A permanent point
of controversy
The theory of Permanent Revolution is much more than just a theory. It is a bedrock of the marxist programme and strategy for revolution in most of the underdeveloped countries today. It began as Trotsky's attempt to develop beyond the carly writings of Mars and Engels, and come to terms with the changes brought about by the rise of imperialism. A few of the key ideas clashed with traditional orthodox marxism', and were only confirmed in the heat of the Russian Revolution of 1917.
The theory remained highly controver.
sial, as Trotsky continued to develop it in
Britain, Holland and France. Trotsky recog-
niscd that even if the undendeveloped countries
were le have hourgeois revolutions it was im-
possible for them to enter the market as qual
competitors. Their small, weak
capitalist classes were totally subordinate to the hankers, politicians and military forces of the imperialist powers. They could mercly struggle
for a slightly larger shice of the cake, and this
nough alances with their Deemen 'stage
ses and the rising working classes. The
ward vauntries were devrinn
allu it the
- in
• as canic, hul the tasks gooss revolution still had to be carried out
demands. But the question remained - who should carry out these tasks and to what end?
Some. like the Russian Mensheviks, arguod that if the revolution was to be a bourgoois one then naturally the bourgeoisie should lead it.
The workers should at best play a supporting rolc until such time in the indefinite future when capitalism had expanded the ranks of the work- ing class and crated conditions for the next
in the revolution - the fight lor socialism. The Bolsheviks, and alongside them Trotsky, maintained that the inability of the ra- tional bourgeoisie to free ilself from im- penalis and Czarism made this impossible.
arguer recois onu
apporting ature wher
1004840
he them
" 1116 sossibie
"This was precisely the idea that
was expressed by the very designation of the revolution as
'permanent", that is an uninterrupted one, a revolution passing over directly from the bourgeois stage into the socialist. To express the same idea Lenin
later used the excellent
expression of the bourgeois
revolution growing over into the
socialist."
Instead, the workers would have to ally
themselves with the peasantry to make
this bourgeois revolution. In a country
like Russia the peasants had the most to
the light of experiences of the Chinese revolutionary struggles of the 1920s and 1930s. Even today it remains a flashpoint of political conflict between trotskyism and stalinist currents in the living revolu- tionary struggles of Central America.
Africa and Asia.
Trotsky's theory was based on the law of combined and uneven development.
Orthodox marxism held that all countries would undergo the same pattern of development as the advanced ones.
Trotsky challenged this notion.
Economically "backward" countrics. he argued, were not only uncqual, but developing in a combined way alongside more advanced economics. This meant they could appropriate, or have imposed on them, advanced forms of technology and economic production without the in termediate stages of development which the first capitalist countries had gone through. Backwardness and the most ad- vanced productive. bined in a vaner.
Eariv twentieth classic case. Huge dustry imposeu bi ‹under whose cont with a tcuual state.
He then we- bined and uneven prospects for revolution.
As imperianstr after country into the wer countries which had no. bourgeois revolutione the feaudal regimes an capitalist developter
Page 26
d that
ulChudl
"ongoide
as méant
nised
32-
Dr
....su
gain by throwing off the chains of icudalism. But the question about who would lead this bourgeois revolution
The Bolsheviks led by Lenin still ar
gued right up to April 1917 that the pur
abus. Who revolution
remained unanswered.
pose of such a (bourgeois) revolution was
to brak froc of imperialist domination
and to herald the unrestrained develop-
ment of capitalism. specially in the ficid of agriculture. They weren't sure which
class - the workers or the peasants - would
play the leading role and have the
govermental majority. Therefore. they Icit thir govemmental slogan deliberate- ly vague on this question.
Trotsky's novel idca was as follows.
gued right up to April 1917 that the pur
Leon Trotsky, Introduction to Permanent
ted
Bourgoois revolution is a process of throw- ing off feudal restrictions which involves the key tasks of national libration, democracy and
agrarian reform. In practice this means a unified
national market. with national sovereignty over
imperialist controlled industries: a national as-
sembly elected by universal sullrage, allowing
political pluralism with the right to form inde-
First, Trotsky recognised that unfet-
tered capitalist development could only
come ahout if the economically back
ward countries had access to world
markets as cqual competitors. But. as
stated earlier, the advent of imperialism had
scale and made this impossible. The imperialist powers were locked in a struggle for coonomic
territory which ended in the carnage of two
world wars. They would not allow a non-im-
penalist country to assume an impenalist role
The capitalism that had been violently imposed
Trotsa-* First. Trot
(Ket
Ist markr e the TVDY
making
pendent
les and trades union mu the 1 the huge estates of the piz land outing land in the peasanus.. and infettered capitanst developmen
enarline 1 of agriculture.
Whue the way Tor. comi important opr swinise itself
bourgeois revolution crears the alist development. it also.- mings for the working class t- to press its own independent
-dam
enia condition tor i 'hen. in the develop
ing countries. had already been set.
Second, he argued that the working class
would have to play the leading role in the
worker-peasant alliance and the revolutionary
govemment.
SOCIALIST O
ITLOOK
T BASIC S
Trotsky's conclusions were based on the view that the coming of capitalism had brought with it the final
LA PAZE
ENDEN The
deel, to survive, any revoln-
tion must march forward. But
it is highly unlikely, to say the
least, that any single country
even one as highly developed
as the United States - has enough resources to bring
hiri
domination of the town over
countryside. peasantry was incapahle of pursuing an independent political course, unless to take human development
backwards. Socictics in which events on the land
the
madl
i aboul on its own a classless
society. After all the im
perialist countries are so ad
vanced precisely because of
* their relation to and domina-
tion of the world market.
dominated social life were a thing of the past. The working class would have to take the leadership of the worker- peasant alliance hecause ofits decisive social and political weight. regardless of its size compared to the peasantry.
But after agreeing with Lenin mat anlv
tion of the world market.
The conquest of proletarian
power in any single country
must be seen as the start of a
revolution in that country. The absence of a favourahle inter- national climate canor be used as an excuse for delaying progress in many areas - rais- "dards ot the working class and
ar taking measures to
ar xum oppression, and so on.
•ALES 036
99*** would im-
Inst the contras - Managua 1987
monopoly on foreign trade and seizing control
of the financial institutions?
Posed in this way the answer is obvious. But
genuine.,.. ion, he tonk 2........
The ver: ...
le!
suen measures are noting less inan ine
salist revolution. Carrying out th
.. revolution successfully a this • •tis carvine oute socialis revamil
is. But start of • heir.
bourgeois revolution would fatally undemnine the bourgeoisie itself. Not only
perialism be affected, but also the national bourgeoisic would be threatened too, especial- ly if their land holdings were broken up and dis- tributed to the peasants. The hourgeoisie would then be forced to resist its own revolution with all its power. (To this day. there is not a bourgcois regime in the whole of the Third World that heads a country where all three major tasks of the bourgenis revolution - democracy, na-
The Nicaraguan revolution clcarly shows the
tremendous problems faced by a small under-
developed country faced with the might of im-
perialism. International solidarity can help
provide a crucial breathing space for such a
le Nicaras:
de
...de:
•cioskin wiftt..rh
vIcc versa.
There was another important dimension to
perialism. International solidarity can help provide a crucial breathing space for such a
" Me only zuaranter..
survival is an extension of the revolution to other countries.
clcarly based on analysis of the objective forces that shape revolutionary struggles:
Motel
"The permanent revolution, in the sense which Marx attached to this
concept, means a revolution which makes no compromise with
any single form of class rule,
which does not stop at the
democratic stage, which goes over to socialist measures and to war against reaction from without; that is, a revolution whose every successive stage is rooted in the preceding one, and which can end only in the complete liquidation of
class society."
The theory of Permanent Revolution is
tiemal liberation and land ruform - have been genuinely carried out.)
If the working class were to pursuc its class interests it would have to embark on
the course of socialist revolution by hreaking the cconomic power of the bour- geoisie. The completion of the tasks of the bourgenis revolution would thercfore take place simultancously with the begin ning of the socialist revolution. There
would he no gap between fixed "stages:
but there is no guarantee that any given revolution will colve naturally along
any given struggle there will be other political currents with very different
airs, policics and methods. If their in fuence predominates. revolutionary op portunities can be missed, or mass strug gies led seriously astray, as has happened so often since World War Two.
tittener then in
.. ~e tundamental
for revolu
coinines
instead the revolution, to be successful. had to he an unhroken, uninterrupted one. permanent" in the sense of permanent session". and culminating in a revolution- ary workers government, the dictatonhip nf the proletariat
the necessity for the complete political in-
the necessity for the complete political in- dependenoc of the working class and its purtics. Many different alhances with all sorts of forces will he possile and neces-
sorts of forces will he possile and neces-
sary for the revolution to succeed - hut the temptation for a working class revolu- tionary party to subsume itself or its inde- pendent identity into a national, anti-im- perialist mass movement must be
Trotsky also tierefore rejected the in- Leon Trotsky. Introduction to Permanent
plied notion in the Bolshevik strategy that
Revolution al some point the new revolutionary government woukl either have 10 give up
resisted. its power or repress the working class.
The bourgeoisic would oppose even those measurex hencficial to the working class which unc achievable under capitalism - an cight hour working day, wage rises, fredom to organise. When the workers responded with strikes, - cupations and even expropriations. what should a revolutionary workers" und peasants govem- ment do? Should it remain faithful to marxist
socialism later? Or should it promote and sup- port such working class action and make in- roads into hourgeois cconomic power: ex- propriating the factories, Imposing a state
orthodoxy
on the need for capitalism first. SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 9 October 1988
proJ 30812121800
the successful socialist, permanent revolution
which Trotsky identified
He insisted that revolutions and counter revolutions are not constrained within national boundaries. The class struggle. he argued, can
have far-reaching effectsright across the workd, thus reinforcing the need for revolutionaries to
organise on an intemational scale and fight to
mobilise solidarity with struggles in countrics
ross tne wE
utiestasir
other than their own.
*yidual munirie
done the road to a classless n
Instead, the fight must be to build a
political leadership which will combatthe
cross-class alliances and stages" theories
proposed by stalinist and reformist currents, and struggle for a strategy and a tactical programme based upon the theory of Per-
manent Revolution. In every such movement there is an ongoing struggle to decide whether
the leadership will be bourgeois or proletarian. It is on the outcome of this struggle that the fu- ture success of the revolution depends.
Richard Rozanski
thether
'age