Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Guru overboard in Militant mutiny

· Socialist Outlook no. 15, February 1 1992 · 500 words

MILITANT tendency has expelled its founder Ted Grant – the person it once extolled as 'the foremost figure of Trotskyism in Britain and internationally' – and 35 other supporters.

The move comes after a bitter 10 month dispute inside Militant which culminated in the candidacy of Lesley Mahmood in Walton and the recent launch of an open organisation counterposed to Labour in Scotland.

Ted Grant utterly opposed this so-called 'Scottish turn', which was nevertheless backed by a large majority of Militant supporters, including the paper's editor Peter Taaffe, and top anti-poll tax activist Tommy Sheridan.

Grant was apparently in the process of organising a de facto breakaway group with a rival publication and its own premises, staff and funds, an obvious breach of discipline. But his co-thinkers counterclaim they have been bureaucratically excluded from the tendency with no right of appeal.

Despite Militant's attempt to ridicule Grant's so-called 'mini-exodus', he is likely to be joined by a further 4-800 activists. The whole affair demonstrates the need for political mechanisms which can handle sharp differences inside socialist tendencies, proving once more that internal democracy is no mere bolt-on extra for the far left.

But the heart of the issue is how socialists in the Labour Party respond to Kinnock's drive to push the party ever-further rightward. Taaffe and his supporters correctly saw that the kind of tactics practised by Militant since its foundation were no longer practical.

Revolutionary socialists need a 'twin-track' approach, working both inside and outside the Labour Party. But this does not mean building mini-parties in opposition to it, such as Scottish Militant Labour.

Such energies could be far better spent developing the Socialist Movement, which has the potential to become a genuine and widely-supported united front based on class-struggler politics.

Yet, as ever, Militant refuses to participate in anything not under its own control.

Yet there is little mileage in the new Grant group sticking to its founder's dogmatic schemas. There is a real danger that such passivity will generate a reversal to the sterile politics which characterised Militant until the mid-1980s, which effectively dismissed feminism, lesbian and gay rights, and black issues as mere sideshows.

The crisis in Militant is an inevitable result of the twin evils of sectarianism and passive propagandism. Both wings of the ex-Militant have a prolonged history of counterposing abstract propaganda for socialism to participation in real struggles; and an organisational sectarianism which treated union broad lefts and anti-poll tax campaigns as a private recruiting ground.

Militant's persistent refusal to build a united campaign against the witch hunt has rebounded on the entire Labour left in its fightback against Kinnockism

The split will give both sides an opportunity to rethink the disastrous Militant heritage. But the evidence so far is that the split will create two dogmatic and sectarian groups, with the sole difference that one is mainly inside the Labour Party and one mainly outside.

← Soft Left plots Campaign G · Time for Labour →

Something wrong on this page?