AS THE HOME of scandal, the London Borough of Hackney keeps hitting the headlines, so it might still be worth commenting on Lizzie Bloom's article in your December issue.
There are several factual errors in the article. For example, Michael Barber is not a Minister, he's a high-profile civil servant, and he was never "Director" of Education in Hackney, he was Chair of the Hackney Council Education Committee for a while before 1990 (when Hackney took over the education service from the old ILEA).
More importantly, there are two judgments in the article which appear to reflect the local NUT analysis of the government's intervention in Hackney education, but which I believe are incorrect and disorienting.
Firstly, if one reads what Ministers actually said when they announced the original Ofsted inspection of Hackney Education in June 1997, it is unambiguous that their target was the management of the local authority, and not (directly) teachers or schools. My view is that they took advantage of Hackney's lamentable reputation to show that they were "tough on education", and to gain an electoral advantage at the May 1998 London local elections.
I don't know why they appointed the right-wing Tory businessman Richard Painter to chair their hit squad, but the best guess I have heard is that they hoped he would carry weight with the local Tories and Liberal Democrats, who run the borough following the ignominious collapse of the Hackney Labour Group (which split acrimoniously in 1996).
However, Painter is a powerful businessman, with an evident habit of getting his own way: when the hit squad reported in November 1997, he wrote their report without discussing it with his advisers, and – perhaps as a result – in local government legal terms it was indefensible.
As a result, the dominant Chief Officers in Hackney were easily able to defy the hit squad recommendations about the structure of Hackney's education department, and Labour ministers backed down, but it is simply untrue to say that central government "supported" the Chief Officers' "Transforming Hackney" project.
I mention these points not only because it is vital for revolutionary socialists to get their facts right, but also because it is important for us to grasp the detailed mechanisms by which bourgeois society works.
To get those wrong would have serious adverse effects for our political activities. In the case of Hackney NUT, for example, misunderstanding the Inspection/Hit squad exercise as a direct attack on schools and teachers helped produce the fiasco of a "mass picket" of the Council on 26 November 1997 which only five or so people attended.
Tony Whelan, Hackney