THE NEW paper has made a promising start. But film reviews need a great deal of improvement. In my opinion the review of Oliver Stone's 'The Doors' (SO 2) was both shallow and inaccurate.
The tone in which the review was written illustrated Mr Tunney's inability to relate to the era in which the film was set. Is the word 'man' an instant point of ridicule? Contrary to Mr Tunney's opinion (and probably experience) the sixties were the sixties, and people did talk like that. Maybe the reviewer would have preferred the characters to use the street-cred lingo of the nineties?
If Jim Morrison had been portrayed as less sexist and egotistical, a worked-out radical leftie, with his girlfriend (sorry - 'partner') being an assertive worked-out feminist would Mr Tunney have approved?
I would prefer to see something that approximates reality. This was what the film tried to do. Jim Morrison is correctly portrayed in the film as he was. A pretentious, self-obsessed degenerate but also an innovative artist whose music animated a generation and continues to have influence today.
If all film reviews follow this pattern of knee-jerk moralistic leftism (also somewhat dated) they will make for pretty boring reading. The review is also riddled with inaccuracies - too numerous and trivial to pursue. Mr Tunney was perhaps too busy listening to 'New Kids on the Block' on his personal stereo to follow the plot! Anyone who likes the Doors shouldn't be put off by the review.
Rachel Newton, Manchester