Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Taking Lenin seriously

· Socialist Outlook no. 107, September 1996 · 756 words

Reviews

Marxism Trotsky

SIMON KENNEDY reviews Neil Harding's new book Leninism, published by Macmillan.

LENIN'S FIRST response was disbelief—the press must have made it up. But the truth soon became apparent. The leadership of socialist parties throughout Europe had voted for war credits.

Harding sees this as the defining moment of "Leninism". The treachery of social democracy in 1914 led Lenin to throw himself into the most important and politically formative period of his intellectual life.

From 1914 he dedicated himself to the study of philosophy—particularly the place of Hegel in Marx's thought—and the reworking of a number of basic Marxist categories.

He combined a dialectical philosophy with an analysis of the dissolution of capitalism and the end of a political epoch. The distinctiveness of Leninism was born in the libraries of Switzerland.

This response to the collapse of the Second "socialist" International Harding finds peculiar. He argues that it is responsible for Leninism's subsequent harshness and intolerance, showing "a deeply doctrinaire and scholastic disposition to the world"—unlike the sensibly pragmatic Bernstein, for example.

Harding's Lenin was also displayed in his Isaac Deutscher prize winning Lenin's Political Thought.

He argues that Lenin was much more than a skilful political schemer or opportunist politician with a nose for power—he was a faithful and orthodox disciple of Marx who built upon the doctrinaire thinking of his mentor. If you want to find the culprit for the sins of Leninism, look to Marx.

Harding is no friend of Lenin. But he has been important in asserting the intellectual strength of Leninism as a coherent ideology.

This enables him to explain well how the slogans of "all power to the soviets", "bread, peace and land", "freedom to the nationalities", all arose from a sophisticated analysis of the world.

Lenin's "doctrinaire" worldview gave him a unique standpoint, one which was to facilitate the revolution and transform the twentieth century.

Arriving from the famous sealed train from Germany, Lenin's proclamation of his April Theses shocked his Bolshevik audience. No significant leader of the organisation gave support. Pravda disclaimed the contents, printing them as a personal position. How could Lenin be so far from his party?

Later the same year Lenin found himself in a minority of one on a scandalised Central Committee. Alone he demanded the organisation of insurrection. His position could not have been more distinctive, and question of where state power should reside—with the bourgeois provisional government or the workers and peasants—could not have been more pivotal.

Harding allows us to understand how this came about. Lenin's writings on imperialism, for example, were not particularly original. But he was able to translate the analysis into a political strategy with clear slogans, goals and a defined target audience.

The internationalisation of capitalism made socialism an international doctrine, with relevance for those beyond the advanced capitalist countries. Understanding national exploitation made socialist revolution intimately connected to national liberation—and so "Leninism introduced a wholly new geographical framework for ideological discourse".

There are some obvious omissions from Harding's account. In the discussion of what was to replace Russian capitalism—something other than capitalism, but not yet socialism—he ignores the debate in the communist international over the question of a workers' state: a concept that is invaluable if we are to understand how capitalism may be overthrown, but a state created that is not socialist.

Curiously absent too is the place of Lenin's Capitalism in Russia.

Most glaring however is any serious consideration of Lenin's intellectual relationship with Trotsky. The author makes much of the April Theses, but fails to note how they represented a shift toward Trotsky's long-held position of permanent revolution.

Harding's focus on ideology leads him to underestimate the material roots of Stalinism in the backwardness of Russian society and the consequent growth of the bureaucracy. This is why he can say that Lenin was "complicit in all that made Stalin and Stalinism".

It is impossible to accept Harding's portrayal of Leninism as the true orthodox version of doctrinaire Marxism.

Putting aside his obvious social democratic prejudices, we have to ask of Harding why it was that Lenin was so isolated among Russian revolutionaries in 1917.

The answer to this question lies in understanding that the iron laws of Marxism are not so ferrous after all—they give us a number of principles and propositions, but in no way can be said to present a "philosophy of certainty".

Marxism gives guidance and explanation to the practical business of politics, but these are of the sort that can only be validated in practical activity—something Lenin knew all about.

← Australian austerity · Get organised, get active! →

Something wrong on this page?