Socialist Outlook

Socialist Viewpoint, International, Socialist Outlook and their supplements, 1984–2009

Which model of socialism?

· Socialist Outlook no. 8, July–September 1988 · p 36 · 986 words

Russia and the USSR Trotsky

Which model of sor

OLIVER MACDONALD

Aber Aganbegyan. ine economics o/ perestroika Hutchunson. Ex.N9.

THIS IS BY far the best guide yet available in English to the economic dimension of the current Soviet leadership's drive for perestroika.

Aganbegyan writes cleariy. vigorously and, within the limits of what is a manifesto, very frankly. His book can form the basis for serious discussion among socialists here attempting to make sense of and evaluate economic perestroika.

It is important to bear in mind that within what might be called the Gorbachev coalition „there is not one single

conception of the desired economic strategy and ultimate aim; and the variety of views is even wider in the leid of tar. and tempo of economic reform.

But for the last three years, the views of Aganbegyan and his Novosibirsk schori of ecoupm have been the dominant influence spon Gorbachev himself and bus immediate of advisers.

Too much of the dine 1e*»

the left here over these issues either assumes that the most extreme marketisers i caller "monetarists' in the Soviet Union) represent the 'real" programme of Gorbachev or that once market indicators are introduced, an iron logic of the market leads "inevitably to the conclusions of the monetarists.

The very extensive east European experience of degrees of marketisation shows that this is far from being the case.

What is true is that the

introduction of market indicators decentralises decisions about economic allocations and leads to increased social differentiation within the working population

by comparison with the formal-legal (as opposed to parallel-market and corrupt network realite- gat. of centralised command

planning

Aganbegyan's platform is a wholesale. axe

traditional stalimst svstem of market. economic management, which

Furthermore, the measure of he describes as administrative, and a call for "coonomic" methods of management, by which he means the use of market indicators of performance by state enterprises. along with the development of

co-operatives and individual enterprises.

how advanced the soviet economy is in this debate must be a relative one: the strength of the Soviet economy vis-a-vis the world capitalist market. And here it remains pitiably weak, and consequently subject to enormously strong material

pressure.

We should be quite frank in

acknowledging that when we face a choice between these two

systems, commandist centralised

planning of exchanges between producers and consumers is not

in principle in any way superior to the use of market indicators.

Neither Lenin nor Trotsky ever gave the slightest indication

after 1921 that they would have supported Stalin's administrative regimentation of connomic relations as being in any way superior to NEP. Those in the Soviet Union who ard currently claiming that Stalin followed Trotsky in 1929 over cconomic policy are either

ignorant fools as far as Soviet

history is concerned, or liars.

Some on the left here, on the other hand, argue that today. unlike in the 1920s, the USSR has a highly advanced cconomy, has freed itself from the

contradictions of backwardness

that made NEP necessary in the

1920s and consequently an

adoption of market indicators is a retreat from advanced, more

socialist positions.

This is simply not the case. The fact is that the commandist

system has for decades operated not only alongside, but to a

arke

в ноли 111303

paralle

As Trotsky argued, the

Bukhanın-Sann tantas»

overtaking the west and

advanced socialism in isolated. autarkie development would

lead to an impasse. And as he

also argued, the more advanced

such an isolater more acute its gilliculties wi be.

None of this means that planning has failed. With an open public life and democratic accountability the Soviet commandist planning system would indeed have worked very much better. And no socialist cconomic policy of any sort can ahandon strategic planning. Trotsky's argument in the 1920s was precisely to combine plan and market with the voluntary development of co-operative

forms of ownership alongside the state and individual-family

opcrative ralonesi

sector.

In the current deep crisis of the Soviet economy, there is no

viable alternative to a policy of this kind. On the other hand,

just as the commandist plan has

great costs attached to it, so does the market. These costs of marketisation are not adequately faced by Aganbegyan.

They include the inevitable growth of social inequalities, threats of poverty for sections of

growth

the population, the domination of tie consumer by producer carteis, speed-up and crosion of

rights at work, the dangers of

powerful centrifugal pressure

thanks to the accompanying opening up to western capital,

new forms of corruption as a

result of this, the emergence of a

new "red bourgenisie' as workers in Poland called those who made a killing in the increasingly marketised Poland of the 1970s.

Ther effeete of thin kind of

marketisation and opening to western capital in Poland in the

1970s led to ferment and revolt

among the working class in the

big lactories, especially the

workers in the Polish communist

valt that event

an believes that willi

workers' self-management and

greater political freedoms.

with a large strenething

of the levels of provision in social

services, that kind of egalitarian

revolt can be avoided. Yet the

se sciection of

• the

show that mic vorkere haue not vol

swung into action in a decisive way to destroy the hold of the

Ligachey wing of the party leadership on the big plants. They haven't moved because they remain suspicious of perestroika.

The answer to this crisis of the Soviet reform movement is for

the reformers to genuinely take the Soviet working class into their confidence: to open the

books to the workers, explain to

them the scope of the crisis, the

need for austerity, the way that austerity will involve the

destruction of the privileges of

the burraucracy, as Yeltsin has demanded, and then put the package of measures to the

id-TJ0M 10 a

THUM SOMSUR

mannie aroue for

-mecrane way

not a defence of

rommandist plannı the introduction of

co-operatives and market indicators •

← Politics, sex and sexual politics · 'They do not love your neck ...' →

Something wrong on this page?