THE sale of Rover to BMW is a massive subsidy to British Aerospace, courtesy of the party that doesn't prop up lame ducks, reports DAVE OSLER.
BRITISH Aerospace was illegally handed a nationalised company at a heavily subsidised price, without the competitive tendering that would accompany a council bog-cleaning contract, and flogged it off at a fat mark-up.
In National Audit Office-speak, the £150 million BAe paid for Rover in 1988 'fell significantly short of the real value of the company', which was worth an absolute minimum of £206.5 million.
It had surplus assets, such as disused sites, worth at least £250 million; BAe realised £126 million of them by the end of 1989. Furthermore, Rover had shareholdings in associated companies, such as Unipart, worth up to £144 million.
The state wrote off £547 million of Rover debt, offered BAe £25 million in tax concessions, and then threw in more sweeteners than the average saccharine factory, collectively worth £44 million. Appropriately enough for a second-hand car deal, BAe was able to defer payment of the meagre asking price, saving £33.4 million in interest. The Government even funded £9.5 million of BAe's acquisition costs.
Leaked correspondence proved that Lord Young, then trade secretary, and Professor Roland Smith, then BAe chairman, discussed how to hide details from parliament and the European Commission.
The German car manufacturer is now paying £800 million for 80 per cent Rover, and shouldering £900 million of debt. BAe shares have risen 30 per cent since the news, adding a further £500 million to its value.
Meanwhile, it holds on to an unspecified amount of Rover's land and property assets, and pockets the money raised from the sale of a 20 per cent stake to Japan's Honda in 1989.
Defenders point out that BAe invested £1,000 million in the car manufacturer, but that capital expenditure was financed by Rover operations. Much of it was borrowed money, with repayments simply passing to BMW.
The Rover sale is just one example of the Tories' astonishing largesse to Britain's largest manufacturing company, which announced a loss of £1,200 million, the biggest in UK corporate history, in February 1993. It is in marked contrast with the treatment of the coal industry.
In another rigged privatisation, BAe bought Royal Ordnance, the highly profitable state-owned munitions, explosives and guns manufacturer, in 1987.
BAe got an operation with a book value of £235 million for just £190 million. Some £69 million had only just been spent on 'rationalisation', while another £40 million had gone on cleaning up a polluted site in Waltham Abbey.
Intellectual property rights, including drawings, designs and data packages for missiles, together worth at least £50 million, went to BAe for just £1 million. Meanwhile, the Ministry of Defence agreed to a further state investment of £12 million, and gave BAe a five-year contract worth £1,500 million.
Through Royal Ordnance, BAe bought Heckler and Koch in 1991. The former managing director of the German small-arms manufacturer, Walter Lamp, currently faces trial in Rottweil, home of the eponymous dogs, on charges of supplying weapons to Iraq, Nicaragua's Contras and East Germany's Stasi.
The prosecution will argue that Royal Ordnance provided false end-user certificates to skirt embargoes. It is unclear whether the alleged events occurred when Royal Ordnance was owned by the Government or by BAe.
Meanwhile, UK Customs and Excise has denied reports that it has supplied the Scott inquiry into British arms sales to Iraq with documents indicating that the Royal Ordnance channelled explosives to Iraq, Iran, Argentina and South Africa, acting as part of a cartel.
But the Scott inquiry has already touched on BAe's attempt to sell £5,000 million worth of Hawk trainer-light attack aircraft, and the factories to make more of them, to Saddam Hussein.
The Foreign Office banned MoD salesmen from visiting the Baghdad arms fair in April 1989, after the uproar following the use of chemical weapons against Iraqi Kurds.
At the time, a former BAe executive, David Hastie, was on secondment to the MoD's Defence Export Services Organisation. He had been handpicked by DESO's head, Sir Colin Chandler, who was previously Hastie's boss as BAe group marketing director.
To get round the ruling, Hastie was released from his secondment for a few days and despatched to Baghdad as a 'BAe representative'. Thus, when Labour MP Tony Banks later asked Alan Clark, then defence minister, if any MoD official had attended the fair, he could safely be told: 'No.' Talk about economical with the actualite.
As Europe's biggest defence contractor, BAe gained massively from Thatcherism's arms-sale-driven foreign policy of the eighties.
Pergau Dam
On a visit to Kuala Lumpur in September 1988, Margaret Thatcher, then prime minister, explicitly linked aid for the Pergau hydroelectric dam with the Malaysian Government Malaysian spending £1,000 million on BAe Tornado fighter-bombers.
The Malaysians subsequently cancelled, but placed an order 28 Hawks, worth up to £400 million, instead. The dam project, at a cost of £234 million to the British taxpayer, has proved totally unsuitable for the country's development needs. Meanwhile, neighbouring Indonesia is buying 24 Hawks, assisting a military effort that includes the illegal occupation of East Timor.
BAe is also the main winner from the gigantic Al Yamamah Two arms deal with Saudi Arabia, worth £20,000 million over 15 years, and probably the biggest export contract of the century. An initial memorandum of understanding was signed by Thatcher and Prince Bandar, Saudi ambassador to Washington, in Austria in July 1985. Sir Colin Chandler, the ex-BAe man, handled subsequent negotiations.
After a period when the Saudis threatened to opt for American equipment instead, 1988 saw the signing of the Al Yamamah Two (AY2) deal, the subject of another NAO report. Scandalously, this one has been suppressed.
Concern centres on commission payments of up 30 per cent to British middlemen, including Thatcher's son Mark, and members of the Saudi ruling families, described as 'exceptional commercial expenses'. One wonders what Michael Portillo makes of it all.
Clive Soley, the Labour MP, has also claimed that Prince Bandar met Michael Heseltine, defence secretary at the time the original deal was struck, in London just before the last election, and donated £7 million to Conservative Party election funds.
In January 1993, John Major, the prime minister, signed the formal contract for BAe to supply Saudi Arabia with 48 Tornado fighter-bombers and 60 Hawks, together worth £5,000 million, as part of AY2. The work will keep BAe's facilities in Warton, Lancashire, going until 1996, when production of the Eurofighter 2000, the scaled-down version of the European Fighter Aircraft, is set to commence.
Eurofighter 2000 is further testimony to Tory support for BAe. German defence minister Volker Ruehe tried to kill the four-nation project in 1992, arguing that it did not suit western Europe's post-USSR defence needs. Only British insistence stayed his hand.
BAe's links with Government remain close. Lord Hesketh, former Government chief whip in the Lords and minister of state in Michael Heseltine's Department of Trade and Industry, was appointed to the board only last December. Presumably his remuneration is not inconsiderable.