Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

The Case for Leon Trotsky

· Socialist Outlook no. 9, October 1988 · p 26 · 754 words

Trotsky Russia and the USSR

The

Case

IN SPITE of the slow progress of glas- nost and perestroika in the Soviet Union, much light has been shed on some of the murkiest corners of Soviet history. The monstrous crimes of Stalin are no longer "counter-revolutionary garbage purvered by the Trotskyrts. but on the contrary verifiable facts.

One after another the murdered victims of Stalin's show trials in the 1930s are being chablitiated - Bukharin, Zinoviev, Kamenev. Rakovsky. Pyatakov and others whose names hecame world famous as leaders of the Octoher revolution. It is now officially recognised that these Bolsheviks were not guilty of the heinous crimes for which they were convicted and ex-

the

ecuted on Stalin's orders. pale - Leon Trotsky, founder of the Red Army. first Soviet Foreign Commissar and the prin-

But one name is still, officially, beyond the

11C17

From a logical point of view, of course. this just does not make sense. The connecting link in the three major Moscow trials was Loon Trutsky.

confessions lo he carrying out their treachery in association with and under direct orders from Leon Trotsky and his son.

Pyrtakov told the court of his secret Might to

diately disproved by the Norwegian paper

All the accused claimed in their abjoct forced

a claim which was im-

Leon Sedov.

Oslo to meet Troesky

to the post, which reported that no civil aitiner

inded at Osto airpon in the month of

Firs.er 1935. In fact, no aircraft at all used foreign frt hetween September 1935 and May governme viously as confessed to having received

viously as confessed to having received new Sovietters from Trotsky, all of them port - the inhich had outlined his plans and tion deals.

port - the inhich had outlined his plans and

directives. Rakovsky confessed

yet worl . for the British intelligence ser socialist intern international won the dock, Trotsky was the - an even morfeat trials, the spider who spun Soviet bureau weh of plots and intrigues, the

However. ik leaders on trial. Lenin's com rigorous defin

Page 22

Why then has Trotsky not been rehahilitated? Why is it

that despite the de-Stalinisation campaign

he saved from burcaucratic degeneration and preserved as a revolutionary factor by al vigorous democracy within the party. It was time to free the party from the tyranny of the machine: to replace ibe mummified bureaucrats" with fresh elements: and most im- portant of all to remove from their posts those who, at the first word of criticism, wielded their whips. It was imperative for the New Course to begin "by making everyone feel that Imam now

From that date on, until his death, Trotsky

when wis hegun sentatively ho Knne

bumpe varned threne

"the party could only

be saved from

on nobody will terrorise the party

bureaucratic

continued toassail not only Stalin hut the whole

degeneration and

burcaucratic machine which nurtured

preserved as a

stalinism. And this is the original sin for which

the ruling bureaucracy in the Soviet Union will

revolutionary factor by Find it hard to forgive him.

a vigorous democracy

But as Emest Mandel has pointed nut, it was.

Trotsky, Sedov and the Left Opposition who by

within the party."

their light against Stalinism 'saved the honour

of communism. assurel its continuity.

Thanks to them, no one can say that com-

thoroughly by Gorbachev, Stalin's most con-

ternational Viewpour no 143).

Trotsav

• the ~

Trotsky's opposition to Stalin was on a

qualitatively higher plane than that of most of the accused who from time to time opposed

than that " The was filter

aspects of Stalin's policies, Trotsky attacked

the very hasis of Stalin's domination

growing bureaucratisation of the party and state

dominal

unse

1027 he wrote a serie. later publisned as The N. caned on the rank and tile meir own understanding ine should case to rea Old tuard as absolute

and

the NOTS

munism leads invitably to Stalimism, because Stalin's fiercest and most irreconcilable adver- sary, the one he considered his mumher one cnemy was the communist Icon Trotsky (In-

That is why we must continue the fight to clearall the victims of the Moscow Trials of the criminal charges, and find of'all leon Trotsky. As Mandel puts it: "this fight is not essentially about the past, truth, honour and justice... the fight is over the crucial principles for straighlening out the present situation of the USSR amal the world workers movement. the principles indispensable for the cmancipation

ot tne it. the

of the workers.

Charlie van Geldren

00k no 9 October 1988

← Gorbachev's Gamble · PERU: death squads and general strikes →

Something wrong on this page?