Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Your letters

Socialist Outlook no. 9, October 1988 · pp 35-36 · 1,055 words

Letters

Women Lesbian and gay

letters on any topic. preferab- ly of not more than 400 words in length.

'No' to policy-making by referendum!

Dear comrades.

For some of the leading figures currently in charge of the party, the current policy review and Lahour Listens cam- paigns do not go far

cnough in transforming

Labour into a party fit for their prejudices to

live in.

In this, they have

been spurred on by a recent bit of "private enterprise indulged in

by Sean Hughes, MP for Knowsley South.

He took advantage of

the Parliamentary vaca-

tion to launch his own

little survey on

Lahour's defence policy

in his constituency, and vociferusty claimed that the verdict recorded

on thai occasion amounted to a massive thumbs-down for the non-nuclear policy on which we fought the 1983 and 1987 clections.

In the aftermath of this rather insignificant event, the press have reported the Labour leader to favour the idca of settling the party's defence policy by means of a referendum held amongst its entire membership.

Superficially, of course, this idea has many attractions and may even tempt some sections of the Left which have become in- creasingly disenchanted with Labour's policy- making machinery as it operates at the annual conference.

One of the central ob- jections which has al-

SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 9 October 1988

ways been raised against the process of decision making by referendum is the power wielded by those who have charge of formulat- ing the all-important question

Here the 1975 EEC referendum can serve as a good example. Nor only was the question loaded in such a way as to provoke a 'yes' vote 'Do you think that this couniry should stay in the European Community ): it was also preceded by a government statement which was as manipula- tve as it was untrue.

Going back even fur tner. It will be remem- hered that in France, De Gaulle was also an ex- pert manipulator of the relerendum question during his term of office.

But come to think of it. is there any guarantee that even a substantial minority of party mem- bers would bother to vote? A result based on a low turnout would cHuse a major credibility problem, not to mention now internal convulsions:

The policy-making techniques which cur- rently apply within the Labour party are far from perfect. However It would he courting dis- aster if Labour were to saddle itself with the sham democracy and arm-twisting potential of one-off members" referenda.

is units

any proposas fect!

Walter Cairns

Lesbians made Invisible once more

Dear Socialist Outlook:

Having just read Valerie Coultas" article "British feminism ten years on" in Outionk No.9. I feelI must write to take issue with the blatant heterosexism that the ar-

ticle displays.

Yet again, patronis-

ing anti-lesbianism is paraded in the name of

"socialist feminism".

thus playing into the

thus playing into the hands of the largely classless politics of radi-

18817021

cal feminism.

I define myself as a socialist feminist and I

am a lesbian (having finally decided that

despite

the two are not mutually exclusive).

I see women's oppres- sion as ronted in the capitalist order, and male violence against women as a symptom of the incqualities of power between men and women in our society. not the causc of that ine-

widen the two-

wer appres sted:" "he inder. and!

quality.

However I complete- ly fail to see what makes the demand for fertility control a vital "social" demand and the extension of that demand to control over

our sexuality - surely a

logical conclusion of

the slogan Our bodies.

our choice - somchow not a social demand, and therefore of little importance. Such a dis- tinction can only he based on ignorance and prejudice,

And for whom were "socialist feminists" demanding cqual pay. education and nursery provision? Straight women only?

Are the massive walls of hostility and prejudice faced by les- hian mothers to be ig nored, and the dis- crimination all lesbians face in terms of employ- ment to be discounted? This is what seems to be implied in your ar-

ticle.

As a socialo feminist. I see the

capitalist state as the enemy but without losing sight of the dit- ferent institutionalised power relationships within that capitalist

staic.

All men bencfit from patriarchy, and all straights benefit from heterosexism within capitalism; and to get these groups of people to relinquish the power they have is far from easy - hut some people have to try.

Yours for a heterosexistn-free socialism, Rebecca Fleming. Oxford.

Heffer: point taken

Eric Heffer has written to us following our ar- ticle on the Benn-Hef- fer campaign in Socialist Outlook No.9, pointing out that a fringe meeting for the campaign did in fact

take place at the NUR conference on July 4.

We are pleased this was the case, and happy to correct the misunderstanding that might have been created by the article.

At the time of going to press, the original fringe meeting - scheduled for June 27- had indeed been can- celled, and no new meeting had been ar- ranged.

Page 33

193850 YEARS 1988

-INTERNALIS

RALLY

Saturday 12 November 1988, 7.30pm

Ernest Mandel

Marxist economist

Heather Dashner

Mexican PRT

Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, London, WCI

Nearest Tube: Holborn

Access: wheelchair access to meeting room, no disabled toilet

facilities There will be a creche. Book in advance to PO Box 705, London,

SW19 1HA Entrance: £2.00 (waged), £1.50 (student), £1.00 (UB40/OAP/school student)

SPONSORED BY SOCIALIST OUTLOOK

Catherine Samary

Paris University Institute of the Soviet

World

Charlie van Gelderen Attended founding conference of FI

SOCIALIST

OUTLOOK

SOCIALISE OUTLOOK is committed to the develop- ment of a real socialist alternative both to the ravages of Thatchersim and to the grey tide of Kinnockism and new

realism.

SOCIALIST OUTI.OOK has in its first eight issues provided in-depth analysis and debate on developments in the trade unions, the struggle in the Labour Party, the recomposition of British politics and many international

issues of crucial importance for socialists.

Annual subscription rate (ten issues): £8.50 for inland subscriptions £17.00 for Inland multi-reader subscriptions @13.00 for European subscriptions [18.00 tor all other international subscriptions (US $ 25.00) £54.00 for overseas airmail multi-reader sub:

Name.

Address..........

25J 15 11

Subscription to start from issue number.

Retum to SOCIALIST OUTLOOK, PO Box 705. London, SWIV DILA, England.

← Gabriel Garcia Marquez · Editorial: Turning to the unions? →

Something wrong on this page?