Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Labour's greens face Blairism

· Socialist Outlook no. 98, March 2 1996 · 713 words

Obituaries

"THE GREENS will become a permanent part of British politics" said Ken Livingstone when the Green Party won 15 per cent of the vote in the 1989 European elections.

"What that means for the left is clear. The Red-Green alliance is no longer simply a matter for West Germany or other European countries. It applies to Britain too."

Livingstone had got it right on the importance of the politics of environmentalism and sustainable economics but got the political form wrong.

This was reflected on February 17 when over 500 people turned up at Westminster Central Hall to the Socialist Environment and Resources Association conference: 'Working for a Green Future - sustainabilty, full employment and the quality of life.'

The hall was full of labour movement activists, a smattering of Green Party members and significant numbers of youth. Activists from Reclaim the Streets were also there.

The significance of the event was underlined by the political battle between the Blair wing of the labour movement and the old fashioned social democrats who have, it seems, at last started to get to grips with the issue that Livingstone first pointed to while in charge of the GLC.

Joan Ruddock and Chris Smith were on the platform for the front bench of the Labour Party.

What was unnerving about their contributions was that they both made almost the same speech—to the embarrassment of everybody watching. Even down to the same opening line which was to quote Margaret Thatcher who had said during the Malvinas crisis "isn't it nice to have a real crisis when you have to deal with such humdrum matters like the environment".

Throughout Chris and Joan spoke with one voice—that of Tony Blair.

Both speeches were a mixture of Tory bashing and Euro-enthusiasm. Most of it was, of course, intellectually vapid but—if you are desperate enough—believable.

It was left to John Edmonds, wearing his Full Employment Forum hat, to pose a socialist environmental politics as opposed to the liberalism served up by the Blairites.

Edmonds argued that high unemployment had led to a social break down and that this could only be corrected by "a large public sector and a well developed system of public services".

For this "you need planning and regulation" and money spent on health, education and sustaining a quality of life for the older generation.

Full employment, he argued, would come from three sectors of the economy, communications, health and education.

At this point Edmonds was well in his stride announcing that Britain needed "a massive infrastructure investment" including water systems and house building (or an improvement in the built environment, as environmentalists would say).

Also needed was a shift from private to public transport. Edmonds went on to explain how the GLCs fares-fair policy had got him out of his car and on to the bus and what a good idea that this had been. He also put a figure on it - £8 billion worth of investment.

At the end of his speech Joan Ruddock was staring at a fixed point in the distance as the conference clapped its head off to a most unexpected tub thumping speech.

In response to a question from the floor about the transfer of skilled workers from he military to environmental sectors Edmonds completely blew the gaff by saying that 'It will not happen if market forces are allowed to do it for us. This is an area where socialist planning has to take place.' Socialist planning! Ruddock gulped down another glass of water. Conference was left wondering how market forces were going to create the 'large public sector' that Edmonds had called for.

Edmonds' speech was only outflanked by that of Jonathon Porrit who, as the last speaker, argued that full employment could only be reached by a cut in the working week, a ban on overtime, a radical redistribution of wealth and a shift of taxation from labour use to resource use. The audience lapped it up.

Is SERA the plaything of Blair and co? Perhaps not. Only its reaction to a Blair government will make it clear.

← IMF/World Bank/WTO: The Free Market Fiasco · Obituary: Ellis Hillman →

Something wrong on this page?