In its capability to mobilise mas- ses. in its success in raising political consciousness within its own constituency. in its ability to confuse and harass British im- perialism, the Irish resistance has recorded many gains. But the twenty year struggle in Britain to make Ireland an issue has, by and large, been a negative experience, recording no mass mobilisation, and very limited success in consciousness raising on the Irish issue, leaving a British political establishment which, despite opinion polls in favour of withdrawal, is unsor- ried and untroubled by such sentiments.
Such a judgement is not un example of the dreaded new realism of Brilish
socialism, it is an updating of an old 'The English worker", wrote Karl Marx in 1X70, 'in relation to the Irish worker. feels himself a member of the ruling nation, and few would deny that a similar sense of supe
it Seline riority, as well is an apathy as to what happens to the backward" Irish. remains a characteristic of British political and social culture.
With the exception of the British Labour Party for a few short weeks in the summer of 1920, no major British political party has ever supported un
tion. Today this includes not just the
nEt•
political party has ever supported un conditional Irish self-determina-
major parties but smaller and more su- perficially radical ones like the Greens, and the Welsh and Scottish
Both historically and contem
porarily, even those which, on paper. have supported unconditional Irish self-determination, such the Com munist Party in 1920-21. or the Socialist Workerx Party today, do so with an obvious lack of enthusiasm or low prioritisation in terms of day-to- day political activity.
The failure to huild any semblance of a mass withdrawal movement in the last twenty years sees history repeat- ing itself. Which makes the obvious
est important pomt or all: that
this is due to the enormous difficulties save • be Satoo in trying to swim
against a tide of chauvinist idcology
and culture.
Nevenheless, it was not invitable that things would tum out as disap- pointingly as they have,
An instant snapshot of the current
stage of the withdrawal movement
certainly does not show a lot to be
proud of. The membership of the
Troops Out Movement (TOM)
remains small, the last three conferen
ces of the Labour Committee on
Ircland (LCI) have scen a fall in atten-
dance, and as we go into the "Year of
Action' those forces which are active on Ireland are, in same ways, more
divided than they have heen for five or
sIx years.
This is most obviously illustrated
by arguments about the "Year", with
the TOM and the Irish in Britain
Representation group (IBRG)
withdrawing from the the organising
committec for it, accusing the LCI Icadership of undemocratic practices- among other reasons - and with jus- tification.
The obvious truth is that twenty
years on there is still not a united movement for British withdrawal. There is no Irish equivalent of the old Victnam Solidarity Campaign, or the CND of today. There is not even an
emhryo of one. And that failure can-
not be simply laid at the door of ob-
jective difficulties.
Th.
a have been a whole serte
Look at the ...
the anish Solidaritu Can- oth carly 1971s and Its cae
...ilv TOM.
wur. for cac. was the anti
moment in the USA and
•ther sland would waltante
Brison society as the
: War dia in the Unted State-
molisue paral?
ns if the Brtish army hat been a conscript one and perhaps if the aunt of Brush soldiers in Ircland had been much greater, such a
save built. Burth
are not and are
13SC not
likely to prevail, despite recent IRA successes In Therefore it was and is wrong to adopt a strategy bused on building a movement on a Bring the Boys Home' sentiment. although such a sentiment could be a contributory factor.
The carly "solidarity" movement was alke rather too onsessed at times
with parading the purity of its slogans.
The carliest one of the Irish Solidarity "Victory to the IRA" again copying the Vietnam model of "Victory to the Vietcong" was used only to prove how revolutionary
was also ramer
"Victory to the IRA"
those advancing it were.
The Troops Out Now successor was also based on the Vietnam model. and was specifically advanced at the
those a
The
ano was sne
A twenty year balance sheet of
the current
struggle for
Ireland's
liberation is
positive. The
same cannot be
said of its
support movement within
Britain.
GEOFFREY
BELL examines
the history of Irish
solidarity and
outlines a
strategy for
building a
movement for withdrawal which
avoids the ultra left and sectarian errors of the past.
time to tie in with a projected "Bring the Boys Home' sentiment. And yet. too often Troops Out Now
was
erected as a barrier to the building of a movement. Anyone who did not agree with it, even to the extent of mildly qualifying it or adding to it could find her/himself dcnouncod.
Many of those on the far left copc- cially used Troops Our Now' not as a guide to building a movement but as a stick with which to heat those who
dit not agree w say the deman in especzailvw.. sell-determiation.
Certainly. u
thes 15r....
campaigns on Ireland which did sur- face during the 1970k and were hased en alternative slogans pacitist campaigns for withdrawal or
the Better Life for All campaign achieved even less than TOM in terms of building a movement or mobilising
an such as
achieved even less than TOM in terms of building a movement or mobilising public opinion. For, while Betler life For All attracted all sorts of paper sup- port. receiving as it did the support of
the TUC. it was heavily based on the Hitsen. common
"Unfortunately,
over the last
couple of political years, the LCI
leadership
has neglected
its
grass-roots
work"
denominator, which is never likely to stimulate the active enthusiasm neces-
The death of Better Life For All coincided with the birth of the Labour
Fictitiss sary to build a movement.
Inc
Committee on Ireland. The LCI's most important achievements in the
early and mid 14%0s were those which
SOCIALIST OUTLOOK no 9 October 1988
Page 19
EM EN T
write them off ur to try and exclude were hased on suppon from within the
them from a withdrawal movement. rank and file of the party.
What all this argues is, that as well
In 1984 an LCI resolution was
as sections of the irish commumly, the passed at the party conference: the
other great muscle of a strong first (and, as yet, last) time this had
withdrawal movement of the future happened to an Irish resolution op-
will be located within the labour and posed by the party leadership since
socialist movement. As far as the
Labour Party is concerned it is
probably possible to go further than
"It should never be forgotten that in building a withdrawal movement
Diplock courts we are taking on the material, political, and strategic interests of British imperialism"
1920. This fact was in some ways more significant than the content of the resolution: a civil rights one in- cluding the demand for the end of the
-which was the
specific ixue the party leadership op-
The victory at the 1984 conterence was due to grass-roots campaigning of the LCI but also to growth of the left
within the party - the Bennite move-
ment - and the effect of the 198l hunger strikes of republican prisoners and the mass mobilisation and the electoral suppore it produced in Ireland. All this helped to build a con- sciousness ahour Ireland within the rank and file of the party which the
LCI and Lakur Women for Ireland (L WI) have heen able to utilise since.
The two most spectacular succes
of ycars.
se have heen winning lhe regional conference of Greater Lordon I abour
Party to withdrawal and the national Labour Women's conference to withdrawal and opposition to the
Anglo-Irish Accord. Such successes forced the leadership of the Labour Party to adopt a more radical approach to the north of Ireland than it practised when in govemment.
Unfortunately, over the last couple
the LC1 leadership has neglocted its grass roots work. certain- ly in terms of challenging the party
"there are parts of the labour movement which remain Virgin territory for Irish work"
Page 20
leadership on Ireland, in favour of negotiating with sections of that Icadership, albeit more junior sea-
What has been a recent positive development is the willingness of the LCT and the TOM to work together on
specific ventures. There has heen a third wing to this partnerships the trish in Britain Representation Group, an organisation formed at the time of the
tons.
from Ireland,
ment League (AL) in the carly 1970% made any sustailled attempt to involve the Irish in Britain. and it is notewor thy that the biggest demonstration over the last 20 years was onc called by the All. built through tours of building sites in London.
For this there are historical proce dents. There have been many move-
the
hunger strikes, which campaigns for the rights of the Irish in Britain and which calls for British withdrawal
The birth und growth of the IBRG is significant. For if there is one in gredient to the withdrawal movement which has not heen treated with the seriousness it has deserved it is the Irish in Britain: Only the Anti-Intem
ments and campaigns concered with Ireland in this country since the Irish
first came to Britain in significant
numbers after the Famine, hut those which have been by far the most suc cessful the campaign around the call for the release of the Fenian prisoners
Confederation of Great Britain/Irish National League in the late 1870s and carly 1880s, the Irish Self-Determina- tion League (IDSL) of 1919-21-were
based either overwhelmingly or cn- tirely on the Irish community in
that and suggest that it will he the left wing of the Labour Party which will he the most fruitful for Irish work.
Recently. for example. it has been the "Bennite" wing of the party which has been the most receptive to the
to 100, 000 working class Irish im-
it would be silly to draw in exact historical parallel and say it is possible to build replica of the ISDL today, but both history and common sense sug- gests if a powerful, quantitatively im
pressive movement on British withdrawal is to huilt in Britain then the Irish in Britam will he a major component of it. This is all the more obvious given the growth of Irish im- migration into Britain in the last few years, and a projected further growth
issue of irclund. That can be con- trasted with the much softer left/Kin- nockite Labour Co-Ordinating Com- mitlee which recently substantially overturned its previous position it
calling for withdrawal
Any worthwhile mass withdrawal movement must always seck to hulld heyund its traditional recruiting grounds of the Irish and the lelt. There has heen some success in involving
the leadership of the Young Liherals. More attention should be paid to the Welsh and Scottish nationalists. the Greens and vanious sections of the black and women's movements, but there is no material evidence to sug gest that any of these, either separate ly or combined have the potential that the Irish community and labour move- ment have for building a withdrawal
Accordingly, it seems sate to sug- gest that the majority of a future withdrawal movement. and its leader-
of 500, 000 by the end of the century
What else can he said about the fu- ture shape of such a movemen? The
successes that have been achieved within the Labour Party underline the existence uf widespread sympathy among the rank and file for British
withdrawal from Ireland. That has yet
h..li movement.
And there are other parts of the labour movemcat which remain vir. gin territory for Irish work. For ex- ample, the annual conference of the Assnciation of Cinematographic. Television and Allied Technicians. (ACTI) recently passela Troops Out
Now resolution. Although individuais within that union have done work on the Insh issue, the passing of this
sue
resolutiom was unexpected and was
There have heen successes in othcr unions, most importantly in the Na- tional Union of Mineworkers, the Na- tional Union of Railwaymen and the National Union of Students, and in other sections of the Labour Party: the
example of the women's conference has already heen cited, and to that can
be added Black Sections which have always in the past heen very sym-
palbetie.
To all of these can be added
socialist organisations outside the
Labour Party. The SWP and the Revolutionary Communist Party
(RCP) have principled positions on Ireland, and the RCP also has a recond of activity. While many Irish activists are, quite rightly, critical of what they see as the sectarianism of those ur-
ganisations, it would be answering sectarianism with sectarianism to
ship, will come from these arcas. For it should never he forgotten that in building a withdrawal movement we are taking in the material. political and strategic interests of British im- perialism and its establishment
This i way the vast mapirity of those within that establishment. in- cluding lis members and servants within the Labour Party leadership and the latiour burcaucracy, will never give such a movement the time ofitay.
Anil That, so return to the question of objective ditticulties. is why the movement has been so difficult to haild. But it is also why socialists need to take such a task a good deal more seriously than most have done over the past twenty ycars.
Both Geoffrey Bell and
Michael Farrell are
contributors to an
important new book on
Ireland Twenty years on,
published this October
by Brandon at E4.95.
/ST .TL00k nn 9 October 1988