In Socialism Today, the monthly journal of Militant Labour, Peter Taaffe writes that Tony Blair's triumph at this year's Labour Conference and the scale of the defeat for the left represent a 'defining moment'.
According to Taaffe, there has been a historic realignment of British politics, with the transformation of the Labour Party into New 'One Nation' Labour.
Here DAVE PACKER argues that the left has suffered serious watershed defeats, but that this cannot be equated with a change in the class character of the Labour Party itself.
Had such a change occurred, it would represent an historic defeat for the working class.
PETER TAAFFE writes: "Socialism Today and its predecessor Militant International Review, have argued that the Labour Party under Blair was in the process of being transformed from a workers' organisation at bottom with a pro-capitalist leadership, into a wholly 'liberal' capitalist party.
"Brighton '95 confirmed this. The majority of capitalist commentators, either implicitly or explicitly, accept it.
"The only issue under dispute is whether the process has been completed, that the Labour Party has now exhausted any historical role as a vehicle for socialists and workers in the struggle against capitalism, or if it is still possible to halt the Blair juggernaut." (pp9-10)
He continues: "The decisions of the conference hold little encouragement for those on the left who, hoping against hope, believe that the Labour Party can be rescued."
The whole weight of Taaffe's argument is that the transformation has been more or less completed and is irreversible. Later in the same text, he writes that Militant Labour has been right about "the processes which have led to a fundamental change in the character of the Labour Party." (p12)
New party
Taaffe draws the conclusion: Militant Labour, with others, should take the opportunity and build a new party of Labour!
His argument is based not simply on the recent defeats for the left and the dramatic rightward shift of party policy, but also on Blair's successful structural and social changes to the Party:
"Left candidates are blocked and Howarth, one of the Tory authors of the Poll Tax, is welcomed on board. ... Thousands of socialist stalwarts have already gone (since the Clause Four defeat). ... Workers drop out and are replaced by a Blair 'levy' of politically raw types, many middle class ..."
Even more significant, according to Taaffe is that Labour's key defining feature has been overturned. It is no longer a 'federation of different trends and ideological currents ... which allowed the freedom of Marxists and others to put forward their ideas and have such a decisive influence at different stages in history."
Given these fundamental changes in the character of the party, Taaffe insists that "A left transformation is now the most unlikely perspective for the Labour Party."
Of course this breaks from their previous analysis, held for more than forty years.
The article rightly emphasises the significance of the new rule changes and changes in social composition, but wrongly argues that these features define the class character of the Labour Party.
Crucially, the most important federal element, trade union affiliation, remains intact.
Militant used to understand this. It is clear that Blair wishes to sever the historic link with the trade unions and transform the Labour Party into a European-style social democratic-type party: but a deal was struck at conference guaranteeing (for the moment!) no further reduction in the unions' 50 percent share of votes.
Unbroken link
Blair achieved his victory because he was able to forge a new alliance with the trade union bureaucracy, although mostly on his terms. The trade union link has not been broken, and there is everything to fight for.
The great mass of the working class still see Labour as their party and will turn out to vote for it at the next election in order to get rid of the Tories.
For Militant Labour to stand against the Labour Party will be seen as a diversion by the masses. Even the broad vanguard, who have few illusions in Blair, will see standing candidates against Labour as sheer folly.
Taaffe's analysis, crucial to his argument for building a new socialist party in the medium term, is unconvincing: he claims that the class character of the Labour Party has already changed.
He argues that a right wing Labour government, intent on attacking the working class, will result in demands on wages, education, and housing, but that Blair is preparing to 'ride out' any opposition.
He therefore needs to make the Labour Party 'safe' from any pressure from the organised working class, hence the attacks on democracy.
Prejudged
The problem with this analysis is that Taaffe is prejudging the outcome of struggles which are still unfolding or yet to begin.
If Blair really were strong enough to brush aside resistance, it would imply a weak or non-existent fightback, and little or no mobilisation of class struggle left in the unions: yet if these are not the very forces on which any 'new party of Labour' would have to base itself, who does Taaffe see as the target audience of his new initiative?
The whole project of building a new left party at this stage faces an insuperable contradiction: its political justification rests on an analysis – a claimed historic and irreversible defeat for Labour's left wing – which suggests the least favourable conditions ever for creating a class struggle organisation.
Despite Taaffe's pessimism, Blair has not yet succeeded: on the contrary, despite the treachery of the union leaders, the pressure of the masses will be felt directly by a Labour government.
Ruptures
At first the union bureaucrats will try to hold down the lid, exploiting the initial mood of 'give them a chance': but a struggle will at some point break through, and ruptures will probably appear within the bureaucracy.
How do we know? because this was the way previous Labour governments have run into conflict with the rank and file of the unions.
If we face this situation again in three or four years time, Taaffe's analysis of the Labour Party would naturally lead him to fight for the unions to disaffiliate. He writes that once Blair refuses to satisfy working class demands, ordinary trade unionists will decide to cut away:
"The cry could go up for unions to disaffiliate from the party, as happened with the New Zealand Labour Party in the 1980s. The ground will be prepared for splits towards the left."
Will the leftward-moving sectors of the bureaucracy move quickly to split the Labour Party and affiliate to Militant Labour? Or will they be forced to place themselves at the head of a struggle to regain control of the Party and its leadership?
At first, at least, the latter scenario seems the most probable. Depending on the character of the new left leadership thrown up in this situation, the fight for the soul of the Labour Party would be on. Under these conditions it would be a sectarian diversion to campaign for the disaffiliation of the trade unions. The task would be to join that fight.
Whatever scenario unfolds in three or four years time, the task of the left today is to fight for a Labour government, but to continue the struggle against the Tories.
If it is to play a role in the unfolding process of Labour's realignment, and defend the trade union link, the left in the Labour Party must break from its narrow parliamentarist perspective and rebuild itself out of the coming struggles.
This means focusing on the battles in the trade unions, and fighting for the Labour Party to take up the struggles of the oppressed and the youth.