Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Can laws stamp out racial harassment?

· Socialist Outlook no. 80, March 25 1995 · 1,352 words

Racism and anti-fascism

THE DEMAND for a law against racial harassment has become central to a wing of the anti racist movement. Ten years ago, HARRY COHEN MP introduced a Bill into parliament calling for such a law, and has been one of the main motivators of such demands in parliament since then. SOCIALIST OUTLOOK spoke to Harry Cohen about the aims of such legislation, and some of its limitations.

SO: What did you aim to achieve with the Bill on racial harassment?

HC: The Racial Harassment Bill was an extremely radical Bill; it was the first time that any legislation against racial attacks had been presented to the House of Commons.

Before that it was claimed that it was not possible to introduce this kind of legislation, as it was claimed that it was not practical. This bill showed that it was: it had a whole schedule that pointed out the different types of racial harassment that black people had to face from day to day.

Since then it's got worse and worse. The British Crime Survey, which only showed the major racist attacks, estimated attacks on Black and Asian people at something like 140,000 per year. That's an enormous number.

SO: The vast majority of these attacks are already a criminal offence, only the perpetrators are seldom prosecuted. How would further legislation help to deal with this?

HC: Well the fact of the matter is that a lot of these attacks may already be illegal, but the law doesn't recognise the racial motivation behind them.

That does add a new and most serious dimension to the crime. It should be recognised in the law and recognised in the punishment.

My bill did three things; it made a specific offence of racial harassment – the "smaller" levels of racial harassment that still make people's lives a misery still are not covered in the present law. My bill would make that an offence.

It also puts a specific duties on the police to investigate all reported cases of racial harassment and then to make public what they've done. That isn't the case now.

Thirdly, instead of the victims having to flee for their own safety from their own homes, it meant that action could be taken against the perpetrators.

The overtly racist elements could be evicted if they were tenants; and if they were owner occupiers measures could be taken to get them out. That isn't in the law at the moment.

Some councils are doing their best against racist attackers, but they are very few. There is very little coordinated action from the law or from the government saying that racial harassers have got to be dealt with. The current law doesn't cover any of those points.

SO: There is an argument that the demand for new legislation could prove a diversion to the anti-racist movement from the day to day struggle against racism which by necessity can't be determined simply by legislation.

HC: No, I don't agree with that, I think they go hand in glove.

I'm not saying that you can pass a legislation and all the problems are solved: far from it.

Most of the problems as you rightly pointed out are on the streets, and racist and fascist organisations need to be tackled there, but it needs to be done in a climate and a legal framework that makes it clear that the state is against racism.

At the moment we have a number of examples of institutionalised racism; immigration law, the way the police deal with Black communities, stop and search and things like that.

All this legislation positively promotes discrimination: the state is perceived as encouraging racism.

The Tory government plays a role in appeasing racism when they feel there are votes in it for them.

Tory backbenchers are constantly playing the racist card when it suits them, ranting about "floods of immigrants" which is just a great lie.

The state is seen to promote racism far more than it promotes anti-racism, despite the fine words that ministers occasionally speak.

The law should take an absolutely clear position that it is anti-racist, and then we can put pressure on the organisations of the state, the police to actually implement it. Then there would be no excuses.

SO: How do you see the development of the European Union, and its immigration policy in relation to this?

HC: The only major contribution I made in parliament on the Maastricht debate was on immigration controls.

What was being proposed there was that everything should be decided by an unelected committee which could put the barriers up around fortress Europe in a big way.

This body would not be accountable to anyone, and every state would have to comply, and would be bringing racism to a new dimension.

Now I oppose what our government does here on immigration, because they break up families and won't allow them to be reunited; they deport people – often with considerable violence, and I object to that.

But at least we do have a say through parliament, we can raise it with the minister responsible, maybe if we get a Labour government we can make some changes to that sort of policy and how it's implemented.

If it goes to an unelected European commissioner, the power to get anything altered will be minimalised. I think that the Maastricht treaty is bad in the respect that we will have even more racist legislation.

SO: What should the demands of the anti-racist movement be?

HC: There are a number of demands that anti-racists should make. Some are to do with changes in the law.

I think that the overwhelming majority of anti-racist activists would like to see a change in the law, and would like to see a racial harassment bill.

Things have moved on since 1985 and there have been new drafts of legislative change, by ARA, the Society of Black Lawyers and by the Commission for Racial Equality.

I would like to see a change in immigration laws, which are grossly unfair. I would like to see discrimination ended.

I've just received a paper from the GMB which points out that for black youth in London between the ages of 16 and 24, unemployment has reached 60%. We have anti-discrimination legislation on the statute book that clearly is not being carried out.

It is appalling that 60% of black youth are unemployed in London, and we need to strengthen legislation to deal with this.

Of course the struggle also goes on on the streets: for example the BNP in Tower Hamlets must be defeated in the elections, and can't be allowed to assault and intimidate black people, so self-defence organisations do have an important role to play.

Again self-defence does have an important role to play, though at least part of that pressure must be on the police to act against racists and racism.

In some areas the police have improved since 1985 but in other areas there has hardly been any change at all and adopt policies of blaming the victims.

There has got to be community pressure on the police to deal with racism, so it's a mixture of the law and the community, and both are vitally important.

SO: Tony Blair said in an interview with The Voice last week that he was supporting a law against racial harassment. Is the Labour Party likely to carry this out?

HC: Well it is Labour policy; that is the impact that my Bill has had, even though the government has opposed it and dragged its feet all the way.

The Labour Party will implement it, I think, or a form of it, though that will depend on the wording and what it commits it to.

But it is an enormous step forward, in the context of the overall picture.

← Quango vote to axe Edgware hospital · Zionist 'union' that sets dogs on strikers →

Something wrong on this page?