby is not a power station, but an armaments factory; it produces bomb-grade uranium for nuclear submarines, using a similar process to that at Tokaimura. According to CND, the threat there is "potentially worse" than at the Japanese factory, since it uses 93% enriched uranium, rather than the 19% used in Tokaimura. Consequently, a far smaller mistake could produce a catastrophic result.
According to the whistleblowers who contacted CND, the plant has no off-site emergency plan, and no procedures for containing radioactivity in the event of an accident.
Despite this, the government has declared Raynesway to be safe, and refused demands to close it. Workers should demand the immediate halt of all nuclear weapons production, and the use of the equipment and skills for socially beneficial purposes.
Tokaimura was not directly engaged in weapons production, but in research for a fast-breeder reactor. The British government last year ordered the closure of the Dounreay fast breeder in Scotland, following a series of accidents and the disappearance of 170 kilograms of highly enriched uranium – enough to produce 12 bombs.
Despite the initial promise that nuclear electricity would be "too cheap to meter", it is now clear that the economic and environmental cost is astronomical.
Indeed, it is only by estimating the value of a human life at £400,000 that the UK Atomic Energy Authority is able to balance its books. If it used the EU Commission figure of £2 million, then Britain's entire nuclear energy programme would be seen as a major economic burden.
In addition, it is leaving a legacy of highly radioactive waste which will need centuries of attention. It is producing plutonium whose only use is in the production of nuclear weapons – it is unsafe and causing major health problems through the release of radioactivity.
As I write, reports are coming through of a "significant statistical link" between stillbirths and exposure of fathers to low levels of radioactivity after extensive research carried out in the Sellafield area.
Socialists need to fight for investment and research into renewable energy sources such as solar, geo-thermal, wind and wave power. Even under workers' control, it is doubtful whether nuclear energy could be produced safely. Under capitalism, it is leading towards catastrophe.