Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Why left should back public sector union merger

· Socialist Outlook no. 17, February 29 1992 · p 3 · 639 words

UNISON

Doug Thorpe (Islington NALGO)

MERGER MADNESS' seems to have seized the union bureaucrats in their desperation to overcome falling membership, and their consequent financial difficulties.

For many, defending the apparatus is more important than mounting a real fight against Tory attacks.

Socialists can't take a position of principle for or against this current phase of mergers. The proposed AEU-EETPU merger would clearly create a powerful, highly undemocratic business union within the TUC, strengthening new realism. Such mergers must be opposed.

Divisions

The proposed NALGO-NUPE-COHSE merger has the potential to strengthen workers' ability to take on the employers, by overcoming divisions between manual, craft and white collar workers. But only if activists within the three unions can get the right rules, conditions and structures before amalgamation.

NALGO's 1991 conference laid down 'baseline' conditions much more positive than many activists thought possible.

The principal demands were that in the new union annual conference should remain the supreme policy making body; branches should retain similar financial control as exists now in NALGO; that the new union should be under lay control and membership led; and the right of individual branches and groups to organise and campaign in the union be recognised.

In addition, demands were made for the rights of self-organisation for women, black members and lesbians and gay men; and for the rapid integration of manual and white collar structures.

A new report by NALGO's leadership goes to a special conference on 4 March (NUPE and COHSE's leaders have chosen not to have conferences) contains substantial advances.

It provides for an annual delegate conference, concessions over the level of branch finances, some provision for self-organisation and a commitment to integration of structures.

Amendments submitted from branches include demands about branch financial autonomy, and the proposal that branches collect dues themselves.

Stumbling block

Central collection of dues would ensure adequate branch financing; but it is a major stumbling block, since NUPE and COHSE are resolutely opposed to branch dues collection.

The left will also be fighting to guarantee the right of groups and individuals to organise within the union.

The fear exists that the document's references to 'unrepresentative groups within the union' and a requirement of adherence to the 'agreed policy of the union' might be used to attack militant branches or rank and file political groupings.

Unfortunately there are no amendments proposed that would strengthen the commitment to women's self-organisation alongside the much-vaunted commitment to proportionality of women on elected bodies.

Opinion on the left has veered from the SWP, who seem to be moving to a position of opposition to all mergers, to advocates of 'One Big Union' who back merger in any circumstances. But most activists, including Socialist Outlook supporters, have reserved judgement depending on the conditions.

There is still a lot to be fought for to make the conditions for merger right; but the process of merger should be supported. The left in the three unions, now woefully divided, must work towards the formation of a democratic broad left encompassing all three unions.

Whatever the outcome of NALGO's special conference, the wider membership of all three unions remains to be persuaded. Many manual workers see NALGO members primarily as managers.

Affiliation to the Labour Party is rejected by many NALGO members. And inter-union rivalry in workplaces is common.

The way to overcome division, and create a stable basis for unity, would be to mobilise the three unions in a common fight against low pay, cuts and jobs losses, and in favour of harmonising pay and conditions for manual and white collar workers.

NALGO, NUPE and COHSE combined would have immense potential power. It remains to be seen whether the leaderships want to use it to throw back all the Tory attacks on the public services.

← Ecological catastrophe? · Anti-Racist Alliance launched in Manchester →

Something wrong on this page?